JUDGMENT
Final Written Decision
Determining No Challenged Claim Unpatentable
Denying Petitioner's Motion to Exclude
Denying Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude
Granting Petitioner's Motion to Seal
Granting Patent Owner's Motions to Seal
35 U.S.C. § 318(a) | May 26, 2020 | PAPER | BOARD |
Petitioner Reply | May 14, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1016 | May 14, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1015 | May 14, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Hearing Transcript | Apr 2, 2020 | PAPER | BOARD |
Joint List of Objections to Demonstrative Exhibits | Feb 28, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibits | Feb 28, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioner's Corrected Demonstratives For Oral Argument | Feb 28, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioner Update on Related Matters | Feb 27, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Order in WD MI staying and administratively closing the pending case | Feb 27, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Order From WD MI Granting Summary Judgment prior to stay and administrative closure of the case | Feb 27, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Demonstratives For Oral Argument | Feb 27, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Reply in Further Support of Its Motion to Exclude | Feb 25, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Reply in Further Support of Its Motion to Exclude Evidence | Feb 25, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Conduct of the Proceeding
37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.5 | Feb 24, 2020 | PAPER | BOARD |
Updated Petitioner Opposition to Motion to Exclude | Feb 20, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude | Feb 18, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
EXPUNGED | Feb 18, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence | Feb 11, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioner's Motion to Exclude | Feb 11, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1017 | Feb 11, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Trial Hearing
37 C.F.R. sec. 42.70 | Feb 3, 2020 | PAPER | BOARD |
Objection to Declaration of Mr. Stasse, Ex 2042 | Jan 28, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner's Sur-reply | Jan 27, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Motion to Seal Patent Owner's Sur-reply and Exhibits 2039-2040 and 2042-2045 | Jan 21, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Sur-reply | Jan 21, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2039 2020-01-10 Deposition Transcript of Nick Hahn | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2041 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2042 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2043 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2040 2020-01-13 Deposition transcript of Paul Bonenberger | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2042 Declaration of Max Stasse | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2043 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2044 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2045 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2039 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2040 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2044 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 2045 | Jan 21, 2020 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument | Jan 21, 2020 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument | Jan 21, 2020 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Notice of Paul R. Bonenberger | Dec 23, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Deposition of Nick Hahn | Dec 23, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Joint Statement Regarding Patent Owner's Request for Additional Rebuttal Evidence in Support of Its Sur-Reply | Dec 20, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
JOINT STATEMENT REGARDING PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S REQUEST TO FILE A MOTION TO STRIKE | Dec 19, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Conduct of the Proceeding
37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.5 | Dec 9, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Notice of Deposition of Nick Hahn | Dec 4, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Deposition of Paul R. Bonenberger | Dec 4, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.64(b)(1) | Nov 25, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioner Motion To Seal | Nov 18, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Petitioner Reply | Nov 18, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1014 | Nov 18, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1015 Deposition of Lornic | Nov 18, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1012 | Nov 18, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Exhibit 1013 | Nov 18, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Deposition of Dr. Stauffer | Nov 18, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
PANEL CHANGE ORDER
Conduct of the Proceedings
37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.5 | Oct 11, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner's Response | Aug 30, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
2019-03-13 Deposition of Nick Hahn | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 9 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 28 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 29 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 81 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 93 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-04-29 Expert Report of A. Brent Strong | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-23 Declaration of Larry A. Stauffer | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 18 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 19 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 20 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 21 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 23 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 24 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 25 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 14 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 27 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 79 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 85 to Nick Hahn 2019-03-13 Deposition | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2017-06-07 Customer Visit Report (L00754) | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-04-29 Expert Report of Larry A. Stauffer | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-23 Declaration of John H. Curtis | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-26 Declaration of Martijn Middelhuis | Aug 30, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Motion to Seal | Aug 26, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Deposition of James A. Medsker | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Pat. No. 2,524,942 Tomlinson | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Pat. No. 2,562,681 Pine | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Pat. No. 2,412,108 Toti | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Pat. No. 7,070,494 Rapp et al. | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Pat. No. 5,447,021 Plamper et al. | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-07-30 Deposition Transcript of James A. Medsker | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-03-27 Deposition Transcript Excerpts of MPS North America 30(b)(6) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Video demonstrating replacement of Patent Owner's patented "Click Whip" brushes | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Video demonstrating the replacement of Patent Owner's standard slide-on (also known as "bolt-on") brushes | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Response | Aug 26, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
2019-03-13 Deposition Transcript of Nick Hahn | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 18 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00865) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 19 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00835) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 21 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00876) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 23 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00733) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 24 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00736) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 25 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00708) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 27 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L01400) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 28 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L01405) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 81 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L02342) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 93 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L03012) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit 8 to MPS North America Deposition (advertising brochure of MPS's patented click whips MPS-000477) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Video demonstrating carcass cleaning brushes being used in a carcass cleaning system | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-23 Declaration of Larry A. Stauffer | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 9 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L01142) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 20 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00883) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 14 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L00976) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 29 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L01407) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 79 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L02333) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Exhibit No. 85 to Nick Hahn Deposition (L02481) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Customer Service Report (L00754) | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-04-29 Expert Report of Larry A. Stauffer | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-04-29 Expert Report of A. Brent Strong | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-23 Declaration of John H. Curtis | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
2019-08-26 Declaration of Martijn Middelhuis | Aug 26, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Order Granting Joint Motion for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order | Aug 14, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Notice of Deposition of James A. Medsker | Jul 11, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Stipulation Regarding Transcripts of Depositions Taken in Related Litigation | Jun 26, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Joint Motion for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order | Jun 19, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence | Jun 17, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Petitioner's Objections | Jun 17, 2019 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Trial Instituted Document | Jun 3, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
SCHEDULING ORDER | Jun 3, 2019 | PAPER | BOARD |
Patent Owner's Preliminary Response | Mar 4, 2019 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Patent No. 7,070,494 to Rapp et al. | Mar 4, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Defendant¿¿¿s Response Memorandum of Law on Claim Construction in Humboldt B.V. v. Lornic Design, Inc. (W.D. Mich. 1:17-cv-00983) (dated June 8, 2018) (without exhibits) | Mar 4, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
U.S. Patent No. 3,840,938 to Carlson | Mar 4, 2019 | EXHIBIT | PATENT OWNER |
Patent Owner's Mandatory Notice | Dec 7, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Power of Attorney in an Inter Partes Review for Patent Owner Humboldt B.V. | Dec 7, 2018 | PAPER | PATENT OWNER |
Notice of Accord Filing Date | Dec 3, 2018 | PAPER | BOARD |
U.S. Pat. No. 9,433,225 | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petition for Inter Partes Review Pursuant to 35 USC 311-319, 37 CFR 42 (Claims 1-5, 7-22 of US Patent No. 9,433,225) | Nov 19, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |
Curriculum Vitae of James A. Medsker | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 5,445,163 Machacek | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 5,447,021 Plamper et al | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Patent Owner¿¿¿s Complaint for Patent Infringement in Humboldt B.V., and MPS North America, Inc. v. Lornic Design, Inc., Case No. 1:17-cv-00983 (W.D. Mich.), served November 20, 2017 | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Markman Order and Opinion by the Court in Humboldt B.V., and MPS North America, Inc. v. Lornic Design, Inc., Case No. 1:17-cv-00983 (W.D. Mich.) | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 9,433,225 Prosecution History | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Declaration of James A. Medsker | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 3,523,324 Debaere | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
U.S. Pat. No. 5,394,584 Breitschmid | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Returned Summons in Humboldt B.V., and MPS North America, Inc. v. Lornic Design, Inc., Case No. 1:17-cv-00983 (W.D. Mich.), showing service on November 20, 2017 | Nov 19, 2018 | EXHIBIT | PETITIONER |
Petitioner's Power of Attorney | Nov 19, 2018 | PAPER | PETITIONER |