Internet search results annotation and filtering for missing search terms

Patent No. US10585959 (titled "Internet search results annotation and filtering for missing search terms") on Aug 28, 2019. The application was issued on Mar 10, 2020.

What is this patent about?

’959 is related to the field of Internet search engines and user interface enhancements. It specifically addresses the common frustration where search results point to webpages that lack the user's specified search terms or consist of low-value content like parked domains and link-heavy advertising sites. The invention aims to improve search efficiency by providing immediate visual feedback regarding the actual content of a result before a user commits to clicking the link.

The underlying idea behind ’959 is to perform a real-time analysis of search result targets to identify which specific search terms are missing from the landing page or its immediate children. Rather than relying on static indices that may be outdated, the system evaluates the live state of the webpage and its descendant webpages to determine if the user’s query is truly satisfied. This insight allows the system to bridge the gap between a search engine's keyword matching and the actual utility of the destination site.

The claims of ’959 focus on a system and method for generating automatically annotated search results that are transmitted to a user's device. The independent claims specifically protect the mechanism of inserting an annotation directly into a search result grouping—alongside the title or URL—that explicitly identifies which search term elements are missing from the referenced webpage. This annotation serves as a proactive relevance indicator, signaling to the user that a particular result may be less useful than it appears.

In practice, the invention works by deploying an analysis engine—either on a server, in the cloud, or as a browser plug-in—that visits the URLs in a search results list. It scans the text of these pages to verify the presence of the user's keywords. If a term is missing from the primary page but found on a sub-page, the system can flag this as a descendant completion, helping the user understand that the information is available but requires further navigation.

This approach differs from traditional search engines that often return results based on metadata or partial matches without warning the user of missing elements. By providing a visual shorthand or symbolic code for the composition of the site—such as identifying it as a price comparison site or an 'echo' site that merely parrots search terms—the invention allows users to filter out irrelevant 'linking sites' and focus on high-substance targets, significantly reducing wasted browsing time.

How does this patent fit in bigger picture?

Technical Landscape

Prosecution Position

Claims

This patent contains 25 claims, with claims 1, 11, and 20 serving as the independent claims. The independent claims focus on a system, method, and apparatus for providing annotated search results that identify specific search terms missing from a referenced webpage to indicate lower relevance to the user. The dependent claims serve to further define the technical implementation by specifying visual formatting for the annotations, incorporating search term analysis of descendant webpages, providing user-selectable filtering functions to remove incomplete results, and integrating advertisements within the annotated search results display.

Key Claim Terms New

Definitions of key terms used in the patent claims.

Term (Source)Support for SpecificationInterpretation
Annotation
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
The annotation is provided in response to a presence or absence of the one or more search term elements in the referenced webpage. The annotation comprises one or more search term elements missing in the referenced webpage and provides an indication that the automatically annotated Internet search result is less relevant with regard to what the user seeks. In addition to the search term element related annotations, background patterns or colors might be used to designate various webpage composition classifications.A visual or textual marker added to a search result that specifically identifies which search terms are missing from the referenced webpage to indicate lower relevance.
Automatically annotated Internet search result
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
A plug-in or software program running on the user's computer or on a compute server on the Internet, may analyze and scrutinize the search results being shown to the user and flag/annotate search results so the user will know in advance which links to avoid. The automatic scrutinizing and marking can be done starting with the links at the top of the page and successively marking search results going down the page as the analysis of each referenced URL is completed. Once a webpage has been analyzed according to the present invention, the search result grouping on search results webpage wherein the URL link to a specific webpage is located may be annotated to indicate its categorization as well as the presence of search term elements.A search result that has been programmatically modified to include visual indicators or text describing the content characteristics or the status of search terms within the linked webpage.
Missing in the referenced webpage
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
It is frequent that many of the search term elements will be missing from the results webpage and in some cases all will be missing. The annotation comprises one or more search term elements missing in the referenced webpage and provides an indication that the automatically annotated Internet search result is less relevant with regard to what the user seeks. Search term elements that are not present may be shown with white text on a black background.The status of specific search query keywords that are not found within the text or content of the primary webpage linked in the search result.
Referenced webpage
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
A plug-in or software program on the user's computer can analyze webpages located at URL links in the search results webpage to determine which sites comprise an unwanted site by automatically visiting each site in the list and running a quick analysis of the landing webpage. Analysis of webpages located at search results URL links (and descendant pages of those pages) may be viewed for example as falling into two major categories—a categorization of the information provided by the webpage, and the presence of search term elements on the webpage. The annotation is provided in response to a presence or absence of the one or more search term elements in the referenced webpage.The specific destination document or site identified by a URL link within a search result that is subjected to analysis for relevance and term presence.
Search result grouping
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
The automatically annotated Internet search result is provided for display on the search results webpage as a search result grouping referencing a webpage associated with the automatically annotated Internet search result. The search result grouping comprises an annotation and at least one of: a title, an Internet link, an excerpt, or a URL. Once a webpage has been analyzed according to the present invention, the search result grouping on search results webpage wherein the URL link to a specific webpage is located may be annotated to indicate its categorization as well as the presence of search term elements.A visual cluster of information on a search results page representing a single website entry, typically including a title, link, and descriptive metadata.
Search term elements
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
The basic format for specifying a search with any search engine includes an implied AND-function of the specified search term elements. A user may find that a webpage located at a URL link provided on a search results page not only contains irrelevant information given their intended search, it also doesn't contain the search terms that they had specified. Knowing in advance which webpages contain which search term elements would be useful to aid the user in minimizing lost time and frustration.The individual words, phrases, or components that constitute a user's search query, which are analyzed for their presence or absence within a target webpage.
Search term elements missing
(Claim 1, Claim 11, Claim 20)
It is frequent that many of the search term elements will be missing from the results webpage and in some cases all will be missing. The annotation comprises one or more search term elements missing in the referenced webpage and provides an indication that the automatically annotated Internet search result is less relevant with regard to what the user seeks. In addition to the search term element related annotations shown in [the figures], background patterns are used behind abbreviation letters to indicate where different colors might be used in an actual implementation.Specific components of the user's original search query that were not found during the analysis of the webpage referenced in the search result.

Litigation Cases New

US Latest litigation cases involving this patent.

Case NumberFiling DateTitle
1:25-cv-00514Apr 29, 2025Accusearch Technologies Llc V. Google Llc

Patent Family

Patent Family

File Wrapper

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Get instant alerts for new documents

US10585959

Application Number
US16553900A
Filing Date
Aug 28, 2019
Publication Date
Mar 10, 2020
External Links
Slate, USPTO , Google Patents