IP Verse

CBS Interactive Inc. et al. vs Wireless Science, LLC et al.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2013-00033 filed by CBS Interactive Inc. et al. against Wireless Science, LLC et al. on Oct 25, 2012. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: IPR2013-00033
Filing Date: Oct 25, 2012
Petitioner: CBS Interactive Inc. et al.
Respondent: Wireless Science, LLC et al.
Status: Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number: 11050775
Respondent Tech Center: 2600
Respondent Patent Number: 7155241
Institution Decision Date: Mar 25, 2013
Termination Date: Mar 3, 2014

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
Order - Lifting Stay of Concurrent Reexamination - 37 CFR 42.122(a)	Apr 10, 2015	PAPER	BOARD
Exhibit 3001	Apr 10, 2015	EXHIBIT	BOARD
CAFC - Affirmed (R36)	Apr 8, 2015	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notice	Dec 12, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner Notice of Appeal	Apr 30, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
FINAL WRITTEN DECISION	Mar 3, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
Record of Oral Hearing	Nov 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Appearance Record	Nov 6, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Oct 23, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PO Exhibit List	Oct 23, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Hearing Transcript	Oct 23, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List - Demonstratives	Oct 21, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Submission of Petitioners Demonstrative Exhibits	Oct 21, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners List of Exhibits	Oct 21, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Expunged Improper Paper	Oct 21, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Expunged Improper Papers	Oct 21, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Expunged Improper Paper	Oct 21, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Expunged Improper Paper	Oct 21, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Petitioners' Reply to PO Opposition to Motion to Exclude Evidence	Oct 14, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
PO Reply Motion to Exclude	Oct 14, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Agreed Motion to Expunge	Oct 11, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - re Errata and Observations	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioners' Opposition to PO's Motion to Exclude Evidence	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' Response to PO's Motion for Observation	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' List of Exhibits	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
PO Opposition to Mot to Exclude	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Response to Observations	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Comments by Third Party Requesters - USP 7499716	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 42 from IPR2012-00005	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
October 4 Hearing Transcript	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Grindon Deposition Transcript	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order - Trial Hearing	Oct 1, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioners' Motion For Observation Regarding Cross-Examination of Reply Witness John R. Grindon, D.Sc.	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' Motion to Exclude Evidence Under 37 C.F.R. 42.64	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' List of Exhibits	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
PO Oral Argument Request	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Motion for Observation	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Motion to Exclude	Sep 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
John Grindon Deposition Transcript, Vol. 1 (Sept. 23, 2013)	Sep 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 2067	Sep 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit 2068	Sep 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Petitioners' Request for Oral Argument	Sep 18, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of John R. Grindon, D.Sc.	Sep 9, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
PO Reply to Opp to Amend	Sep 6, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List	Sep 6, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Grindon Declaration	Sep 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
143 Application	Sep 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
775 Application	Sep 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Support Chart	Sep 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Idle Free Case	Sep 6, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Sep 5, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Mandatory Disclosures by Patent Owner	Sep 5, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Sep 3, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PO Exhibit List	Sep 3, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
August 29 Transcript	Sep 3, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Decision - Request for Rehearing	Aug 30, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioners Updated Mandatory Notices	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Deri Deposition Notice	Aug 20, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Mitchell Deposition Notice	Aug 20, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List	Aug 14, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
13-08-08-Transcript	Aug 14, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5	Aug 9, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PO Request for Rehearing	Aug 2, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision - Motion to Withdraw Arguments and Expunge Exhibits	Aug 1, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Agreed Motion To Expunge	Jul 29, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Exhibit List	Jul 29, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioners' Reply to Patent Owner's Response	Jul 29, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Amend	Jul 29, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners' List of Exhibits	Jul 29, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Microsoft Press Computer Dictionary	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Second Declaration of John C. Mitchell, Ph.D.	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 19 from IPR2013-00099	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 26 from IPR2012-00027	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 27 from IPR2012-00005	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Comments by Third Party Requesters - USP 8134450	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Comments by Third Party Requesters - USP 8224294	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IETF Request for Comments 1081	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Amendment from USP 8116741 File History	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Action Closing Prosecution - USP 8116741	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Reilly et al. 1997 Conference	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Declaration of Luca Deri	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Reilly et al. 1997 Comp. Networks and ISDN Sys.	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Action Closing Prosecution - USP 7499716	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IETF Request for Comments 1738	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 5850520	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 6125281	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 13 from IPR2013-00126	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Paper 16 from IPR2013-00100	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 5706434	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Grindon Dep. Transcript, Vol. I	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Grindon Dep. Transcript, Vol. II	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Helferich Dep. Transcript, Vol. I	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Helferich Dep. Transcript, Vol. II	Jul 29, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5	Jul 26, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
EXPUNGED-Untimely Filing	Jul 23, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Expunged	Jul 22, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Jul 11, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Corrected Cert of Service re Paper 64	Jul 10, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Jul 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Updated Mandatory Notices	Jul 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
EXPUNGED UNAUTHORIZED FILING	Jul 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
EXPUNGED UNAUTHORIZED FILING	Jul 9, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
EXPUNGED UNAUTHORIZED FILING	Jul 9, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
EXPUNGED UNAUTHORIZED FILING	Jul 9, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Petitioners' Updated Mandatory Notices	Jul 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Order: re Supplemental Information After Reponse	Jul 8, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Decision Motion to Terminate § 42.74	Jul 3, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Joint Motion to Terminate with Respect to One Petitioner, Phoenix Newspapers, Inc.	Jun 28, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Joint Request to File Settlement Agreement as Business Confidential Information	Jun 28, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
EXPUNGED-Confidential Agreement-PAPER COPY HELD BY PTAB	Jun 28, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Jun 27, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PO Amended Response	Jun 25, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Supplemental Expert Declaration of John R. Grindon, D.Sc.	Jun 25, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Deposition of Richard J. Helferich Under 37 CFR 42.53	Jun 24, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of Leonard I. Palevsky Under 37 CFR 42.53	Jun 24, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of John R. Grindon, D.Sc. Under 37 CFR 42.53	Jun 24, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of Bobby R. Hunt, Ph.D. Under 37 CFR 42.53	Jun 24, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding	Jun 21, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PO Motiion to Amend	Jun 8, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Response	Jun 7, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 6,233,430	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Request for Inter Partes Reexamination of related Helferich Patent No. 7,280,838	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Identifier Dictionary Definitions	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronic Terms	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Identifies Dictionary Definition	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Deposition of John C. Mitchell, Ph.D., June 3, 2013	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
DECLARATION OF RICHARD J. HELFERICH	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Redacted Draft “CONSULTING AGREEMENT”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Redacted “Confidential Technology Activities Report”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Redacted Draft “Intellectual Property License Agreement”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich Handwritten Specifications	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Redacted Letter “Re: HELFERICH - READYCOM AGREEMENTS”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Letter “Re: Helferich-ReadyCom Agreements”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, Redacted Signature Pages of Executed Agreements	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Redacted “Invention Development Agreement”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Blank “INVENTION DISCLOSURE FORM”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Rep Support for Claims of the '241 patent as found in exhibit 2017	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
“INVENTION DISCLOSURE FORM” for “Selective Call Paging Transceiver and Method for Retrieving Remotely Stored Messages”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
“INVENTION DISCLOSURE FORM” for “Paging System and Method for Transmitting Message	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
“INVENTION DISCLOSURE FORM” for “Intuitive User Interface for Controlling Corresponding functions of Remote Devices”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
“INVENTION DISCLOSURE FORM” for “Selective call Paging transceiver and Method for Retrieving Erased Messages”	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, “Invention Disclosure and Specification” (RJH73197)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
REPRESENTATIVE SUPPORT FOR CLAIMS OF THE ‘241 PATENT AS FOUND IN EXHIBITS 2028, 2030, 2031, 2032, 2033, 2034, and 2037	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
rjhoo1.doc	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
rjh002.doc	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
rjh003.doc	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
rjh004.doc	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
rjh005.doc	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, “Invention Disclosure and Specifications,” Cover Sheet	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, Letter to Geoff Sutcliffe, dated August 12, 1997	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, Original Hand Drawn Figures	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
The first pages of twenty-five art references, sent from Richard J. Helferich to Geoff Sutcliffe on August 12, 1997	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Richard J. Helferich, Letter to Brian Kinahan, dated August 12, 1997	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Email from Geoff Sutcliffe to Rich Helferich with subject “Draft patent application,” dated September 3, 1997	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
REPRESENTATIVE SUPPORT FOR CLAIMS OF THE ‘241 PATENT AS FOUND IN EXHIBIT 2039	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Declaration of Leonard I. Palevsky, Managing Member of Helferich Patent Licensing, LLC (June 7, 2013)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
List of Helferich Licensees as of June 6, 2013	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
CBS Notice Letter (June 2, 2010)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
CBS ‘241 Claim Infringement Chart (June 2, 2010)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Standard Form Lump Sum Agreement (June 7, 2013)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
HPL Standard Form Lump Sum Agreement with MMS Messaging Excluded (June 7, 2013)	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
“Nomadic Access to Information Services by a GSM phone,” by M. Kylanpaa	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent 6,047,327 to Tso et al.	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent 6,119,167 to Boyle	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent 5,809,415 to Rossmann	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Expert Declaration of Bobby R. Hunt, Ph.D.	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Curriculum Vitae of Bobby R. Hunt, Ph.D.	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Expert Declaration of John R. Grindon, D.Sc.	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Curriculum Vitae of John R. Grindon, D.Sc.	Jun 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Decision - Pro Hac Vice Admission of Michael M. Markman	May 17, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Decision - Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Victoria Curtin	May 17, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Agreed Motion to Modify Schedule Dates 1 and 2	May 14, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Motion for Pro Hac Vice-Curtin	May 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	May 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO List of Exhibits	May 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PO Updated Mandatory Notices	May 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
241 Patent Reexam Req 95001864	May 9, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Curtin Declaration	May 9, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Petitioners Updated Mandatory Notices	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Michael Markman	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioners Exhibit List	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Deposition Notice pursuant to Rule 42.53(d)(4)	May 8, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit 1017 Declaration of Michael Markman	May 8, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Notice - Decision on Motion to Adjust Schedule	Apr 19, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order - CBS Revised Scheduling Order	Apr 19, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Agreed Motion to Adjust Schedule	Apr 18, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order Conduct of the Proceeding § 42.5	Apr 17, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioners' List of Proposed Motions	Apr 11, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner List of Proposed Motions	Apr 10, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision Institution of Inter Partes Review § 42.108	Mar 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Scheduling Order	Mar 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner Preliminary Response	Jan 18, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit WIRELESS SCIENCE 2001	Jan 18, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit WIRELESS SCIENCE 2002	Jan 18, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit WIRELESS SCIENCE 2003	Jan 18, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit WIRELESS SCIENCE 2004	Jan 18, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order	Dec 20, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
Order - Expunging Papers - 37 CFR 42.7(a)	Dec 6, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
Mandatory Disclosures By Patent Owner	Nov 14, 2012	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Nov 13, 2012	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
Order-To Stay Concurrent Reexamination	Nov 6, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
Notice of Filing Date Accorded	Oct 26, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
Petition for Inter Partes Review	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner Exhibit List	Oct 25, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
USP 7155241	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
95001864 Reexam Grant and Office Action	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Suns Legacy Partners Complaint	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Bravo Media Complaint	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CBS Complaint	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 6333973	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 5878351	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 5487100	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Suns Legacy Partners Preliminary Infringement Contentions	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Bravo Media Preliminary Infringement Contentions	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CBS Preliminary Infringement Contentions	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Expunged	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Curriculum Vitae of John C. Mitchell	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
USP 7155241 File History	Oct 25, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER