IP Verse

BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. vs Walmart Apollo, LLC

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2022-01563 filed by BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. against Walmart Apollo, LLC on Sep 22, 2022. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number
IPR2022-01563
Filing Date
Sep 22, 2022
Petitioner
BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.
Respondent
Walmart Apollo, LLC
Status
Final Written Decision - Appealed
Respondent Application Number
16730567
Respondent Tech Center
3600
Respondent Patent Number
10803435
Institution Decision Date
Apr 12, 2023
Termination Date
Apr 11, 2024

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.


Document NameFiling DateCategoryFiling Party

Alert me when new update on this case

PO's Notice of Appeal

Jun 12, 2024PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 3002

Apr 11, 2024EXHIBITBOARD

Ex. 3001

Apr 11, 2024EXHIBITBOARD

Final Written Decision: original

Apr 11, 2024PAPERBOARD

Other: Hearing transcript

Apr 5, 2024PAPERBOARD

LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Patent Owner)

Jan 8, 2024PAPERBOARD

2024-01-08 Patent Owner's Exhibit List

Jan 8, 2024PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2018 - PO Oral Argument Demonstratives

Jan 8, 2024EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Updated Exhibit List

Jan 8, 2024PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Demonstratives Exhibit

Jan 8, 2024EXHIBITPETITIONER

ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. § 42.70

Dec 19, 2023PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument

Nov 29, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument

Nov 29, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Sur-Reply in IPR2022-01563

Nov 28, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Stipulation to Move Due Date 3

Oct 26, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply

Oct 11, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Exhibit 1022

Oct 11, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1031

Oct 11, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1032

Oct 11, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1033

Oct 11, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Exhibit 1034

Oct 11, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner Amended Notice of Cross-Examination of Dr. Williams

Sep 18, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

PETITIONER’S NOTICE OF CROSS-EXAMINATION OF DR. TIM WILLIAMS

Aug 17, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Stipulation of Due Dates

Aug 17, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Jul 20, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner Response - IPR2022-01563

Jul 19, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Dr Tim A Williams Declaration

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Dr Tim A Williams CV 2023

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Michael Shamos PhD Depo Transcript

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Barcode_MerriamWebster11th

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Barcode_American Heritage 4th

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Receipt_American Heritage 4th

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Article - Is it legal to search shopping bags

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Article - Stop, Thief! _ The New Yorker

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Matthew Johnson Declaration Dated July 19, 2023

Jul 19, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Notice of Stipulation of Due Dates

Jun 21, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Updated Exhibit List

Jun 16, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Combined Declaration from Translator Hyunjoo Kim and Patent Attorney Seongsu Hong adding a declaration attestation for the original certified translation in Ex. 1010

Jun 16, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Certified English translation of Korean Patent Pub. No. KR 10-2007-0087811 in the format of the order of appearance of content presented in Ex. 1009

Jun 16, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Certified English translation of Korean Patent Pub. No. KR 10-2007-0087811 in the format of the order of appearance of content presented in Ex. 2001

Jun 16, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

Letter dated January 31, 2023 issued by Korean Intellectual Property Office (KIPO) with a certified English translation (identifying the publication of Korean Patent Pub. No. KR 10-2007-0087811 (Ex. 1009) by KIPO)

Jun 16, 2023EXHIBITPETITIONER

PETITIONER’S UPDATED MANDATORY NOTICES UNDER 37 C.F.R. § 42.8

Jun 15, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

ORDER Granting Petitioners Motion to Submit Supplemental Information 37 C.F.R. sec 42.123 a

Jun 13, 2023PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner Notice

Jun 1, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner Motion to Submit Supplemental Information_01563 MAY 26 2023

May 26, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Notice of Cross-Examination of Dr. Shamos

May 24, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Objections to Evidence

Apr 24, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence

Apr 24, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Institution Decision: DECISION Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314

Apr 12, 2023PAPERBOARD

Order: SCHEDULING ORDER

Apr 12, 2023PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply

Feb 22, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner Preliminary Response

Feb 15, 2023PAPERPETITIONER

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Jan 13, 2023PAPERPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2001 - KIPO Yong

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2002 - Johnson Declaration

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2003 - Claim 1 to Claim 15 Comparison

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2004 - Lichtenstein

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2005 - Barbaro

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2006 - Definition of "Receipt"

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2007 - Fletchall File History

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Ex. 2008 - Hodge

Jan 13, 2023EXHIBITPATENT OWNER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

Oct 17, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Petitioner's Notice of Ranking Petitions for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,803,435

Oct 17, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Plaintiff's Preliminary Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions to BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Sam's West, Inc. and Walmart Apollo, LLC. v. BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc., No. 6:22-cv-00587-WWB (M.D. Fla.), served June 20, 2022.

Oct 17, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Notice: Notice filing date accorded

Oct 13, 2022PAPERBOARD

Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices

Sep 29, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney

Sep 29, 2022PAPERPATENT OWNER

U.S. Patent No. 10,803,435 to Nelms et al.

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Curriculum Vitae of Michael Shamos, Ph.D

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History of the '435 Patent, U.S. Patent Application No. 16/730,567, filed Dec. 30, 2019

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History of Prior-Filed Parent U.S. Patent Application No. 15/956,400, filed Apr. 18, 2018

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History of Prior-Filed Parent U.S. Patent Application No. 12/947,545, filed Nov. 16, 2010

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

continued (2/3) - File History of Prior-Filed Parent U.S. Patent Application No. 12/947,545, filed Nov. 16, 2010

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

continued (3/3) - File History of Prior-Filed Parent U.S. Patent Application No. 12/947,545, filed Nov. 16, 2010

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

File History of Prior-Filed Parent U.S. Patent Application No. 61/392,908, filed Oct. 13, 2010

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Korean Patent Publication No. KR 10-2007-0087811 to Yong

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

continued (2/2) - Korean Patent Publication No. KR 10-2007-0087811 to Yong

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Certified English translation of Korean Patent Publication No. KR 10-2007-0087811 to Yong

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2009/0094100 to Xavier

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Jerry Gao et al. "A 2D Barcode-Based Mobile Payment System," 2009 Third International Conference on Multimedia and Ubiquitous Engineering

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

AisleBuyer Announces Self-Checkout iPhone Application, Softpedia News, Aug. 17, 2010

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Case Management and Scheduling Order, Sam's West, Inc. and Walmart Apollo, LLC. v. BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc., No. 6:22-cv-00587-WWB (M.D. Fla.), ECF No. 51, June 8, 2022.

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Middle District of Florida, Judicial Caseload Profile, June 30, 2022

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Korean Patent Publication No. KR 10-2007-0087811 Patent Biblio Page (English) downloaded Sept. 9, 2022

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Microsoft Computer Dictionary 475 (5th ed. 2002)

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petitioner BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.'s Power of Attorney

Sep 22, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

Yong English Annotated Drawings Figures 1-11

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Docket, Sam's West, Inc. and Walmart Apollo, LLC. v. BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc., No. 6:22-cv-00587-WWB (M.D. Fla.)

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Declaration of Michael Shamos, Ph.D

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,803,435

Sep 22, 2022PAPERPETITIONER

U.S. Patent No. 8,751,316 to Fletchall et al.

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER

U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2010/0082444 to Lin et al.

Sep 22, 2022EXHIBITPETITIONER