Patent No. US10583397 (titled "Process control systems and methods for use with filters and filtration processes") on May 13, 2015. The application was issued on Mar 10, 2020.
’397 is related to the field of biopharmaceutical downstream processing, specifically the integration and control of tangential flow filtration (TFF) within a continuous or connected purification train. In protein production, unit operations like chromatography and viral filtration typically run at constant flow rates, whereas ultrafiltration naturally experiences a decline in permeate flux as the product concentrates. This mismatch traditionally requires large intermediate pool tanks to decouple the steps, which increases the facility footprint and risks product degradation during hold times.
The underlying idea behind ’397 is to synchronize the variable hydraulic performance of a filtration unit with the steady-state requirements of upstream purification steps through active feedback control. By monitoring the permeate flow rate in real-time, the system can dynamically adjust either the upstream supply or the filtration parameters—such as feed crossflow and transmembrane pressure—to maintain a balanced mass flow. This insight allows for the replacement of massive storage vessels with small surge tanks, enabling a truly connected process where fluid moves seamlessly from purification to final formulation.
The claims of ’397 focus on a process control system and method that links upstream processing units to a downstream TFF loop via a feedback loop based on permeate flow sensing. The independent claims cover four specific control architectures: (i) modulating upstream flow to match filtration flux, (ii) adjusting the TFF feed pump to force the permeate flux to match a constant upstream flow, (iii) a tiered approach that switches from pump control to upstream flow control at a limit, and (iv) a hybrid mode that allows tank volume to fluctuate once a pump threshold is reached.
In practice, the invention overcomes the concentration polarization effect, where a boundary layer of protein builds up on the membrane and slows down filtration. Instead of allowing this to stall the process, the control system uses a Constant Flow Strategy by ramping up the feed pump’s crossflow rate as the protein concentration rises. This increases the mass transfer coefficient, effectively 'pushing' the permeate through at a steady rate that matches the output of the preceding chromatography columns, thereby keeping the retentate tank level stable.
This approach differs from prior solutions by eliminating the need for discrete batch processing and the associated large-scale infrastructure. Traditional systems treat ultrafiltration as a standalone end-step, but this invention treats it as a dynamic component of a connected downstream process. By utilizing the stagnant film model to predict and counteract flux decline, the system achieves high-concentration formulation without the flow disparities that previously made continuous bioprocessing difficult to implement at scale.
In the mid-2010s when ’397 was filed, industrial bioprocessing systems were typically implemented using discrete unit operations where filtration, purification, and concentration stages functioned as independent batches. At a time when tangential flow filtration (TFF) was a standard method for cell separation and protein concentration, systems commonly relied on recirculating loops to achieve desired concentrations, which necessitated large hold tanks and complex manual balancing of volumes. Hardware and software constraints of the era made the real-time synchronization of upstream harvest rates with downstream filtration performance non-trivial, often resulting in significant volumetric bottlenecks when diafiltration was used to enhance product yield.
The disclosed invention represents a technical advancement through the architectural integration of a permeate-side sensing and control loop that dynamically links upstream processing units with downstream filtration stages. By utilizing a sensor at the permeate outlet to determine flow rates and automatically adjusting either the upstream processing flow or the feed pump speed, the system enables a continuous, synchronized flow that overcomes the technical constraint of concentration variability during diafiltration. This structural solution allows for the implementation of single-pass tangential flow filtration (SPTFF) in a manner that maintains a stable flow reduction factor despite changing feed concentrations, effectively enabling high-yield product recovery without the volumetric overhead typically associated with large-scale buffer exchange.
This patent contains 19 total claims, with claims 1, 7, and 13 serving as the independent claims. The independent claims focus on a process control system, a corresponding control method, and a protein purification process that utilize a sensor at a filter permeate outlet to dynamically adjust flow rates through upstream processing units or feed pumps to maintain system balance or manage tank volumes. The dependent claims serve to specify particular control configurations, such as decreasing upstream flow in response to permeate flow changes, establishing maximum flow rate thresholds, and incorporating protein formulation steps.
Definitions of key terms used in the patent claims.
US Latest litigation cases involving this patent.

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.
Get instant alerts for new documents