IP Verse

TalexMedical, LLC et al. vs Becon Medical Ltd. et al.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2020-00028 filed by TalexMedical, LLC et al. against Becon Medical Ltd. et al. on Oct 9, 2019. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2020-00028
Filing Date
Oct 9, 2019
Petitioner
TalexMedical, LLC et al.
Respondent
Becon Medical Ltd. et al.
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
12368765
Respondent Tech Center
3700
Respondent Patent Number
8167942
Institution Decision Date
Apr 17, 2020
Termination Date
Apr 5, 2023

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Final written decision: On remand

Apr 5, 2023PAPERBOARD

Other: Fed Circuit mandate

Jan 11, 2023PAPERBOARD

Other: other court decision

Jan 11, 2023PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply Brief on Remand

Jan 10, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply Brief on Remand

Dec 20, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Response Brief on Remand

Nov 28, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2047 Herschcovitch November 10, 2022 Deposition Transcript

Nov 28, 2022EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Meir D. Hershcovitch, M.D.

Nov 4, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney to Appoint New Back-Up Counsel

Nov 3, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notice and Service Information Under 37 C.F.R. Section 42.8(b)(3) and 42.8(b)(4)

Nov 3, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Dr. Hershcovitch Supplemental Declaration

Oct 31, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Opening Brief on Remand

Oct 31, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Order: Conditionally Granting Patent Owner’s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nicholas A. Kurk 37 C.F.R. sec. 42.10

Oct 25, 2022PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Oct 12, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex 3001

Oct 7, 2022EXHIBITBOARD

Order Conduct of the Proceeding

Oct 7, 2022PAPERBOARD

ORDER Granting Motion to Withdraw 37 C.F.R. sec s 42.5 a , 42.10 e

Oct 7, 2022PAPERBOARD

Ex. 2046 - Kurk Declaration in Support of Pro Hac Vice Admission

Oct 6, 2022EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

PETITIONER TALEXMEDICAL, LLCS UNOPPOSED MOTION TO WITHDRAW COUNSEL PURSUANT TO 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(e) AND POWER OF ATTORNEY TO APPOINT NEW COUNSEL

Sep 12, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Cross-Appeal to CAFC

Jun 30, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Appeal to CAFC

Jun 16, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Judgment Final Written Decision

Apr 15, 2021PAPERBOARD

Hearing Transcript

Mar 31, 2021PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner Demonstrative Exhibits for Combined Oral Hearing

Jan 15, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Demonstrative Exhibit

Jan 15, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Jan 15, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Exhibit List

Jan 15, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order - Trial Hearing

Dec 22, 2020PAPERBOARD

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Dec 8, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner Request for Oral Argument

Dec 4, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Sur-Reply to Institution

Nov 25, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Updated Mandatory Notice

Nov 24, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Updated Power of Attorney

Nov 24, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 1027

Nov 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1028

Nov 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response

Oct 19, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1003

Oct 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1004

Oct 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

EXPUNGED

Oct 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

EXPUNGED

Oct 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1029

Oct 19, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notice

Oct 13, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner¿¿¿s Notice of Deposition of Dr. Lily N. Daniali

Sep 8, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Rohit K. Khosla

Sep 8, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Declaration of Dr. Lily N. Daniali

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Email between Bryan Griffiths and Dr. Bartlett Dated November 4, 2015

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts of Deposition Transcript of Dr. Scott Bartlett, Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa.)

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Exh. 169 to Deposition of Dr. Scott Bartlett, Hand Drawing

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Response

Aug 5, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Dr. Rohit K. Khosla

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Intentionally Blank

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

TalexMedical LLC¿¿¿s and Dr. Scott Bartlett¿¿¿s Answer. Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 22, 2019).

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Excerpts of Deposition Transcript of Bryan Griffiths, Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa.)

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

ECF # 31, Plaintiff¿¿¿s infringement Contentions, Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 22, 2019).

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Image of Talex Product, exhibit 103 in Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 22, 2019)

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Talex Website Cap Piece Printout, https://www.infantear.com/how-it-works-1, last accessed January 24, 2020.

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

EarBuddies Website Printout, https://www.earbuddies.com/pages/fitting-guide, last accessed July 30, 2020

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

¿¿¿Ear molding in new-born infants with auricular deformities,¿¿¿ Byrd HS, Langevin CJ, Ghidoni LA., Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 2010;126:1191 -1200.

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

NPR Article praising Becon¿¿¿s Patented EarWellTM System, https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/02/27/389483345/molding-baby-s-new-ears-to-be-normal, last accessed July 30, 2020

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Payne, Phileemon & Mitchell, Damien & Trovato, Matthew & Cook, Thomas & Ha, Richard & Kravitz, Michelle. (2012). ¿¿¿Ear Molding In Newborn Infants: Dispelling the Myths about Ear Deformities.¿¿¿

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Chan, et al ¿¿¿Efficacy of Ear Molding in Infants using the EarWell Infant Correction System and Factors Affecting Outcome,¿¿¿ Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: October 2019 - Volume 144 - Issue 4 - p 648e-65

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Payne, Phileemon ¿¿¿Eric¿¿¿ Video, available at https://www.houstoncraniofacial.com/ear-deformities-and-malformations/infant-ear-molding-which-system-is-right-for-my-newborn/

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Daniali et al. Classification of Newborn Ear Malformations and their Treatment with the EarWell Infant Ear Correction System. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2017;139(3):681-691.

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Talex Website Printout ¿¿¿ Rim Piece, https://www.infantear.com/how-it-works-1, last accessed January 24, 2020

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

ECF # 31, Dr. Bartlett¿¿¿s and Talex¿¿¿s Non-Infringement Contentions, ECF #30-1 Contentions, Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 22, 2019)

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Hershcovitch

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

EarWell Centers Website, https://www.earwellcenters.com/infant-ear-deformities/cryptotia-ear-deformity-in-newborn-infants/, last accessed July 30, 2020

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Cornell Website Printout, https://news.weill.cornell.edu/news/2015/02/newborn-butterfly-program-non-surgically-corrects-infant-ear-deformities-melissa-doft, last accessed July 30, 2020

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Doft, Melissa A. M.D.; Goodkind, Alison B. B.A.; Diamond, Shawn M.D.; DiPace, Jennifer I. M.D.; Kacker, Ashutosh M.D.; LaBruna, Anthony N. M.D. The Newborn Butterfly Project, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: March 2015 - Volume 135 - Issue 3

Aug 5, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Revised Notice of Deposition of Dr. Meir Hershcovitchh, M.D.

Jul 14, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Stipulation to Modified Scheduling Order

Jul 14, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Meir Hershcovitchh, M.D.

Jun 12, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Stipulation to Modify the Scheduling Order

Jun 11, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

SCHEDULING ORDER

Apr 21, 2020PAPERBOARD

Trial Instituted Document

Apr 17, 2020PAPERBOARD

Defendant¿¿¿s Motion to Stay in Civil Action No. 2:18-cv-4169-JD (E.D. Pa. Mar. 20, 2020)

Apr 7, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Apr 7, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Order Granting Defendant¿¿¿s Motion to Stay in Civil Action No.2:18-cv-4169-JD (E.D. Pa. Mar. 24, 2020)

Apr 7, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Motion for Summary Judgment in Related District Court Case

Mar 20, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Mandatory Notice

Mar 20, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Order Denying Stay

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

July 24, 2017 Meeting Minutes

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

July 16, 2017 Meeting minutes

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Physician Interview

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

March 22, 2016 Email

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner Business Plan

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Jan 21, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Scheduling Order

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner Letter to Court

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Griffiths Depo Trs Excerpts

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Final Invalidity Contentions

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Byrd Depo Trs Excerpts

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Rubin/Anders Scientific Email

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

July 17, 2017 Meeting Minutes

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Bartlett Application

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Bartlett Application Prosecution History

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Bartlett Article

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Yotsuyanagi - 2004

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner Business Plan

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr. Bartlett Depo Trs Excerpts

Jan 21, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Mandatory Notice

Nov 8, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Power of Attorney

Nov 8, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Mandatory Notice

Nov 8, 2019PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Oct 18, 2019PAPERBOARD

Petition for Inter Partes Review

Oct 9, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Power of Attorney

Oct 9, 2019PAPERPETITIONER

Dr. Hershcovitch Declaration

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(English Translation of Yotsuyanagi) "The Use of a Thermoplastic Splint for Treating Cryptotia"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Ullmann) "Early Nonsurgical Correction of Congenital Auricular Deformities"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Brown) "Correction of Congenital Auricular Deformities by Splinting in the Neonatal Period"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Matsuo) "Nonsurgical Correction of Congenital Auricular Deformities"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Weerda) "Surgery of the Auricle" - Part 1

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Hirose) "Non-surgical correction for cryptotia using simple apparatus"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

"Earbuddies ear shape corrector for babies, infants, toddlers - premium kit", www.worthpoint.com

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Muraoka) "A simple prosthesis for correction of cryptotia"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,167,942 to Byrd et al.

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Excerpts from the prosecution history of U.S. Patent No. 8,167,942

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Dancey) "Acrylic Ear Splints for Treatment of Cryptotia"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

Claim Construction Memorandum and Opinion, Becon Medical, Ltd. et al. v. Scott P. Bartlett, M.D. et al., No. 18-4169 (E.D. Pa. Aug 22, 2019)

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Kurozumi) "Non-surgical correction of a congenital lop ear deformity by splinting with Reston foam"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Yotsuyanagi) "The Use of a Thermoplastic Splint for Treating Cryptotia"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

GB2304579 (Gault)

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Weerda) "Surgery of the Auricle" - Part 2

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

(Hamiishi) "Evaluation of a simple prosthesis for correction of cryptotia"

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER

"EarBuddies Sales to Hospitals, Clinics & Health Professionals", http://www.earbuddies.co.uk

Oct 9, 2019EXHIBITPETITIONER