The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2014-00075 filed by Medtronic, Inc. against NuVasive, Inc. on Oct 21, 2013. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2014-00075
Filing Date
Oct 21, 2013
Petitioner
Medtronic, Inc.
Respondent
NuVasive, Inc.
Status
Terminated-Settled
Respondent Application Number
11789284
Respondent Tech Center
3700
Respondent Patent Number
8016767
Institution Decision Date
Apr 8, 2014
Termination Date
Apr 3, 2015

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Judgment Granting Joint Motion to Terminate after Remand from the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

Aug 15, 2017PAPERBOARD

Joint Motion to Terminate Proceeding and Joint Notice of Settlement

Aug 14, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 2096 - Confidential Settlement Agreement

Aug 14, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

CAFC DECISION

Aug 3, 2017PAPERBOARD

CAFC MANDATE

Aug 3, 2017PAPERBOARD

Notice of Appeal

Jun 2, 2015PAPERPATENT OWNER

Final Written Decision

Apr 3, 2015PAPERBOARD

Record of Oral Hearing

Mar 17, 2015PAPERBOARD

Power of Attorney

Mar 5, 2015PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Related Matters

Mar 5, 2015PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notice

Feb 12, 2015PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Demonstratives Under 37 C.F.R. 42.70(b)

Nov 26, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Reply to Opposition to Motion to Exclude

Nov 12, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Order - Trial Hearing

Nov 10, 2014PAPERBOARD

Response to Patent Owner's Observations on Cross Examination

Nov 6, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude

Nov 6, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Updated Exhibit List

Nov 6, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Email from Michael A. Amon to Justin Oliver sent on September 14, 2014

Nov 6, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Motion to Exclude Evidence

Oct 23, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Oct 23, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Request for Oral Argument

Oct 23, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Updated Exhibit List

Oct 23, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Motion for Observation Regarding Cross-Examination of Dr. Robert G. Watkins, IV, M.D.

Oct 23, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Objections to Evidence Under 37 CFR 42.64(B)(1)

Oct 23, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Email correspondence between Petitioner's Attorney and Patent Owner's Attorneys

Oct 23, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Intraoperative Neuromonitoring

Oct 23, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition of Dr. Robert G. Watkins, IV, M.D.

Oct 23, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 4 and 5 in Scheduling Order

Oct 20, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Deposition of Robert G. Watkins, IV, MD

Oct 8, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

IPR2014-00075 Petitioner's Reply

Oct 3, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Watkins Reply Declaration

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 2030 from IPR2013-00506 (Declaration of Patrick Miles)

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

IPR2013-00506 Response (dated May 21, 2014)

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Miles trial transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Miles Phase III deposition

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

NVM5 Brochure

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

PX2000 - Part 1

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

PX2000 - Part 2

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,361,156

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

NuVasive 2005 10k

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

NuVasive 2010 10k - Part 1

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

NuVasive 2010 10k - Part 2

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Amon Deposition Transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Knight Article

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Watkins Article

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Miles Deposition Transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Phillips Deposition Transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Obenchain Depositoin Transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Williams Article

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Millennium Research Paper

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Schwender Article

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Yuan Deposition Transcript

Oct 3, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Notice of Stipulation to Modify Due Date 2

Sep 18, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Depositions of Dr. Phillips and Dr. Obenchain

Aug 22, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Michael Amon

Aug 21, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Patrick Miles

Aug 20, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

Decision - On Patent Owner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Recognition of Counsel - 37 CFR 42.10

Jul 8, 2014PAPERBOARD

Decision - On Patent Owner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Recognition of Counsel - 37 CFR 42.10

Jul 8, 2014PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner Response

Jul 8, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Hand-drawn diagram by Dr. Schwartz

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Hand-drawn diagram by Dr. Watkins

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Curriculum Vitae of Robert G. Watkins, IV, M.D.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

U.S. Patent No. 4,545,374

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Annotated excerpt by Dr. Watkins of Declaration of Barton Sachs, M.D., M.B.A., F.A.C.P.E., F.A.C.H.E.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Complete Declaration of Barton Sachs, M.D., M.B.A., F.A.C.P.E., F.A.C.H.E.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition transcript of Dr. Watkins

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Schwartz Deposition

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Phillips Declaration

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Mr. Miles declaration

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Obenchain Declaration

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

US File History for 60/392,214

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Arbuckle confirming true and correct copies of US File History for 60/392,214

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

XLIF surgical technique for MaXcess II

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Quick reference guide for NeuroVision

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Spine December 2010 Supplement - Part 1 of 2

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Spine December 2010 Supplement - Part 2 of 2

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

SOLAS News, Issue 10, published in April 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Extreme Lateral Interbody Fusion a novel surgical technique for anterior lumbar interbody fusion, Ozgur, O., et al, The Spine Journal, 6 2006 435-443

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

June 4, 2008 Article from www.ozgurmd.com

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Sept. 7, 2011 Trial Testimony of William Smith, MD

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

March 9, 2012 printout of article from www.stiebermd.com/xlif

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

January 25, 2008 Article from www.ozgurmd.com

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Copy of the Better Way Back Book

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

2013 NuVasive Form 10-K report

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from iData Research re Spinal Market September 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Q2 2011 NuVasive Publication of Predator

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

iData Reseearch for U.S. Spinal Implant Market August 2010 - Part 1 of 3

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

iData Reseearch for U.S. Spinal Implant Market August 2010 - Part 2 of 2

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

iData Reseearch for U.S. Spinal Implant Market August 2010 - Part 3 of 3

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from January 17, 2013 deposition of Jason Highsmith, MD

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Experience and Early Results with a Minimally Invasive Technique for Anterior Column Support Through eXtreme Lateral Interbody Fusion (XLIF), Rodgers, W., et al, US Musculoskeletal Review 2007.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Point of View, Matthews, H., Spine, Vol. 28 2003 at pp. 427-428

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Bending the Paradigm, Thomas Weisel Partners

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Lateral Interbody Fusion Comes to Birmingham Birmingham Medical News

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from August 2, 2013 Deposition Of Jim Youssef

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

The Relationship of Intrapsoas Nerves During a Transpsoas Approach to the Lumbar Spine June 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Budge, A New Solution webpage on South Texas Spinal Clinic P.A.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Malham, Clinical Outcome and Fusion Rates after the First 30 Extreme Lateral Interbody Fusions, The Scientific World Journal, Volume 2012

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

JP Morgan NuVasive Analysis from 10/2008

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Canaccord 2010 NASS Meeting Notes

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

2011 Caris Co Financial Analysis on NuVa

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deukmedjian, Bowel and Vascular Injury Following 13,000 Lateral Interbody Fusions, SMISS 2013 Annual Conference

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Crock, Anterior Lumbar Interbody Fusion Indications for its Use and Notes on Surgical Technique, in Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research, No. 165, May 1982

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Crock Affidavit

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

U.S. 5,860,973 to Michelson

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dezawa et al., Retroperitoneal Laparoscopic Lateral Approach to the Lumbar Spine A New Approach, Technique, and Clinical Trial, Journal of Spinal Disorders, 2000

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

McAfee, Minimally Invasive Anterior Retroperitoneal Approach to the Lumbar Spine, Spine, 1998

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

JP Morgan Analysis of Spine Market for October 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Vloka, Obturator and Genitofemoral Nerve Blocks, Techniques in Regional Anesthesia and Pain Management, Vol. 3, No. 1 1999

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Romanes Chapter 11 The peripheral nervous system

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Farny, Anatomy of the posterior approach to the lumbar plexus block, Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia, Vol. 41, No. 6 1994

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Pre-trial order from Medtronic Sofamor Danek USA, Inc. et al. v. NuVasive, Inc., Case No. 3 08-cv-1512 S.D. Cal., Doc. No. 338

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

September 6, 2011 trial transcript excerpt from Medtronic Sofamor Danek USA, Inc. et al. v. NuVasive, Inc., Case No. 308-cv-1512 S.D. Cal.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

September 13, 2011 trial transcript excerpt from Medtronic Sofamor Danek USA, Inc. et al. v. NuVasive, Inc., Case No. 3 08-cv-1512 S.D. Cal.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

September 14, 2011 trial transcript excerpt from Medtronic Sofamor Danek USA, Inc. et al. v. NuVasive, Inc., Case No. 3 08-cv-1512 S.D. Cal.

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Grays Anatomy, 38th Edition, 1995

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Phillips, Intertransverse Lumbar Interbody Fusion, Spine, Vol. 27, No. 2, 2002

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

U.S. Patent No. 5,195,541 to Obenchain, entitled Method of performing laparoscopic lumbar discectomy

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Obenchain, Laparoscopic lumbar discectomy case report, in Journal of Laparoendoscopic Surgery, Vol. 1.3, pp. 145-49 June 1991

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Cloyd and Obenchain, Transperitoneal Laparoscopic Approach to Lumbar Discectomy, in Surgical Endoscopy and Laparoscopy, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp. 85-89, p. 85 and Figure 2 1995)

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Obenchain and Cloyd, Laparoscopic Lumbar Discectomy Description of Transperitoneal and Retroperitoneal Techniques, in Neurosurgery Clinics of North America, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 77-85, at p. 77 Jan. 1996

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Obenchain, Speculum lumbar extraforaminal microdiscectomy, in The Spine Journal, Vol. 1, No. 6, pp. 415-20 Nov. Dec. 2001

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

U.S. Patent No. 5,730,754 to Obenchain, entitled Nerve deflecting conduit needle and method

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Obenchain and Cloyd, Percutaneous Foraminal Endoscopic Lumbar Discectomy Evolution from a Laparoscopic Approach, in Lasers in the Muscoskeletal System, Gerber et al. eds., pp. 340-42 2001

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Park DK, Lee MJ, Lin EL, Singh K, An HS, Phillips FM The Relationship of Intrapsoas Nerves During a Transpsoas Approach to the Lumbar Spine Anatomic Study. J Spinal Disord Tech. 23 4 223-8, 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Direct Lateral MAST Project Activation marked DX5410 admitted at trial

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Providence Medical Center Journal - Back in the Game In Good Health

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

News Tribune Health A New Fix for an Old Problem Black Rogers

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Journal of Business Spokane - Surgeon Here Offers New Approach to Spinal Fusion Journal of Business - Dr Tomeh 2007

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Twin Cities Newsletter - First Surgeon to Introduce XLIF in Okaloosa and Walton Counties Dr Enguidanos 2008

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Pharmawire -Nuvasives XLIF Medtronic's DLIF Other Lateral Fusion Techniques Likely To See Increased Adoption Despite Pricing Pressure 2010

Jul 8, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Order - Conduct of the Proceeding 37 C.F.R. 42.5

Jul 2, 2014PAPERBOARD

Notice of Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 1 and 2 in the Scheduling Order

Jun 18, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Michael A. Amon

Jun 6, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Michael Amon in Support of Pro Hac Vice Admission

Jun 6, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petioner Nuvasive Incs Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Jun 4, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Affidavit of Frank E. Scherkenbach in Support of Petitioners Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Jun 4, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Notice of Deposition of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D.

May 29, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Deposition of Robert G. Watkins, IV, M.D.

May 29, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Notice of Designation of Additional Back Up Counsel

May 13, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Initial Conference Summary - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5

May 1, 2014PAPERBOARD

Decision Institution of Inter Partes Review

Apr 8, 2014PAPERBOARD

Scheduling Order

Apr 8, 2014PAPERBOARD

Decision - Petitioner's Motion to Submit Corrected Exhibits - 37 CFR 42.104(c)

Apr 1, 2014PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Motion to Submit Corrected Exhibit Under 37 CFR 42.104(c)

Mar 5, 2014PAPERPETITIONER

CORRECTED Certified English Translation of Cistac

Mar 5, 2014EXHIBITPETITIONER

Order Conduct of the Proceeding

Feb 28, 2014PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Jan 31, 2014PAPERPATENT OWNER

Medtronic, "DLIF Marketing Plan" (2009)

Jan 31, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Medtronic "MAST Breakout 2"

Jan 31, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Medtronic "Direct Lateral Marketing Plan"

Jan 31, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Moro et al., "An Anatomic Study of the Lumbar Plexus..."

Jan 31, 2014EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Power of Attorney

Nov 13, 2013PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Related Matters

Nov 13, 2013PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Notice of Accepting Corrected Petition

Nov 8, 2013PAPERBOARD

Notice of Corrected Petition for Inter Partes Review

Nov 7, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Corrected Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 8,016,767

Nov 7, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition

Oct 31, 2013PAPERBOARD

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 8,016,767

Oct 21, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Oct 21, 2013PAPERPETITIONER

German Patent Pub No. DE 100 48 790 A1 (“Cistac”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Expunged

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 5,313,962 (“Obenchain”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

International Patent Application Pub. No. WO 01/37728 A1 (“Kelleher”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 6,224,549 (“Drongelen”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 6,139,493 (“Koros ‘493”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 5,944,658 (“Koros ’658”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 4,595,013 (“Jones”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Nerve Integrity Monitor, Intraoperative EMG Monitor, User’s Guide, Medtronic, Inc. (2000) (“NIM Guide”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 5,171,279 (“Mathews”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 5,792,044 (“Foley”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

International Application Pub. No. WO 00/38574 (“Marino”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 6,945,933 (“Branch”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

International Application Pub. No. WO 03/005887 (“Blewett”)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of David Hacker

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Robert G. Watkins, IV, MD. - Part 1 of 2

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Robert G. Watkins, IV, MD. - Part 2 of 2

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 1 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 2 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 3 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 4 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 5 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Daniel Schwartz, Ph.D. - Part 6 of 6

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,016,767

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

May 17, 2011 Amendment in U.S. Patent Appln. 11/789,284

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

July 18, 2011 Notice of Allowance in U.S. Patent Appln. 11/789,284

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

February 7, 2011 Office Action in U.S. Patent Appln. 11/789,284

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

March 18, 2013 Decision on Appeal in Inter Partes Reexamination Control No. 95/001,247

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER

Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, p. 65 (10th ed. 1998)

Oct 21, 2013EXHIBITPETITIONER