Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC vs OnPoint Systems, LLC

Final Written Decision: JUDGMENT Determining all Challenged Claims Unpatentable Denying Patent Owner’s Motion to Amend Denying Patent Owner’s Motion to Exclude Denying Petitioner’s Motion to Exclude 35 U.S.C. § 318(a)

Other: Hearing transcript

Exhibit 3002

Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibits for Oral Argument

Patent Owners Objections to Petitioners Demonstratives

Petitioner's Demonstrative Exhibit - Not Evidence

2039 Patent Owners Trial Hearing Demonstratives

Patent Owners Updated Exhibit List

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Petitioner)

Patent Owners Reply to Opposition to Motion to Exclude Petitioners Evidence

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude Portions of EX2035 and EX2038

Petitioner's Sur-Reply to Patent Owner's Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

Patent Owners Opposition to Petitioners Motion to Exclude Portions of EX2035 and EX2038

Petitioner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude Evidence

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Objections to Patent Owner_s Evidence In Support Of Reply to Petitioner_s Opposition to the Revised Motion to Amend Under 37 C.F.R. sec. 42.64

Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Petitioner's Evidence

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Motion to Exclude Portions of EX2035 and EX2038

Patent Owners Reply to Opposition to Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

2038 Declaration of Mark A. Sturza in Support of Patent Owners Reply to Petitioners Opposition to Patent Owners Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Mark Alan Sturza

ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. sec 42.70

Patent Owners Objections to Petitioners Evidence

Patent Owners Request for Oral Argument

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Petitioner's Opposition To Patent Owner's Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

Declaration of Dr. Vijay K. Madisetti In Support of Petitioner’s Opposition to Patent Owner’s Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

NMEA Output Description – Standards

Gonzalez, Behavioral Classification of Data From Collars Containing Motion Sensors In grazing Cattle

Molina, On The Use of Qualitative Inertial/GPS Integration For Personal Motion Analysis For Elderly People

US Patent No. 7,688,259 to Mizuochi

Guidelines for RTK/RTN GNSS Surveying in Canada

LEA-6 u-blox 6 GPS Modules Data Sheet

U.S. Patent Application 2014/0002239 to Rayner

Nayak, Reliable and Continuous Urban Navigation Using Multiple GPS Antennas and A Low Cost IMU

2012 International Conference on Indoor Positioning and Indoor Navigation, 13-15th November 2012

International Patent Application WO2012045484A1 to Lai, et al.

U.S. Patent Application 20070204804 to Swanson et al.

Tracking Animals With GPS, ISBN 2001

Hubert, The Accuracy of GPS For Wildlife Telemetry

An Introduction to GNSS

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. V. K. Madisetti

Second Revised Scheduling Order

Ex. 3001

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Notice Identifying Support For Reply Arguments And Exhibits

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Objections To Patent Owner_s Evidence In Support Of Motion To Amend Under 37 C.F.R. 42.64

Patent Owner's Revised Notice Concerning Petitioner's Reply and Exhibits

EXPUNGED

Order: Scheduling Order

EXPUNGED

Patent Owner's Revised Contingent Motion to Amend

EX-2035 Declaration of Mark A. Sturza

EX-2036 US Pat No. 9922522

EX-2037 US Pat No 9924314

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply

Patent Owner���s Second Updated Power of Attorney

Patent Owners Third Updated Mandatory Notices

Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 3 and 5

DECISION Granting Patent Owners Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Benjamin M. Stern, Seth S. Coburn, and Timothy R. Shannon 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

ORDER Granting Patent Owners Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10 e

Petitioner_s Notice of Non-Opposition to Patent Owner_s Motion for Messrs. Stern, Shannon, and Coburn To Appear Pro Hac Vice

Transcript of Remote Proceedings_ Hearing Before The Board_ September 14_ 2022

Certificate of Service of Petitioner's Exhibit 1059_ September 14_ 2022 Transcript of Proceedings

Patent Owners Revised Notice of Deposition of Dr. Vijay K. Madisetti

Notice: Preliminary Guidance

Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission

Declaration of B. M. Stern

Declaration of S. S. Coburn

Declaration of T. R. Shannon

Joint Motion for Entry of Protective Order

Protective Order May 7, 2021

Email chain from 5.12-17.2022

Email chain from 8.12-9.1.2022

Email chain from 9.1-12.22

Email chain from 9.1-12.2022

Patent Owners Notice of Deposition of Dr. Vijay K. Madisetti

Patent Owners Unopposed Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Lead Counsel

Patent Owner's Objections To Petitioner's Evidence

EXPUNGED

Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence in Support of Petitioner's Reply

Patent Owners Second Updated Mandatory Notices

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Reply to Patent Owner_s Response to Petition

Madisetti Declaration In Support of Reply

Spot on Collar Advertisement

Spot On Dog Collar Advertisement

EXPUNGED

GNS Intro - Part 1 of 4

GNSS Intro - Part 2 of 4

GNSS Intro - Part 3 of 4

GNSS Intro - Part 4 of 4

https://www.lunitek.it/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/ProPak6-OEM6%C2%AE-Firmware-Reference-Guide-OM-20000129.pdf

https://www.rtklib.com/prog/manual_2.4.2.pdf

Rayner

ungnss

Claim construction memo

U.S. Patent App. No. 20160116602 to McFarland, et al. (McFarland II)

U.S. Patent App. No. 20130127658 to McFarland, et al. (McFarland)

LMU USER_s Guide

Madisetti Declaration ISO Opposition to PO_s Motion to Amend

Aggregate definition

Kim

Ublox

https://patents.google.com/patent/US8131463B2/en?q=GNSS&q=carrier-noise&q=noise&before=priority:20160601

https://patents.google.com/patent/US9442178B2/en?q=GNSS&q=constellation&q=collar&q=pet&q=glonass&before=priority:20160601&page=1

314 IPR petition

522 IPR petition

Rosing

Shaprio

invensense

Bno055

New Rich

US 8,935,093 to Chansarkar

Jessop

ORIAN

SKYTRAQ

TELIT JUPTIER

LOWRANCE

TRIMBLE NOMAD

TELTONIK

SIF HARDWARE

EXPUNGED

EXPUNGED

EXPUNGED

Petitioner Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC_s Opposition to Patent Owner_s Contingent Motion to Cancel and Amend Claims

Patent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney

Petitioner_s Notice of Deposition of Mark Alan Sturza

Denying Petitioner Request for Authorization to File a Motion to Compel Denying Petitioner Request to Waive Page Limits Granting Parties Request to Stipulate New Due Dates 2 and 3 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5(b), 42.24(b)(3), 42.51(b)(1)

Patent Owner's Contingent Motion to Amend

Exhibit-2022-US Pat Application No. 15190479

Exhibit-2023-Clam Construction Memorandum and Order

Patent Owner Response

Exhibit 2024-Declaration of Mark A. Sturza

Exhibit 2025-Curriculum Vitae of Mark A. Sturza

Patent Owner���s Power of Attorney

Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review

Scheduling Order

Order: Granting Patent Owners Motion to Withdraw Counsel

Patent Owners Updated Mandatory Notices

Patent Owners Substitute Power of Attorney

Patent Owners Preliminary Response

2001 Complaint without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 1

2002 Answer and Counterclaims without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 9

2003 First Amended Complaint without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 20

2004 Second Amended Complaint without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 43

2005 First Amended Answer and Second Amended Counterclaims without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 28

2006 Amended Answer and Second Amended Counterclaims without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 40

2007 Second Amended Answer and Third Amended Counterclaims without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 61

2008 Order Setting Trial E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 65

2009 Email Thread with Texas Court, Petitioner, and Patent Owner Nov. 10-17, 2021 E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM

2010 Joint Motion for Entry of Scheduling Order without exhibit E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657-ALM, Docket No. 22

2011 Joint Motion to Amend Scheduling Order without exhibit E.D. Tex., Case No. 420-cv-00657, Docket No. 62

2012 Order in Evicam Intl, Inc. v. Enforcement Video, LLC E.D. Tex., Case No. 416-cv-105-ALM, Docket No. 99

2013 Reporters Transcript of March 16, 2021 Telephone Conference in AMS Sensors USA, Inc. v. Renesas Elecs. Am E.D. Tex., Case No. 408-cv-00451-ALM, Docket No. 757

2014 EDTEX Judge Mazzant Talks Holding Trials Amid COVID-19 in LAW360 Nov. 23, 2020

2015 Trials Before Judge Mazzant During COVID-19 Pandemic E.D. Tex

2016 OnPoint System, LLCs Disclosures Pursuant to Patent Rules 3-1 and 3-2 Mar. 18, 2021 without exhibits E.D. Tex., Case No. 408-cv-00451-ALM

2017 PAWSs Invalidity Contentions Apr. 30, 2021 without appendices Case No., 408-cv-00451-ALM

2018 PAWSs Second Amended Invalidity Contentions Sept. 23, 2021 without appendices E.D. Tex., Case No. 408-cv-00451-ALM

2019 Docket Sheet for OnPoint Systems LLC v. Protect Animals With Satellites, LLC E.D. Tex., Case No. 408-cv-00451-ALM

2020 PAWSs First Amended Invalidity Contentions May 28, 2021 without appendices E.D. Tex., Case No. 408-cv-00451-ALM

2021 Judge Mazzants Markman Hearing Dates, Issuance of Markman Rulings, and Time Intervals E.D. Tex. 2012-2021

PATENT OWNER'S UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR WITHDRAWAL AND SUBSTITUTION OF LEAD COUNSEL

Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney

Notice: Notice filing date accorded

Petition For Inter Partes Review of United States Patent No. 9,848,295 Pursuant To 35 U.S.C. 311-319, 37 C.F.R. 42

U.S. Patent No. 9,848,295

Prosecution History of U.S. Patent No. 9,848,295

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2011/0140884

Joint Claim Construction and Pre-Hearing Statement & Exhibit A [Case 4:20-cv-00657-ALM Documents 57 and 57-1]

Order Amending Scheduling Order [Case 4:20-cv-00657-ALM Document 63]

Declaration of Vijay Madisetti

W. Randolph Franklin, PNPOLY - Point Inclusion in Polygon Test W. Randolph Franklin (WRF), May 18, 2005

Donald H. House, Chapter 9 - Raycasting Polygonal Models, December 28, 2013

OnPoint Infringement Contentions Served on June 28, 2021 in Connection with Case 4:20-cv-00657-ALM

Johnathan Chang, et al., Wireless Pet Containment System, Presented 04-26-2016

How to check if a given point lies inside or outside a polygon? Geeks for Geeks, July 11, 2013

Alvaro Llaria, et.al., Geolocation and monitoring platform for extensive farming in mountain pastures, June 18, 2015

Schirra, S. How reliable are practical point-in-polygon strategies?

U.S. Patent No. 8,939,111 to Berntsen, et al.

U.S. Patent No. 8,448,607 to Giunta

U.S. Patent No. 9,173,380 to Trenkle, et al.

U.S. Patent App. No. 20110298615 to Rich, et al.

Vivek Shah, When is a Point Inside a Polygon?, May 17, 2013

Collision Course II: Ray-Polygon-Intersection, April 28, 2016

U.S. Patent 9,848,295 Claims

A. Bahga and V. Madisetti, Cloud-Based Information Technology Framework for Data Driven Intelligent Transportation Systems

Prasad, S., Weeks, M., Zhang, Y., Zelikovsky, A., Belkasim, S., Sunderraman, R., & Madisetti, V. (2002). Mobile Fleet Application using Soap and System on Devices (SYD) Middleware Technologies. Communications, Internet, and Information Technology

Madisetti, Vijay, et al. (2004). SyD: A Middleware Testbed for Collaborative Applications over Small Heterogeneous Devices and Data Stores

Curriculum Vitae of Vijay Madisetti

Petitioner's Power of Attorney