IP Verse

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company vs Progressive Casualty Insurance Company

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number CBM2012-00002 filed by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company against Progressive Casualty Insurance Company on Sep 16, 2012. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: CBM2012-00002
Filing Date: Sep 16, 2012
Petitioner: Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
Respondent: Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
Status: Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number: 09135034
Respondent Tech Center: 2800
Respondent Patent Number: 6064970
Institution Decision Date: Jan 25, 2013
Termination Date: Jan 23, 2014

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal	Mar 26, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List	Feb 24, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Transcript of February 19, 2014 Teleconference	Feb 24, 2014	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5	Feb 20, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
BLANK	Jan 23, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
FINAL WRITTEN DECISION	Jan 23, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
Oral Hearing Transcript	Jan 14, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Dec 4, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition	Oct 17, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Reply in Support of Motion to Exclude	Oct 17, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List	Oct 16, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibits	Oct 16, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude	Oct 11, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner Opposition to Motion to Exclude	Oct 11, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner Response to Patent Owner's Observations	Oct 11, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner Updated Exhibit List 10-11-13	Oct 11, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Excerpts from Transcript of Depo of Mary L. O'neil	Oct 11, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Excerpts of Transcript of Depo of Scott Andrews	Oct 11, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Rossen Declaration	Oct 11, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Order - Trial Hearing Notice	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Motion to Exclude	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Request for Oral Hearing	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Updated Exhibit List - 10-1-13	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Observations on O'Neil Testimony	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Hearing	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's First Set of Objections	Oct 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Second Set of Objections	Oct 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exh 2022 - O'Neil Deposition Excerpts	Oct 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exh 2023 - Andrews Deposition Excerpts	Oct 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exh 2024 - Declaration of John V Biernacki	Oct 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order Conduct of the Proceeding § 42.5	Sep 30, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Transcript of 8-29-13 Board Conference Call	Sep 30, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Objections to Evidence and Objections to Evidence	Sep 25, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Deposition of Scott Andrews	Sep 19, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Service of Rule 42.64(b)(2) Exhibits	Sep 18, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Updated Exhibit List 9-18-13	Sep 18, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Second ONeil Declaration	Sep 18, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Mary O'Neil	Sep 11, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Notice of Objections and Objections	Sep 4, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Stipulation of Due Dates Sept. 4, 2013	Sep 4, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - re Conference Call (8/29/2013)	Sep 3, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioners Notice of Service	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners Notice of Service	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners Exhibit List	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Andrews Declaration	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Oneil Declaration	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Rossen Declaration	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Notice of Objection to Evidence	Aug 13, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner Reply	Aug 6, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Andrews Rebuttal Dec	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Ehsani Article re Application Clustering	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Fuzzy Logic Information	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Declaration Mary O'Neil	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
AAA Interpretive Opinion	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Shapiro Fuzzy Logic Article	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Carreno Fuzzy Article	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Lemaire Article Fuzzy Insurance	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Derrig Article Fuzzy Techniques	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Young Article re Adjusting Ins. Rate	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Snapshot Privacy Statement	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Declaration Darrell Stark	Aug 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Notice of Stipulation Due Date No. 1	Jul 12, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice Deposition Mark Ehsani	Jul 3, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice Deposition Michael J. Miller	Jul 3, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Updated Exhibit List	May 22, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2020 - Supplemental Declaration of Michael J. Miller	May 22, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2021 - Supplemental Declaration of Dr. Mark Ehsani	May 22, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Response Under 42.220	May 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Exhibit List	May 1, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2010 Miller Declaration	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2012 1996 Standards	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2013 O'Neil Transcript	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2015 Miller CV	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2016 Ehsani Declaration	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2017 Ehsani CV	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2018 Andrews Transcript	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2019 Biernacki Declaration	May 1, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Second Stipulation of Due Dates	Apr 23, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Amended Notice of Deposition of Mary L. O'Neil	Apr 3, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Amended Notice of Deposition of Scott Andrews	Mar 28, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Amended Notice of Deposition of Mary L. O'Neil	Mar 28, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Stipulation to Move Due Dates	Mar 21, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Mar 19, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Decision- Granting Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admisstion	Mar 15, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Myers Pro Hac Motion	Mar 14, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Order Conduct of the Proceeding § 42.5	Feb 26, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order non-joinder	Feb 22, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Power of Attorney	Feb 21, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's List of Proposed Motions	Feb 21, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Progressive - Patent Owner's Proposed Motions	Feb 21, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision - Institution of Covered Business Method Review	Jan 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
SCHEDULING ORDER	Jan 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Progressive's Preliminary Response	Dec 21, 2012	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Progressive's Exhibit List	Dec 21, 2012	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2001 - Cognizant	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2002 - Property Casualty	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2003 - Cong Rec	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2004 - Acharya	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2005 - Fuzzy Thinking	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2006 - Taguchi	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2007 - Krivokapic	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2008 - Oetiker	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Progressive Exhibit 2009 - Hirsch	Dec 21, 2012	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Oct 10, 2012	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
PO Power of Attorney	Oct 9, 2012	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Mandatory Notices	Oct 9, 2012	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Filing Date	Sep 20, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
CBMR	Sep 16, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Sep 16, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Mandatory Notice	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Certificate of Service	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Service Notice	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Service - PoA	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Reexam Cert	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Translation Affadavit	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History '970	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
FL Insurance Guide	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
NY Insurance Guide	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
NY Insurance Guide	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Herrod GB2286369A	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Black Magic Motor	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
O'Neill Dec.	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
O'Neil CV	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
O'Neil Disparate Impact	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews Dec.	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews Dec	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews CV	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews OBD	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews Car Electronics	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews Automotive	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Andrews Automotive	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Wieker	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Blundell Dec.	Sep 16, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER