Order: Decision on Petitions | Jun 14, 2023 | PAPER | BOARD |
Ex. 3202 | Jun 14, 2023 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Ex. 3203 | Jun 14, 2023 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Ex. 3201 | Aug 30, 2021 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Notification of Request for Rehearing by the Director Ex. 3200 | Aug 20, 2021 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Request for Rehearing by the Director | Aug 16, 2021 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Petition Under 37 C.F.R. 1.181(a)(3) Invoking the Supervisory Authority of the Director | Aug 16, 2021 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Petition Under 37 C.F.R. 1.182 Regarding Question Not Specifically Provided For | Aug 16, 2021 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Petition Under 37 C.F.R. 1.183 for Suspension of Rules | Aug 16, 2021 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Response to Patent Owner's Notice Regarding Grant of Cert Petition | Nov 3, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice Regarding Pending Supreme Court Case with Bearing on this IPR | Nov 2, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice of Supreme Court's Decision Regarding Petition for a Writ of Certiorari | Oct 7, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order - Denying Petition for Writ of Certiorari, Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, Inc., et al., No. 19-1204 | Oct 6, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Notice That Patent Owner's Petition for a Writ of Certiorari Has Been Denied | Oct 6, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice of Filing of Petition for Writ of Certiorari | May 21, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit A - Petition for Writ of Certiorari | May 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice of Intent to File Petition for Writ of Certiorari | Nov 15, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal | Feb 14, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Decision Denying Request for Rehearing | Dec 15, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Request for Rehearing | Nov 15, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Final Written Decision
and
Incorporating Decision on Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence | Oct 16, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, 2:15-CV-01047 (E.D. Texas), Jury Verdict Form | Oct 16, 2017 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, 2:15-CV-01047 (E.D. Texas Feb. 13, 2017), Order of Dismissal with Prejudice | Oct 16, 2017 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, 2:15-CV-01047 (E.D. Texas Feb. 13, 2017), Joint Stipulated Motion for Dismissal with Prejudice | Oct 16, 2017 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, 2:15-CV-01047 (E.D. Texas), Docket Sheet | Oct 16, 2017 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
US Patent No. 6,652,563 B2, issued Nov. 25, 2003 (Dreyfuss) | Oct 16, 2017 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Hearing Transcript | Aug 4, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Petitioners' Notice of Filing Demonstrative Exhibits | Jul 14, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Demonstrative Exhibits (Part 1 of 3) | Jul 14, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Demonstrative Exhibits (Part 2 of 3) | Jul 14, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Demonstrative Exhibits (Part 3 of 3) | Jul 14, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Notice of Filing Demonstrative Exhibits | Jul 14, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibit | Jul 14, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Trial Hearing
37 C.F.R. sec 42.70 | Jun 13, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner's Reply Brief in Support of Motion to Exclude Certain Evidence | Jun 12, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Corrected Updated Exhibit List | Jun 6, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Supplemental Declaration of Alexander Slocum | Jun 5, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
PDF of Electronic Image Files for Paragraph 106 of Slocum Declaration | Jun 5, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
PDF of Electronic Image Files for Paragraph 119 of Slocum Declaration | Jun 5, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Email Correspondence | Jun 5, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude | Jun 5, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List | Jun 5, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Response to Patent Owner's Motion for Observations | Jun 5, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Joint Request for Oral Argument and Request for Alternative Hearing Date | May 22, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 4,632,100 (Slocum Exhibit 2) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,370,662 (Slocum Exhibit 3) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
CAD diagram (Slocum Exhibit 4) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Figure 1 diagram (Slocum Exhibit 9) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Figure 3 diagram (Slocum Exhibit 10) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Screenshot of file list from Exhibit 1173 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Transcript of Deposition of Alexander H. Slocum (May 17, 2017) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Motion for Observation Regarding Cross-Examination of Dr. Alexander Slocum | May 22, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Patent No, 7,090,690 (Slocum Exhibit 1) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Handwritten formula (Slocum Exhibit 5) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Diagram showing cortical layer (Slocum Exhibit 6) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Diagram showing cortical layer (Slocum Exhibit 7) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Figure 2 diagram (Slocum Exhibit 8) | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Rotated view of screw cross section with female and male configuration from Exhibit 1173 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Screenshot of file list from Exhibit 1174 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Image of PDF "drivers in hexagons 0.36 mm slot.PDF" from Ex. 1174 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Annotated screenshot of file "drivers in hexagons.SLDASM" from Ex. 1174 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Rotated view of "drivers in hexagons.SLDASM" from Ex. 1174 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Patent Application No. US 2005/0277985A1 | May 22, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Updated Exhibit List | May 22, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Certain Evidence Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.62(a) and 42.64(c) | May 22, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Slocum Deposition Exhibit 11, "Precision Machine Design" by Alexander H. Slocum | May 19, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners Response to Arthex's List of Alleged Improper Arguments | May 19, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List | May 19, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Transcript of April 27, 2017 Deposition of Alexander Slocum | May 19, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
ORDER Modifying Scheduling Order | May 16, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice of Deposition of Alexander H. Slocum, Ph.D. | May 11, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s List of Improper Evidence and Argument Relating to Petitioners' Reply | May 10, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order on Authorizing List of Allegedly Improper Arguments | May 2, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Arthrex's Objections to Evidence | Apr 14, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Updated Mandatory Notices | Apr 12, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Notice of Deposition of Alexander H. Slocum, Ph.D. | Apr 11, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order Withdrawal of Counsel | Apr 7, 2017 | PAPER | BOARD |
Annotated Figures 6, 7A and 8 of U.S. Patent No. 8,821,541 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Dictionary of Mechanical Engineering, Fourth Edition (1996) | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Reply to Patent Owner's Response | Apr 7, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Hand Drawing | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Transcript of Deposition of Kenneth A. Gall, Ph.D. | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
The American College Heritage Dictionary, Third Edition (2000) | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Arthrex 4.5mm Bio-Corkscrew FT Anchor SKU | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Curriculum Vitae of Professor Alexander H. Slocum | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
US Patent No. 8,801,755 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Reporter¿¿¿s Transcript of Jury Trial, Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, Inc. et al., Civ. No. 2:15-cv-01047-RSP | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
USP Monographs: Nonabsorbable Surgical Suture | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Arthrex, Inc.¿¿¿s Opening Claim Construction Brief | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
SpeedScrew Brochure | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Arthrex Preliminary Patent Owner Response, IPR2016-00486 (PTAB April 28, 2016) | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
US Patent No. 5,336,240 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
US Patent No. 5,911,721 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
US Patent No. 5,746,272 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
European Patent Publication No. 0502509 A1 | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Professor Alexander H. Slocum | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
ORDER, Arthrex, Inc. v. Smith & Nephew, Inc. et al., Civ. No. 2:15-cv-01047-RSP, Doc. No. 277 (E.D. Tex. November 30, 2016) | Apr 7, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Motion for Counsel to Withdraw | Mar 30, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Notice of Deposition of Ken Gall, Ph.D. | Mar 7, 2017 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Oxford Paperback Dictionary and Thesaurus | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Arthrex Covered Products Chart | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
SpeedScrew | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Christopher A. Vellturo, Ph.D. (redacted) | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Machinery's Handbook | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Transcript of Deposition of Mark A. Ritchart | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Transcript of Trial Testimony | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Copying Products Chart | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
ArthroCare Spartan 510k | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
ArthroCare Spartan Press Release | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Cayenne Quattro Press Release | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
ConMed CrossFT 510k | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
DePuy Healix Ti 510k | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
FDA Twist Peek 510k Summary | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
S&N TwinFix Ultra Ti 510k | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Tornier Insite 510k | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Modified Protective Order (clean) | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Jessica Zilberberg | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Article - Use of 3D Printed Bone Plate | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Ken Gall, PhD | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Christopher A. Vellturo, Ph.D. (unredacted) | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Modified Protective Order | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Christopher Holter (redacted) | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Christopher Holter (unredacted) | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Judgment | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Atlas of Stress-Strain Curves | Jan 13, 2017 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Motion to Seal | Jan 13, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Arthrex, Inc.'s Response Pursuant to 37 CFR 42.120 | Jan 13, 2017 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order - Granting Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nathan R. Speed - 37 CFR 42.10 | Nov 17, 2016 | PAPER | BOARD |
Notice of Deposition of Mark Ritchart | Nov 14, 2016 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Corrected Mandatory Notices for Arthrex, Inc. | Nov 11, 2016 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Scheduling Order | Oct 17, 2016 | PAPER | BOARD |
Decision - Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review | Oct 17, 2016 | PAPER | BOARD |
Random House Webster's College Dictionary | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
American Heritage College Dictionary | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
PRELIMINARY RESPONSE | Jul 22, 2016 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Arthrex-About Us | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Forbes-Meet Reinhold Schmieding | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Oxford Dictionary | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
ArthroCare Closes Opus Medical Acquistion | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Opus Medical and ArthroCare Merger Agreement | Jul 22, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission for Nathan R. Speed | Jun 1, 2016 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List | Jun 1, 2016 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Nathan R. Speed in support of Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice | Jun 1, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Power of Attorney | May 10, 2016 | PAPER | INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER. |
Related Matters | May 10, 2016 | PAPER | INDICATES ARTIFACT WAS SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF POTENTIAL_PATENT OWNER. |
Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition and Time for Filing Patent Owner Preliminary Response | Apr 22, 2016 | PAPER | BOARD |
Power of Attorney | Apr 19, 2016 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petition for Inter Partes Review | Apr 19, 2016 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 8,821,541 (the '541 patent) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
File History of U.S. Patent No. 8,821,541 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Mark A. Ritchart | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Curriculum vitae of Mark A Ritchart | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Pub. No. 2006/0271060 (Gordon) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 7,322,978 (West) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,464,427 (Curtis) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Pub. No. 2002/0111653 (Foerster) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 6,656,183 (Colleran) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Pub. No. 2004/0106950 (Grafton) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Pub. No. 2003/0065361 (Dreyfuss) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 3,716,058 (Tanner) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 11/097,172 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 10/083,568 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 09/495,816 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 11/224,060 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 60/271,414 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 60/118,228 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 60/125,781 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Application Ser. No. 60/715,614 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
The American Heritage College Dictionary (3d ed. 2000) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Appendix B, Exhibit 120 to Arthrex's Disclosures of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Food and Drug Administration Guidance - Use of International Standard ISO-10993 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Publ. No. 2003/187444 (Overtaker) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,690,676 (DiPoto) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Appl. Publ. No. 2002/052629 (Morgan) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Goble, et al., The Development of Suture Anchors for Use in Soft Tissue Fixation to Bone | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Rupp, et al., Fatigue Testing of Suture Anchors | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., Suture Anchor Failure Strength - An In Vivo Study | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., The Ultimate Strength of Suture Anchors | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., Suture Anchor Strength Revisited | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., Suture Anchors - Update 2003 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Hecker, et al., Pull-out Strength of Suture Anchors for Rotator Cuff and Bankart Lesion Repairs | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., Suture Anchors - Update 1999 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Goradia, M.D., et al., Cyclic Loading of Rotator Cuff Repairs | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Burkhart, M.D., et al., Cyclic Loading of Anchor-Based Rotator Cuff Repairs | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 4,632,100 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Lajtai, et. al., Shoulder arthroscopy and MRI Techniques (2003) | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Barber, M.D., et al., Internal Fixation Strength of Suture Anchors - Update 1997 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,824,011 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,851,219 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. D331,463 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,573,548 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,156,616 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 2,243,717 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 2,489,870 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,411,523 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,236,445 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,935,129 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 5,411,506 | Apr 19, 2016 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |