The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2016-00388 filed by Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al. against Elm 3DS Innovations, LLC on Dec 28, 2015. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2016-00388
Filing Date
Dec 28, 2015
Petitioner
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al.
Respondent
Elm 3DS Innovations, LLC
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
10614067
Respondent Tech Center
2800
Respondent Patent Number
7193239
Institution Decision Date
Jul 1, 2016
Termination Date
Jun 23, 2017

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Petitioners' Notice of Appeal

Aug 24, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Final Written Decision

Jun 23, 2017PAPERBOARD

Record of Oral Hearing

May 12, 2017PAPERBOARD

Revised Trial Order

Mar 15, 2017PAPERBOARD

Order - Trial Hearing

Mar 7, 2017PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Request for Oral Hearing

Feb 24, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Feb 24, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Objection to Evidence

Feb 13, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response

Feb 6, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Ex. 1080

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1083

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1084

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1085

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1088

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1089

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1090

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1081

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1082

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1086

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1087

Feb 6, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Alexander D. Glew

Dec 19, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Second Joint Stipulation to Adjust Schedule

Dec 19, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

MULTICHIP MODULE TECHNOLOGIES AND ALTERNATIVES: THE BASICS (Daryl Ann Doane & Paul D. Franzon eds., 1993) (Part 1)

Dec 9, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Alexander D. Glew, PH.D.

Dec 9, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Oct 25, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence

Oct 21, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Response

Oct 14, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

S. Wolf, Silicon Processing

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Microchip Fabrication

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Runyan - Semiconductor (Part 2)

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Silicon Nitride and Silicon Dioxide

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Glew Declaration

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Multichip Module (Part 1)

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Multichip Fabrication (Part 2)

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

12-497,652 File History

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

12-497,652 File History

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Runyan - Semiconductor Integrated

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Multichip Fabrication

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Multichip Fabrication (Part 4)

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Multichip Fabrication (Part 5)

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Silicon Dioxide

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition Transcript of Paul Franzon

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

The Oxford American Disctionary

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Semiconductor Manufacturing

Oct 14, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Oct 14, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Mr. Harold Davis

Oct 4, 2016PAPERBOARD

Order - Petitioner's Pro Hac Vice Motion for Mr. Andrew B. Grossman

Oct 4, 2016PAPERBOARD

Power of Attorney for Petitioner SK Hynix Inc.

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney for Petitioner Micron Technology, inc.

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney for Petitioner Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Andrew B. Grossman

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Harold H. Davis, Jr.

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1077

Sep 30, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1078

Sep 30, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Sep 30, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Sep 26, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Decision - Patent Owner's Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel

Sep 20, 2016PAPERBOARD

Decision - Patent Owner's Mot. Pro Hac Vice Admis. Mr. Michael C. Newman

Sep 20, 2016PAPERBOARD

Amended Notice of Deposition of Dr. Paul D. Franzon

Sep 16, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Sep 16, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owners Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel

Sep 16, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Adjust Schedule

Sep 15, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 2157 - Declaration of Michael C. Newman in Support of PHV

Sep 13, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Michael C. Newman

Sep 13, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owners Power of Attorney

Sep 7, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owners Supplemental Mandatory Notices

Sep 7, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Deposition

Sep 6, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit LIst

Aug 25, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1068

Aug 25, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Aug 25, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit LIst

Aug 22, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1067

Aug 22, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Decision - 37 C.F.R. 42.20

Aug 11, 2016PAPERBOARD

Revised Scheduling Order

Aug 8, 2016PAPERBOARD

Summary of Conference Call

Aug 8, 2016PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Response to Patent Owner's Motion Regarding Claim Construction

Jul 27, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Notice Correcting Certificates of Service

Jul 19, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Elm Motion Regarding Claim Construction

Jul 18, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Patent Expiration

Jul 18, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 2149

Jul 18, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence

Jul 15, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owners Objections To Petitioners Evidence

Jul 15, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Jul 11, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Decision - Institution of Inter Partes Review - 37 CFR 42.108

Jul 1, 2016PAPERBOARD

Scheduling Order

Jul 1, 2016PAPERBOARD

Order - Patent Owners Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Samuel L. Walling

Jul 1, 2016PAPERBOARD

Order- Conduct of the Proceeding

Jul 1, 2016PAPERBOARD

Exhibit 3001

Jul 1, 2016EXHIBITBOARD

Elm 3DS Innovations LLC's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Samuel L. Walling and Declaration of Samuel L. Walling in Support of Motion

May 6, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Power of Attorney

May 5, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Apr 7, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2100

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2101

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2102

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2103

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2104

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2105

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2106

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2107

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2108

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2109

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2115

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2116

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2117

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2118

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2119

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2120

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2121

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2122

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2123

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2125

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2127

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2131

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2132

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2133

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2134

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2135

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2136

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2137

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2139

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2143

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2144

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2145

Apr 7, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Power of Attorney

Jan 19, 2016PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Related Matters

Jan 19, 2016PAPERINDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER.

Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition

Jan 7, 2016PAPERBOARD

Power of Attorney

Dec 28, 2015PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Dec 28, 2015PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Dec 28, 2015PAPERPETITIONER

IPR Petition - U.S. Patent No. 7,193,239

Dec 28, 2015PAPERPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 7,193,239

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Cirriculum Vitae of Dr. Paul D. Franzon

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

USP 5354695 (Leedy)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Real-Time Microvision System (Yu)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Three-Dimensional Integration Technology (Matsumoto)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 7,193,239 - File History

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

499 Patent FH - 5-29-13 OA

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

499 Patent FH - 6-20-13 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

499 Patent FH - As-Filed Patent Application

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

652 App. FH - 9-26-13 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

653 App. FH - 10-24-13 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

652 App FH - 4-5-13 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

167 Patent - 4-28-98 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

167 Patent FH - 9-8-98 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

542 Patent FH - 7-30-12 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

466 Patent FH - 2-16-09 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

466 Patent FH - 6-25-09 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

119 Patent FH - 9-4-12 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

119 Patent FH - Appeal Brief

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

617 Patent FH - 12-14-10 Response

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

652 App FH - 8-27-14 OA

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

652 App FH - 11-20-14 Express Abandonment

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

653 App - 8-27-14 Advisory Action

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

653 App FH - 11-20-14 Express Abandonment

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Gerard P. Grenier

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

A New Three-Dimensional Multiport Memory (Hirano)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Concept One CVD System Process Specification

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Processing for the VLSI Era (Wolf)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

USP 3508980 (Jackson)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

USP 3044909 (Shockley)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Stress-Induced Dislocations (Fahey)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Physics of Thin Films (Hass)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Stress in Thermal SiO2 During Growth (EerNisse)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Delamination and Fracture of Thin FIlms (Klokholm)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

USP 4948482 (Kobayashi)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Dielectric Film Influence (Isobe)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Advantages of Dual Frequency PECVD (VandeVen)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

USP 5160998 (Itoh)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Polymer Dielectrics for Multichip Module Packaging (Garrou)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Warpage and Mechanical Strength (Grief)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Japan's Push into Creative Semiconductor Research (Tatsuno)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Three-Dimensional IC Trends (Akasaka)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Evaluatoin of Cubic Devices (Hayashi)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Future WSI Technology (Williams)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

3-D Multichip Packaging (Crowley)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Memory-Chip Stacks Send Density Skyward (Malinak)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Interconnect Capacitances (Kuhn)

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

WorldCat Entry - Yu

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Dr. Paul D. Franzon

Dec 28, 2015EXHIBITPETITIONER