Navigating Autonomous Vehicles Based On Modulation Of A World Model Representing Traffic Entities

Patent No. US11520346 (titled "Navigating Autonomous Vehicles Based On Modulation Of A World Model Representing Traffic Entities") was filed by Piccadilly Patent Funding Llc As Security Holder on Jan 30, 2020.

What is this patent about?

’346 is related to the field of autonomous vehicle navigation and, more specifically, to predicting the behavior of traffic entities (pedestrians, cyclists, other vehicles) to improve the safety and naturalness of autonomous driving. Existing autonomous systems often struggle to accurately predict the intentions of these traffic entities, leading to erratic vehicle behavior such as sudden stops or unnecessary delays. This patent addresses the problem of predicting the behavior of traffic entities to enable safer and more human-like autonomous navigation.

The underlying idea behind ’346 is to leverage machine learning models trained on human observations to predict the 'hidden context' or internal state (intentions, awareness) of traffic entities. Instead of relying solely on motion parameters, the system uses images of traffic entities as input to a model that has been trained to mimic how humans interpret the behavior of other road users. This allows the autonomous vehicle to anticipate actions based on a more nuanced understanding of the situation.

The claims of ’346 focus on an autonomous vehicle receiving sensor data, generating a point cloud representation of its surroundings, identifying traffic entities, and then, for each entity, determining motion parameters and a 'hidden context' using a machine learning model. The system then determines a region in the point cloud where the traffic entity is expected to be within a certain time, and modifies this region based on the predicted hidden context. Finally, the autonomous vehicle navigates to maintain a safe distance from these modified regions.

In practice, the system uses sensors like cameras and lidars to perceive the environment. The images captured are fed into a machine learning model that outputs summary statistics representing the predicted hidden context of each traffic entity. This hidden context is then used to adjust the predicted future location of the traffic entity in the point cloud. For example, if the model predicts that a pedestrian intends to cross the street, the region representing their potential future location is extended in the crossing direction, causing the autonomous vehicle to adjust its path to maintain a safe distance.

This approach differentiates itself from prior solutions by incorporating human-like reasoning into the autonomous navigation system. Instead of simply reacting to observed motion, the system anticipates behavior based on predicted intentions. Furthermore, the system can adjust its behavior based on the confidence level of the hidden context prediction. For example, if the model is uncertain about a pedestrian's intentions, the system may adopt a more conservative approach, increasing the safety margin to avoid potential collisions.

How does this patent fit in bigger picture?

Technical landscape at the time

In the late 2010s when ’346 was filed, autonomous vehicle navigation was at a time when systems commonly relied on sensor data fusion from cameras and LiDAR to perceive the environment. At a time when path planning was typically implemented using a combination of rule-based systems and early machine learning models for object detection and prediction. When hardware or software constraints made real-time processing of high-resolution sensor data and complex prediction models non-trivial.

Novelty and Inventive Step

The claims were amended during prosecution. Some claims were rejected for obviousness over prior art combinations, and some claims were provisionally rejected for nonstatutory double patenting. The examiner withdrew the obviousness rejection after the applicant argued that the prior art did not disclose a machine learning model configured to output summary statistics of expected human responses describing a hidden context of a traffic entity. Claims 2-3, 11-12 and 20 were objected to as being dependent upon a rejected base claim. The application proceeded to allowance.

Claims

This patent contains 23 claims, with independent claims 1, 10, and 19. The independent claims are focused on a method, a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium, and a computer system, respectively, all relating to autonomous vehicle navigation that uses sensor data and machine learning to determine the hidden context of traffic entities and modify a region for navigation. The dependent claims generally elaborate on and refine the specifics of the independent claims.

Key Claim Terms New

Definitions of key terms used in the patent claims.

Term (Source)Support for SpecificationInterpretation
Hidden context
(Claim 1, Claim 10, Claim 19)
“Embodiments of the invention predict hidden context attributes associated with traffic entities that determine behavior of these traffic entities in the traffic. Hidden context includes factors that affect the behavior of such traffic entities, for example, a state of mind of a user represented by a traffic entity such as a pedestrian. A hidden context may represent a task that a user represented by the traffic entity is planning on accomplishing, for example, crossing the street or stepping on to the street to pick up some object.”A predicted state of mind, intention, or goal of a traffic entity, derived from a machine learning model trained on human responses to traffic scenarios.
Motion parameters
(Claim 1, Claim 10, Claim 19)
“According to another embodiment, an autonomous vehicle modifies a world model based on the hidden context predicted by a machine learning based model. Traffic entities are identified based on the sensor data. For each traffic entity, motion parameters describing movement of the traffic entity are determined.”Data describing the movement of a traffic entity.
Point cloud representation
(Claim 1, Claim 10, Claim 19)
“According to another embodiment, an autonomous vehicle modifies a world model based on the hidden context predicted by a machine learning based model. A point cloud representation of the surroundings of an autonomous vehicle is generated, for example, based on sensor data obtained by sensors of the autonomous vehicle.”A data structure representing the surroundings of the autonomous vehicle, generated from sensor data.
Summary statistics of expected human responses
(Claim 1, Claim 10, Claim 19)
“summary information about the responses of a large number of users (or human observers) presented with similar image, video, or text segments while the algorithm was being trained. summary statistics are generated based on the user responses. For example, the statistics may characterize the aggregate responses of multiple human observers to a particular derived stimulus.”Aggregated data representing how human observers would react to a traffic scenario, used to train the machine learning model for predicting the hidden context.
Traffic entities
(Claim 1, Claim 10, Claim 19)
“Embodiments of the invention predict hidden context attributes associated with traffic entities that determine behavior of these traffic entities in the traffic. The traffic entities represent non-stationary objects in the traffic in which the autonomous vehicle is driving, for example, a pedestrian, a bicycle, a vehicle, a delivery robot, and so on.”Non-stationary objects in the traffic in which the autonomous vehicle is driving, such as pedestrians, bicycles, or other vehicles.

Litigation Cases New

US Latest litigation cases involving this patent.

Case NumberFiling DateTitle
2:25-cv-00742Jul 23, 2025Perceptive Automata Llc V. Tesla, Inc.

Patent Family

Patent Family

File Wrapper

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.

  • Date

    Description

  • Get instant alerts for new documents

US11520346

PICCADILLY PATENT FUNDING LLC AS SECURITY HOLDER
Application Number
US16777673
Filing Date
Jan 30, 2020
Status
Granted
Expiry Date
Mar 31, 2040
External Links
Slate, USPTO, Google Patents