IP Verse

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company vs Progressive Casualty Insurance Company

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number CBM2013-00009 filed by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company against Progressive Casualty Insurance Company on Nov 20, 2012. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
CBM2013-00009
Filing Date
Nov 20, 2012
Petitioner
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
Respondent
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
12132487
Respondent Tech Center
3600
Respondent Patent Number
8140358
Institution Decision Date
Mar 28, 2013
Termination Date
Feb 11, 2014

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal

Jun 2, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Decision Request for Rehearing

Apr 1, 2014PAPERBOARD

Petitioner Decision Request for Rehearing

Apr 1, 2014PAPERBOARD

Petitioner Opposition to Patent Owner's Request for Rehearing

Mar 28, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Opposition to Paper No. 73

Mar 28, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Transcript of 3-25-14 teleconference

Mar 26, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Conduct of the Proceeding

Mar 26, 2014PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Request For Rehearing Seeking Conditional Relief Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. Section 42.71

Mar 13, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Request for Rehearing Pursuant to 37 CFR 42.71

Mar 12, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Mar 12, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Declaration of James L. Wamsley

Mar 12, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Feb 24, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Transcript of February 19, 2014 Teleconference

Feb 24, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5

Feb 20, 2014PAPERBOARD

Blank System Correction

Feb 11, 2014PAPERBOARD

Expunged

Feb 11, 2014PAPERBOARD

Final Written Decision - 35 UCS 328(a) and 37 CFR 42.73

Feb 11, 2014PAPERBOARD

Oral Hearing Transcript

Jan 14, 2014PAPERBOARD

Order - Conduct of the Proceeding

Dec 4, 2013PAPERBOARD

Joint Notice of Statutes and Regulations

Nov 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List - 11/8/13

Nov 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Excerpted sections

Nov 8, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1052 - 15 U.S.C. Section 78m, 1996 edition

Nov 8, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1053 - 15 U.S.C. Section 78o, 1996 edition

Nov 8, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1054 - 17 C.F.R. Section 200.80, 04/01/1996

Nov 8, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Oct 11, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Notice of Service of Oral Hearing Demonstrative Slides

Oct 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhbit List 10-9-13

Oct 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Notice of Service of Oral Hearing Demonstrative Slides

Oct 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List 10-9-13

Oct 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Oral Hearing Demonstrative Slides

Oct 9, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Oral Hearing Demonstrative Slides

Oct 9, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Patent Owner Oral Argument Slides

Oct 9, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner Reply to Patent Owners Opposition

Oct 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Notice of Third Set of Objections

Oct 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Reply in Support of Motion to Exclude

Oct 8, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude

Oct 4, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Oct 4, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List 10-4-13

Oct 4, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Response to Patent Owner Obersations

Oct 4, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude

Oct 4, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Excerpts Deposition of Mary L. O'Neil

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpts Depositon of Scott Andrews

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Rossen Declaration

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exh 2031 - Risk Classification Statement of Principles

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exh 2032 - Andrews Deposition Excerpts

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exh 2033 - Declaration of John V Biernacki

Oct 4, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Order - Trial Hearing

Oct 2, 2013PAPERBOARD

Transcript of 8-29-13 Board Teleconference

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order Conduct of the Proceeding ยง 42.5

Sep 30, 2013PAPERBOARD

Notice of Service

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Motion to Exclude

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Request for Oral Hearing

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Updated Exhibit List 9-30-2013

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Observation on O'Neil Deposition

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Request for Oral Hearing

Sep 30, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Oneill Declaration

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners First Set of Objection

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners Second Set of Objection

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 2027 - Automobile Insurance Article

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2028 - O'Neil Deposition Transcript - 9 13 2013

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2029 - Andrews Deposition Transcript - 9 24 2013

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2030 - Biernacki Declaration

Sep 30, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Notice of Deposition of Scott Andrews

Sep 19, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Notice of Objections and Objections Under 37 C.F.R. 42.64

Sep 16, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Mary O'Neil

Sep 11, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Service

Sep 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Updated Exhibit List 9-9-13

Sep 9, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

O'Neil Declaration

Sep 9, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews Declaration

Sep 9, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Rossen Declaration

Sep 9, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Order - Conduct of the Proceeding

Sep 6, 2013PAPERBOARD

Notice of Stipulation of Due Dates Sept. 4, 2013

Sep 4, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - re Conference Call (8/29/2013)

Sep 3, 2013PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner Notice of Objections and Objections to Evidence

Aug 23, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply

Aug 16, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Andrews Rebuttal Declaration

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ehsani Article re App Clustering

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fuzzy Logic Intelligence Info

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

CAN Specification

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

O'Neil Rebuttal Declaration

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

O'Neil CV

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

AAA Interpretive Opinion

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Shapiro Article re Overview Insurance Uses

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Carreno article re Fuzzy Expert Approach

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Lemaire article re Fuzzy Insurance

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Derrig article re Fuzzy Techniques

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Young article re Adjusting Insurance Rates

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Miller Supplemental Declaration

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Rossen Declaration

Aug 16, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Decision Granting Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Jul 10, 2013PAPERBOARD

Notice Deposition of Ivan Zatkovich

Jul 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Notice Deposition Mark Ehsani

Jul 3, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Notice Deposition Mark J. Miller

Jul 3, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice

Jun 28, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Ex 2026 - Miller Supplement

Jun 26, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit List

Jun 13, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Response Under 42.220

Jun 13, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex 2013 Miller Declaration

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2014 Miller CV

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2015 Ehsani Declaration

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2016 Ehsani CV

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2017 Buchanan

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2018 TMS320C5x

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2019 Tretter

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2020 Zatkovich Dec

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2021 Zatkovich CV

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2022 2013-00003 Institution Decision

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2024 Microsoft Definition

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2025 Dussaud

Jun 13, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

6-12-13 Due Date Stipulation

Jun 12, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

May 24 2013 Due Date Stipulation

May 24, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Order on Scheduling

Apr 19, 2013PAPERBOARD

Order - Second Revised Scheduling Order

Apr 19, 2013PAPERBOARD

Order - Authorizing Motions

Apr 12, 2013PAPERBOARD

Order - First Revised Scheduling Order

Apr 12, 2013PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Proposed Motions

Apr 8, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's List of Proposed Motions

Apr 8, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Decision- Institution of Covered Business Method Patent Review

Mar 28, 2013PAPERBOARD

Scheduling Order

Mar 28, 2013PAPERBOARD

Progressive's Preliminary Response

Feb 21, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Progressive - Exhibit List

Feb 21, 2013PAPERPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2001 - Cognizant

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2002 - Property Casualty 360

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2003 - U.S. Pat. No. 5,797,134

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2005 - Denial of Grounds Order

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2006 - IBM

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2007 - ex parte Reexam Request

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2008 - Black Magic

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2009 - 2012-00003 - Institution of CBM

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2010 - Redundant Grounds Order

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2011 - Cong. Rec.

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Progressive Exhibit 2012 - Danise

Feb 21, 2013EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Power of Attorney

Dec 10, 2012PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Patent Owner Mandatory Notices

Dec 10, 2012PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Filing Date Accorded Petition

Nov 21, 2012PAPERBOARD

Petition_Certificate of Service

Nov 19, 2012PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Nov 19, 2012PAPERPETITIONER

Patent 8,140,358

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Kosaka File History Part 1

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History - Part 2

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History - Part 3

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History - Part 4

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History - Part 5

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Kosaka Translation Affidavit

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Geostar Understanding - Part 1

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Geostart Understanding - Part 2

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Geostar Annual Report

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Chang Patent 5,446,757

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Beaverton patent 5,210,854

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Lowrey patent 7,228,211

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Qualcomm

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

US Patent 5,797,134

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

US Patent 6,064,970

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

US Patent 6,868,386

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

US Patent 8,090,598

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews Declaration

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews Curriculum vitae

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews OBD-II Background

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews Car Electronics

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Andrews Automotives Handbook

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Briskman RDSS

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

358 Wieker Declaration

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

358 Blundell Declaration

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

Bouchard Patent 5,465,079

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

358 Gray US Patent 4,651,157

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

358 Lewis Patent 5,438,312

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

358 Stanifer Patent 5,243,530

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER

POA_Cert of Service

Nov 19, 2012EXHIBITPETITIONER