IP Verse

Sustainable Cleaning Agents And Detergents - EP2592134

The patent EP2592134 was granted to Compad Consulting on Nov 2, 2022. The application was originally filed on Dec 12, 2011 under application number EP11405367A. The patent is currently recorded with a legal status of "Granted And Under Opposition".

EP2592134

COMPAD CONSULTING
Application Number
EP11405367A
Filing Date
Dec 12, 2011
Status
Granted And Under Opposition
Sep 30, 2022
Publication Date
Nov 2, 2022
External Links
Slate, Register, Google Patents

Patent Summary

Patent Family

Patent Family

Patent Oppositions

Patent oppositions filed by competitors challenge the validity of a granted patent. These oppositions are typically based on claims of prior art, lack of novelty, or non-obviousness. They are a key part of the process for determining a patent's strength and enforceability.

CompanyOpposition DateRepresentativeOpposition Status

Get instant alerts for new oppositions and patent status changes

WERNER & MERTZAug 2, 2023EISENFUHR SPEISERADMISSIBLE

Patent Citations (47) New

Patent citations refer to prior patents cited during different phases such as opposition or international search.

Citation PhasePublication Number
DESCRIPTIONCH699230
EXAMINATIONCH699230
OPPOSITIONCN1215160C
OPPOSITIONDE202006007594U
OPPOSITIONDE60111770T
OPPOSITIONEP1964543
OPPOSITIONEP2008708
OPPOSITIONEP2865740
OPPOSITIONPL206552B
OPPOSITIONUS2004127380
OPPOSITIONUS860485
OPPOSITIONUS86702
OPPOSITIONUSH1635H
OPPOSITIONWO2009020546
OPPOSITIONWO2010061239
OPPOSITIONWO2010061240
OPPOSITIONWO2018029069
OPPOSITIONWO9528236
SEARCHCN101225349
SEARCHEP0673992
SEARCHEP2428556
SEARCHFR2954778
SEARCHFR2959753
SEARCHGB1186411
SEARCHGB2319256
SEARCHJP2009185139
SEARCHJPH03153800
SEARCHJPH10316999
SEARCHJPH11246348
SEARCHUS2002010104
SEARCHUS2005184273
SEARCHUS2006019866
SEARCHUS2007238780
SEARCHUS2009054298
SEARCHUS2011124544
SEARCHUS3083143
SEARCHUS5656585
SEARCHWO0077135
SEARCHWO0183665
SEARCHWO0202731
SEARCHWO2005121291
SEARCHWO2006007741
SEARCHWO2007051337
SEARCHWO9003419
SEARCHWO9533027
SEARCHWO9817750
SEARCHWO9823808

Non-Patent Literature (NPL) Citations (143) New

NPL citations refer to non-patent references such as research papers, articles, or other publications cited during examination or opposition phases.

Citation PhaseReference Text
OPPOSITION- "1-Dodecanol", Wikipedia, (20100607), Wikipedia, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Dodecanol, XP093169043
OPPOSITION- Abrahm Lustgarten, "Palm Oil Was Supposed to Help Save the Planet. Instead It Unleashed a Catastrophe.", New York Times Magazin, (20181120), pages 1 - 22, New York Times Magazin, URL: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/20/magazine/palm-oil-borneo-climate-catastrophe.html, XP093167588
OPPOSITION- Albert Koechlin, "Umweltfreundliche Waschmittel der Good Soaps AG, Luzern und die Elektrolastwagen der E-Force One AG, Beckenried werden mit dem Umweltpreis 2019 der Albert Koechlin Stiftung ausgezeichnet", ALBERT KOECHLIN STIFTUNG, (20190327), ALBERT KOECHLIN STIFTUNG, XP093168696
OPPOSITION- "Alcohol Ethoxylates", HERA Human & Environmental Risk Assessment on ingredients of European household cleaning products, (20090901), pages 1 - 244, HERA Human & Environmental Risk Assessment on ingredients of European household cleaning products, URL: https://www.heraproject.com/files/34-F-09%20HERA%20AE%20Report%20Version%202%20-%203%20Sept%2009.pdf, XP093168945
OPPOSITION- "Alcohol Ethoxysulphates (AES) Environmental Risk Assessment", Human & Environmental Risk Assessment on ingredients of European household cleaning products, (20041225), pages 1 - 36, Human & Environmental Risk Assessment on ingredients of European household cleaning products, URL: https://www.heraproject.com/files/1-E-04-HERA%20AES%20ENV%20%20web%20wd.pdf, XP093168968
OPPOSITION- Anatol Helb, "Erfinderin lässt Lehrbücher alt aussehen ", Institut für Geistiges Eigentum - IGE/IPI, (20230426), Institut für Geistiges Eigentum - IGE/IPI, URL: https://www.ige.ch/index.php?eID=tx_cabaghtml2pdf&URL=%2Fde%2Fblog%2Fblog-artikel%2Ferfinderin-laesst-lehrbuecher-alt-aussehen%3Fpdf%3D1&page_uid=19963&signature=e077b931f58ee8b5becb228b96db8565c6f7e9d9d6b55cd00ba297d7445c3c84, XP093167597
OPPOSITION- Andreas Weber-Mußmann, "Butanole", Römpp Chemie Lexikon, (20230101), Römpp Chemie Lexikon , URL: https://roempp.thieme.de/lexicon/keywordoftheweek, XP093168289
OPPOSITION- Anna Lif , Martin Hellsten, "Nonionic Surfactants Containing an Amide Group D20", (19980101), pages 177 - 199
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "1-Hexadecanol", Wikipedia, (20240128), Wikipedia, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=1-Hexadecanol&oldid=241629077, XP093260900
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "1-Octadecanol", Wikipedia, (20211106), Wikipedia, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=1-Octadecanol&oldid=217043348, XP093260899
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Alkohole", Anonymous, Karl Heinz Wallhäußer, Praxis der Sterilisation Desinfektion - Konservierung, Georg Thieme Verlag, (19950101), pages 469 - 469, ISBN 978-3-13-416305-6, XP093191613
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Alkylierung", Anonymous, Jurgen Falbe , Manfred Regitz, Rompp Lexikon Chemie, Georg Thieme Verlag, (19960101), pages 116 - 117, ISBN 978-3-13-107830-8, XP093099199
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Basic Soaps", Anonymous, Coney Norma, The Complete Soapmaker , Sterling Pub Co Inc, (19960101), pages 1 - 9, ISBN 978-0-8069-4868-3, XP093099350
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Bereitung ber festen Seife", Anonymous, Carl Leuchs, Der europaische Seifen-Fabrikant, Verlag von C. Leuchs und Co, (18350101), pages 122 - 127, XP093099752
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Castile Soap Recipe - 100% Olive Oil Soap", (20110818), pages 1 - 2, Soaprecipes101, URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20110818234558/http://www.soaprecipes101.com/homemade-soap-recipes/castile-soap-recipe-100-olive-oil-soap/, (20231109), XP093099818
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Chemische Desinfektionsmittel ", Anonymous, Schneiderbaur Alfred, Lehrbuch der inneren medizin fur schwestern, Wien , Springer-Verlag , (19610101), pages 219 - 219, XP093191612
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Die Schmierseifen", Anonymous, Carl Deite, Handbuch der Seifenfabrikation: Hausseifen, Textilseifen und Seifenpulver , Julius Springer Verlag, (19170101), pages 319 - 327, XP093099745
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Empfehlung zur Qualitätsbewertung für Badezimmerreiniger", SÖFW-Journal, (20030101), vol. 129, pages 62 - 70, XP093099389
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Empfehlung zur Qualitatsbewertung fur saure WC-Reiniger ", lndustrieverbandes Korperpflege- und Waschmittel e,V. (IKW), (19990101), pages 1 - 5, XP093099405
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, ""fatty acids"", IUPAC Compendium of Chemical terminology "Gold Book", (20060101), XP093168973
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Fettsauren", Anonymous, Jurgen Falbe , Manfred Regitz, Rompp Lexikon Chemie, Georg Thieme Verlag, (19970101), pages 1324 - 1327, ISBN 3-13-734710-6, XP093099190
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Fluorölsäure", Wikipedia, (20240212), Wikipedia, URL: ttps://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fluorölsäure&oldid=242132410, XP093260895
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Flüssigwaschmittel ", (20081203), pages 1 - 2, Ecover, URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20081203065543/www.ecover.com/ch/de/Products/Laundry/20050704+LQW+D.htm, (20231109), XP093099762
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Kohlevergasung", Anonymous, Jurgen Falbe , Manfred Regitz, Rompp Lexikon Chemie, Georg Thieme Verlag, (19970101), pages 2202 - 2203, ISBN 978-3-13-107830-8, XP093099250
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Meister Proper kann Held nichts vormachen", Saldo, (20110511), pages 18 - 19+21, XP093191607
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Methoden zur Bestimmung der Reinigungsleistung von maschinellen Geschirrspulmitteln", SOFW journal, DE , (20060307), vol. 132, no. 03, ISSN 0942-7694, pages 55 - 70, XP001240096
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "N,N-Dimethyldodecylamine N-oxide", Sigma Aldrich- SAFETY DATA SHEET a, (20240103), Sigma Aldrich- SAFETY DATA SHEET a, XP093168704
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Nouracid LE 80 Safety data sheet ", Oleon, (20230128), pages 1 - 11, XP093171131
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Olivenölseife Pure Olive", (20070308), pages 1 - 2, waschkultur, URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20070308063525/www.waschkultur.de/sensitiv/sensitiv/pureolive.htm, (20231109), XP093099779
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Saponine", Anonymous, J. Falbe & M. Regitz, Römpp-Lexikon Chemie, Stuttgart , Georg Thieme Verlag , (19990101), pages 3928 - 3929, ISBN 978-3-13-734610-4, XP093099772
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Tenside", Anonymous, Jürgen Falbe, Manfred Regitz, Rompp-Lexikon: Chemie, Stuttgart, Georg Thieme Verlag , (19990101), pages 4434 - 4440, ISBN 978-3-13-734610-4, XP093099777
OPPOSITION- Barrelerio Paula , "European plant-based surfactants as building blocks for sustainable consumer products", Frosch, (20201201), pages 1 - 12, XP093191608
OPPOSITION- Bernd Sonnberger, "4.4 Kohlendioxidbilanz und Resourcenschonung", Umweltaspekte der Reinigungschemie, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, (20000101), page 114, ISBN 978-3-8169-1821-9, XP093168263
OPPOSITION- Bertrand Matthäus, "Verhalten von verschiedenen Speiseölen während des Frittierens", Institut für Lipidforschung der Bundesanstalt für Ge-treide-, Kartoffel und Fettforschung, (20020101), Institut für Lipidforschung der Bundesanstalt für Ge-treide-, Kartoffel und Fettforschung, URL: https://www.ufop.de/files/2713/3879/4162/Abschlussber_Matthaus.pdf, XP093167589
OPPOSITION- Bond Annie B, " Washing Wood: Linseed Oil Soaps", (20101231), pages 1 - 3, Care2, URL: https://web.archive.Org/web/20101231075323/http://www.care2.com/greenlivinq/washing-wood-linseed-oil.html , (20231109), XP093099741
OPPOSITION- Bundesanstalt Für Arbeitsschutz Und Arbeitsmedizin (baua), "AMINES, TALLOW ALKYL, (Z)-OCTADEC-9-ENYLAMINE, OCTADECYLAMINE, AMINES, HYDROGENATED TALLOW ALKYL, AMINES, COCO ALKYL", EU RISK ASSESSMENT - PRIMARY ALKYL AMINES, Risk Assessment, (20081001), page 20, EU RISK ASSESSMENT - PRIMARY ALKYL AMINES, Risk Assessment, XP093168942
OPPOSITION- Claudia Kasper, "Naturseufenherstellung nach dem kaltverfahren", Claudia Kasper, Claudia Kasper, Verlag Freya, (20070101), pages 1 - 132, ISBN 978-3-902540-10-2
OPPOSITION- Cornelia Von Däniken, "Waschen mit europäischem öl", FrauenLand, (20190613), vol. 2019, no. 3, XP093168995
OPPOSITION- D311 - Gottschalck, Tara E. et al., "International Cosmetic Ingredient Dictionary and Handbook - Eintrag für PEG-4 Rapeseedamide " Personal Care Products Council, 2010, Ed. 13 ISBN: 1-882621-47-6
OPPOSITION- D314 - Stellungnahme Prof. Dr. Birgit Glüsen vom 7. Februar 2025
OPPOSITION- D315 - Anlage 1 zu D 314_Fettalkohole Fauth
OPPOSITION- "Determination of Monoglycerides and Glycerol", DGF Standard Methods Section C -Fats Replaces C-VI 5 (61) C-VI 5 (02), (20051001), pages 1 - 7, DGF Standard Methods Section C -Fats Replaces C-VI 5 (61) C-VI 5 (02), XP093168731
OPPOSITION- Deutscher Bundestag, "Bericht der Enquete-Kommission “Chancen und Risiken der Gentechnologie“ gemäß Beschlüssen des Deutschen Bundestages — Drucksachen 10/1581, 10/1693 — Deutscher Bundestag 10. Wahlperiode ", Deutscher Bundestag 10. Wahlperiode, (19870106), page 50. 53, Deutscher Bundestag 10. Wahlperiode, XP093168982
OPPOSITION- Dgf-Fachgruppe, "DGF-Einheitsmethoden", Deutsche Einheitsmethoden zur Untersuchung von fetten, Fettprodukten, Tensiden und verwandten Stoffen, Stuttgart, Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, (20060701), XP093169068
OPPOSITION- Dittmar-Ilgen Hannelore, "Fettlöser für den Haushalt selber herstellen", (20110202), pages 1 - 3, Web archive , URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20110205065214/https://www.helpster.de/fettloeser-fuer-den-haushalt-selber-herstellen_22690, (20231108), XP093099303
OPPOSITION- Eberhard Breitmaier, "18 Carbonsäuren und ihre Derivate", Organische Chemie: Grundlagen, Stoffklassen, Reaktionen, Konzepte, Molekülstruktur, Stuttgart, York New, Thieme Georg Verlag, (20050101), page 260, XP093168307
OPPOSITION- Edgar Endlein, "Nachhaltiges Innovationsmanagement im Mittelstand", Open Innovation in der Praxis Erfahrungen, Fallbeispiele, Erfolgsmethoden Herausgeber, Symposion Publishing, (20140101), pages 159 - 169, XP093168991
OPPOSITION- Edgar Endlein, "Tenside auf Basis europäischer Pflanzen", Werner & Mertz, Nachhaltigkeitsbericht 2013/2014, (20130101), page 22, Werner & Mertz, Nachhaltigkeitsbericht 2013/2014, XP093168975
OPPOSITION- Edgar E Woollatt, "The oils and fats; their nature, storage and pretreatmen", THE MANUFACTURE OF SOAPS, OTHER DETERGENTS AND GLYCERINE, John Wiley & Sons, (19850101), page 144, XP093169002
OPPOSITION- Elizabeth B. Goldsmith, Betsy Sheldon, Green Cleaning for DUMmIES, Wiley Publishing, Inc, (20090101), pages 1 - 290, ISBN 978-0-470-39106-8
OPPOSITION- Elizabeth Letcavage, Basic. SOAP MAKING All the Skills and Tools You Need to Get Started, Stackpole Books, (20090101), pages 1 - 134, ISBN 10-0-8117-3573-7
OPPOSITION- Eugen Müller, "Alkyl", Houben-Weyl Methods of Organic Chemistry 4t h Edition Editorial Board, STUTTGART, GEORG THIEME VERLAG , (19730101), page 367, XP093168281
OPPOSITION- Europäische Kommission, "BESCHLUSS (EU) 2017/1217 DER KOMMISSION vom 23. Juni 2017 zur Festlegung der Umweltkriterien für die Vergabe des EU-Umweltzeichens für Reinigungsmittel für harte Oberflächen", Amtsblatt der Europäischen Union, (20170712), pages L 180/45 - L 180/46, XP093168740
OPPOSITION- F. D. Gunstone, "1.2.2 Esters", Oleochemical Manufacture and Applications, Wiley & Sons, (20010101), page 5, XP093168680
OPPOSITION- Fereidoon Shahidi, "Vegetable Oils", Oil Crops, Handbook of Plant Breeding, Springer Science+Business Media, (20090101), page 256, XP093169020
OPPOSITION- Fisher David, "Where to Buy Lye", Candle & Soap Making - About.com, (20111017), pages 1 - 1, Candle & Soap Making - About.com, URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20111017062335/http:/candleandsoap.about.com/od/coldprocesssoapmaking/a/lyesources.htm, XP093249069
OPPOSITION- Franois Merklen, Die Kernseifen; ihre Zusammensetzung und Fabrikation vom Standpunkte der physikalischen Chemie, Verlag von Wilhelm Knapp, (19070101), pages 1 - 133
OPPOSITION- Gisela Boeck, "3.2.2 Die Klassifizierung organischer Verbindungen", Kurzlehrbuch Chemie, Georg Thieme Verlag, (20080701), page 93, XP093168276
OPPOSITION- Gordon L Hollis, Surfactants Europa A Directory of Surface Active Agents available in Europe, The Royal Society of Chemistry, (19950101), pages 1 - 479, ISBN 0-85404-804-9
OPPOSITION- "Greenbentin-XES/070 Rapeseed oil fatty acids, methyl esters, ethoxylated with approx. 7 EO", KLK OLEO Technical Data Sheet, (20160210), pages 1 - 1, XP093191605
OPPOSITION- Gregory Remez, "Revolution in der Waschküche Konsum Eine Luzerner Firma hat eine neue Technologie zur Herstellung von Waschmitteln entwickelt. Unterstützt wurde sie dabei von der Klimastiftung Schweizwegen ihres Beitrags zur Reduktion von COz-Emissionen", Luzerner Zeitung, (20180620), XP093168996
OPPOSITION- Günter Wagner, "Rohstoffe", Waschmittel, WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, (20100101), page 293, ISBN 978-3-527-32678-5, XP093168266
OPPOSITION- Gunter Wagner, Waschmittel, WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co., (20100101), pages 1 - 346, ISBN 978-3-527-32678-5
OPPOSITION- Harold Hart, "15.3 Verseifung von Fetten und Ölen", Organische Chemie. , WILEY-VCH, (19990101), page 531, ISBN 978-3-527-30379-3, XP093169006
OPPOSITION- Hossein Janshekar, "Table 10", INDUSTRIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL CLEANERS, SPECIALTY CHEMICALS • SRI CONSULTING, (20101001), XP093168709
OPPOSITION- Hossein Janshekar, "Table 38 (continued)", INDUSTRIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL CLEANERS, SPECIALTY CHEMICALS • SRI CONSULTING, (20101001), pages 100 - 101, XP093168716
OPPOSITION- H. P. Latscha , H. A. Klein, Organische Chemie Chemie - Basiswissen II, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg GmbH, (19820101), pages 1 - 570, ISBN 978-3-540-10814-6
OPPOSITION- Hreczuch W, Mittelbach, M., Holas, J., Soucek, J., Bekierz, G., "Produkcja i główne kierunki przemysłowego wykorzystania estrów metylowych kwasów tłuszczowych", Przemyst chemiczny, (20000101), vol. 79, no. 4, page 111+113, XP093191606
OPPOSITION- J.Falbe, Surfactants in Consumer Products, Springer Berlin, Heidelberg, (19870101), pages 1 - 556, doi:10.1007/978-3-642-71545-7
OPPOSITION- Johann Vollmann, "Table 4.2 Variation of seed lipid composition in different types of oilseed rape (B. napus)", Oil Crops, New York, NY, Springer New York, (20100101), page 99, ISBN 978-0-387-77594-4, XP093169074
OPPOSITION- J. P. Kass and G. O. Burr, "Linoleyl Alcohol II Preparation, Properties, and Rearrangement", American Chemical Society, (19400101), vol. 62, pages 1796 - 1798, XP009560141
OPPOSITION- Jürgen Falbe, ""Alkene" und "Alkine "", Jürgen Falbe, FALBE J., REGITZ M., RÖMPP CHEMIE LEXIKON, STUTTGART NEW YORK , GEORG THIEME VERLAG , (19900101), pages 1343 - 1345, 016837, ISBN 978-3-13-734709-5, XP093168277
OPPOSITION- Jürgen Falbe, "Octanol", Jürgen Falbe, Jürgen Falbe , Manfred Regitz, Römpp Chemie Lexikon, STUTTGART, NEW YORK , GEORG THIEME VERLAG , (19910101), page 3083, ISBN 978-3-13-734909-9, XP093168985
OPPOSITION- "Kerosin", Wikipedia, der freien Enzyklopädie, (20110815), Wikipedia, der freien Enzyklopädie, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerosin, XP093169081
OPPOSITION- Kirk, "SURFACTANTS", Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology (4th Edition), Editing by Watcher, (20010101), pages 232 - 233, XP093169037
OPPOSITION- Klaus Sommer, "Isomere Kohlenstoffverbindungen", Chemie in Übersichten, Aulis Verlag Deubner & Co KG, (19760101), page 94, ISBN 978-3-7614-0318-1, XP093168287
OPPOSITION- "Kosmetika, Inhaltsstoffe, Funktionen, Hintergrundin-formationen für Verbraucher", Industrieverband Körperpflegeund Waschmittel e.V, (20130601), pages 1 - 111, Industrieverband Körperpflegeund Waschmittel e.V, URL: https://www.ikw.org/fileadmin/IKW_Dateien/downloads/Schoenheitspflege/2013_Kos_Inh_Funk.pdf, XP093168939
OPPOSITION- "Kraft-Fettreiniger: Empfehlungen zur Qualitätsbewertung (2017)", Industrieverband Körperpflege- und Waschmittel e. V., (20170101), Industrieverband Körperpflege- und Waschmittel e. V., URL: https://www.ikw.org/haushaltspflege/wissen/kraft-fettreiniger-empfehlungen-zur-qualitaetsbewertung-2017, XP093249427
OPPOSITION- Lars Gotsch, "Ausgezeichnetes Luzerner Startup soll Erfindung gestohlen haben", Regionaljournal Zentralschweiz - News, (20200915), Regionaljournal Zentralschweiz - News, URL: https://www.srf.ch/news/schweiz/patentstreit-vor-gericht-ausgezeichnetes-luzerner-startup-soll-erfindung-gestohlen-haben#:~:text=Patentstreit%20vor%20Gericht%20Ausgezeichnetes%20Luzerner,deutscher%20Konzern%20dieses%20f%C3%BCr%20sich.&text=Im%20Mai%202019%20konnte%20das,Koechlin%2DStiftung%20gewonnen%20zu%20haben., XP093168692
OPPOSITION- Leusink L, C Boer , "Ingredients in highly concentrated washing-up liquids : a comparison", SÖFW. Journal, (19930101), vol. 119, no. 13, pages 810 - 818, XP093099785
OPPOSITION- Lühs Wilfried, Thierfelder Andreas , Friedt Wolfgang, "Raps-eine alternative Olquelle", Spiegel der Forschung, (20080317), pages 2 - 7, XP093099279
OPPOSITION- "Lutensol® AO 7", BASF - Sicherheitsdatenblatt, (20180529), pages 1 - 15, BASF - Sicherheitsdatenblatt, XP093168962
OPPOSITION- Mabel Harriet Norris, "CLXI1.-A Study of the Rate of Saponification of Oils and Fats by Aqueous Alkali under Various Conditions. ", J. Chem. Soc., Trans., (19220101), vol. 121, pages 1362 - 1375, XP093168738
OPPOSITION- Maren Meyer, "Schlussakt im Seifen-Streit Putzund Waschmittel ohne Palmöl Vor Gericht kämpft die Firma Good Soaps gegen die deutsche Werner & Mertz. Beide wollen eine bahnbrechende Erfindung gemacht haben", Sonntagszeitung CH, Wirtschaft, (20220123), XP093168940
OPPOSITION- Martin Brust, "Der Frosch ist auf dem Sprung", Frankfurter Rundschau, Wirtschaft, (20190107), pages 1 - 3, Frankfurter Rundschau, Wirtschaft, URL: https://www.fr.de/wirtschaft/frosch-sprung-11045398.html, XP093167592
OPPOSITION- Maurice R Porter, "2.5.1 The hydrophilic group", HANDBOOK OF SURFACTANTS, Media Springer Science+business, Associates, (19910101), page 11, ISBN 978-1-4757-1295-7, XP093168262
OPPOSITION- Michael and Irene Ash, Michael and Irene Ash, Michael and Irene Ash, Handbook of Green Chemicals, 2nd Edition, Synapse Information Resources, Inc., (20040101), page 819, ISBN 1-890595-79-9, XP009559404
OPPOSITION- Mikael Kjellin , Ingegärd Johansson, Sufactants from Renewable Resources, John Wiley and Sons, Ltd., (20100101), pages 1 - 343, ISBN 9780470760413
OPPOSITION- Miller Kathy, ""Traditional Methods" Working from Old Lye Company Instructions", (20111031), pages 1 - 15, Web Archive , URL: https://web.archive.org/web/20111031014151/WWW.MILLERSOAP.COM/PENNWALTETC.HTML, (20231108), XP093099343
OPPOSITION- Möhle Lothar , "Der 68. SEPAWA® CONGRESS, die 17. European Detergents Conference und die Cosmetic Science Conference", SOFW Journal, (20220217), pages 1 - 5, XP093191610
OPPOSITION- "Nouracid LE 80 ", Oleon, (20230128), pages 1 - 11, XP093191615
OPPOSITION- "Olivenöl nativ extra Ph. Eur. 11.0 Herkunft: Spanie", Gustav Heess Oleochemische Erzeugnisse GmbH - Produkt-Spezifikation, (20230310), pages 1 - 2, Gustav Heess Oleochemische Erzeugnisse GmbH - Produkt-Spezifikation, URL: https://www.heessoils.com/, XP093168928
OPPOSITION- "Olivenöl raffiniert Ph. Eur. 11.0", Gustav Heess Oleochemische Erzeugnisse GmbH - Produkt-Spezifikation, (20230602), pages 1 - 2, Gustav Heess Oleochemische Erzeugnisse GmbH - Produkt-Spezifikation, URL: https://www.heessoils.com/, XP093168931
OPPOSITION- "Oxo Alcohols. OUR OXO ALCOHOLS FOR YOUR INDIVIDUAL APPLICATION", EVONIK - Flyer, (20200929), EVONIK - Flyer, URL: https://c4-chemicals.evonik.com/product/performance-intermediates/downloads/flyer_oxo-alcohols_evonik_performance_intermediates_es.pdf, XP093168959
OPPOSITION- "PEG-4 Rapeseedamide", TARA E GOTTSCHALCK; GERALD N MCEWEN (EDITORS), INTERNATIONAL COSMETIC INGREDIENT DICTIONARY AND HANDBOOK, CTFA 13th Ed, WASHINGTON , PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS COUNCIL , (20100101), pages 2152 - 2153, ISBN 1-882621-47-6, XP009561580
OPPOSITION- Polieren Anonymous, "Polieren", Wikipedia, (20240123), Wikipedia, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polieren, XP093169009
OPPOSITION- "Politur", Duden, (20130101), Duden, URL: https://www.duden.de/rechtschreibung/Politur, XP093169007
OPPOSITION- Redaktion Lz, "Frosch hüpft der Konkurrenz davon", Lebensmittelzeitung, (20130315), Lebensmittelzeitung, URL: https://www.lebensmittelzeitung.net/industrie/nachrichten/Frosch-Huepft-Konkurrenz-davon-98249, XP093167598
OPPOSITION- Regine Schneider, "About Regine Schneider", WIPO, (20030509), WIPO, XP093168687
OPPOSITION- Regine Schneider, "Table of content", Regine Schneider, Regine Schneider, Synthese alpha-(2-8)-verknüpfter Disialoside, Konstanz, DE, Hartung-Gorre, (19980101), pages 1 - 6, ISBN 3-89649-334-5, XP009559401
OPPOSITION- "Reiniger aus Sonnenblumenöl", Nachrichten aus der Chemie, Industrie + Technik Reiniger aus Sonnenblumenöl, (20211001), vol. 69, page 47, XP093169028
OPPOSITION- "Reinigung (Instandhaltung)", Wikipedia, (20101004), Wikipedia, URL: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinigung_(Instandhaltung)#:~:text=Reinigung%20(oder%20das%20Reinigen%20bzw,(Ordnung)%20und%20%C3%A4sthetische%20Gesichtspunkte., XP093168987
OPPOSITION- Renkin M , Fleurackers , I Szwach , W Hreczuch, "Rapeseed Methyl Ester Ethoxylates: A New Class of Surfactants of Environmental and Commercial Interest", Tenside, Surfactants , Detergents, DE , (20050901), vol. 42, no. 5, ISSN 0932-3414, pages 280 - 287, XP001235608
OPPOSITION- S. Claude, "Oleochemistry as an opportunity to consolidate the sustainable development of European oil crops - an updated prospect. ", CAB Direct, (20240101), CAB Direct, XP093168274
OPPOSITION- Seite 262 und 263 aus Bailey ́s Industrial Oil & Fat Products
OPPOSITION- "SIDS Initial Assessment Report For SIAM 22", OECD SIDS, (20060401), page 1, 6, OECD SIDS, XP093168707
OPPOSITION- Silvia Dreide, "Heimische Alternativen", Werner & Mertz, Nachhaltigkeitsbericht 2010/2011, (20100101), page 16, Werner & Mertz, Nachhaltigkeitsbericht 2010/2011, XP093168979
OPPOSITION- S. Krist, G. Buchbauer, C. Klausberger, Lexikon der pflanzlichen Fette und Öle, New York, Springer, (20080101), pages 1 - 533, ISBN 978-3-211-75606-5
OPPOSITION- ".Soap Manufacture in Two Volumes", J Davidson, Technical Soaps, (19530101), pages 427 - 437
OPPOSITION- Steffen Noleppa, "Auf der Ölspur. Berechnungen zu einer palmölfreieren Welt", WWF, (20160701), pages 1 - 92, WWF, URL: https://www.wwf.de/fileadmin/fm-wwf/Publikationen-PDF/WWF-Studie_Auf_der_OElspur.pdf, XP093168272
OPPOSITION- Subirats N, P. Castan , "PEG-4 Rapeseedamide A »Unique« Low Viscous Concentrated Ethoxylated Fatty Acid Monoethanolamide for Personal Care", SOFW-Journal, (20110101), vol. 137, pages 60 - 66, XP093099795
OPPOSITION- Susan Miller, "CHAPTER 3 Lye and Water", The Natural Soap Book. MAKING Herbal and Vegetable-Based Soaps, Storey Publishing, (19950101), page 31, XP093168999
OPPOSITION- Tilley F W., J. M. Schaffer, "Germicidal Efficiency of Coconut Oil and Linseed Oil Soaps and of Their Mixtures with Cresol", The Journal of Infectious Diseases, (19250930), vol. 37, no. 4, pages 359 - 367, XP093099832
OPPOSITION- Vincent Eckert, "Erstes palmölfreies Waschmittel auf Basis europäischer Pflanzenöle Klimaschutz in der Waschküche", Klimastiftung Schweiz - Medienmitteilung, (20180609), Klimastiftung Schweiz - Medienmitteilung, XP093168701
OPPOSITION- Wachs W, "Fette und Lipoide (Lipide), Wachse, Harze", Wachs W, Josef Schormüller, Die Bestandteile der Lebensmittel, Berlin, Springer-Verlag , (19650101), pages 320 - 320, ISBN 978-3-642-46012-8, XP093099287
OPPOSITION- Werner & Mertz, "ZEIT WISSEN- Preis „Mut zur Nachhaltigkeit“ für Werner & Mertz", Werner & Mertz - Pressetexte, (20160303), Werner & Mertz - Pressetexte , URL: https://www.cossma.com/business/article/zeit-wissen-preis-mut-zur-nachhaltigkeit-fuer-werner-mertz-33666.html, XP093168684
OPPOSITION- W Hreczuch, "Ethoxylated Rapeseed Oil Acid Methyl Esters as New Ingredients for Detergent Formulations", Tenside , Surfactants , Detergents, (20010301), vol. 38, no. 2, ISBN 0932-3414, pages 72 - 79, XP001005064
OPPOSITION- Wolfgang Werther, "Vorlesungsverzeichnis Lebensmittelanalytik - II (SS 2008)", Universität Wien, (20080603), Universität Wien, XP093168934
OPPOSITION- Woollatt, Edgar, "Chapter 3: The oils and fats; their nature, storage and pretreatment ", Woollatt, Edgar, Edgar Woollatt, The Manufacture of Soaps, other Detergents and Glycerine, Ellis Horwood Limited, (19850101), pages 118 - 151, ISBN 0-85312-567-8, XP009559403
OPPOSITION- Eduard Smulders, "Laundry Detergents", Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co, (20070101), pages 1 - 184, doi:10.1002/14356007.a08_315.pub2, XP055931384
OPPOSITION- Rob. Henriques, "Über partielle Verseifung von Ölen und Fetten II", Angewandte Chemie, Wiley - V C H Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, DE, DE , (18980726), vol. 11, no. 30, doi:10.1002/ange.18980113003, ISSN 0044-8249, pages 697 - 702, XP093167595
OPPOSITION- Behr A., Westfechtel A., Pérez Gomes J., "Catalytic Processes for the Technical Use of Natural Fats and Oils", Chemical Engineering & Technology, Hoboken, USA, (20080501), vol. 31, no. 5, doi:10.1002/ceat.200800035, ISSN 0930-7516, pages 700 - 714, XP055896100
OPPOSITION- Dirk W. G. Develter; Luc M. L. Lauryssen, "Properties and industrial applications of sophorolipids", European Journal of Lipid Science Technology, DE , (20100419), vol. 112, no. 6, doi:10.1002/ejlt.200900153, ISSN 1438-7697, pages 628 - 638, XP072140848
OPPOSITION- Roland Verhé, "Dilemma: Petrochemistry and oleochemistry as resources for fuel and oleochemicals", European Journal of Lipid Science Technology, WILEY VCH VERLAG, WEINHEIM., DE, DE , (20100421), vol. 112, no. 4, doi:10.1002/ejlt.201000088, ISSN 1438-7697, pages 427 - 427, XP072141412
OPPOSITION- M.W. Sulek ; A. Bocho-Janiszewska, "The effect of ethoxylated esters on the lubricating properties of their aqueous solutions", Tribology Letters, Ne , (20061115), vol. 24, no. 3, doi:10.1007/s11249-006-9140-6, ISSN 1573-2711, pages 187 - 194, XP019454990
OPPOSITION- Brent Flickinger, Noboru Matsuo, "Nutritional Characteristics of DAG Oil", Lipids, (20030101), vol. 38, no. 2, doi:10.1007/s11745-003-1042-8, pages 129 - 132, XP055305367
OPPOSITION- Hark Sander, Härröd Magnus, Møller Poul, "Hydrogenation of fatty acid methyl esters to fatty alcohols at supercritical conditions", Journal of the American Oil Chemists Society, DE , (19990101), vol. 76, no. 11, doi:10.1007/s11746-999-0151-y, ISSN 0003-021X, pages 1363 - 1370, XP093099323
OPPOSITION- Frankel, E.N., "Chemistry of free radical and singlet oxidation of lipids", Progress in Lipid Research, FR , (19840101), vol. 23, no. 4, doi:10.1016/0163-7827(84)90011-0, ISSN 0163-7827, pages 197 - 221, XP023450393
OPPOSITION- Brondz, I. , "Lipids. Fatty Acids", Brondz, I. , Paul Worsfold, Alan Townshend, Colin Poole, Encyclopedia of Analytical Science, Elsevier, (20050101), pages 76 - 88, doi:10.1016/B0-12-369397-7/00310-1, ISBN 978-0-12-369397-6, XP009560970
OPPOSITION- Portarena S.; Gavrichkova O.; Lauteri M.; Brugnoli E., "Authentication and traceability of Italian extra-virgin olive oils by means of stable isotopes techniques", Food chemistry, Elsevier Ltd., NL, NL , (20140512), vol. 164, doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2014.04.115, ISSN 0308-8146, pages 12 - 16, XP028861043
OPPOSITION- Piekoszewski W, Szczerek M, Tuszynski W, "The action of lubricants under extreme pressure conditions in a modified four-ball tester", Wear, CH , (20010501), vol. 249, no. 3-4, doi:10.1016/S0043-1648(01)00555-5, ISSN 0043-1648, pages 188 - 193, XP093099309
OPPOSITION- Ravasio, N. Zaccheria, F. Gargano, M. Recchia, S. Fusi, A. Poli, N. Psaro, R., "Environmental friendly lubricants through selective hydrogenation of rapeseed oil over supported copper catalysts", Applied Catalysis A: General, ELSEVIER, AMSTERDAM, NL, AMSTERDAM, NL , (20020710), vol. 233, no. 1-2, doi:10.1016/S0926-860X(02)00128-X, ISSN 0926-860X, pages 1 - 6, XP004367098
OPPOSITION- Pel Axel, "Fatty acids: a versatile and sustainable source of raw materials for the surfactants industry", OCL, (20010301), vol. 8, no. 2, doi:10.1051/ocl.2001.0145, ISSN 1258-8210, pages 145 - 151, XP093099314
OPPOSITION- "Fakten zur Verwendung von Palm(kern)ölen in Wasch-, Pflegeund Reinigungsmitteln in Deutschland ", IKW - FORUM WASCHEN - FAKTENPAPIER, doi:10.1162/108819803323059398/pdf, (20130328), IKW - FORUM WASCHEN - FAKTENPAPIER, URL: https://www.ikw.org/fileadmin/IKW_Dateien/downloads/Haushaltspflege/HP_PalmkernoelinWPRProduktenV4.pdf, XP093168976
OTHER- "Klaron Handreinigungscreme weiß", SicherheitsdatenblattKlaron Handreinigungscreme weiß, (20061103), pages 1 - 4, URL: http://www.igefa.de/mediadatenNeu/pdf_dinblaetter/2033628.pdf, XP055263285
OTHER- Michael and Irene Ash, Handbook of Green Chemicals. 2nd ed., Synapse Information Resources, (20040000), page 819, XP055263243
OTHER- "Nature Hair & Body", Plum Sicherheitsdatenblatt, (20100709), pages 1 - 3, XP055263290
OTHER- "Nonionic Surfactants Containing an Amide Group", Nico M. van Os, Nonionic Surfactants. Group Organic Chemistry, MARCEL Dekker, (19980000), pages 177 - 184, XP055263245
OTHER- "Produktinformationsblatt Handelsprodukt", AMIDET® TEC N, URL: http://www.kaochemicals-eu.com/sites/default/files/tds/5578063c45a48amidet-20tec-20n-e.pdf, XP055263257
SEARCH- DAIO A ET AL, "Manufacture of transparent gel-like soap used as toilet soap, involves mixing olive oil, palm oil, castor oil, coconut oil, water and potassium hydroxide, followed by performing saponification, adding ethanol, heating and cooling", WPI / THOMSON,, (20081224), vol. 2009, no. 3, XP002585097 [X] 1-4,7,10-13 * abstract * [Y] 9
SEARCH[ ] - DATABASE WPI, 0, Derwent World Patents Index, vol. 1999, no. 07, Database accession no. 1999-076722, XP002697771 & JPH10316999 A 19981202 (KAO CORP) [ ] * abstract *
SEARCH- DATABASE WPI, 0, Derwent World Patents Index, vol. 2008, no. 70, Database accession no. 2008-L87393, XP002697772 & CN101225349 A 20080723 (GUO J) [Y] 9,13 * abstract *
SEARCH[ ] - Vishwanath Patil, Torsten K�llqvist, Elisabeth Olsen, Gjermund Vogt, Hans R. Gislerod, "Fatty acid composition of 12 microalgae for possible usein aquaculture feed", Aquacult Int (2007), (20060627), Springer, URL: http://moritz.botany.ut.ee/~olli/b/Patil07.pdf, (20121112), XP002688544 [ ] * table 3 *

Download Citation Report

Get a free citation report including examiner, opposition, and international search citations.

Get Citation Report

Dossier Documents

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent’s prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent’s legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Date

    Description

  • Get instant alerts for new documents