IP Verse

Method Of Producing A Containerboard From Pulp Comprising Nssc Pulp - EP3026173

The patent EP3026173 was granted to Billerudkorsns on Dec 7, 2022. The application was originally filed on Nov 26, 2014 under application number EP14194891A. The patent is currently recorded with a legal status of "Patent Maintained As Amended".

EP3026173

BILLERUDKORSNS
Application Number
EP14194891A
Filing Date
Nov 26, 2014
Status
Patent Maintained As Amended
Nov 4, 2022
Grant Date
Dec 7, 2022
External Links
Slate, Register, Google Patents

Patent Summary

Patent Family

Patent Family

Patent Oppositions (4)

Patent oppositions filed by competitors challenge the validity of a granted patent. These oppositions are typically based on claims of prior art, lack of novelty, or non-obviousness. They are a key part of the process for determining a patent's strength and enforceability.

CompanyOpposition DateRepresentativeOpposition Status

Get instant alerts for new oppositions and patent status changes

MONDIJan 5, 2018CUNOWADMISSIBLE
SMURFIT KAPPA IRELANDJan 5, 2018FRKELLYADMISSIBLE
PAPERJan 5, 2018FISH & RICHARDSON PCWITHDRAWN
STORA ENSO OYJJan 5, 2018FORSTMEYERWITHDRAWN

Patent Citations (13) New

Patent citations refer to prior patents cited during different phases such as opposition or international search.

Citation PhasePublication NumberPublication Link
OPPOSITIONDE29923284U
OPPOSITIONEP0219643
OPPOSITIONEP2022891
OPPOSITIONJP2008031585
OPPOSITIONUS6322667
OPPOSITIONUS6730192
OPPOSITIONUS8142615
OPPOSITIONWO2004038095
OPPOSITIONWO2013050436
OPPOSITIONWO9509946
SEARCHDE29923284U
SEARCHEP2022891
SEARCHWO9509946

Non-Patent Literature (NPL) Citations (77) New

NPL citations refer to non-patent references such as research papers, articles, or other publications cited during examination or opposition phases.

Citation PhaseReference TextLink
OPPOSITION- "1 CARCANO. Semi-chemical Fluting Liner paper machine with (with) NSSC Pulp-Plant and Waste Paper Stock Preparation, 2600 mm", Wotol, (20110111), pages 1 - 8, URL: https://www.wotol.com/1-carcano-semi-chemical-fluting-liner-paper-machin/second-hand-machinery/prod_id/233884, XP055450276-
OPPOSITION- Anon: Neue Pressenpartie erhöht die Kapazität, 2014-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "1 CARCANO. Semi-chemical Fluting Liner paper machine with (with) NSSC Pulp-Plant and Waste Paper Stock Preparation, 2600 mm, 112-240 gr / sqm, 300 tpd", WOTOL, (20110124), URL: https://www.wotol.com/1-carcano-semi-chemical-fluting-liner-paper-machin/second- hand-machinery/prod id/233884, XP055450276-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "1 CARCANO. Semi-chemical Fluting Liner paper machine with (with) NSSC Pulp-Plant and Waste Paper Stock Preparation, 2600 mm, 112-240 gr / sqm, 300 tpd", WOTOL, (20120417), URL: https://web.archive.0rg/web/20120417235910/https://www.wotol.com/1-carcano-semi- chemical-fluting-liner-paper-machin/second-hand-machinery/prodid/233884, (20180104), XP055451882-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Optimization of machine properties for compressive strength: survey of factors affecting compressive strength", Project 2695-22, report one: a progress report to the Fourdrinier Kraft Board Group of the American Paper Institute, (19820315), pages 1 - 54, XP055451584-
OPPOSITION- Anonymous, "Paper and board - Compressive strangth - Short-span test", ISO 9895:2008(E), (20081015), XP055451662-
OPPOSITION- Back. Multistage press drying of paper, 1979-
OPPOSITION- Back. Press drying compared to other means of densifying paper. 1985-
OPPOSITION- Back. The properties of NSSC-based and waste based corrugating. 1989-
OPPOSITION- Back, Using the wet press to optimize paper properties, 1987-
OPPOSITION- BALA PANCHAPAKESAN, "Press, dryer section operation affected by recycled fiber use", Pulp & Paper, (19960400), vol. 70, no. 4, pages 115 - 118, XP055451551-
OPPOSITION- B. PANCHAPAKESAN, "Press, Dryer Section Operation Affected by Recycled Fiber Use", Materials Science & Engineering Database, (19960400), vol. 70, no. 4, pages 115 - 118, XP055451551-
OPPOSITION- Cepi ContainerBoard, Liste der Europaischen Wellpappenpapiere, 2012-
OPPOSITION- "Chapter 6 Structural mechanics of paper board", Papermaking Science and Technology, vol. 16, pages 210 - 213, ISBN 952-5216-16-0, XP055451648-
OPPOSITION- C. ZOTTERMAN, "New shoe press design now operational on world's largest linerboard machine", Papermakers Conference Proceedings, (19930000), pages 311 - 318, XP055451816-
OPPOSITION- C. ZOTTERMAN, "The new shoe press in operation at Obbola, Gruvon, Pori and Kemsley mills", Paper Technology, (19940500), pages 18 - 23, XP055451818-
OPPOSITION- DAVE LANGE, "Shoe pressing of paper grades", Papermakers Conference, (19960000), pages 437 - 440, XP055451568-
OPPOSITION- DAVID LANGE et al., "Experiences with various shoe press applications", Materials Science & Engineering Database, (20060900), vol. 107, no. 9, pages 22 - 24, XP055451557-
OPPOSITION- DAVID V. LANGE, "Shoe presses and their application to recycled fibers", Engineering Conference, (19910000), pages 51 - 54, XP055451562-
OPPOSITION- D. I. ORLOFF et al., "Linerboard drying on a sheet-fed pilot impulse drying shoe press", Tappi Journal, (19950100), vol. 78, no. 1, pages 129 - 141, XP000486103-
OPPOSITION- Dix and Roffael: Halbzellstoffe nach dem NSSC-Verfahren aus Pappelholz. 1989-
OPPOSITION- D. LANGE et al., "Experiences with various shoe press applications", Pulp & Paper, Canada, (20060900), vol. 107, no. 9, pages 22 - 24, XP055451557-
OPPOSITION- D. LANGE, "Shoe Pressing of Paper Grades", Papermakers Conference Proceedings, (19960000), pages 437 - 440, XP055451568-
OPPOSITION- D. V. LANGE, "Shoe Presses and their Application to Recycled Fibers", TAPPI Proceedings, 1991 Engineering Conference, (19910101), pages 51 - 54, XP055451562-
OPPOSITION- E. BACK et al., "Multistage press drying of paper", Svensk Papperstidning, (19790000), pages 35 - 39, XP055451899-
OPPOSITION- E. BACK, "Using the Wet Press to Optimise Paper Properties", Pap. Technol. Ind., (19870400), vol. 28, no. 3, pages 454 - 455, XP055451807-
OPPOSITION- E.J. JUSTUS et al., "Extended Nip-Presse - Experimentelle und praktische Anwendung", Das Papier, (19820000), vol. 36, pages V152 - V158, XP055451896-
OPPOSITION- E. L. BACK et al., "The properties of NSSC-based and waste based corrugating", Paper Technology, (19891000), pages 16 - 23, XP055451580-
OPPOSITION- EN 643. List of Grades of Paper and Board for Recycling. 2013-
OPPOSITION- English translation of D32-
OPPOSITION- English translation of D32 - Figures-
OPPOSITION- ERNST L. BACK, "Press drying compared to other means of densifying paper", Tappi Journal, (19850300), vol. 68, no. 3, pages 92 - 96, XP055451658-
OPPOSITION- Flyer PMP, Intelli-Nipshoe Press, 2018-
OPPOSITION- Fourdrinier Kraft Board Group, Optimization of machine properties, 1982-
OPPOSITION- Glossary of Papermaking Terms, (20180104), URL: www.pita.org.uk/images/PDF/Glossary of Terms.pdf-
OPPOSITION- Glossary of papermaking terms, undated-
OPPOSITION- Hendry et al, Paper drying under z-direction restraint..., 1987-
OPPOSITION- "Intelli-Nip® Shoe Press", PMP Group, (20180103), URL: http://www.pmpgroup.com/technology/paper/new-sections/intelli-nip-shoe-press.html#/sigProldd90bc2d613, XP055450284-
OPPOSITION- I. PIKULIK et al., "The effects of shoe pressing on the properties of wood-containing papers", TAPPI JOURNA L, (20000800), vol. 83, no. 8, XP055451814-
OPPOSITION- ISO 4046-1, 2002-
OPPOSITION- ISO 534:2011(E)-
OPPOSITION- ISO 9895, 2008-
OPPOSITION- JOHN SPACHMAN, "Not Just Hot Air", PaperAge, (20070500), pages 30 - 32, XP055451575-
OPPOSITION- Justus et al.. Extended Nip-Presse, 1982-
OPPOSITION- Lange. Experiences with various shoe press applications, 2006-
OPPOSITION- Lange. Shoe presses and their application to recycled fibers. 1991-
OPPOSITION- Lange, Shoe pressing of paper grades, 1996-
OPPOSITION- Lavrov et al. The influence of Fiber Composition..., 2011. Including English translation-
OPPOSITION- Machine translation of JP 2008031585 A-
OPPOSITION- M. GUNILLA, et al., "Note on the compression strength of fluting over a temperature and moisture range", Das Papier, (19850000), vol. 39, pages 302 - 305, XP055451789-
OPPOSITION- Mondi, Higher Performance..., undated-
OPPOSITION- Mondi. Investing in the future, undated-
OPPOSITION- Monica Öberg, personal declaration. 2018-
OPPOSITION- "Neuen Pressenpartie erhoht die Kapazitat", Wochenblatt fur Papierfabrikation, (20141000), pages 615 - 617, XP055451888-
OPPOSITION- Panchapakesan, Press Dryer Section Operation 1996-
OPPOSITION- Paper and Board Grades, 2000-
OPPOSITION- Papermaking Science and Technology. 1998-
OPPOSITION- Papnews. News from the paper industry sector. 2014-
OPPOSITION- Pikulik et al, The effects of shoe pressing. 2000-
OPPOSITION- "PMP Group successfully implements ist intelli-nip® shoe press in china", Papnews - News, (20140512), pages 1 - 9, URL: https://www.papnews.com/pmp-group-successfully-implements-1st-intelli-nip-shoe-press-in-china/, (20180103), XP055450291-
OPPOSITION- Richardson et al, Note on the compression strength of fluting..., 1985-
OPPOSITION- Rogut, Nowoczesne prasy a jakosc papieru, 2006-
OPPOSITION- R. ROGUT, "Nowoczesne prasy a jakosc papieru", Przeglqd Papierniczy, (20060900), pages 525 - 529, XP055451901-
OPPOSITION- Rydholm, Pulping Processes. 1965-
OPPOSITION- Shuohui cl.al.. A comparison of the effects of papermaking.... 2005-
OPPOSITION- Spachman, Not just hot air. 2007-
OPPOSITION- Summary of test results relating to commercially available flutings sold by BillerudKorsnas before the filing date-
OPPOSITION- Table of p.90 of D6 with calculated SCI’ index-
OPPOSITION- TAPPI Journal. Revisiting paper strength measurements.... 2007-
OPPOSITION- Test results in connection with D18-
OPPOSITION- Whitsitt, Compressive strength relationships and factors. 1985-
OPPOSITION- W. J. WHITSITT, "Compressive strength relationships and factors (IPC Technical Paper Series Number 163)", The Institute of Paper Chemistry, (19851000), XP055451602-
OPPOSITION- WOTOL/Carcano. Semi Chemical fluting liner paper. 2012-
OPPOSITION- WOTOL/Carcano. Semi Chemical fluting liner paper machine. 2011-
OPPOSITION- Zotterman. New shoe press design, 1993-
OPPOSITION- Zotterman: The new shoe press in Operation at Obbola..., 1994-
OPPOSITION- G. CERAGIOLI et al., "Paper drying under Z-direction restraint to improve the strength properties of short-fiber high-yield pulps (Contract n° BOS-055-I)", G. CERAGIOLI et al., I F Hendry, W J H Hanssens, Pulp, Paper and Board, ELSEVIER APPLIED SCIENCE PUBLISHERS LTD, pages 138 - 148, XP055451607

Download Citation Report

Get a free citation report including examiner, opposition, and international search citations.

Get Citation Report

Dossier Documents

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent’s prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent’s legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Date

    Description

  • Get instant alerts for new documents