IP Verse

Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al. vs Carucel Investments, LP

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2019-01404 filed by Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al. against Carucel Investments, LP on Jul 26, 2019. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2019-01404
Filing Date
Jul 26, 2019
Petitioner
Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al.
Respondent
Carucel Investments, LP
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
12908181
Respondent Tech Center
2600
Respondent Patent Number
7979023
Institution Decision Date
Jan 22, 2020
Termination Date
Jan 15, 2021

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Other: Fed Circuit mandate

Apr 9, 2024PAPERBOARD

Other: other court decision

Apr 9, 2024PAPERBOARD

PATENT OWNER���S AMENDMENT TO APRIL 29, 2021 NOTICE OF APPEAL

May 6, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order Denying Request for Director Review

Feb 7, 2022PAPERBOARD

Ex. 3100 Director Review Request

Dec 16, 2021EXHIBITBOARD

PATENT OWNER���S REQUEST FOR DIRECTOR REVIEW

Dec 13, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

PATENT OWNER���S NOTICE OF APPEAL

Apr 29, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Denying Patent Owners Request on Rehearing of Final Written Decision - 37 C.F.R. Sect. 42.71(d)

Mar 3, 2021PAPERBOARD

PATENT OWNER���S REQUEST FOR REHEARING UNDER 37 C.F.R. �� 42.71(d)

Feb 14, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. § 318(a)

Jan 15, 2021PAPERBOARD

Hearing Transcript

Dec 16, 2020PAPERBOARD

Ex. 1200 - Petitioners Demonstratives

Nov 30, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners Exhibit List

Nov 30, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner Oral Argument Demonstratives

Nov 29, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Nov 29, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S SUR-REPLY TO PETITIONER¿¿¿S REPLY TO PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S RESPONSE

Nov 12, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order Oral Hearing

Oct 30, 2020PAPERBOARD

PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT UNDER 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.70(a)

Oct 20, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioners Request for Oral Argument under 37 CFR 42.70(a)

Oct 20, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioners Updated Mandatory Notices

Oct 20, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioners Updated Power of Attorney

Oct 20, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

CORRECTED Ex 1106 - Declaration of Jeffrey Fischer ISO Petitioners Reply

Oct 9, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

JOINT NOTICE OF STIPULATION TO ADJUST SCHEDULE

Oct 8, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioners Reply to Patent Owner Response

Oct 8, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Ex 1102 - Deposition Transcript of Mark Lanning 2020-09-24

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1103 - Oxford Desk Dictionary

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1106 - Declaration of Jeffrey Fischer ISO Petitioners Reply

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1107 - File History of U.S. Patent No. 7,221,904

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1109 - Dictionary.com (Mobile Device)

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1110 - Cambridge Dictionary (Mobile Device)

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1101 - Deposition Transcript of Mark Lanning 2020-09-18

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1104 - Joint Claim Construction Worksheet, Carucel v. Novatel

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1105 - Lee - CDMA Systems Engineering Handbook

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1108 - U.S. Patent No. 7,221,904

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 1111 - Declaration of Cary Adickman ISO Petitioners Reply

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

CORRECTED Ex 1111 - Declaration of Cary Adickman ISO Petitioners Reply

Oct 8, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Mark Lanning

Sep 23, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

JOINT NOTICE OF STIPULATION TO ADJUST SCHEDULE

Sep 21, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Granting Petitioners Motions for Pro Hac Vice Admission 37 C.F.R. seC 42.10 C

Sep 1, 2020PAPERBOARD

Ex. 1054 - Declaration of Brian P. Biddinger in Support of Pro Hac Vice Motion

Aug 25, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Updated Petitioner Power of Attorney

Aug 25, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Unopposed Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Brian P. Biddinger

Aug 25, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Granting Petitioner's Motions for Pro Hac Vice Admission 37 C.F.R. 42.10

Aug 14, 2020PAPERBOARD

Petitioners Unopposed Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Cary E. Adickman

Jul 31, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Declaration of Cary E. Adickman in Support of Pro Hac Vice Motion

Jul 31, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex 2100 IPR2019-01404 (023 Patent) Declaration of M. Lanning

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2101 Mark Lanning CV

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2102 - Contentions of Facts and Law

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2105 Claim Construction Order

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2106 - Dkt. No. 356 Order denying Carucel JMOL

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2107 - 7,848,701 File Wrapper (excerpt)_compressed

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S RESPONSE TO THE PETITION PURSUANT TO 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.120

Jun 12, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex 2103 Electrical Engineering Tutorials How Cordless Telephones Work

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2104 Newton Book Pages_compressed

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2108-2 Fischer Depo Transcript 2020-05-29

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2109 - Book-CDMA RF System Engineering by Yang

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2114 What is the Personal Access Communications System (PACS) - Definition from Techopedia

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2116 Wireless Communications Principle by Rappaport

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2117 - Multiple Division Techniques by Al-Fuqaha

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2108-1 Fischer Depo Transcript 2020-05-28

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2110 CDMA Systems Engineering Handbook by Lee et al. 1998

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2111 Repeater Station Defined

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2112 US5257283 by Gilhousen

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2113 How Towers Work

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2115 - Personal Communications Service - Wikipedia

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex 2118 Wireless Communications-Past Events and a Future Perspective by Rappaport et al-CLEAN

Jun 12, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF MR. JEFFREY FISCHER

May 21, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

JOINT NOTICE OF STIPULATION TO ADJUST SCHEDULE

May 15, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

REVISED SCHEDULING ORDER

Apr 7, 2020PAPERBOARD

PO Updated Power Of Attorney

Mar 6, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

PO Updated Mandatory Notice

Mar 6, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Trial Instituted Document

Jan 22, 2020PAPERBOARD

Scheduling Order

Jan 22, 2020PAPERBOARD

PO Sur_Reply

Nov 25, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2005

Nov 25, 2019EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 2004

Nov 25, 2019EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Reply To Patent Owner¿¿¿s Preliminary Response To Address Discretionary Factors Arguments

Nov 18, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1049

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1050

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1051

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1052

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1047

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1048

Nov 18, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Cary E. Adickman

Nov 18, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Authorizing Petitioner Reply and Patent Owner Sur-reply 37 C.F.R. sec. 42.5

Nov 12, 2019PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Nov 6, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

PO Exhibit 2003

Nov 6, 2019EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

PO Exhibit 2001

Nov 6, 2019EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

PO Exhibit 2002

Nov 6, 2019EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Power of Attorney

Aug 23, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

Mandatory Notice

Aug 21, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

NOTICE OF FILING DATE ACCORDED TO PETITION AND TIME FOR FILING PATENT OWNER PRELIMINARY RESPONSE

Aug 6, 2019PAPERBOARD

Notice of Corrected Petition

Aug 5, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Ex. 1001 - U.S. Patent No. 7,979,023

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1003 - U.S. Patent No. 5,276,686 (Ito)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1005 - U.S. Patent No. 5,519,761 (Gilhousen761)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1008 - Declaration of Jeff Fischer

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1011 - Plaintiff First Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. General Motors Company, C.A. No. 3:18-cv-03332-M, Dkt. 1 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 18, 2018) (GM Complaint)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1002 - File History of U.S. Patent No. 7,979,023

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1004 - U.S. Patent No. 5,101,501 (Gilhousen501)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1006 - U.S. Patent No. 5,103,459 (Gilhousen459)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1007 - U.S. Patent No. 4,901,307 (Gilhousen307)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1009 - Curriculum Vitae of Jeff Fischer

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1010 - Plaintiff First Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Fiat Chrysler Automobiles US LLC et al., C.A. No. 3:18-cv-03331-M, Dkt. 1 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 18, 2018) (FCA Complaint)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1013 - Plaintiff Original Complaint for Patent Infringement, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al., C.A. No. 3:18-cv-03334-M, Dkt. 1 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 18, 2018) (MB Complaint)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1017 - Schwartz et al., COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS AND TECHNIQUES (McGraw-Hill 1966) (Schwartz)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1022 - Gilsic et al., WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS: TDMA VERSUS CDMA (Springer 1997) (Gilsic)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1023 - Grant, MANAGING TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND NETWORKING TECHNOLOGIES IN THE 21ST CENTURY: ISSUES AND TRENDS (Idea Group Publishing 2001) (Grant)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1024 - Chen, Evolution of wireless and personal communications. Road towards FPLMTS, Proc. of the Int¿¿¿l Conf. on Commc¿¿¿n Tech., ICCT ¿¿¿96, vol. 1 (1996) (Chen)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1025 - U.S. Patent No. 5,659,882 (Fukutomi)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1012 - Plaintiff Original Complaint for Patent Infringement, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., C.A. No. 3:18-cv-03333-M, Dkt. 1 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 18, 2018) (VW Complaint)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1014 - Klein Gilhousen, a Qualcomm Founder, Developed Mobile Technology and Fostered Philanthropy: 1942-2016, Wall Street Journal, Apr. 30, 2016 (WSJ Article)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1015 - Jury Special Verdict, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Novatel Wireless, Inc., No. 3:16-cv-00118-H-KSC, Dkt. 335 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 10, 2017) (Novatel Verdict)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1016 - Cox, 910 MHz Urban Mobile Radio Propagation: Multipath Characteristics in New York City, IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 22, no. 4 (Nov. 1973) (Cox)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1018 - Price et al., A Communication Technique for Multipath Channels, Price and Green, Proceedings of the IRE, vol. 46, issue 3 (Mar. 1958) (Price)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1019 - Fischer et al., Wide-band packet radio technology, Proc. of the IEEE, vol. 75, issue 1 (1987) (Fischer)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1020 - Kahn et al., Advances in Packet Radio Technology, Proc. of the IEEE, vol. 66, issue 11 (1978) (Kahn)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1021 - McBee, Evaluation of Wireless Local Area Networks, Naval Postgraduate School (Sept. 1993) (McBee)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1026 - Steinbock, WIRELESS HORIZON: STRATEGY AND COMPETITION IN THE WORLDWIDE MOBILE MARKETPLACE (AMACOM 2003)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1027 - Judgment in Favor of Defendants, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Novatel Wireless, Inc. et al., C.A. No. 16-cv-118-H-KSC, Dkt. 336 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 10, 2017) (Novatel Judgment)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1030 - Declaration of Coral Sheldon-Hess

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1031 - U.S. Patent No. 5,652,765 (Adachi)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1035 - Multipath Fading Statistics Of A Direct Sequence CDMA Signal At 2 GHz, In Microcellular And Indoor Environment, IEEE, Ghassemzadeh, et al. (1994) (Ghassemzadeh)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1028 - Gilhousen, On the Capacity of a Cellular CDMA System, IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Tech., vol. 40, issue 2 (May 1991) (Gilhousen CDMA Paper)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1029 - Vehicle, WEBSTER¿¿¿S NEW WORLD COLLEGE DICTIONARY (1997)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1032 - A Comparison of Specific Space Diversity Techniques for Reduction of Fast Fading in UHF Mobile Radio Systems, IEEE Transactions On Vehicular Technology, Vol. VT-20, No. 4, Jakes et al. (November 1971) (Jakes)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1033 - U.S. Patent No. 5,614,914 (Bolgiano)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1034 - U.S. Patent No. 5,280,472 (Gilhousen472)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1036 - Statistics of Short Time Variations of Indoor Radio Propagation, IEEE, Ganesh et al. (1991) (Ganesh)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Ex. 1037 - Claim Construction Order, Carucel Investments, L.P. v. Novatel Wireless, Inc. et al., C.A. No. 16-cv-118-H-KSC, Dkt. 131 (S.D. Cal. Sept. 19, 2016) (Novatel CC Order)

Jul 26, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Power of Attorney

Jul 26, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 7,979,023

Jul 26, 2019PAPERPETITIONER