IP Verse

Coated Steel Strips, Methods Of Making The Same, Methods Of Using The Same, Stamping Blanks Prepared From The Same, Stamped Products Prepared From The Same, And Articles Of Manufacture Which Contain Such A Stamped Product - EP2086755

The patent EP2086755 was granted to Arcelormittal on Nov 29, 2017. The application was originally filed on Oct 30, 2006 under application number EP06842403A. The patent is currently recorded with a legal status of "Granted And Under Opposition".

EP2086755

ARCELORMITTAL
Application Number
EP06842403A
Filing Date
Oct 30, 2006
Status
Granted And Under Opposition
Oct 27, 2017
Grant Date
Nov 29, 2017
External Links
Slate, Register, Google Patents

Patent Summary

Patent Family

Patent Family

Patent Oppositions (5)

Patent oppositions filed by competitors challenge the validity of a granted patent. These oppositions are typically based on claims of prior art, lack of novelty, or non-obviousness. They are a key part of the process for determining a patent's strength and enforceability.

CompanyOpposition DateRepresentativeOpposition Status

Get instant alerts for new oppositions and patent status changes

MUHR UND BENDERAug 29, 2018NEUMANN MULLER OBERWALLENEY PATENTANWALTE PARTG MBBADMISSIBLE
THYSSENKRUPP STEEL EUROPEAug 29, 2018EISENFUHR SPEISERADMISSIBLE
VOLKSWAGENAug 29, 2018LIEBLADMISSIBLE
SALZGITTER FLACHSTAHLAug 28, 2018MOSER GOTZE & PARTNER PATENTANWALTE MBBADMISSIBLE
TATA STEEL IJMUIDENAug 28, 2018GROUP SERVICESADMISSIBLE

Patent Citations (16) New

Patent citations refer to prior patents cited during different phases such as opposition or international search.

Citation PhasePublication NumberPublication Link
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTEP0356783
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTEP1013785
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTEP1336666
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTFR2720079
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTFR2758571
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTUS6296805
INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORTWO2006097593
OPPOSITIONDE102004007071
OPPOSITIONEP1013785
OPPOSITIONEP1380666
OPPOSITIONEP2242863
OPPOSITIONFR2833504
OPPOSITIONUS2001042393
OPPOSITIONUS6296805
OPPOSITIONWO2005078144
OPPOSITIONWO2008053273

Non-Patent Literature (NPL) Citations (75) New

NPL citations refer to non-patent references such as research papers, articles, or other publications cited during examination or opposition phases.

Citation PhaseReference TextLink
OPPOSITION- A. Geilfuss et al., "Hot Forming and casting technologies for lightweight automobile design : Untersuchungen zum Warmumfromprozess", International Circle of Experts Lightweight Automobile Design, (20031100), pages 221 - 242, XP055520834-
OPPOSITION- "Anlage zur Akkreditierungsurkunde D-PL-11169-01-00 nach DIN EN ISO/IEC 17025:2005", Akkreditierungsurkunde TAZ GmbH, Eurasburg, (20180417), XP055518261-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Applikationsbericht der TAZ GmbH ''Charakterisierung von AISi-Schichten'' Applikations- Nr. 18041102d", pages 1 - 32-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Fahrzeugdaten", pages 1 - 2, URL: https://portal.cpn.vwg/elsapro/VehicleInfo/data.html-
OPPOSITION- Applikationsbericht ?18041806a-A2004'' der TAZ GmbH-
OPPOSITION- Applikationsbericht ?18041806a-S2001'' der TAZ GmbH-
OPPOSITION- ASTM International, "Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, Aluminium-Coated, by the Hot-Dip Process", ASTM Designation A 463/A 463M - 06, (20061015), pages 1 - 7, XP055516366-
OPPOSITION- Auswertung der Heizraten der Fig. 2 der E3 im Bereich zwischen 20 und 700°C sowie im Bereich zwischen 500 und 700°C-
OPPOSITION- BABBIT M, "D12- SOME HIGHLIGHTS ON NEW STEEL PRODUCTS FOR AUTOMOTIVE USE", STEEL RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, vol. 77, no. 9/10, (20060000), pages 620 - 626, XP001503675-
OPPOSITION- Carsten Lachmann, "Entwicklungen hochfester Stahlblechqualitäten und fügetechnische Aspekte für den Einsatz im Automobilbau...aus werkstofflicher Sicht", Zentrallabor, (20050118), pages 1 - 77, XP055518509-
OPPOSITION- "chapter 1, 4", M. Geiger et al., Auslegung des Prozessfensters für die Blechumformung höchstfester Vergütungsstähle bei erhöhten Temperaturen, Determination of the process window for hot stamping, Verlag und Vertriebsgeselischaft mbH, FOASTA, (20061000), pages 1 - 13, ISBN 3-937567-42-9, XP055520830-
OPPOSITION- Chawla ET AL., "Microstructure and mechanical behavior of porous sintered steels", Material Science and Engineering A, (2005), vol. 390, pages 98 - 112-
OPPOSITION- CORNETTE, D. et al., "HIGH STRENGTH STEELS FOR AUTOMOTIVE SAFETY PARTS", SAE International., (20010000), XP0055518530-
OPPOSITION- Cornette D; Et Al, "High strength steels for automotive safety parts", SAE Technical Paper Series (Usinor research), (20010300), pages 1 - 13, XP055518177-
OPPOSITION- D. Cornette et al, "High strength steels for automotive safety parts", ; 2001-01-00 78, (20010305), XP055518177-
OPPOSITION- Dr. ING. H. Engels et al., "Controlling and monitoring of the hot-stamping process of bron-alloyed heat-treated steels", New development in sheet metal forming, (20060000), pages 134 - 151, XP055516374-
OPPOSITION- Dr. Ing. P. Hein et al., Warmumformung von Usibor 1500 P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Porzessanalyse, (20060500), ISBN 3_88355-350-6, XP055518496-
OPPOSITION- DR LACHMANN ET AL., "Legierter Vergü- tungsstahl 22MnB5 unbeschichtet oder vorbeschichtet", Technische Lieferspezifikation TL VW 4225-2006:5, (20060500), pages 1 - 11, XP055518195-
OPPOSITION- "Einleitung", Geiger M. et al, Forschung für die Praxis P 644, Fosta, (20061026), pages I-X, 1 - 76, ISBN 3-937567-42-9, XP055518566-
OPPOSITION- Engels et al., "Controlling and Monitoring of the Hot-Stamping Process of Boron- Alloyed Heat-Treated Steels", New Developments in Sheet Metal Forming, pages 134 - 151, XP055516374-
OPPOSITION- ENGELS, H. et al., "Warmumformung", '' Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumformung '', 60486 Frankfurt, (20060509), pages 141 - 157, XP0055518551-
OPPOSITION- "Entwicklungen hochfester Stahlblechqualitäten und fügetechnische Aspekte für den Einsatz im Automobilbau...aus werkstofflicher Sicht", (20050118), pages 1 - 77, XP055518509-
OPPOSITION- Gokhale, "Quantitative Characterization and Representation of Global Microstructural Geometry", ASM Handbook , Volume 9 : Metallography and Microstructures, (2004), vol. 9, pages 428 - 447-
OPPOSITION- GROTHE, K. H. et al., "Dubbel-Taschenbuch für den Maschinenbau", SPRINGER, (20050000), pages W38-E41 - S24-S25, XP055518199-
OPPOSITION- Hein et al., "Presshärten von USIBOR 1500P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Prozessanalyse ", Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumfor, (20060501), pages 171 - 184, XP009156206-
OPPOSITION- Hein P. et al, "Presshärten von USIBOR 1500 P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Prozessanalyse", Internationale Konferenz, Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumformung, (20060510), pages 171 - 184, XP009156206-
OPPOSITION- HEIN, P. et al., "Warmumformung von Usibor 1500 P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Porzessanalyse", ''Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumformung'', 60486 Frankfurt, (20060510), pages 171 - 184, XP055518496-
OPPOSITION- Hein P; Kefferstein R; Dahan Y, "Presshärten von USIBOR 1500P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Prozessanalyse", Hein P; Kefferstein R; Dahan Y, Mathias Liewald, Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumformung, (20060000), pages 171 - 184, XP009156206-
OPPOSITION- H. ENGELS et al., "Controlling and Monitoring of the Hot-Stamping Process of Boron- Alloyed Heat-Treated Steels", H. ENGELS et al., Mathias Liewald, New Developments in Sheet Metal Forming, (20060000), pages V, 135 - 151, XP055516374-
OPPOSITION- "Hot stamping experiment and numerical simulation of pre-coated USIBOR 1500 quenchable steels", (20031000), XP055516331-
OPPOSITION- Jean-Pierre LAURENT, "WARMUMFORMBARE vorbeschichtete ultrahochfeste bor-stähle Eine Lösung für das Festigkeits-Umformbarkeits-Dilemma", Viertes Industriekolloquium SFB 362, (20040000), pages 27 - 36, XP055519504-
OPPOSITION- Jörg WINKEL, "Quetten zum Pressharten von Stahlblech im Automobilbau (Quenches for press hardening steel plate in the car industry)", Gaswärme International, (20040000), vol. 53, no. 7, pages 402 - 405, XP055516351-
OPPOSITION- Jörg Winkel, "Quetten zum Presshärten von Stahlblech im automobilbau-Quenches for press hardening steel plate in the car industry", Gaswärme International, no. 53, (20040000), pages 402 - 405, XP055516351-
OPPOSITION- Jörg Winkel, "Quetten zum Pressharten von Stahlblech im Automobilbau (Quenches for press hardening steel plate in the car industry)", Gaswärme International, vol. 53, no. 7, pages 402 - 405, XP055516351-
OPPOSITION- J. P, Laurent, "Hot Forming and Casting Tecnologies for light weight Autobile Design ; Hot formed Pre-coated boron steels: A solution of the resistance-formability's delimma?", International Circle of Experts Lightweight Automobile Design, (20030000), pages 205 - 206, XP055519487-
OPPOSITION- KARL ROLL ET AL., "TAGUNGSBAND SFU LEICHTBAU DURCH UMFORMTECHNIK, PROZESSKETTE ZUM WARMUMFORMEN VON BLECHEN", GWT-TUD MbH, (20050900), pages 71 - 85, XP055519063-
OPPOSITION- L. GARCIA AMANDA ET AL., "Hot stamping of quenchable steels: material data and process simulations", (20030000), pages 155 - 163, XP009098696-
OPPOSITION- L. Garcia Aranda et al., "Experiments and simulation of hot stamping of quenchable steels", Advanced Technology of Plasticity, vol. 2, (20020000), pages 1135 - 1140, XP055520785-
OPPOSITION- L. Gehringhoff, "Neueste Trends und Entwicklungen in der Warmumformung", 6th Euro- pean Conference: aluminum and steel forming in automotive engineering, (20050217), pages 171 - 176, XP055518190-
OPPOSITION- L. Gracia Aranda et al., "Etude expérimentale et simulation de l'emboutissage à chaud des aciers trempables", Matériaux, (20020000), XP055520791-
OPPOSITION- LUCIA GARCIA-ARANDA, "Etude thermo-mecanique et modelisation numerique de I' emboutissage a chaud de l'U sibor 1500, these", (20040126), pages 1 - 181, URL: https://pastel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00443614/document, XP055519080-
OPPOSITION- Manfred Geiger, Marion Merklein, Cornelia Hoff, Forschung fur die Praxis P 644 - Auslegung des Prozessfensters für die Blechumformung höchstfester Vergütungsstähle bei erhöhten Temperaturen ( Determination of the process windodw for hot stamping), Verlag und Vertriebsgesellschaft mbH, Düsseldorf, (20060000), pages 1 - 76, ISBN 3-937567-42-9-
OPPOSITION- Marthias Liewald, "Presshärten von USIBOR 1500 P: Simulationsbasierte Bauteil- und Pro- zessanalyse", ''Neuere Entwicklungen in der Blechumformung, (20060509), XP055518165-
OPPOSITION- MASAYOSHI SUEHIRO ET AL, "Properties of aluminium-coated steels for hot forming", NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT, no. 88, pages 16 - 21, XP002393305-
OPPOSITION- Masayoshi SUEHIRO ET AL., "Properties of Aluminum-coated Steels for Hot-forming", NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT, (20030700), no. 88, pages 16 - 21, XP002393305-
OPPOSITION- M.A. van den Nieuwenhof, A. Bahrami, S. Wiegersma, "TNO Report 0100288444 - Analysis on hot-formed coated steel samples", TNO, (20150820), pages 1 - 26, XP055516337-
OPPOSITION- MERKLEIN, M. et al., "Einflussgrößen im Presshärteprozess", MERKLEIN, M. et al., Reimund Neugebauer, CBC 2005, 4. Chemnitzer Karosseriekolloquium, Flexibilität im Karosseriekonzept, Verlag Wissenschaftliche Scripten, (20051100), pages 3-5, 137 - 153, XP055516425-
OPPOSITION- MERKLEIN, M. et al., "Einflussgrößen im Pressharteprozess", MERKLEIN, M. et al., Reimund Neugebauer, Flexibilität im Karosseriekonzept-Schlüssel zum Markt oder Kostenfalle? (Flexibility in Car Body Concepts - Key to New Market Share or Potential Trap?) 4. Chemnitzer Karosseriekolloquium (The 4th Chemnitz Car Body Colloquium), Verlag Wissenschaftliche Scripten, (20050000), pages 3-5, 137 - 153, ISBN 3-937524-33-9, XP055516425-
OPPOSITION- Merklein M ET AL., "Neuere Entwicklungen zum Umformung hoechstfester Stahlwerkstoffe", EFB TAGUNGS, ( ), vol. 25, pages 119 - 133, XP009098693-
OPPOSITION- M. Merklein et al., "Investigation of the thermo-mechanical properties of hot stamping steels", Journal of Materials Processing Technology, (20060700), vol. 177, pages 452 - 455, XP0005552768-
OPPOSITION- "Neuzulassungen von Personenkraftwagen nach Marken und Modellreihen", KBA, (20050000), pages 1 - 24, URL: https://www.kba.de/DE/Statistik/Produktkatalog/produkte/Fahr-zeuge/fz10/fz1 0_gentab.html, XP055518245-
OPPOSITION- PALAND, E.-G., "Technisches Taschenbuch", INA, (20020000), page 241, XP055518213-
OPPOSITION- P. HEIN, Y. Dahan, "Hot Stamping of USIBOR 1500 P: Part and Process Analysis Based on Numerical Simulation", P. HEIN, Y. Dahan, Mathias Liewald, New Developments in Sheet Metal Forming, (20060000), pages v, 163 - 175, XP055516319-
OPPOSITION- "Product description: USIBOR 1500", USINOR Auto Groupe USINOR, (20030221), pages 1 - 11, URL: www.usino- rauto.com/v_anglaise/produits/fiches/a_usibor1 .htm, XP055518150-
OPPOSITION- " Product range - Product description: USIBOR hEAT-TREATABLE manganese-boron steel, bare of precoated", USINOR Auto, Groupe USINOR, (20020429), URL: http://www-usinorauto.com/v_anglaise/produits/fiches/a_usibor1.htm-
OPPOSITION- Prof. Dr. Habil Ing., "Chemnitzer Karosseriekolloquium ( The 4th Chemnitz Car Body Colloquium)", Institut Werkzeugmaschinen und Umformtechnik, (20051108), pages 137 - 153, XP055518189-
OPPOSITION- RAVIER P, Aranda L G, Chastel Y, "Hot Stamping Experiment and Numerical Simulation of Pre-coated USIBOR1500 Quenchable Steels", JSEA 20037138 (SAE 2003-01-2859), (20031000), pages 261 - 266, XP055516331-
OPPOSITION- Ravier P, Aranda L G, Chastel Y, "Hot Stamping Experiment and Numerical Simulation of Pre-coated USIBOR1500 Quenchable Steels", JSEA 20037138 (SAE 2003-01-2859), (20031001), pages 261 - 266, XP055516331-
OPPOSITION- RAVIER, P. et al., "Hot Stamping Experiment And Numerical Simulation of Pre-coated USIBOR1500 Quenchable Steels", JSAE 20037138 SAE 2003-01-2859, (20031027), pages 261 - 266, XP055516331-
OPPOSITION- R. Kefferstein, "Development of saftey and structural automotive parts by hot-stamping: "USIBOR" 1500" SOLUTION", Acier pour l'indutrie automobile, La Rvue de Metallurgie- ATS-JSI, (20040000), XP055520796-
OPPOSITION- SUEHIRO, M. et al., "Properties of aluminium-coated steels for hot-forming", Nippon Steel Technical Report, (20030700), XP002393305-
OPPOSITION- Taylan ALTAN, "Hot-stamping boron-alloyed steels for automotive parts - Part II: Microstructure, material strength changes during hot stamping", Stamping Journal, (20070100), pages 14 - 15, XP055516356-
OPPOSITION- Turetta A. et al., "Testing material formability in hot stamping operations", pages 99 - 104, XP055519468-
OPPOSITION- Wilsius J; Hein; Kefferstein, "Status and future trends of hot stamping of USIBOR 1500P®", Tagungsband zum 1.e Erlanger Workshop Warmblechumformung 2006, (20061231), pages 1 - 20, XP055285190-
OPPOSITION- WINKEL , JÖRG, "Quetten zum Presshärten von Stahlblech im Automobilbau", GASWÄRME International, (20040000), vol. 53, no. 7, pages 402 - 405, XP055516351-
OPPOSITION- Zulassungsbescheinigungen ''Citroen C5, VF7 DE 4HXB76075211, Erstzu- lassung 2001-
OPPOSITION- Zulassungsbescheinigungen ''Citroen C5 VF7RC4HXE76658312 , Erstzu- lassung 2005-
OPPOSITION- Merklein ET AL., "Investigation of the thermo-mechanical properties of hot stamping steels", JOURNAL OF MATERIALS PROCESSING TECHNO - ELSEVIER, vol. 177, no. 1-3, (20060703), pages 452 - 455, XP005552768
OPPOSITION- M. MERKLEIN et al., "Investigation of the thermal-mechanical properties of hot stamping steels", Journal of Materials Processing Technology, (20060621), vol. 177, no. 1, pages 452 - 455, XP028807743
OPPOSITION- M. MERKLEIN et al., "Investigation of the thermal-mechanical properties of hot stamping steels", Journal of Materials Processing Technology, (20060703), vol. 177, no. 1-3, pages 452 - 455, XP005552768
OPPOSITION- Merklein M. et al, "Characterisation of the Flow Properties of the Quenchenable Ultra High Strength Steel 22MnB5", CIRP ANNALS, vol. 55, (20060000), pages 229 - 232, XP022135435
OPPOSITION- "High Strength Steels for Automotive Safety Parts", SAE Technical Paper, XP055518530
OPPOSITION- "Development of pre-coated boron steel for applications on PSA Peugeot Citroen and Renault bodies in white", Konferenzbeitrag ''IBEC 2003'' und SAE Technical Paper Series 2002-01-20 48, (20020709), XP055518158
OPPOSITION- VAISSIERE, L. et al., Development of pre-coated boron steel for applications on PSA Peugeot Citroen and RENAULT bodies in white, (20020000), XP055518158
OPPOSITION- Vaissiere L; Et Al, "Development of pre-coated boron steel for applications on PSA Peugeot Citroen and Renault bodies in white", Konferenzbeitrag ''IBEC 2003'' und SAE Technical Paper Series 2002-01-20 48, (20020000), pages 1 - 12, XP055518158

Download Citation Report

Get a free citation report including examiner, opposition, and international search citations.

Get Citation Report

Dossier Documents

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent’s prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent’s legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Date

    Description

  • Get instant alerts for new documents