Chanel, Inc. vs Molo Design, Ltd.

Final Written Decision

Other: Hearing transcript

Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibits

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Petitioner's Demonstratives

Petitioner's Sur-Sur-Reply re PO's Copying Allegations

Exhibit 1061 (MOLO_00001811)

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notice

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notice

Order: ORDER Denying Petitioner’s Motion to Strike 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.20, 42.23(b)

Exhibit 3002

ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. sec 42.70

Patent Owner's Response to Motion to Strike

Petitioner's Motion to Strike Exhibits 2034-2037

Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Exhibits

Patent Owner's Surreply

Email from Tran Vinh to molostore.com

Email from Victoria Megans to Tran Vinh

Email from Tran Vinh to Victoria Megans

Email from Victoria Megans to Tran Vinh

ORDER Conditionally Granting Patent Owner’ Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Conor M. Civins 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

PETITIONER’S REPLY TO PATENT OWNER RESPONSE

Transcript of March 21, 2023 Deposition of Alan Ball (Ball-Dep.)

Transcript of March 22, 2023 Deposition of Todd MacAllen (MacAllen-Dep.)

Transcript of March 24, 2023 Deposition of Stephanie Forsythe (Forsythe-Dep.)

Declaration of Miles Ladin, dated June 24, 2021

Molo's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Conor M. Civins

Declaration of Conor M. Civins

Updated Scheduling Order

Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument

IPR 2022-00546 - Amended Notice of Deposition of Alan Ball

IPR 2022-00546 - Amended Notice of Deposition of Stephanie Forsythe

IPR 2022-00546 - Amended Notice of Deposition of Todd MacAllen

IPR 2022-00546 - Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

IPR 2022-00546 - Notice of Deposition of Alan Ball

IPR 2022-00546 - Notice of Deposition of Stephanie Forsythe

IPR 2022-00546 - Notice of Deposition of Todd MacAllen

Curriculum Vitae of Alan Ball

Transcript of deposition of Lance Rake, taken December 20, 2022

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Molo softwall Product Webpage (2005)

Letter from Museum of Modern Art to Stephanie Forsyth (2005)

Moma.org webpage (2005)

Email from Evelyn Lacson To Stephanie Forsyth (2023)

Years of Emerging Voices - The Architectural League of New York - Princeton Architectural Press (2021)

MoMA PS1 Young Architects Program (YAP) Competition (2005)

Azure Magazine - A-Z Awards (2011)

Best of NeoCon - Gold Award Architectural products for softwall + softblock modular system (2014)

AIT Award - Retail Trend for softwall (2014)

ADEX Awards Certificate - Molo Design-Gold-softwall + softblock modular system (2015)

FRAME Magazine Award at Orgatec Germany (2018)

Affidavit of Leo Lubke (2021)

Molo Clients – See Brands we Worth (Google Cache of https://molodesign.com/clients/)

MUSEUMS & ART GALLERIES that have acquired molo products

Complaint filed in Molo Design Ltd. v. Chanel, Inc., No 21-cv-1578 (S.D.N.Y.), dated February 22, 2021 (Dkt. No. 1 2031)

Declaration of Alan Ball in support of Patent Owner’s Response

Patent Owner Molo Design Ltd.'s Response

The Index Project webpage (2005)

Notice of Deposition of Lance Rake

IPR2022-00546 - Joint Stipulation to Revise Scheduling Order

Joint Stipulation to Revise Scheduling Order

ORDER Granting Petitioners Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Shannon L. Bjorklund and Geoffrey M. Godfrey 37 C.F.R. sec 42.10

Chanel, Inc.'s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Shannon L. Bjorklund Under 37 C.F.R. 42.10(c)

Declaration of Shannon L. Bjorklund in Support of Chanel, Inc.'s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Shannon L. Bjorklund Under 37 C.F.R. 42.10(c)

Chanel, Inc.'s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Geoffrey M. Godfrey Under 37 C.F.R. 42.10(c)

Declaration of Geoffrey M. Godfrey in Support of Chanel, Inc.'s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Geoffrey M. Godfrey Under 37 C.F.R. 42.10(c)

Institution Decision: Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. sec. 314

Order: SCHEDULING ORDER

Exhibit 3001

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Joint Disputed Claim Terms Chart

Defendant Chanel, Inc.'s Claim Construction Brief

Plaintiff Molo Design Ltd.'s Notice Regarding Chanel's Supplement Claim Construction Positions

Chanel's Response to Molo's Supplemental Claim Construction Statement

Notice accepting corrected petition

Patent Owner's Mandatory Notice Information

Power of Attorney

Notice: defective petition

Response to Notice of Filing Date Accorded and Defective Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,797,134

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 9,797,134

Power of Attorney Pursuant to 37 CFR 42.10(B)

USPN 9797134

File History of USPN 9797134

Declaration of Lance Gordon Rake

Affidavit of Duncan Hall

DBEW, "Golden Prize" ("SoftHousing I") May 2004

DBEW, "Collection of Winning Works of DBEW International Design Competition", March 2004

Common Ground "First Step Soft Housing" ("SoftHousing III")

JPS4987173A (Okuno)

"Soft Housing" produced by Molo

SoftHousing I and II 00000768-0772 and 00000666-0675

Soft Housing 00000831 00000779

DBEW, 3rd DBEW International Design Competition produced by Molo

DBEW International Design Competition 2003 Refs

USPN 4307768 (Anderson)

JPH0520204Y2 (Sankyo)

USPN 6427409 (Colson)

USPN 2807405 (Lambert)

Scheduling Order in Molo Design, Ltd. v. Chanel, Inc.

Lex Machina Report for S.D.N.Y.

Declaration of Shannon Bjorklund

US Patent Pub 2006/0260231 (MacAllen)

US Patent Pub 2006/0082987 (Dorsey)

US Patent Pub 2007/0017172 (Kennedy)

Molo's Infringement Contentions in Molo Design, Ltd. v. Chanel, Inc.

MacAllen Patent Application No. 12/343,042

Soft Housing First Step Articles