Patent Quality Assurance, LLC vs VLSI Technology LLC et al.

Ex. 3051

Ex. 3052

Ex. 3053

Ex. 3054

Ex. 3055

Patent Owner VLSI Technology LLC's Amended Notice of Appeal

EXPUNGED

Ex. 3050

Director Review Order

Ex. 3034 (Redacted)

Ex. 3035 (Public Version)

Ex. 3036 (Public Version)

Ex. 3049

Patent Owner's Brief Addressing Why PQA Should Pay Compensatory Expenses - Public Version

Patent Owner's Response to PQA's Opening Brief - Public Version

EXPUNGED

Public Copy of Paper 133 - PQA Opening Brief re Show Cause Order

Public Copy of Paper 136 - PQA Response in Opposition to VLSI Brief re Show Cause Order

Notice of Cross-Appeal by PQA

PQA Response in Opposition to VLSI's Request for Fees

Patent Owner's Response to PQA's Opening Brief

PQA Opening Br. Explaining Why No Admonishment or Compensatory Expenses Are Warranted

Patent Owner's Brief Addressing Why PQA Should Pay Compensatory Expenses

Ex. 2104 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2105 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2106 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2107 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2108 The 2023 Am Law 100: Ranked Revenue Per Lawyer

Ex. 2109 Will Billing Rates for Elite Firms Rise More in 2020

Ex. 2110 The $1500 an Hour Lawyer

Ex. 2111 Raising Billing Rates in 2023

Ex. 2112 Real Rate Report

Ex. 2113 AIPLA 2021 Report of the Economic Survey

Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal

Ex. 3046

Ex. 3048

Ex. 3047

Ex. 3044

Ex. 3045

Director Review Decision (Confidential Version)

Director Review Decision (Public Version)

Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. § 318(a)

Denying Patent Owner Motion to Terminate

Rehearing:Decision on Request for Rehearing

Other: Hearing transcript

Order on VLSI's Response to the Order to Show Cause (Confidential Version)

Order on VLSI's Response to the Order to Show Cause (Public Version)

Ex. 3040

Ex. 3041

Ex. 3042

Ex. 3043

Petitioner's (Intel) Updated Mandatory Notices

Ex. 3037

Ex. 3038

Director Review Order Granting Extension of Time

Ex. 3039

PQA Additional Briefing Authorized by Paper 106

PQA Additional Briefing Authorized by Paper 106 (Non-Confidential Version)

Declaration of B.C. Banner re Additional Briefing Authorized by Paper 106

Patent Owner's Response to Director's February 23, 2023 Order to Show Cause

Patent Owner's Submission Regarding Patent Owner's Request for Discovery Pursuant to Director's February 23, 2023 Order

Ex. 3034

Ex. 3035

Ex. 3036

Director Review Order

PATENT OWNER'S REQUEST FOR PARTIAL REHEARING OF FEBRUARY 3, 2023 ORDER

Patent Owner Fourth Updated Mandatory Notice

Patent Owner Updated Power of Attorney

Ex. 3033

Order Granting Extension to Requested Briefing

Ex. 3031

Ex. 3032

Director Review Order

Ex. 3029

Ex. 3030

Order re: ex parte communication

Petitioner's (Intel) Updated Mandatory Notices

Ex. 3025

Ex. 3026

Ex. 3027

Ex. 3028

Order Granting-in-Part Extension to Requested Briefing

ORDER Lifting the Stay of the Underlying Proceeding; Restoring PQA as a Party 37 C.F.R. § 42.5

Ex. 3024

Ex. 3023

Patent Quality Assurance LLC Response to Paper 106

CAFC Order re Briefing Schedule

PQA Petition for Writ of Mandamus and Nonconfidential Appendix

Order: Granting Additional Briefing; Staying the Proceeding

PQA Motion for Reconsideration of Director's Decision Determining Abuse of Process, Issuing Sanctions, Ordering Petitioner Patent Quality Assurance LLC to Show Cause, and Lifting Stay

Ex. 3022

Director Review Order Granting Extension of Time for Rehearing Request

Ex. 3021

Director Review Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time

Ex. 3016

Ex. 3017

Ex. 3018

Ex. 3019

Ex. 3020

Ex. 3015

Decision on Director Review (Confidential Version)

Decision on Director Review (Redacted Public Version)

EXPUNGED

Order Staying the Proceeding

Patent Owner's Reply In Support of Motion to Terminate

Petitioner (Intel) Opposition to Motion to Terminate

(Intel) Weatherwax E-mail 8/26/2022

Ex. 3013

Ex. 3014

Petitioner Demonstratives

Patent Owner's Oral Argument Demonstratives

Petitioner's (Intel) Updated Mandatory Notices

Order: ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. sec 42.70 on Motion

EXPUNGED

Patent Owner's Motion to Terminate (Provisionally Sealed)

Patent Owner's Motion to Terminate (Public)

Ex. 2076 CONFIDENTIAL

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply

EXPUNGED

Ex. 2124 Intel Notice of Appeal

Ex. 2125 Intel Principal Brief

Petitioner PQA's Reply in Support of Its Motion to Seal (Paper 49)

Petitioner PQA's Reply in Support of Its Motion to Seal (Paper 75)

Petitioner PQA's Reply in Support of Its Motion to Seal (Paper 79)

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Seal (Paper 79)

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Seal (Paper 75)

Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Seal (Paper 49)

Petitioner request for oral argument

Patent Owner VLSI Technology LLC's Request for Oral Argument

Petitioner���s Motion to Seal Confidential Information in Paper 74

Patent Owner's Responsive Brief (REDACTED)

Non-confidential Petitioner PQA's Brief in Response to Patent Owner's Director Review Brief

Petitioner (Intel) Responsive Brief - REDACTED

2022-08-19 Email Weatherwax to PQA - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-05-10 Email Redjaian to POP - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-05-11 Email Redjaian to POP re disclosure of confidential material - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-08-02 Email Weatherwax to PQA Counsel - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-08-19 Email Weatherwax to PQA Counsel

2022-08-24 Email Wen to PQA Counsel - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-08-27 Email Wen to PQA Counsel - CONFIDENTIAL

2022-08-16 Email Weatherwax to Director

Ex. 2091

2022-05-20 Ltr Lamken to Slayden (PQA_0343)

Ex. 2092

Ex. 2093

Ex. 2094

Ex. 2095

Ex. 2096

Ex. 2097 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2098

Ex. 2099

Ex. 2100

Ex. 2101

Ex. 2103

Petitioner PQA's Brief in Response to Patent Owner's Director Review Brief

Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Petitioner's (Intel) Responsive Brief

(Intel) Stolarski Declaration

Patent Owner's Responsive Brief

PQA Motion to Seal Confidential Information and Exhibits

Order: Authorization for Motion to Terminate as to Intel - 37 CFR 42.20-42.25, 42.72

Patent Owner's Brief in Response to Director Review Order (Redacted)

Patent Owner's Objections Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.64(b)(1)

NON-CONFIDENTIAL - Petitioner Opening Brief in Response to Director Review (Re-filed)

Ex. 3012

NON-CONFIDENTIAL - Petitioner Opening Brief in Response to Director Review

Brief of Amicus Curiae - High Tech Inventors Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Engine Advocacy, ACT | The App Association, and The Developers Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Ramzi Khalil Maloouf

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Naples Roundtable

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Association of Amicus Counsel

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Computer & Communications Industry Association

Brief of Amicus Curiae - BSA | The Software Alliance

Brief of Amicus Curiae - US Startups and Inventors for Jobs, Conservatives for Property Rights, and Valencell Corporation

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Hon. Paul R. Michel

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Unified Patents, LLC, The Alliance for Automotive Innovation, and US Manufacturers for Development and Enterprise

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Public Interest Patent Law Institute

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Centripetal Networks, Inc.

Ex. 3011

Patent Owner's Brief in Response to Director Review Order (Redacted)

Patent Owner's Motion to Seal Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.54

Ex. 2064 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2065 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2066 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2067 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2068 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2069 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2070 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2071 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2072 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2073 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2074 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2075 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2077 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2078 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2079 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2080 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2081

Ex. 2082

Ex. 2083

Ex. 2084

Ex. 2085

Ex. 2086 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2087 CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2088 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2089 HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Ex. 2090

Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Petitioner's Objections

(Intel) Privilege Log

(Intel) Fernandez Letter 8/15/22

(Intel) Fernandez Letter 8/4/22

(Intel) Weatherwax E-mail

(Intel) Wen E-mail

Intel 1501

Intel 1502

Intel 1503

Intel 1504

Intel 1505

Intel 1506

Intel 1507

Intel 1508

Intel 1509

Intel 1510

Intel 1511

Intel 1512

Intel 1513

Intel 1514

Intel 1515

Intel 1516

Intel 1517

Petitioner's (Intel) Brief

Motion to Seal

South Dakota - Initial Filing - Patent Quality Assurance LLC

VLSI-IPR-PQA00000011

VLSI-IPR-PQA00000013

Patent Owner's Brief in Response to Director Review Order

Email Fenton to Ivey et al - re Opensky 2022-01-11

Email Ivey - Fenton et al - re Opensky - 2022-01-12

Email Fenton to Ivey - 2022-01-17

Email Fenton to Oliver - Action required to correct material errors - 2022-01-13

Director Vidal provides clarity to Patent Trial and Appeal Board practice on discretionary denials of patent challenges based on parallel litigation

Senator Leahy, PTAB Reform Act of 2022 One Pager

CONFIDENTIAL / SEALED - Petitioner Opening Brief in Response to Director Review

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response

Second Declaration of Adit Singh, PhD

Conte Deposition Transcript

Excerpts of Day 2 Trial Transcript (Public) - 21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.) - Feb. 23 2021

Excerpts of Day 3 Trial Transcript (Public) - 21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.) - Feb. 24 2021

Excerpts of Day 4 Trial Transcript (Public) - 21-cv-00057 (W.D. Tex.) - Feb. 25 2021

Patent Owner's Identification of Documents for Review In Camera as to Patent Quality Assurance, LLC

Patent Owner's Identification of Documents for Review In Camera as to Intel Corporation

Ex. 3010

Ex. 3009

Ex. 3008

Ex. 3007

E-mail regarding access to case files

Brief of Amicus Curiae - AIPLA

Brief of Amicus Curiae - Armitage

Order: Denying POP Request

PETITIONER OBJECTIONS TO DIRECTOR ORDERS

Ex. 3004

Ex. 3005

Order Addressing Scope of Mandated Discovery

Notice of Deposition of Thomas Conte PhD

Director Review Order Extending Due Dates

Director Review Scheduling Order

Order entering Modified Default Protective Order

Modified Default Protective Order

Exhibit 3002 POP Request

Notice: notice of receipt of POP request

Patent Owner's Requests for Rehearing and Precedential Opinion Panel Review

Order Granting Sua Sponte Director Review

Order Dismissing Request for POP Review

Institution decision and grant of joinder, IPR2022-00479

ORDER Granting Petitioners Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Brian C. Banner 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

Ex. 2029 PQA Email (Confidential)

Ex. 2030 Christopher Newman Amicus Form

Ex. 2031 Conservatives for Property Rights Amicus Form

Ex. 2032 WARF Amicus Form

Ex. 2033 Kristen Osenga Amicus Form

Ex. 2034 Eagle Forum Education and Legal Defense Fund Amicus Form

Ex. 2035 Alliance of U.S. Startups and Inventors for Jobs Amicus Form

Ex. 2036 Cornell University Amicus Form

Ex. 2038 OpenSky Attorney Emails Expose the Seedy Underbelly of PTAB Practice

Ex. 2039 Matich LinkedIn Post

Ex. 2040 PTAB Needs to Immediately Check Unethical Practices

Ex. 2041 IAM Media

Ex. 2042 Sabotage Claims Swirl in Patent Feud With Billions at Stake

Ex. 2043 PTAB Denies OpenSky's Request for Rehearing But VLSI Cases Highlight Broader PTAB Problems

Ex. 2044 Vidal Expected to Tackle Patent Board PR Nightmare, Reviews

Ex. 2045 Priorities: The IP Community Has Its Say on What Should Top Vidal's To Do List

Ex. 2046 Tillis/Hirono Letter

Ex. 2047 Weaponization of PTAB Presents First Challenge for Vidal

Ex. 2048 Senate Grows Impatient with PTAB

Ex. 2053 Singh Deposition

Ex. 2054 U.S.P.N. 6,469,883

Ex. 2055 U.S.P.N. 10,408,888

Ex. 2056 U.S.P.N. 7,3435,944

Ex. 2057 68HC16Y1 Motorola User's Manual

Ex. 2058 Bickford

Ex. 2059 Helsinn Br. of United States

Ex. 2060 Uradnik Deposition (Confidential)

Ex. 2061 IPR2022-00480 Petition

Ex. 2062 IPR2021-01064 Requests for Rehearing and POP Review

Ex. 2063 U.S.P.N. 7,312,644

Ex. 2052 Conte Declaration

Patent Owner Response

PETIONERS MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF BRIAN C. BANNER PURSUANT TO 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(c)

DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF BRIAN C. BANNER PURSUANT TO 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(c)

Notice of Stipulation

Banner Declaration for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Notice of Second Joint Stipulation to Modify Schedule

First Amended Notice of Deposition of Dr. Singh

Notice of Deposition of Uradnik

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Singh

ORDER Granting Patent Owners Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Nathan Lowenstein, Alan Heinrich, and Dominik Slusarczyk 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10 c

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Schedule

Patent Owner's Third Updated Mandatory Notice Information

Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nathan Lowenstein

Ex. 2001 Lowenstein Declaration - 1229

IPR2021-01229 PHV Motion for Alan Heinrich

Ex. 2027 IPR2021-01229 Declaration in Support of PHV Motion for Alan Heinrich

PHV Motion for Dominik Slusarczyk

Ex. 2028 IPR2021-01229 Declaration in Support of PHV Motion for Dominik Slusarczyk

Order: Scheduling Order

Ex. 3001 POP Request

Notice: notice of receipt of POP request

Patent Owner's Requests for Rehearing and Precedential Opinion Panel Review

Ex. 2025 Tillis Press Release

Ex. 2026 Tillis IP Watchdog

Patent Owner Second Updated Mandatory Notice

Institution Decision: Grant

Patent Owner's Objections Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. 42.64(b)(1)

Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply

Ex. 2024 Email Chain

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Fenton Declaration

Engagement Agreement

Letter

Ex. 2002 '373 Conte Declaration

Ex. 2003 Conte Report

Ex. 2004 Dennhardt Email

Ex. 2005 Bultmann Bloomberg Article

Ex. 2007 Sylvester Report

Ex. 2008 IPR2020-00158 POPR

Ex. 2009 PQA Articles

Ex. 2010 Invalidity Contentions - Cover Pleading

Ex. 2011 Invalidity Contentions - Harris

Ex. 2012 Final Invalidity Contentions - Additional Art

Ex. 2013 Invalidity Contentions - Additional Art

Ex. 2014 Davis Law360 Article

Ex. 2015 Docket Attorneys

Ex. 2016 Intel-PQA Comparison Chart

Ex. 2017 Harris '103

Ex. 2018 Oxford Dictionary

Ex. 2019 Microsoft Computer Dictionary

Ex. 2020 Newton's Telecom Dictionary

Ex. 2021 Jury Instructions

Ex. 2022 Singh Decl. Comparison Chart

Ex. 2023 OpenSky-PQA Comparison Chart

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Patent Owner Updated Mandatory Notice

Patent Owner Mandatory Notice

Patent Owner Power of Attorney

Notice of Accord Filing Date

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent 7,523,373

Petitioner's Power of Attorney

U.S. Patent No. 7,523,373

Declaration of Dr. Adit Singh

U.S. Patent No. 5,867,719

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2006/0259840

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2003/0122429

U.S. Patent No. 7,702,935

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0188230

System-on-Chip for Real-Time Applications (2003)

Computer Architecture: A Quantitative Approach (2d ed. 1996)

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0077919

U.S. Patent No. 5,086,501

U.S. Patent No. 4,461,003

U.S. Patent No. RE37,593

U.S. Patent No. 4,709,202

U.S. Patent No. 4,553,225

U.S. Patent No. 6,697,978

U.S. Patent No. 7,142,996

U.S. Patent No. 7,276,925

U.S. Patent No. 6,772,379

U.S. Patent No. 6,975,551

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2007/0174642

'373 Patent File History - August 19, 2008 Office Action

'373 Patent File History - November 13, 2008 Response

McGraw Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms (6th ed. 2003)

U.S. Patent No. 7,484,140

U.S. Patent No. 5,760,624

Declaration of Dr. Sylvia Hall-Ellis

VLSI v. Intel - Claim Construction Order

VLSI v. Intel - Joint Claim Construction Statement

Jaycar Electronics Reference Data Sheet

VLSI v. Intel - Jury Verdict in District Court Case

Declaration of Petitioner