Varian Medical Systems, Inc. et al. vs Best Medical International, Inc.

Other: other court decision

Other: Fed Circuit mandate

Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal

JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining Some Challenged Claims Unpatentable Denying-in-Part and Dismissing-in-Part Petitioner’s Motion to Exclude 35 U.S.C. § 318(a); 37 C.F.R. § 42.64

PANEL CHANGE ORDER Conduct of the Proceedings 37 C.F.R. �� 42.5

Hearing Transcript

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Request For Ex Parte Reexamination of U.S. Patent No. 6,393,096 Under 35 U.S.C. ���� 302-307 and 37 C.F.R. �� 1.150 ET SEQ, dated December 23, 2019

Order Granting Request For Ex Parte Reexamination of U.S. Patent No. 6,393,096, dated January 29, 2020

Patent Owner Request for Consideration of an Amendment Cancelling claims 1, 3-8, and 37-42, dated November 23, 2020

Request For Ex Parte Reexamination of U.S. Patent No. 6,038,283 Under ���� 302-307 and 37 C.F.R. �� 1.150 ET SEQ, July 27, 2020

Order Granting Request for Ex Parte Reexamination of U.S. Patent No. 6,038,283, dated September 10, 2020

Joint Stipulation

Order - Conduct of the Proceedings - 37 C.F.R. 42.5

Petitioner's Reply In Support of its Motion to Exclude

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney

Order - Provisionally Granting Patent Owner's Motions to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude

Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel

Petitioner's Motion to Exclude

Granting Requests for Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. § 42.70

Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Trial Due Date 3

Patent Owner's Objections to Evidence

Order - Granting Elekta's Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Ronald S. Lemieux - 37 CFR 42.10

ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.5

PETITIONER¿¿¿S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF RONALD LEMIEUX UNDER 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.10(c)

Ex. 1040

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Papers Presented by Nomos Corp. at X11th Int'l Conf. on the Use of Computers in Radiation Therapy - Salt Lake City (May 27-30 1997)

Petitioner's Reply ISO Petition

Peacock: A System for Planning and Rotational Delivery of Intensity-Modulated Fields, Int'l Journal of Imaging Systems and Technology (Spring 1995)

LinkedIn profile page for Bruce Curran

Premarked Notification - Peacock System (K963259) Summary of Safety and Effectiveness (Nov. 18, 1996)

October 9, 2020 Deposition of Daniel Chase

October 16, 2020 Deposition Daniel Chase

September 29, 2020 Deposition of Mark Carol (public, redacted version)

October 1, 2020 Deposition of Thomas Rowden (public, redacted version)

October 6, 2020 Deposition of Merle Romesberg (public, redacted version)

Expert Reply Declaration of Dr. Kenneth Gall

October 8, 2020 Deposition of Merle Romesberg

SEALED October 6, 2020 Deposition of Merle Romesberg

Order Increasing Word Limit for Reply and Sur-reply

ORDER Granting Patent Owner¿¿¿s Motions to Seal Entry of Protective Order 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.54

ORDER Conduct of the Proceedings 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.5

Notice of Deposition of Mr. Merle Romesberg III

Notice of Deposition of Mr. Thomas Rowden

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Mark P. Carol

Notice of Deposition of Mr. Daniel Chase

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Date 2

Petitioner's Objections to Evidence

Patent Owner's Motion to Seal

District Court Claim Construction Ruling

Declaration of Thomas Rowden

Corvus_2.0 rl user manual (Part 1 of 2)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreePlanner.c (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreeInfo.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/ /Peacock /Dosimetrist.m (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc Peacock/ Projectionist.m (Confidential)

Patent Owner's Response (Confidential)

Patent Owner's Response (Public Version - Redacted)

Declaration of Daniel Chase

Nishimura 2015

Smith 2020

Arimura 2017

Transcript of July 2, 2020 Deposition of Kenneth P. Gall, Ph.D. in IPR2020-00072

Declaration of Mark P. Carol

Declaration of Merle Romesberg III (Public Version - Redacted)

CORVUS 2.0 rl user manual (Part 2 of 2)

ECO No. 97-0734

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List as of August 7, 2020

Declaration of Merle Romesberg III (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreePlanner.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreeAnneal,.c (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreeAnneal.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctPlanCost.c (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctPlanCost.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctPlanCost_integral.c (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctPlanCost_integral.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/OctTreeInfo.c (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/Optimize/Site.OctTreeAnnealer.Values (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc/ /Peacock /Dosimetrist.h (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc//Peacock /Anatomist.m (Confidential)

CORVUS_2.0_Support_Tree/progsrc//Peacock /Anatomist.h (Confidential)

Notice of Second Joint Stipulation to Modify Trial Due Date 1

Patent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

IPR2020-00971 Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review and Granting Motion for Joinder

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Trial Due Date 1

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Sylvia Hall-Ellis, Ph.D.

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Kenneth P. Gall, Ph.D.

Granting Petitioners Unopposed Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Reuben Chen, Adam M. Pivovar, and Yuan Liang 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

Granting Patent Owner's Unopposed Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Steven A. Maddox

Petitioner's Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice - Reuben Chen

Biography of Reuben Chen

Declaration of Reuben Chen ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission - Adam Pivovar

Declaration of Adam Pivovar ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Biography of Adam Pivovar

Declaration of Yuan Liang ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission - Yuan Liang

Biography of Yuan Liang

Declaration of Steven A. Maddox in Support of Pro Hac Vice Motion

Patent Owner's Exhibit List as of June 5, 2020

Patent Owner's Unopposed Motion For Steven A. Maddox to Appear Pro Hac Vice

Patent Owner's Objections to Evidence Submitted During the Preliminary Proceeding

Trial Instituted Document

SCHEDULING ORDER

ORDER Conditionally Granting Patent Owner's Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel

Patent Owner¿¿¿s Updated Power of Attorney

Patent Owner¿¿¿s Updated Mandatory Notices

Motion to Withdraw and Substitution of Counsel

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply to Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Petitioner's Reply on Proper Service to Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Order - Authorizing Replies and Sur-replies - 37 CFR 42.5, 42.108

Exhibit 2009 - Bortfeld

Exhibit 2010 - Purdy 1996

Exhibit 2012 - Nutting

Exhibit 2013 - Klein

Exhibit 2021 - Priority Mail Express Information

Exhibit 2001 - Daniel Chase CV

Exhibit 2011 - WEBB 1998

Exhibit 2014 - Varian Proof of Service 10.18.2018

Exhibit 2023 - FedEx Office - Palo Alto California - 249 S California Ave 94306

Exhibit 2033 - Owen 1994

Exhibit 2022 - FedEx Tracking No. 780362214336

Exhibit 2027 - US6038283

Exhibit 2032 - Woo 1996

Exhibit 2034 - Shale 1988

Exhibit 2035 - Welcome to Advanced Medical Publishing

Exhibit 2002 - Declaration of Daniel Chase IPR2020-00071

Patent Owner's Exhibit List as of February 7, 2020

Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Patent Owner Mandatory Notice Information

Petitioner's Power of Attorney

U.S. Patent No. 6,393,096 B1 to Mark P. Carol et al. (filed May 27, 1999, issued May 21, 2002) ("'096 patent" or "096")

Declaration of Kenneth Gall

Declaration of Christopher Butler

The Physics of Three Dimensional Radiation Therapy: Conformal Radiotherapy, Radiosurgery and Treatment Planning (1993) ("Webb 1993")

Lawrence T.S. et al., "An Application of Dose Volume Histograms to the Treatment of Intrahepatic Malignancies with Radiation Therapy," Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., 19:1041-1047 (1990) ("Lawrence 1990")

Notice of Allowance for US Application 09/320,980 dated Sept. 1, 2000

Webb, S., "Optimisation of conformal radiotherapy dose distribution by simulated annealing," Phys. Med. Biol., 34(10):1349-1370 (1989) ("Webb 1989")

Langer, M. et al., "Large Scale Optimization of Beam Weights Under Dose-Volume Restrictions," Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., 18:887-893 (1990) ("Langer 1990")

Goitein, M., "The Comparison of Treatment Plans," Seminars in Radiation Oncology, 2(4):246-256 (1992) ("Goitein 1992")

Morrill, S.M., "Constrained simulated annealing for optimized radiation therapy treatment planning," Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 33:135-144 (1990) ("Morrill 1990")

Drzymala, R.E. et al., "Dose-Volume Histograms," Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., 21:71-78 (1991) ("Drzymala 1991")

Kirkpatrick, S. et al., "Optimization by Simulated Annealing," Science 220(4598):671-680 (1983) ("Kirkpatrick 1983")

Oldham, M. et al., "A comparison of conventional forward planning with inverse planning for 3D conformal radiotherapy of the prostrate," Radiotherapy and Oncology, 35:248-262 (1995) ("Oldham")

Carol, M.P., Chapter 17 Where we go from here: one person s vision, The Theory & Practice of Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (1997) 243-252 ( Carol 17 )

Chen, G.T.Y. et al., Evaluation of Treatment Plans Using Dose Volume Histograms, Front. Radiat. Ther. Onc., 21:44-55 (1987) (Chen-1987)

Webb, S., "Optimizing Radiation Therapy Inverse Treatment Planning Using the Simulated Annealing Technique," International Journal of Imaging Sytems and Technology, 6:71-79 (1995) ("Webb 1995")

Viggars D.A., et al., "The Objective Evaluation of Alternative Treatment Plans III: The Quantitative Analysis of Dose Volume Histograms," Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., 23:419-427 (1992) ("Viggars")

U.S. Patent No. 5,596,619 ("'619 patent")

Carol, M.P., Chapter 2 MRT: Where we are today, The Theory & Practice of Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (1997) 17-36 ( Carol 2 )

Morrill, S.M. et al., Treatment planning optimization using constrained simulated annealing, Phys. Med. Biol., 36(10):1341-1361 (1991) (Morrill 1991)

Brooks, S.P., et al., "Optimization using simulated annealing," The Statistician, 44(2):241-257 (1995) ('Brooks-1995')

Neal, A.J. et al., Comparison of treatment techniques for conformal radiotherapy of the prostate using dose-volume histograms and normal tissue complication probabilities, Radiotherapy and Oncology, 37:29-34 (1995) ( Neal-1995 )

Webb, S., Optimization of conformal radiotherapy dose distributions by simulated annealing: 2. Inclusion of scatter in the 2D technique, Phys. Med. Biol., 36(9):1227-1237 (1991) (Webb-1991)

Shalev, S. et al., "The Objective Evaluation of Alternative Treatment Plans: II. Score Functions," Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., 20:1067-1073 (1991) ("Shalev-1991")

Oldham, M. et al., "The optimization and inherent limitations of 3D conformal radiotherapy treatment plans of the prostate," The British Journal of Radiology, 68:882-893 (1995) ("Oldham-1995")

Mohan, R., et al., "Clinically relevant optimization of 3-D conformal treatments," Med. Phys., 19(4):933-944 ('Mohan-1992')

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 6,393,096

Hall-Ellis Declaration