IP Verse

Corning Incorporated vs DSM IP ASSETS B.V.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2013-00050 filed by Corning Incorporated against DSM IP ASSETS B.V. on Nov 16, 2012. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: IPR2013-00050
Filing Date: Nov 16, 2012
Petitioner: Corning Incorporated
Respondent: DSM IP ASSETS B.V.
Status: Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number: 09163188
Respondent Tech Center: 1700
Respondent Patent Number: 6323255
Institution Decision Date: May 13, 2013
Termination Date: May 1, 2014

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
Final Decision	May 1, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
Oral Hearing Transcript	Mar 28, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
IPR2014-00050 - Patent Owner's Corrected Motion to Amend	Feb 18, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - On Corning's Objections to DSM's Demonstrative Evidence - 37 C.F.R. 42.70	Feb 10, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
IPR2013-00050 2014-02-10 Corning Submission of Feb 7 Transcript	Feb 10, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Reply to Opposition to Motion to Exclude	Feb 7, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 2014-02-04 CORNING EXHIBIT LIST NO 8	Feb 4, 2014	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Demonstratives for Hearing (255 Patent)	Feb 4, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 2014-02-04 CORNING Submission of Demonstrative Exhibit	Feb 4, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 2014-02-04 Ex 1039 Corning Demonstrative Exhibit	Feb 4, 2014	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Order - Trial Hearing	Feb 3, 2014	PAPER	BOARD
IPR2013-00050 2014-02-03 Corning Responses to Observations	Feb 3, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
Pet Opp to PO Mot Exclude	Feb 3, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Exhibit List No. 8	Jan 21, 2014	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Motion for Observations on Cross-Examination of Corning Reply Declarants	Jan 21, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Corning Evidence	Jan 21, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Request For Oral Argument	Jan 21, 2014	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 2014-01-21 Corning Request for Oral Argument	Jan 21, 2014	PAPER	PETITIONER
Ex. 2037 - Objections served 05.28.13	Jan 21, 2014	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2038 - Objections served 12.05.13	Jan 21, 2014	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2039 - Objections served 12.30.13	Jan 21, 2014	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Reply in Support of Motion to Amend	Dec 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 - Patent Owner's Exhibit List No. 7	Dec 23, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2035 - 2013-12-19 Dep. of M. Winningham (Vol. 6)	Dec 23, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2036 - Wu, Column Handbook for Size Exclusion Chromotography (Dep. Ex. 655)	Dec 23, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 2013-12-20 Corning Exhibit List 7	Dec 20, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 2013-12-20 Corning Reply to PO Supp Response	Dec 20, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex 1037 Sogah Tran 2013-12-14	Dec 20, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex 1038 Winningham Rough Tran 2013-12-19	Dec 20, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent Owners Exhibit List No. 5	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Supplemental Response to Corning's Petition for Inter partes Review of Claims 1-19 of Patent 6,323,255	Dec 13, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2029 - CORNING 001292	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2030 - CORNING 001289	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2031 - CORNING 001290	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2032 - CORNING 001296	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2033 - CORNING 001297	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2034 - CORNING 001280	Dec 13, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Decision On Request for Rehearing	Dec 10, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Decision On Request for Rehearing and Other Matters	Dec 9, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
IPR2013-00048 - Deposition Notice for Michael Winnighham (2013.12.9)	Dec 9, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 (_255 Patent) - Request for Rehearing Regarding Supplemental Bowman Declaration (2013.12.02)	Dec 2, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 2013-11-27 Corning Exhibit List 6	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 2013-11-27 Corning Opp to PO Mot to Amend	Nov 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 2013-11-27 Corning Reply to PO Response	Nov 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 2013-11-27 Corning Not re Removal of Conf Desig	Nov 27, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1027 WO 98-45344 to Kongauz	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1028 US Prov Pat App 60-045,707	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1029 Resp. Winningham Decl.	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1030 Oct 28 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1031 Oct 29 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1032 Oct 30 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1033 Nov 12 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1034 Nov 13 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1035 Nov 14 2013 Bowman Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 Ex_1036 July 2 2013 Kouzmina Transcript	Nov 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner’s Certification in Response to Board’s Decision of Nov 18, 2013	Nov 20, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Decision - On DSM's Motion to File Supplemental Information and Motion to Compel Compliance with the Decision of June 21, 2013	Nov 18, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Certification in Response to Board's Decision of November 1, 2013	Nov 6, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision Request for Rehearing	Nov 1, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Corning Exhibit List 5	Oct 30, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Corning Request for Rehearing under 37 CFR 42.71(d)	Oct 30, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
1023 - Oct 9 2013 Email	Oct 30, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
1024 - Oct 17 2013 Email re 3-page prod	Oct 30, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
1025 - Oct 17 2013 Email re addl Prod	Oct 30, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
1026 - July 11 2013 Transcript re Conf Call	Oct 30, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Corning Notice of Deposition of Bowman	Oct 28, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Decision Motion for Discovery	Oct 16, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion for Discovery	Oct 10, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Corning Exhibit List No. 4	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Corning Motion for Discovery	Oct 7, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
CI 1015	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1016	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1017	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1018	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1019	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1020	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1021	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
CI 1022	Oct 7, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Order Conduct of the Proceedings	Oct 4, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Revised Exhibit List No. 4	Sep 25, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order Conduct of the Proceedings	Sep 20, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
IPR2013-00050 Patent Owner's Exhibit List No. 4	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Motion to Seal	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 - Patent Owner's Response Brief	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 - Patent Owner's Motion to Amend	Aug 27, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2018 - 2013.07.16 - Kouzmina Vol. 3 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2019 - 2013.07.17 - Kouzmina - Vol. 4 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2020 Confidential 2013.07.18 Kouzmina Vol. 5	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Expunged	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2021 - 2013.07.30 - Winningham Vol. 1 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2022 - 2013.07.31 - Winningham Vol. 2 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2023 - 2013.08.01 - Winningham Vol. 3 (Mini	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2024 - 2013.08.12 Winningham Vol. 4 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2025 - 08.13.13 Winningham, Michael Vol. 5 (Mini)	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2026 - Christopher Bowman Declaration	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2027 - Christopher Bowman CV	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
IPR2013-00050 Ex. 2028 - 6,323,255 File History	Aug 27, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order Conduct of the Proceedings	Aug 23, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order - Case Transfer to Administrative Patent Judge Jennifer S. Bisk	Aug 12, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order - Conduct of the Proceedings - Protective Order	Jul 25, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Notice of Deposition of Michael Winningham	Jul 19, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Motion for Entry of Protective Order	Jul 18, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision On Request for Rehearing and on Motion	Jul 16, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Pet Opp to PO Mot to Enforce	Jul 15, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Pet Exh List No 3	Jul 15, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Carlson Decl	Jul 15, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit List	Jul 12, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Motion to Enforce Compliance With Decision Granting Discovery [Paper No. 23] Or In the Alternative For Additional Discover	Jul 12, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2014	Jul 12, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2015	Jul 12, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2016	Jul 12, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2017	Jul 12, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exhibit List	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Request for Expedited Rehearing on Board's Decision Dated 7.8.13	Jul 10, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2008	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2009	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2010	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2011	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2012	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2013	Jul 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order - Deposition Telephone Conference	Jul 8, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Joint Stipulation Extending Due Dates 2-6	Jul 1, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of Kouzmina	Jun 25, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision, Motion for Discovery	Jun 21, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Order- Conduct of the Proceedings	Jun 14, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Power of Attorney	Jun 12, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Corning Notice of Additional Back-up Counsel	Jun 12, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Corning Mot for Pro Hac Vice Admission of McGuirk	Jun 12, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
IPR2013-00050 - Patent Owner's List of Anticipated Proposed Motions	Jun 11, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Corning Opp to DSM Mot for Discovery	Jun 10, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Corning Exhibit List No 2	Jun 10, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Corning Motions List	Jun 10, 2013	PAPER	PETITIONER
Corning Objections to PO Evidence	Jun 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Kouzmina Decl ISO Opp to Mot for Discovery	Jun 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Winningham Decl ISO Opp to Mot for Discovery	Jun 10, 2013	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit List	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Motion for Discovery	Jun 5, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2001	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2002	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2003	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2004	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2005	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2006	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2007	Jun 5, 2013	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order - Conduct of the Proceedings - 37 CFR 42.5	May 31, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Decision- Institution of Inter Partes Review	May 13, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
Scheduling Order	May 13, 2013	PAPER	BOARD
PATENT OWNER’S PRELIMINARY RESPONSE	Feb 19, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Feb 15, 2013	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
Notice Pursuant to Rule 42.10	Feb 15, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Feb 15, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice Pursuant to Rule 42.8	Feb 15, 2013	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Dec 6, 2012	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
Notice of Filing Date Accorded	Nov 16, 2012	PAPER	BOARD
Power of Attorney	Nov 15, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petition	Nov 15, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Exhibit List	Nov 15, 2012	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent 6323255	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent 4849462	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent 5664041	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent 5554785	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent 4900126	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Winningham Declaration	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Kouzmina Declaration	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Winningham CV	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Kouzmina CV	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Patent 5416880	Nov 15, 2012	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER