The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2016-01763 filed by Kapsch TrafficCom IVHS Inc. et al. against Neology, Inc. et al. on Sep 9, 2016. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2016-01763
Filing Date
Sep 9, 2016
Petitioner
Kapsch TrafficCom IVHS Inc. et al.
Respondent
Neology, Inc. et al.
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
14060407
Respondent Tech Center
2800
Respondent Patent Number
8944337
Institution Decision Date
Mar 21, 2017
Termination Date
Mar 20, 2018

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

EXPUNGED

Dec 19, 2018PAPERPETITIONER

EXPUNGED

Dec 19, 2018PAPERPETITIONER

Final Written Decision

Mar 20, 2018PAPERBOARD

Application Data Sheet

Mar 20, 2018EXHIBITBOARD

Hearing Transcript

Feb 26, 2018PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Notice of Filing Corrected Opposition to Patent Owner's Contingent Motion to Amend

Feb 13, 2018PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Corrected Opposition to Patent Owner's Contingent Motion to Amend

Feb 13, 2018PAPERPETITIONER

Response to Corrected Motion for Observations on Cross Examination of Patent Owner's Sur-Sur-Reply Declarant Jeffrey Fischer

Jan 4, 2018PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Corrected Motion for Observations on Cross Examination of Jeffrey Fischer

Dec 30, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Motion for Observations on Cross Examination of Jeffrey Fischer

Dec 29, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1059: Diagram

Dec 29, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1061: Diagram

Dec 29, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Fourth Amended Appendix of Exhibits

Dec 29, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1060: Diagram

Dec 29, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1062: Diagram

Dec 29, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Deposition of Jeffrey Fischer, December 22, 2017

Dec 29, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Third Notice of Deposition of Jeffrey Fischer

Dec 20, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Creative Materials Spec Sheet for 125 through 128 Conductive Ink and Coating

Dec 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Sur-Sur-Reply to Petitioner's Sur-Reply to Contingent Motion to Amend

Dec 19, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Pelco Spec Sheet for High Performance Silver Paste

Dec 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Sirit Inc Spec Sheet for RSI 654 RFID Inlay

Dec 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Fischer Declaration in Support of Patent Owners Sur Sur Reply

Dec 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Appendix of Exhibits

Dec 19, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order Trial Hearing

Dec 13, 2017PAPERBOARD

Order Conduct of the Proceeding

Dec 13, 2017PAPERBOARD

PATENT OWNER NEOLOGY INC.¿¿¿S REPLY TO PETITIONER¿¿¿S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE

Dec 11, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude

Dec 11, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude Evidence

Dec 8, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Response to Patent Owner's Motion for Observation

Dec 8, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Supplemental Evidence in Response to Patent Owner's Objections

Dec 8, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Third Amended Appendix of Exhibits

Dec 8, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence

Dec 8, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Errata to Exhibit 1049 (Roesner Declaration)

Dec 8, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Bruce Roesner¿¿¿s current curriculum vitae (as of December 2017)

Dec 8, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Handwritten diagram

Dec 8, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Errata Sheet to December 1, 2017 Deposition Transcript of Bruce Roesner

Dec 8, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Motion for Observations on Cross Examination of Petitioner's Sur-Reply Declarant Dr. Roesner

Dec 6, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Motion to Exclude Evidence Under CFR Sections 42.62 and 42.64

Dec 6, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from Antenna Theory by Constantine A. Balanis

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Motion to Exclude

Dec 6, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Excerpts from RFID Design Principles by Harvey Lehpamer

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from RFID Handbook by Finkenzeller

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to Roesner deposition taken on December 1 2017 Photograph of Concentrics

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to December 1, 2017 Roesner deposition Electronic Diagram

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition transcript of Dr. Bruce Roesner taken December 1 2017

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Appendix of Exhibits

Dec 6, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to December 1 2017 Roesner deposition Electronic Circuit Schematic

Dec 6, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Transcript of the 11/30/17 Teleconference held before Hon. Judge Christa P. Zado and Judge Trevor M. Jefferson.

Dec 4, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Corrected Transcript of 11/30/17 Teleconference before Judge Christa P. Zado and Judge Trevor M. Jefferson.

Dec 4, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Objections to Petitioner's Evidence Submitted with Petitioner's Sur-Reply

Nov 27, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Third Notice of Deposition of Bruce B. Roesner

Nov 27, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner¿¿¿s Sur-Reply To Patent Owner¿¿¿s Reply To Petitioner¿¿¿s Opposition To Patent Owner¿¿¿s Contingent Motion To Amend

Nov 17, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1035A: Model

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1039: Sheet of Figure 2 from ¿¿¿337 Patent

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1041 Hand-drawn Antenna for RF Tag

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1043 Hand-drawn Antenna for RF Tag

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1047: U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2008/0265039 to Skowronek et al.

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Bruce Roesner

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from Boylestad, Robert L., Introductory Circuit Analysis, 2007

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner¿¿¿s Second Amended Appendix of Exhibits

Nov 17, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1033: Model

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1034: Model

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1035B: Model

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1036: Transparency

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1037: Excerpt from ¿¿¿337 Patent

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1038: Excerpt from ¿¿¿337 Patent

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1040: Excerpt from ¿¿¿337 Patent

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1042 Hand-drawn Antenna for RF Tag

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1044: Antenna Design

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1045: Antenna Design

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1046: U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2007/0109101 to Colby

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1048: Smartrac Product & Solution Finder

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from Stein, Jess (Editor) The Random House Dictionary of the English Language, 1966

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 6,121,544 to Petsinger (issued Sept. 19, 2000)

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,604,995 to Hammad (issued Dec. 10, 2013)

Nov 17, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Stipulation Modifying Due Dates 4 and 5, and Joint Request to Modify Due Date 6 of the Scheduling Order

Nov 9, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Supplemental Evidence in Response to Petitioner's Objections

Nov 9, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex 2055 to Supplemental Evidence in Response to Petitioner's Objections

Nov 9, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Appendix of Exhibits

Nov 9, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Nov 8, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Request for Oral Argument

Nov 8, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Errata for Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Contingent Motion to Amend

Nov 3, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Errata for Declaration of Dr. Bruce Roesner in Support of Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Amend (Ex. 1031)

Nov 3, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Conduct of the Proceeding

Oct 27, 2017PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Second Notice of Deposition of Jim Fischer

Oct 27, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Objections to Admissibility of Evidence Served with Patent Owner's Reply in Support of Contingent Motion to Amend

Oct 26, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re Roesner Decl. ISO Petitioners Opposition to POs Motion to Amend

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re US Patent Pub. US 2010.0302012 A1 to Roesner

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re International Patent Appl. Pub. WO 2008.074050 A1 to Atherton

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 9.8.17 Fischer deposition - M shape antenna on RFID Windshield tag sold by Neology

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re POs Claims Appendix

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re U.S. Patent Pub. US 2010.0283690 A1 to Artigue

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re US Patent 8944337 to Neology

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re US Patent Application Publication No. US 2017.0098106 A1 to Roesner

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re Roesners 2nd hand drawn modification to Atherton antenna

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from RFID Handbook by Finkenzeller p. 64

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

10.13.17 Roesner deposition transcript condensed

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from Antennas 2nd Ed. by John D. Krauss

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit to 10.13.17 Roesner deposition re Dr. Roesners 1st hand drawn modification to Atherton antenna

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Paper titled Novel Empirical Equations to Calculate the Impedance of a Strip Dipole Antenna

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Paper titled Microstrip Dipole Antenna Analysis with Different Width and Length at 2.4 GHz

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Internal photos

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts from Microwave Engineering 4th Ed. by David M. Pozar

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

EXPUNGED

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

EXPUNGED

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Reply to Petitioner's Opposition to Contingent Motion to Amend

Oct 19, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Video demonstration of a switch in operation

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Supplemental Fischer Declaration ISO PO's Motion to Amend

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Video of experiment demonstrating that Artigues amplifying loop antenna 3 is not a booster antenna

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Errata Sheet for the October 13, 2017 deposition of Dr. Bruce Roesner

Oct 19, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Appendix of Exhibits

Oct 19, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Second Notice of Deposition of Bruce B. Roesner

Sep 27, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response

Sep 21, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1023- Annotated Excerpt from U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner¿¿¿s Opposition to Patent Owner¿¿¿s Contingent Motion to Amend

Sep 21, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner¿¿¿s Amended Appendix of Exhibits

Sep 21, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1021- Annotated Excerpt from U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1022- Annotated Excerpt from U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1026- Handwritten Diagram

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Instructables: Pull Out Birthday Card

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1024- Annotated Excerpt from U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Fischer Deposition Exhibit 1025- U.S. Patent Application Publication No. US 2010/0283690 A1 to Artigue et al.

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Deposition of Jim Fischer, IPR Case No. 2016-01763, September 8, 2017

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from Steven M. Kaplan, Wiley Electrical and Electronics Engineering Dictionary (2004)

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from Merriam-Webster¿¿¿s Collegiate Dictionary (10th ed. 2002)

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Bruce Roesner in Support of Petitioner¿¿¿s Opposition to Patent Owner¿¿¿s Contingent Motion to Amend

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 9,582,746 to Mullis et al.

Sep 21, 2017EXHIBITPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Jim Fischer

Aug 24, 2017PAPERPETITIONER

Response to IPR

Jun 21, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

WIPO Publ. ¿¿¿4050 to Atherton

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Electronics for Scientists by Malmstadt, Enke

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Introductory Circuit Analysis by Boylestad

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Transcript of June 8 2017 Bruce B. Roesner Deposition

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Holt et al. Physics 1999

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Glossary of RFID Terms May 22 2013

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

EPC based RFID Item Level Tagging

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

How to Read Circuit Diagrams and Electronic Graphs by Clifford

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Introductory Circuit Analysis by Boylestad

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

¿¿¿337 Patent to Mullis

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Introductory Electric Circuit Analysis by Johnson & Johnson

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Random House Dictionary (¿¿¿Mechanism¿¿¿)

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Fischer Declaration ISO Patent Owners Response to Petition

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Mazda F.F. Discrete Electronics Components 1981

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Motion to Amend Claims

Jun 21, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

586 Application

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

372 Application

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

834 Cont. Appl.

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

407 Nonprov. Appl.

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

206 Patent to Burnett

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

4461 Patent Publ. to Gelbman

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Fischer Declaration ISO Patent Owners Contingent Motion to Amend Claims

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Transcript of June 8 2017 Bruce B. Roesner Deposition

Jun 21, 2017EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Appendix of Exhibits

Jun 21, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Guidance on Motion to Amend Claims - 37 CFR 42.121

Jun 15, 2017PAPERBOARD

Notice of Deposition of Bruce B. Roesner

May 5, 2017PAPERPATENT OWNER

Trial Instituted Document

Mar 21, 2017PAPERBOARD

SCHEDULING ORDER

Mar 21, 2017PAPERBOARD

Preliminary Response

Dec 22, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

US Patent App. Pub. 2004 0242285 A1 to Farshi Pub. Date Dec. 2 2004

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Reference Designer Chapter 4.1 Impedance of Capacitor 2009

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Fischer Declaration ISO Patent Owners Preliminary Response

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

WO 2003 079487 A1 to Roshchupkin

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Poynting Universal Modem to Antenna Adaptor

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

US Patent 7437148 B1 to Vaghi et al. issued Oct. 14 2008

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

US Patent 5659324 to Taniguchi et al. issued Aug. 19 1997

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Lee et al Designing Antenna Booster Cases for Mobile Phones using Capacitive Coupling Techniques 2015

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Reference Designer Chapter 4.1 Parallel Plate Capacitor 2009

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Finkenzeller RFID Handbook Fundamentals and Applications in Contactless Smart Cards and Identification, 2nd Ed. 1999 Copyright pages and Chapters 2-4

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

US Patent 8416079 B2 to Roesner issued on April 9 2013

Dec 22, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Robert H. Sloss

Oct 28, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Robert H. Sloss ISO Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice

Oct 28, 2016EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Mandatory Notice

Oct 25, 2016PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Sep 22, 2016PAPERBOARD

Declaration of Anders P. Fjellstedt

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

PCT International Application No. 2008/074050 A1, to Peter Samuel Atherton

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Bruce Roesner in Support of Petition

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Bruce Roesner's curriculum vitae

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337 to Mullis et al.

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

USPTO Assignment on the Web for U.S. Patent No. 8,944,337

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 7,460,018, to Yuki Kubo, issued December 2, 2008

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2007/0290858 to Janke et al.

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,350,673, to Nyalamadugu et al., issued January 8, 2013

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U. S. Patent No. 674,284, to G.A. Sachs, issued May 14, 1901

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U. S. Patent Application Publication No. 2007/0144662, to Armijo et al.

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 7,361,251, to Green et al., issued April 22, 2008

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2010/0302012, to Bruce B. Roesner

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from '337 file history: April 4, 2014 Non-Final Rejection

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from '337 file history: Nov. 4, 2014 Response After Final Action

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 7,571,694, to Rick Boerner, issued August 11, 2009

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

European Patent No. 2230174, to Yoshizaki, issued September 22, 2010

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U. S. Patent No. 7,120,987, to Peikang Liu et al., issued October 17, 2006

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpt from '337 file history: Nov. 14, 2014 Notice of Allowance

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2010/0283690, to Artigue, et al.

Sep 9, 2016EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petition

Sep 9, 2016PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Sep 9, 2016PAPERPETITIONER