Patent No. US8652474 (titled "Composition comprising antibody that binds to domain II of HER2 and acidic variants thereof") on Jan 28, 2009. The application was issued on Feb 18, 2014.
’474 is related to the field of monoclonal antibody production and pharmaceutical chemistry, specifically focusing on the purification and characterization of HER2 antibodies. In the production of complex biologics, antibodies often exist as a mixture of a primary molecular form and various structural variants that arise during cell culture or processing. This patent addresses the specific challenge of managing charge heterogeneity, where certain antibody variants exhibit a more acidic profile than the intended main species.
The underlying idea behind ’474 is that while a therapeutic antibody composition inevitably contains molecular variants, these variants can be identified, quantified, and maintained within specific limits to ensure product consistency. The inventor’s key insight is that for the HER2-binding antibody Pertuzumab, the presence of specific acidic variants—including those that are glycated, deamidated, or structurally altered—does not negatively impact the drug's performance. By demonstrating that these variants possess nearly identical pharmacokinetics to the main species, the invention establishes a defined chemical profile for a safe and effective pharmaceutical formulation.
The claims of ’474 focus on a composition containing a main species HER2 antibody, defined by the specific amino acid sequences of Pertuzumab (SEQ ID Nos. 3 and 4), alongside a specific suite of acidic variants. These variants must include disulfide reduced and non-reducible forms, and in broader embodiments, also include glycated, deamidated, and sialylated versions. Crucially, the independent claims require that these acidic variants collectively constitute less than 25% of the total antibody composition.
In practice, the invention is implemented by monitoring the molecular distribution of the antibody using cation exchange chromatography, which separates the proteins based on their charge. The acidic variants are those that elute earlier than the main peak. The process involves preparing the antibody in a cell culture, evaluating the variant levels through analytical methods like mass spectrometry or capillary electrophoresis, and confirming that the variant threshold is not exceeded before combining the mixture with a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier.
This approach differs from prior art by providing a precise characterization of the Pertuzumab-specific variant profile rather than just general antibody mixtures. While previous methods might have viewed these variants as impurities to be eliminated, ’474 recognizes them as bioequivalent components that can remain in the final product. By proving that the acidic variants and the main species have essentially the same behavior within the body, the patent enables a more robust and predictable manufacturing process for HER2-positive cancer treatments.
In the late 2000s when ’474 was filed, the production of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies was typically implemented using large-scale mammalian cell culture systems that inherently generated a heterogeneous mixture of protein products. At a time when biopharmaceutical characterization commonly relied on identifying primary amino acid sequences, the industry faced significant engineering constraints regarding the consistent monitoring of post-translational modifications and degradation products. During this era, quality control for complex biologics like HER2-targeting antibodies was non-trivial because standard purification workflows often struggled to resolve subtle molecular variants—such as those differing by charge or disulfide connectivity—from the intended main species antibody.
The disclosed invention addresses the technical problem of maintaining the purity and consistency of HER2 antibody compositions, specifically those targeting domain II, by identifying and limiting specific acidic variants that arise during manufacturing. The architectural solution involves a composition where the main species antibody is integrated with a strictly controlled fraction of variants, including glycated, deamidated, disulfide-reduced, and non-reducible forms, maintained at a level below 25%. This technical advancement enables a capability for ensuring uniform pharmacokinetics and therapeutic efficacy, overcoming the constraint of molecular heterogeneity in recombinant protein production through defined analytical evaluation methods such as ion exchange chromatography and capillary electrophoresis.
The patent contains a total of 16 claims, with claims 1, 13, 15, and 16 serving as the independent claims. These independent claims focus on compositions and pharmaceutical formulations containing a specific HER2 antibody defined by its amino acid sequences, characterized by the inclusion of various acidic variants such as disulfide reduced, non-reducible, glycated, and deamidated forms. The dependent claims serve to further define the composition by specifying the concentration limits of the acidic variants, identifying additional structural variants like amino-terminal leader extensions or C-terminal lysine residues, and detailing the requirements for sterile pharmaceutical carriers.
Definitions of key terms used in the patent claims.
US Latest litigation cases involving this patent.

The dossier documents provide a comprehensive record of the patent's prosecution history - including filings, correspondence, and decisions made by patent offices - and are crucial for understanding the patent's legal journey and any challenges it may have faced during examination.
Get instant alerts for new documents