IP Verse

The Toro Company vs MTD Products Inc.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2016-00219 filed by The Toro Company against MTD Products Inc. on Nov 19, 2015. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: IPR2016-00219
Filing Date: Nov 19, 2015
Petitioner: The Toro Company
Respondent: MTD Products Inc.
Status: Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number: 12055668
Respondent Tech Center: 3600
Respondent Patent Number: 8136613
Institution Decision Date: May 13, 2016
Termination Date: May 10, 2017

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
CAFC Decision and Mandate (April 5, 2019)	Oct 18, 2019	PAPER	BOARD
Termination Decision Document	May 10, 2017	PAPER	BOARD
Record of Oral Hearing	Feb 28, 2017	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibits for Oral Argument	Feb 2, 2017	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioners' Demonstratives	Feb 2, 2017	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Demonstrative Exhibits for Oral Argument	Feb 2, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Demonstratives	Feb 2, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Reply in Support of its Motion to Exclude	Jan 24, 2017	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's [Second Corrected] Sur-Sur Reply	Jan 19, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List	Jan 18, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude	Jan 17, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Proffer of Supplemental Evidence and Response to Patent Owner's Objections to Evidence	Jan 17, 2017	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
ORDER TRIAL HEARING	Jan 5, 2017	PAPER	BOARD
[Corrected] Petitioner's Sur-Sur Reply	Jan 4, 2017	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude	Jan 3, 2017	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument	Jan 3, 2017	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument	Dec 30, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Sur-Sur Reply	Dec 26, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
PATENT OWNER'S SUR-REPLY	Dec 19, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order Authorizing Sur-Reply and Sur-Sur-Reply	Dec 14, 2016	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence	Dec 5, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Supplemental Declaration of Fred Smith	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
MTD web site page - careers at MTD - Project Engineer	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
MTD web site page - careers at MTD - Mechanical Engineer	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Selected pages from Dictionary of Mechanical Engineering	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 5,042,238 White	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Reply	Nov 28, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Deposition Transcript of Steven Velinsky	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Select pages from Webster's Collegiate Dictionary, Fifth Edition	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 3,913,695 Holdenried	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 5,078,222 Hauser	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 2,704,112 Rice	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 4,029,226 Seaberg	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 4,337,836 Seaberg	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 3,680,723 Seaberg	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent 2,017,178 Braukhof	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Handbook of Ergonomic and Human Factors Tables	Nov 28, 2016	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List	Nov 28, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Velinsky Deposition Notice	Oct 4, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence	Sep 6, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Possible Seaberg Orientation	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Merriam-Webster Definition	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Dictionary.com Definition	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Smith Deposition Transcript	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Theory of Machines	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Kinematics and Dynamics	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Kinematics and Dynamics	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Response	Aug 29, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 7,540,506 (Cheney)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
'613 Patent Movement Illustration	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
'613 Patent Movement Illustration 2	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Velinsky Declaration	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Velinsky CV	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Kinematic Synthesis	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Seaberg Animation	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Anthropometric Data Part 1	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Anthropometric Data Part 3	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 3,751,754 (Quinlan)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Anthropometric Data Part 2	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Designing for Humans	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Case Model 1840 Specs	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
CASE Model 1845C Specs	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 6,324,939 (Cicotte)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 4,875,385 (Sitrin)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 3,151,499 (Roe)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 5,208,939 (Oulie)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 5,502,351 (Katoh)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
U.S. Patent No. 4,598,603 (Hiramitsu)	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Machines and Mechanisms	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Kinematics and Mechanisms	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Mechanical Engineering Definition	Aug 29, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner Exhibit List	Aug 29, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Smith Deposition Notice	Jul 21, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Stipulation	Jun 10, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Decision - Institution of Inter Partes Review - 37 CFR 42.108	May 13, 2016	PAPER	BOARD
Scheduling Order	May 13, 2016	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices	Apr 12, 2016	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Preliminary Response	Feb 24, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Exhibit List	Feb 24, 2016	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Complaint	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Toro Completes Acquisition	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Toro Company Locations	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Exmark Homepage	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Time Cutter SW4200 Home Depot	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
305 patent	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Various articles	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Cub Cadet Article	Feb 24, 2016	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Power of Attorney	Dec 7, 2015	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
Related Matters	Dec 7, 2015	PAPER	INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.
Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition	Nov 24, 2015	PAPER	BOARD
Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 8,136,613	Nov 19, 2015	PAPER	PETITIONER
Power of Attorney	Nov 19, 2015	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Exhibit List	Nov 19, 2015	PAPER	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 8,136,613	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 4,100,738 (Seaberg)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,927,527 (Engel)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Declaration of Fred P. Smith	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Fred P. Smith Curriculum Vitae	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.K. Patent Application No. 2,303,829 (Barnes)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Great Britain Published Specification No. 986,260 (Richard)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 8,011,458 (Hauser 458)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 2,446,242 (Orshansky)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,351,147 (Williamson)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,869,014 (Federspiel)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 5,152,382 (Hoch 382)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 5,216,935 (Shimamura)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 5,934,400 (Larsen)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 6,603,663 (Hauser 663)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Hydraulics and Pneumatics Article	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,315,759 (Bohlen)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. Re, 34,057 (Middlesworth Re 057)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,431,993 (Case)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 3,612,199 (Vissers)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 7,992,659 (Schaedler)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
U.S. Patent No. 6,874,305 (Ishimori)	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
File History - U.S. Patent No. 8,136,613	Nov 19, 2015	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER