Machine Learning Based Prediction Of Human Interactions With Autonomous Vehicles

Patent No. US11126889 (titled "Machine Learning Based Prediction Of Human Interactions With Autonomous Vehicles") was filed by Piccadilly Patent Funding Llc As Security Holder on Mar 24, 2020.

What is this patent about?

’889 is related to the field of data analytics and, more specifically, to systems and methods for predicting how humans will interact with vehicles, particularly in the context of autonomous driving. Existing autonomous vehicle systems often struggle to accurately predict the behavior of pedestrians, cyclists, and other drivers, especially in complex urban environments. This deficiency can lead to unsafe driving conditions and hinder the widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles.

The underlying idea behind ’889 is to leverage the collective intelligence of human observers to train a machine learning model that can predict the state of mind and likely actions of road users. This is achieved by presenting human observers with images and video segments of road scenes, collecting their responses regarding the intentions and awareness of other road users in those scenes, and then using this data to train a supervised learning model . The trained model can then be used by an autonomous vehicle to predict the behavior of road users in real-time.

The claims of ’889 focus on a computer-implemented method for controlling an autonomous vehicle. The method involves receiving images of road scenes and user responses describing the state of mind of road users in those images. A training dataset of summary statistics is generated from the user responses and used to train a supervised learning model. The autonomous vehicle then receives a new image, predicts the state of mind of road users in the image using the trained model, and controls the vehicle based on this prediction.

In practice, the system captures video from a vehicle's camera and extracts frames or segments. These are presented to human observers, potentially with manipulations to highlight relevant aspects. The observers' responses, indicating their assessment of the road users' intentions (e.g., whether a pedestrian will cross the street), are aggregated into summary statistics. These statistics, along with the corresponding image data, are used to train a model, such as a deep convolutional neural network , to predict the state of mind of road users in new, unseen images.

This approach differs significantly from prior methods that rely solely on motion vectors or other kinematic data to predict behavior. By incorporating human judgment, the system can capture subtle cues and contextual information that are often missed by purely sensor-based approaches. The system can also be continuously improved by incorporating new data and feedback from human observers, leading to more accurate and reliable predictions of road user behavior and, ultimately, safer autonomous driving.

How does this patent fit in bigger picture?

Technical landscape at the time

In the late 2010s when ’889 was filed, autonomous driving technology was rapidly developing, at a time when machine learning models were increasingly being used for perception and decision-making in vehicles. Systems commonly relied on sensor data fusion from cameras, lidar, and radar to understand the environment, and when hardware or software constraints made real-time processing of complex models non-trivial.

Novelty and Inventive Step

The examiner approved the application because the prior art of record does not teach the claimed subject matter of claims 2, 12 and 21. Also, the closest prior art fails to anticipate the claimed invention.

Claims

This patent contains 20 claims, with independent claims 1, 2, and 12. The independent claims are directed to a computer system, a computer-implemented method, and a computer readable storage medium, all relating to controlling an autonomous vehicle based on a predicted state of mind of road users using a supervised learning model. The dependent claims generally elaborate on the method steps and features of the supervised learning model used in the independent claims.

Key Claim Terms New

Definitions of key terms used in the patent claims.

Term (Source)Support for SpecificationInterpretation
State of mind
(Claim 1, Claim 2, Claim 12)
“The predictions produced by the trained model comprise a set of predictions of the state of mind of road users that can then be used to improve the performance of autonomous vehicles, robots, virtual agents, trucks, bicycles, or other systems that operate on roadways by allowing them to make judgments about the future behavior of road users based on their state of mind.”A road user's intention, awareness, or willingness to perform an action, as perceived by human observers and represented in user responses. The model predicts summary statistics that characterize the distribution of human responses that predict the state of mind of a road user.
Summary statistics
(Claim 1, Claim 2, Claim 12)
“Summary statistics are generated based on the responses of all of the observers who looked at an image. Individual variability in responses to a given stimulus can be characterized in the information given by the observers to the learning algorithm. The summary statistics might include unweighted information from all observers, or might exclude observers based on extrinsic or intrinsic criteria such as the time it took an observer to respond, the geographical location of an observer, the observer's self-reported driving experience, or the observer's reliability in making ratings of a set of other images.”Aggregate data derived from user responses that describe the state of mind of road users displayed in images or video segments. These statistics are used to train a supervised learning model.
Supervised learning based model
(Claim 1, Claim 2, Claim 12)
“For example, the collection of images and statistics can be used to train a supervised learning algorithm, which can comprise a random forest regressor, a support vector regressor, a simple neural network, a deep convolutional neural network, a recurrent neural network, a long-short-term memory (LSTM) neural network with linear or nonlinear kernels that are two dimensional or three dimensional, or any other supervised learning algorithm which is able to take a collection of data labeled with continuous values and adapt its architecture in terms of weights, structure or other characteristics to minimize the deviation between its predicted label on a novel stimulus and the actual label collected on that stimulus using the same method as was used on the set of stimuli used to train that network.”A predictive model trained using a dataset of images and corresponding summary statistics of user responses. The model learns to predict summary statistics describing the state of mind of road users in new images.

Litigation Cases New

US Latest litigation cases involving this patent.

Case NumberFiling DateTitle
2:25-cv-00742Jul 23, 2025Perceptive Automata Llc V. Tesla, Inc.

Patent Family

Patent Family

File Wrapper

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Date

    Description

  • Get instant alerts for new documents

US11126889

PICCADILLY PATENT FUNDING LLC AS SECURITY HOLDER
Application Number
US16828823
Filing Date
Mar 24, 2020
Status
Granted
Expiry Date
Dec 4, 2037
External Links
Slate, USPTO, Google Patents