The weekly litigation news digest is live. Subscribe now
The patent EP2459310 was granted to Cristal USA on Dec 15, 2021. The application was filed on Sep 7, 2010 under application number EP10803976A. The patent is currently recorded with a legal status of "Granted And Under Opposition".

Patent oppositions filed by competitors challenge the validity of a granted patent. These oppositions are typically based on claims of prior art, lack of novelty, or non-obviousness. They are a key part of the process for determining a patent's strength and enforceability.
| Company | Opposition Date | Representative | Opposition Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| UMICORE | Sep 14, 2022 | VOSSIUS & PARTNER PATENTANWALTE RECHTSANWALTE MBB | ADMISSIBLE |
| VENATOR GERMANY | Sep 12, 2022 | SEYER & NOBBE PATENTANWALTE PARTMBB | ADMISSIBLE |
Patent citations refer to prior patents cited during different phases such as opposition or international search.
| Citation Phase | Publication Number |
|---|---|
| DESCRIPTION | US2003129153 |
| INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORT | US2003129153 |
| INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORT | US2007129241 |
| INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORT | US4221768 |
| INTERNATIONAL-SEARCH-REPORT | US4547557 |
| OPPOSITION | DE69701859T |
| OPPOSITION | EP0225062 |
| OPPOSITION | US2003103889 |
| OPPOSITION | US2003129153 |
| OPPOSITION | US2007003464 |
| OPPOSITION | US2007129241 |
| OPPOSITION | US4221768 |
| OPPOSITION | US4547557 |
| OPPOSITION | US4725572 |
| OPPOSITION | US6956006 |
| OPPOSITION | WO0220407 |
| OPPOSITION | WO2008024635 |
| OPPOSITION | WO2009027433 |
The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.
Date
Description
Get instant alerts for new documents
Dec 18, 2025
Dec 18, 2025
Dec 3, 2025
Dec 3, 2025
Dec 3, 2025
May 20, 2025
May 20, 2025
May 16, 2025
(Electronic) Receipt
Appeal
May 16, 2025
May 16, 2025
Apr 16, 2025
Apr 16, 2025
Apr 11, 2025
(Electronic) Receipt
Appeal
Apr 11, 2025
Apr 11, 2025
Reply to appeal
Appeal
Dec 13, 2024
Dec 13, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
(Electronic) Receipt
Appeal
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Dec 9, 2024
Sep 16, 2024
Sep 16, 2024
Sep 16, 2024
Sep 11, 2024
(Electronic) Receipt
Appeal
Sep 11, 2024
Sep 11, 2024
Notice of appeal
Appeal
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Means of redress
OPPO
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 12, 2024
Aug 8, 2024
Jun 4, 2024
May 31, 2024
May 31, 2024
May 29, 2024
May 29, 2024
May 29, 2024
Apr 12, 2024
Apr 12, 2024
Apr 10, 2024
Apr 10, 2024
Apr 8, 2024
Apr 8, 2024
Apr 8, 2024
Apr 5, 2024
Apr 5, 2024
Apr 5, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 4, 2024
Apr 3, 2024
Apr 3, 2024
Apr 3, 2024
Apr 3, 2024
Feb 26, 2024
Feb 26, 2024
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Oct 9, 2023
Jun 26, 2023
Jun 26, 2023
Jun 26, 2023
Apr 12, 2023
Apr 12, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Apr 5, 2023
Dec 19, 2022
Dec 19, 2022
Dec 19, 2022
Dec 14, 2022
Dec 14, 2022
Dec 14, 2022
Oct 4, 2022
Oct 4, 2022
Sep 28, 2022
Sep 28, 2022
Sep 28, 2022
Sep 28, 2022
Sep 28, 2022
Sep 27, 2022
Sep 27, 2022
Sep 27, 2022
Sep 21, 2022
Sep 16, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 14, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Sep 12, 2022
Jan 5, 2022
Nov 18, 2021
Decision to grant a European patent
Search/Exam
Nov 3, 2021
(Electronic) Receipt
Search/Exam
Nov 3, 2021
Filing of the translations of the claims
Search/Exam
Nov 3, 2021
French translation of claims
Search/Exam
Nov 3, 2021
German translation of the claims
Search/Exam
Nov 3, 2021
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
Aug 13, 2021
Aug 5, 2021
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
Aug 5, 2021
Jul 12, 2021
Jul 12, 2021
Jul 12, 2021
Intention to grant (signatures)
Search/Exam
Jul 12, 2021
Text intended for grant (clean copy)
Search/Exam
Jul 12, 2021
Aug 10, 2020
(Electronic) Receipt
Search/Exam
Aug 10, 2020
Amended claims with annotations
Search/Exam
Aug 10, 2020
Claims
Search/Exam
Aug 10, 2020
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
Aug 10, 2020
Jul 23, 2020
Annex to the communication
Search/Exam
Jul 23, 2020
Communication from the Examining Division
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
(Electronic) Receipt
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Amended claims with annotations
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Amended description with annotations
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Claims
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Description
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
Jan 22, 2020
Oct 11, 2019
Annex to the communication
Search/Exam
Oct 11, 2019
Communication from the Examining Division
Search/Exam
Sep 26, 2019
Examination started
Search/Exam
Jun 14, 2019
Jun 4, 2019
Jun 4, 2019
May 24, 2019
(Electronic) Receipt
Search/Exam
May 24, 2019
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
May 24, 2019
May 24, 2019
Sep 1, 2016
Sep 1, 2016
Amended claims with annotations
Search/Exam
Sep 1, 2016
Amendments received before examination
Search/Exam
Sep 1, 2016
Letter accompanying subsequently filed items
Search/Exam
Mar 8, 2016
Feb 18, 2016
Feb 18, 2016
European search opinion
Search/Exam
Feb 18, 2016
Information on Search Strategy
Search/Exam
Feb 18, 2016
Supplementary European search report
Search/Exam
Jan 12, 2016
Search started
Search/Exam
Sep 2, 2015
Aug 14, 2015
Oct 11, 2013
Oct 7, 2013
Jun 26, 2013
Jun 6, 2013
Submission concerning representation
Search/Exam
May 16, 2012
May 9, 2012
May 3, 2012
Apr 25, 2012
Enquiry with the International Bureau
Search/Exam
Mar 16, 2012
Feb 14, 2012
Feb 2, 2012
(Electronic) Receipt
Search/Exam
Feb 2, 2012
Feb 2, 2012
Request for entry into the European phase
Search/Exam
Dec 7, 2011
Information on entry into European phase
Search/Exam
Sep 22, 2011
Jun 6, 2011
Annex
Search/Exam
May 26, 2011
Copy of the international search report
Search/Exam
May 26, 2011
Mar 25, 2011
Annex
Search/Exam
Mar 22, 2011
Annex
Search/Exam
Feb 3, 2011
Annex
Search/Exam
Feb 3, 2011
Published international application - A2
Search/Exam