JUDGEMENT
Final Written Decision
Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable
35 U.S.C. § 318(a)
ORDER
Dismissing Patent Owner’s Motion to Strike
Dismissing Patent Owner’s Motion to Exclude Evidence
37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5, 42.64 | Sep 27, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Hearing Transcript | Jul 12, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Petitioners' Demonstratives | Jun 20, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Submission of Demonstratives | Jun 20, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order - 37 C.F.R. 42.70 | Jun 11, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Reply in Support of Motion to Exclude Evidence | Jun 10, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Opposition to Motion to Exclude | Jun 4, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Motion to Exclude Evidence | May 29, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Request For Oral Argument | May 28, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument IPR2018-00788 | May 28, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Opposition To Motion To Strike | May 21, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 3001 | May 15, 2019 | EXHIBIT | BOARD |
Conduct of the Proceeding | May 15, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Motion to Strike Petitioner's Untimely New Reply Arguments and Evidence | May 7, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Sur-Reply | May 7, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Order Granting PO Request to File Motion to Strike | Apr 24, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Objections to Evidence | Apr 18, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Second Declaration of Joseph L. Mundy, Ph.D. | Apr 11, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Lu, Xiaguang, Image Analysis for Face Recognition, in
Proceedings of Personal Notes, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Michigan State University, 2003 | Apr 11, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Deposition Transcript of Eli Saber, Ph.D., April 1, 2019 | Apr 11, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioners' Reply to Patent Owner's Response To Petition | Apr 11, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List As of April 11, 2019 | Apr 11, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
The American Heritage College Dictionary, Fourth Edition 2004 | Apr 11, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Corrected Notice of Deposition of Dr. Eli Saber, Ph.D. | Mar 18, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Notice of Deposition of Dr. Eli Saber, Ph.D. | Mar 15, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner Response IPR2018-00788 | Jan 17, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2003 - Blanz et al | Jan 17, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Exhibit List (Jan 17, 2018) IPR2018-00788 | Jan 17, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2001 - Saber Declaration IPR2018-00788 | Jan 17, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2002 - Saber CV | Jan 17, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2004 - American Heritage College Dictionary | Jan 17, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2005 - Computer Graphics | Jan 17, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioners' Power of Attorney | Jan 7, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Notice of Cancellation of Deposition (IPR2018-00788) | Jan 3, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Additional Backup Counsel | Jan 2, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
ORDER - Petitioner¿¿¿s Motion for Pro Hac Vice
Admission of Kevin M. Littman
37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.10(c) | Dec 19, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Granting-in-Part Petitioner's Motion to Submit Supplemental Information
37 C.F.R. sec. 42.123 | Dec 17, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Notice of Deposition of Joseph Mundy (IPR2018-00788) | Dec 11, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Joint Stipulation and Notice of Stipulation To Change Due Dates | Dec 10, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Unopposed Motion For Pro Hac Vice Admission of Kevin M. Littman | Dec 10, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Kevin M. Littman in Support of Unopposed Motion For Pro Hac Vice Admission | Dec 10, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Opposition to Motion to Submit Supplemental Information | Nov 30, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding | Nov 20, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List As of November 16, 2018 | Nov 16, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Motion To Submit Supplemental Information Under 37 C.F.R. Section 42.123(a) | Nov 16, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Manfred Wiedmann | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Transcript of teleconference held on November 6, 2018, between
Petitioner, Patent Owner, and the Board | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Notice of filing Transcript of November 6, 2018 Conference Call | Nov 16, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Michelle Antoinette | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
EXPUNGED | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Declaration of Oliver Wiedmann | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Letter from Susanne P¿¿tz-Jagner of ZB Med, dated November 8, 2018 | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Letter from Dr. Elisabeth Niggemann of Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, dated November 14, 2018 | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
LIVIVO Search results ¿¿¿ digital dental news | Nov 16, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Trial Instituted Document | Oct 3, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Scheduling Order | Oct 3, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Preliminary Response | Jul 8, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner Updated Mandatory Notice Information | Jul 5, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Accord Filing Date | Apr 9, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner Mandatory Notice Information | Apr 4, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Declaration of Joseph Mundy, Ph.D. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Image File Wrapper for the '336 patent (Part 2 of 3) | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Image File Wrapper for the '336 patent (Part 3 of 3) | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 7,156,655 to Sachdeva et al. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
International Publication Number WO 2008/128700 A1 to Malfliet et al. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Wiedmann, Oliver, "According to the Laws of Harmony to find the right tooth shape with the assistance of the computer," Digital Dental News, 2nd Volume, April 2008 | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petition for Inter Partes Review Under 35 U.S.C. Sections 311-319 and 37 C.F.R. Section 42.100 et seq. | Mar 15, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 9,336,336 to Deichmann et al. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Curriculum Vitae of Joseph Mundy, Ph.D. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Image File Wrapper for the '336 patent (Part 1 of 3) | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 6,568,936 to MacDougald | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Lehman, Thomas M., et al., "Survey: Interpolation Methods in Medical Image Processing," IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, Vol. 18, No. 11, November 1999 | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent Publication No. US2002/0075389 to Seeger | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Power of Attorney | Mar 15, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 6,845,175 to Kopelman et al. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Definition of "virtual" from www.webopedia.com | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Patent No. 7,234,937 to Sachdeva et al. | Mar 15, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |