OpenSky Industries, LLC vs VLSI Technology LLC et al.

Patent Owner's Amended Notice of Appeal

Second Notice of Appeal

Granting-in-Part Petitioner’s Request on Rehearing of Order Granting Motion for Fees

Ex 3102

Petitioner OpenSky Updated Mandatory Disclosures

Ex. 3101

Ex. 3028

Director Review Order (Originally entered December 15, 2023)

Patent Owner's Motion for Fees (Public)

OpenSky Request for Rehearing of the December 15 Director Review Order (Paper 141)

REDACTED Public Version of Paper 131 OpenSky Opposition to VLSI Fee Mot 2023.03.23

REDACTED Public Version of Paper 137 OpenSky Ntc of Objs to Evid 2023.05.22

Certificate of Service for Papers 142 and 143

Director Review Order

EXPUNGED

Ex. 3027

Ex. 3026

OpenSky's Notice of Appeal

Patent Owner VLSI Technology LLC's Notice of Appeal

Order Admonishing Patent Owner and Granting Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Petitioner OpenSky Notice of Objections to VLSI Attorney Fee Evidence

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Ex. 2127 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2128 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2129 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2130 The 2023 Am Law 100: Ranked Revenue Per Lawyer

Ex. 2131 Will Billing Rates for Elite Firms Rise More in 2020

Ex. 2132 The $1500 an Hour Lawyer

Ex. 2133 Raising Billing Rates in 2023

Ex. 2134 Real Rate Report

Ex. 2135 AIPLA 2021 Report of the Economic Survey

Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. § 318(a) Denying Patent Owner Motion to Exclude 37 C.F.R. § 42.64

Ex. 3024

Ex. 3025

Order Authorizing Patent Owner to File Evidence

ORDER Notice of Adjustment of One-Year Pendency Due to Joinder

DECISION Denying Patent Owner’s Motion to Terminate

OpenSky Oppn to VLSI Att Fees Motion

Ex. 1068 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Patent Owner's Motion for Fees

Ex. 2126 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 3023

Order Granting Extension for Briefing on Motion for Fees

Rehearing:Decision on Request for Rehearing

Order Restoring Opensky as a Party, Awarding Sanctions, and Authorizing a Motion for Fees

Intel Reply Brief Regarding Award of Attorney Fees

PATENT OWNER VLSI TECHNOLOGY LLC'S RESPONSE TO INTEL'S PAPER ADDRESSING ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

Ex. 3022

Intel's Motion to Seal

(Intel) Attorneys Fees for Counsel of Record

Intel's Response to Director's Order re: Attorneys Fees

PATENT OWNER VLSI TECHNOLOGY LLC’S RESPONSE TO DIRECTOR’S ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

Decision on Request for Director Rehearing

Patent Owner's Reply Brief to Petitioner OpenSky's Response to the October 4, 2022 Order to Show Cause

Petitioner’s Reply Brief to Patent Owner’s Response to October 4, 2022, Order to Show Cause

Patent Owner's Reply In Support of Motion to Terminate

Peititioner OpenSky Industries Br re Order Show Cause

Patent Owner's Brief to Show Cause Regarding Compensatory Damages

Petitioner's (Intel) Response to Patent Owner's Request for Director Rehearing

Director Review Decision on Request for Reconsideration

Patent Owner's Request for Director Rehearing

PETITIONER OPENSKY INDUSTRIES, LLCS POWER OF ATTORNEY

PETITIONER OPENSKY INDUSTRIES, LLCS NOTICE OF CHANGE OF COUNSEL AND UPDATED MANDATORY NOTICES

PETITIONER INTEL CORPORATIONS OPPOSITION TO PATENT OWNERS MOTION TO TERMINATE BASED ON RES JUDICATA FROM THE FINAL DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT IN VLSI TECHNOLOGY LLC V. INTEL CORP.

Ex. 1536

Order Issuing Sua Sponte Director Review of Compelling Merits Decision

Ex. 3021

Order Granting Motion to Withdraw as Counsel and Granting Motion for Extension of Time

Order: Decision on Remand

Other: Hearing transcript

Patent Owner's Request for Reconsideration of and Objections to Director's October 4, 2022 Decision

AMIN, TUROCY & WATSON LLP���S MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL FOR PETITIONER OPENSKY INDUSTRIES, LLC and MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FIND AND RETAIN REPLACEMENT COUNSEL

Declaration of Andrew T. Oliver

Ex 1062 - August 6 voicemail

Ex 1064 - December 23 voicemail

Ex. 3019

Ex. 3020

Decision on Director Review

Email dated August 6, 2021

Email dated December 23, 2021

First email confirming that VLSI received produced documents

Second email confirming that VLSI received produced documents

Petitioner OpenSky Industries Corrected Updated Exhibit List

Petitioner OpenSky Notice of Correction to Paper No. 91

Patent Owner's Motion to Terminate

Intel Notice of Appeal

Intel Principal Brief

Petitioner's Oral Hearing Demonstratives

Patent Owner's Oral Argument Demonstratives

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Seal Portions of Paper No. 67

Patent Owner's Reply to Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude

Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner VLSI Technology LLC's Motion to Exclude

ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. sec 42.70

Ex. 2111 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2112

Ex. 2113

Ex. 2114

Ex.. 2115

Ex. 2116

Ex. 2117

Ex. 2118

Ex. 2080 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2119

Ex. 2120

Ex. 2121

Ex. 2122

Ex. 2123

Patent Owner VLSI Technology LLC's Motion to Exclude Pursuant to 37 CFR 42.64

Petitioner's Responsive Brief

Patent Owner's Responsive Brief

PETITIONER���S OPENSKY INDUSTRIES LLC���s RESPONSIVE BRIEF PURSUANT TO DIRECTOR���S ORDER

Patent Owner's Responsive Brief (Redacted)

EXPUNGED

EXPUNGED

EXPUNGED

EXPUNGED

Petitioner OpenSky Updated Exhibit List

Order: Authorization for Motion to Terminate as to Intel

VLSI Technology LLC's Sur-Reply ISO Patent Owner Response

Petitioner OpenSky's Motion to Seal Paper No. 67 and Portions of this Motion

Nonconfidential version of Petitioner OpenSky's Motion to Seal Paper No. 67 and Portions of this Motion

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Engine Advocacy, ACT | The App Association, and The Developers Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - High Tech Inventors Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Armitage

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Computer & Communications Industry Association

Brief of Amicus Curiae - BSA | The Software Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - US Startups and Inventors for Jobs, Conservatives for Property Rights, and Valencell Corporation

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Hon. Paul R. Michel

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Unified Patents, LLC, The Alliance for Automotive Innovation, and US Manufacturers for Development and Enterprise

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Public Interest Patent Law Institute

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Centripetal Networks, Inc.

Ex. 3018

Patent Owner's Brief in Response to Director Review Order (Redacted)

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Ramzi Khalil Maalouf

IPR2021-01064 Notice of Withdrawal Of Deposition of Jacob FINAL

Ex. 2076

Ex. 2081 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2082 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2083 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2084 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2085 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2086 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2087 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2088 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2089 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2090 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2091 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2092 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2093 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2094

Ex. 2095

Ex. 2096

Ex. 2097

Ex. 2098

Ex. 2099

Ex. 2101

Ex. 2102

Ex. 2103

Ex. 2104

Ex. 2105

Ex. 2106

Ex. 2107

Ex. 2108

Ex. 2109

Ex. 2110

Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Petitioner's Objections

(Intel) Privilege Log

(Intel) Fernandez Letter

(Intel) VLSI Privilege Log

(Intel) Fernandez Letter 8/4/22

(Intel) Wen E-mail

Intel 1501

Intel 1502

Intel 1503

Intel 1504

Intel 1505

Intel 1506

Intel 1507

Intel 1508

Intel 1509

Intel 1510

Intel 1511

Intel 1512

Intel 1513

Intel 1514

Intel 1515

Intel 1516

Intel 1517

Intel 1518

Intel 1519

Intel 1520

Intel 1521

Intel 1522

Intel 1523

Intel 1524

Intel 1525

Intel 1526

Intel 1527

Intel 1528

Intel 1529

Petitioner's (Intel) Brief

Petitioner OpenSky's Initial Brief Responsive to Director's Order (Paper No. 47)

Patent Owner's Brief in Response to Director Review Order

Nonconfidential version of Paper No. 67 (Petitioner OpenSky's Initial Brief Responsive to Director's Order (Paper No. 47))

Notice of Second Deposition of Dr. Bruce Jacob

Amended Notice of Second Deposition of Dr. Bruce Jacob

Patent Owner Request for Oral Argument

Patent Owner's Identification of Documents for Review In Camera as to OpenSky Industries, LLC

Ex. 2079 Emails to/from Andrew Oliver

Patent Owner's Identification of Documents for Review In Camera as to Intel Corporation

Notice of Third Joint Stipulation to Modify Schedule

E-mail regarding access to case files

Brief of Amicus Curiae - AIPLA

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Association of Amicus Counsel

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Naples Roundtable

Order: Denying POP Request

Petitioner OpenSky's Notice of Objections

Order Addressing Scope of Mandated Discovery

Ex. 3012

Ex. 3013

Ex. 3014

Ex. 3015

Ex. 3016

Director Review Order Extending Due Dates

Patent Owner's Objections Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.64(b)(1)

Transcript of Deposition of Dr. Conte, July 7, 2022

Declaration of Dr. Bruce Jacob, dated July 10, 2022

Day 2 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.), Feb. 23, 2021, excerpts.

Day 3 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.), Feb. 24, 2021, excerpts.

Day 4 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.), Feb. 25, 2021, excerpts.

Day 5 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.), Feb. 26, 2021, excerpts.

Day 6 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.), Mar. 1, 2021, excerpts.

Day 3 Trial Transcript (Public), 6:21-cv-00299 (W.D. Tex.), Apr. 14, 2021, excerpts.

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner Response

Director Review Scheduling Order

Order entering Modified Default Protective Order

Modified Default Protective Order

Exhibit 3010 POP Request

Notice: notice of receipt of POP request

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Thomas Conte

Patent Owner's Requests for Rehearing and Precedential Opinion Panel Review

Institution decision and grant of joinder, IPR2022-00366

Order Granting Sua Sponte Director Review

Order Dismissing Request for POP Review

Ex. 2065 Conte Declaration

Ex. 2066 Jacob Tr.

Ex. 2067 Trial Tr.

Ex. 2068 Intel IEEE Paper

Ex. 2069 OTI Sound Card

Ex. 2070 Dictionary of Science and Technology

Ex. 2071 Public Jacob Tr.

Patent Owner Response

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Ex. 2045 Tillis IP Watchdog

Ex. 2054 Tillis Press Release

Ex. 2055 Ivey Email

Ex. 2057 OpenSky Attorney Emails Expose the Seedy Underbelly of PTAB Practice

Ex. 2058 Matich LinkedIn Post

Ex. 2059 PTAB Needs to Immediately Check Unethical Practices

Ex. 2060 IPR filer denies VLSI���s allegation of ���fraud��� in settlement discussion email

Ex. 2061 Sabotage Claims Swirl in Patent Feud With Billions at Stake

Ex. 2062 PTAB Denies OpenSky���s Request for Rehearing But VLSI Cases Highlight Broader PTAB Problems

Ex. 2063 Vidal Expected to Tackle Patent Board PR ���Nightmare,��� Reviews

Ex. 2064 Priorities_ The IP Community Has Its Say on What Should Top Vidal���s To Do List

MOTION TO SEAL PORTIONS OF EXHIBIT 2053, PORTIONS OF THIS MOTION, AND EXHIBIT 1051

Default Protective Order

Agreement

Redacted Version of Motion to Seal

Redacted version of Exhibit 2053

Updated Exhibit List

Second Joint Stipulation to Modify Schedule

Notice of Deposition of Jacob

Patent Owner's Fourth Updated Mandatory Notice Information

Motion for Default Protective Order for Deposition of Christopher Larocca

Default Protective Order for Deposition of Christopher Larocca

Updated Exhibit List

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Christopher Larocca

Ex. 2053 March 8, 2022 Transcript

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Patent Owner Third Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner Updated POA

ORDER Granting Patent Owners Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Mr. Alan Heinrich 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10(c)

Patent Owner's Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Alan Heinrich

Ex. 2044 Declaration for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Alan Heinrich

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Schedule

Patent Owner Second Updated Mandatory Notice

Ex. 3009

Ex. 3008

Ex. 3007

Ex. 3006

Ex. 3005

Ex. 3004

Ex. 3003

Notice: Notification of Receipt of POP Request: Amicus Forms

Ex. 2042 Singh Engagement [CORRECTED]

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Exhibit 3002

Notice: notice of receipt of POP request

Patent Owner's Requests for Rehearing and Precedential Opinion Panel Review

Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314

SCHEDULING ORDER

Patent Owner's Objections Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. �� 42.64(b)(1)

Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply

Ex. 2027 Zint LA Times Article

Ex. 2028 TRIIAD presentation

Ex. 2029 Idaho T Group Annual Report

Ex. 2030 KBMO Consulting [Larocca]

Ex. 2031 KBMO Consulting [Tomasulo]

Ex. 2032 Winston & Strawn - WacoWatch

Ex. 2033 Court Grants VLSI Mtn to Transfer Case Back to Waco Moves Trial to Feb 16 2021 So Intel Can Seek Review

Ex. 2034 Federal Circuit Clears VLSI and Intel Trial

Ex. 2035 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Feb. 22 2021 Podcast

Ex. 2036 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Feb. 23 2021 Podcast

Ex. 2037 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Feb. 24 2021 Podcast

Ex. 2038 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Mar. 2 2021 Podcast

Ex. 2039 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Mar. 4 2021 Part I Podcast

Ex. 2040 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Mar. 4 2021 Part 2 Podcast

Ex. 2041 Trial Alert, VLSI Technologies v. Intel-WacoWatch Mar. 5 2021 Podcast

EXPUNGED

Ex. 2043 Fenton Declaration [IPR2021-01229 Ex. 1033]

Petitioner Supplemental Opposition Regarding Vivint

Order: Order Granting Patent Owner's Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Nathan Nobu Lowenstein

Petitioner Corrected Reply to Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Patent Owner's Supplemental Brief

Articles of Organization - Patent Quality Assurance LLC

Declaration of Christopher Larocca

EXPUNGED

Request for Conference Call

Order: Conduct of Proceeding

Ex. 2003 Conte Rebuttal Expert Report TOC

Ex. 2004 Dennhardt Email

Ex. 2005 Bultmann Bloomberg Article

Ex. 2006 OpenSky Incorporation File

Ex. 2007 PQA Articles

Ex. 2008 Final Invalidity Contentions

Ex. 2009 Final Invalidity Contentions - Shaffer

Ex. 2010 Final Invalidity Contentions - Lint

Ex. 2011 Final Invalidity Contentions - Chen

Ex. 2012 Final Invalidity Contentions - Terrell

Ex. 2013 Final Invalidity Contentions - Additional Art

Ex. 2014 Davis Law360 Article

Ex. 2015 Intel JMOL

Ex. 2016 Docket Attorneys

Ex. 2017 PCI 2.2

Ex. 2018 Padua

Ex. 2019 Liu

Ex. 2020 Intel's First Microprocessor

Ex. 2021 PIC10F Microcontroller Presentation

Ex. 2022 PIC10F Datasheet

Ex. 2023 2020-10-14 Intel's Second Identification of Prior Art Combinations

Ex. 2024 Comparison

Ex. 2025 Trial Transcript

Ex. 2026 Grunwald Expert Report TOC

Ex. 2002 '759 Conte Declaration

Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Patent Owner Updated Mandatory Notice

Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nathan Lowenstein

Ex. 2001 Lowenstein Declaration

Patent Owner Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner Power of Attorney

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Power of Attorney

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Pat. No. 7,725,759

Fee Authorization

U.S. Pat. No. 7,725,759

Declaration of Dr. Bruce Jacob in Support of Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 7,725,759, dated October 31, 2019

U.S. Pat. No. 5,838,995 ("Chen")

U.S. Pat. App. Pub. No. 2004/0098631 ("Terrell")

U.S. Pat. No. 6,298,448 ("Shaffer")

U.S. Pat. No. 7,360,103 ("Lint")

U.S. Pat. App. Pub. No. 2005/0102560 ("Taketoshi")

U.S. Pat. No. 4,670,837 ("Sheets")

excerpts from The Art of Computer Systems Performance Analysis, by Jain, 1991

U.S. Patent Application Serial No. 11/170,475, filed June 29, 2005

Preliminary Amendment of July 27, 2006

Office Action, dated June 18, 2007

Amendment, dated September 17, 2007

Final Office Action, dated November 27, 2007

Amendment and Request for Continued Examination, dated February 27, 2008

Office Action, dated April 2, 2008

Response to Office Action, dated April 29, 2008

Final Office Action, dated July 10, 2008

Amendment and Request for Continued Examination, dated September 10, 2008

Office Action, dated October 6, 2008

Response to Office Action, dated December 26, 2008

Office Action, dated April 3, 2009

Response to Office Action, dated June 25, 2009

Final Office Action, dated October 27, 2009

Response to Office Action, dated January 7, 2010

Notice of Allowance, dated January 28, 2010

Jury Verdict Form, dated March 2, 2021, in case No. 6:21-cv-00057-ADA (in the U.S. Dist. Ct. for the W. Dist. of Texas)

U.S. Pat. App. Pub. No. 2003/0159080 ("Kiriake")

European Patent Application Pub. No. 0032818 ("McDonald")

U.S. Pat. No. 6,163,848 ("Gephardt")

U.S. Pat. No. 6,643,792 ("Kurosawa")

U.S. Pat. No. 6,813,719 ("Athas")

U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,121 ("Ansari")

U.S. Pat. No. 7,155,631 ("Kiriake")

Policies for Dynamic Clock Scheduling, by Grunwald et al., 2000

The Simulation and Evaluation of Dynamic Voltage Scaling Algorithms, by Pering et al., 1998

A Control-Theoretic Approach to Dynamic Voltage Scheduling, by Varma et al., 2003

Scheduling for Reduced CPU Energy, by Weiser et al., 1994

Cache Implementation for Multiple Microprocessors, by Ravishankar et al., 1983

Declaration of Sylvia D. Hall-Ellis, Ph.D.

U.S. Pat. No. 4,789,926 ("Clarke")

U.S. Pat. No. 5,583,999 ("Sato")

U.S. Pat. No. 5,987,614 ("Mitchell")

U.S. Pat. No. 6,115,823 ("Velasco")

Claim Construction Order, dated January 3, 2020, in case no. A-19-CV-00977-ADA (in the U.S. Dist. Ct. for the W. Dist. of Texas)

Declaration of Dr. Bruce Jacob in Support of Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 7,725,759, dated February 4, 2020