IP Verse

BMW of North America, LLC et al. vs Paice LLC et al.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2020-01299 filed by BMW of North America, LLC et al. against Paice LLC et al. on Jul 14, 2020. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2020-01299
Filing Date
Jul 14, 2020
Petitioner
BMW of North America, LLC et al.
Respondent
Paice LLC et al.
Status
Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number
13573728
Respondent Tech Center
3600
Respondent Patent Number
8630761
Institution Decision Date
Jan 15, 2021
Termination Date
Jan 3, 2022

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

Other: other court decision

Oct 13, 2023PAPERBOARD

Other: Fed Circuit mandate

Oct 13, 2023PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal

Mar 4, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. 318(a)

Jan 3, 2022PAPERBOARD

Other: Hearing transcript

Nov 12, 2021PAPERBOARD

Other: Hearing transcript

Nov 8, 2021PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Oct 15, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owners' Demonstratives

Oct 15, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

BMW1111 - Petitioners' Oral Argument Demonstratives

Oct 15, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List

Oct 15, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. 42.70

Sep 15, 2021PAPERBOARD

Patent Owners' Request for Oral Argument

Sep 7, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioners' Request for Oral Argument

Sep 1, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owners' Sur-Reply

Aug 17, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioners' Response Identifying Issues Raised in the Patent Owner Response or the Institution Decision to Which the Evidence and/or Arguments Identified by Patent Owners Responds

Jul 28, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owners' Identification of New Evidence and Arguments

Jul 21, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owners' Objections to Evidence

Jul 13, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioners' Reply to Patent Owners' Response

Jul 6, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

BMW1088 - Reply Declaration of Dr. Gregory W. Davis

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Mahdi Shahbakhti (May 6, 2021) for IPR2020-00994

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1090 - European Patent No. EP 0,576,703 (���Graf ���703���)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1092 - Ehsani, M., et al., Modern Electric, Hybrid Electric, and Fuel Cell Vehicles: Fundamentals, Theory, and Design

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1098 - Declaration of Mahdi Shahbakhti, Ph.D. Regarding U.S. Patent No. 7,723,932 in Case IPR2019-00011

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1099 - U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2004/0069548 (Kira)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1100 - U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2003/0150352 (Kumar)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1102 - Declaration of Mahdi Shahbakhti, Ph.D. for IPR2020-00994 (U.S. Patent No. 7,104,347)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1103 - Deposition Transcript of Dr. Mahdi Shahbakhti (June 17, 2021) for IPR2020-01299 (U.S. Patent No. 8,630,761)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1104 - Excerpts from Handbook of Air Pollution From Internal Combustion Engines(Additional excerpts from the reference attached as Patent Owner Exhibit 2032)

Jul 6, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners' Notice of Deposition of Mahdi Shahbakhti Ph.D.

May 28, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Gregory W. Davis

May 28, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioners' Objections to Evidence Submitted with Patent Owners' Response

Apr 27, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

ORDER Granting Petitioners Motions for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Jacob Z. Zambrzycki 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

Apr 22, 2021PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Response to Petition

Apr 20, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Declaration of Mahdi Shahbakhti, Ph.D.

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Curriculum Vitae of Mahdi Shahbakhti, Ph.D.

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Selected Pages From Merhdad Ehsani et al, Modern Electric, Hybrid Electric, and Fuel Cell Vehicles

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Oxford Dictionary

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Encarta World English Dictionary

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Handbook of Air Pollution From Internal Combustion Engines

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Guzzella et al., Vehicle Propulsion Systems

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Deposition Transcript of Gregory Davis, Ph.D.

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

BMW���s Reply Claim Construction Brief from Paice LLC and the Abell Foundation v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft and BMW of North AmericA, LLC

Apr 20, 2021EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Jacob Z. Zambrzycki

Mar 31, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

BMW1087 - Declaration of Jacob Z. Zambrzycki in Support of Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Mar 31, 2021EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List

Mar 31, 2021PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Gregory W. Davis

Mar 30, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Date 1

Mar 30, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Exhibit 3001

Mar 8, 2021EXHIBITBOARD

ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding

Mar 8, 2021PAPERBOARD

Patent Owners' Updated Mandatory Notices

Feb 11, 2021PAPERPATENT OWNER

Decision Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review

Jan 15, 2021PAPERBOARD

Scheduling Order

Jan 15, 2021PAPERBOARD

Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List

Dec 3, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

BMW1086 - Paice LLC et al. v. BMW AG et al., No. 1:19-cv-003348-SAG, Order (D. Md. Nov. 25, 2020)

Dec 3, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Oct 26, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

BMW¿¿¿s Opening Claim Construction Brief from Paice LLC and the Abell Foundation v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft and BMW of North America, LLC

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. P to BMW Invalidity Contentions dated June 8, 2020

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Docket Navigator Statistics ¿¿¿ Top Patents by Number of IPRs

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Printout of http://www.paicehybrid.com/licensing-agreements/

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Scheduling Order [Docket No. 36] from Paice LLC and the Abell Foundation v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft and BMW of North America, LLC

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

BMW¿¿¿s Responsive Claim Construction Statement from Paice LLC and the Abell Foundation v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft and BMW of North America, LLC

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Markman Order from Paice LLC and the Abell Foundation v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft and BMW of North America, LLC

Oct 26, 2020EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Sep 30, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices

Jul 31, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Power of Attorney

Jul 31, 2020PAPERPATENT OWNER

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Jul 24, 2020PAPERBOARD

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 8,630,761

Jul 14, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner BMW AG Power of Attorney

Jul 14, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner BMW NA Power of Attorney

Jul 14, 2020PAPERPETITIONER

BMW1001 - U.S. Pat. 8,630,761

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1002 - USPTO Assignments for U.S. Pat. 7,104,347

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1004 - IPR2014-00579 FWD

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1005 - Fed. Cir. Decision in IPR2014-00571, -00579, and -00884 FWDs.

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1006 - IPR2015-00794 FWD

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1007 - Fed. Cir. Decision in IPR2015-00794 and -00795 FWDs.

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1009 - Davis CV

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1010 - IPR2015-00795 FWD.

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1003 - IPR2014-00571 FWD

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1008 - Davis Declaration

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1011 - IPR2014-00884 FWD

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1022 - Nii (U.S. Pat. 5,650,931).

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1031 - DOE Report to Congress (1994).

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1039 - Introduction to Automotive Powertrains (Davis)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1013 - Severinsky (U.S. Pat. 5,343,970)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1020 - Graf (U.S. Pat. 6,188,945)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1023 - 1993 Hybrid Challenge

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1024 - 1996 Future Car Challenge.

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1025 - 1997 Future Car Challenge.

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1027 - History of Hybrid Electric Vehicle (Wakefield-1998)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1028 - SAE 760121 (Unnewehr-1976)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1029 - SAE 920447 (Burke-1992)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1030 - Vehicle Tester for HEV (Duoba-1997)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1032 - SAE SP-1331 (1998)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1033 - SAE SP-1156 (1996)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1034 - DOE HEV Assessment (1979)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1036 - Microprocessor Design for HEV (Bumby-1988)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1040 - Propulsion System for Design for EV (Ehsani-1996)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1041 - Propulsion System Design for HEV (Ehsani-1997)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1042 - Bosch Automotive Handbook (1996)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1043 - SAE SP-1089 (Anderson-1995)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1044 - Farrall (U.S. Pat. 5,656,921)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1052 - File History of U.S. Patent No. 8,630,761

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1053 - USPTO Assignments for U.S. Pat. 8,630,761

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1055 - Hall-Ellis Declaration

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1054 - Quigley

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1056 - Onari (U.S. Pat. 5,189,621)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1057 - Hosaka (U.S. Pat. 4,625,697)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER

BMW1058 - Adler (U.S. Pat. 5,533,583)

Jul 14, 2020EXHIBITPETITIONER