IP Verse

Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al. vs Spero, Yechezkal et al.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number IPR2023-01039 filed by Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al. against Spero, Yechezkal et al. on Jun 7, 2023. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: IPR2023-01039
Filing Date: Jun 7, 2023
Petitioner: Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC et al.
Respondent: Spero, Yechezkal et al.
Status: Final Written Decision - Appealed
Respondent Application Number: 13357549
Respondent Tech Center: 2800
Respondent Patent Number: 9955551
Institution Decision Date: Dec 12, 2023
Termination Date: Dec 9, 2024

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
Notice of Appeal	Dec 16, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. § 318(a)	Dec 9, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
Other: Hearing transcript	Nov 20, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
Cover for Demonstrative 2068 & updated exhibit list 2023-01039	Oct 21, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Demonstratives IPR2023-01039	Oct 21, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List	Oct 21, 2024	PAPER	PETITIONER
EX1014-Petitioner's Demonstrative Exhibit	Oct 21, 2024	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Patent Owner)	Oct 16, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. § 42.70	Sep 19, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Patent Owner)	Sep 11, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
Order: Setting Oral Argument	Aug 19, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owners Request for Oral Argument IPR2023-01039	Jul 30, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument	Jul 30, 2024	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owners Sur Reply to Petitioners Reply to Patent Owner Response 2023-01039	Jul 10, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Date 3 IPR2023-01039	Jul 3, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response	May 28, 2024	PAPER	PETITIONER
EX1013-Turk Deposition Transcript	May 28, 2024	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Matthew A. Turk	May 10, 2024	PAPER	PETITIONER
Response to IPR2023-01039	Mar 5, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2040 Second Turk Declaration	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2041 Papanikolopoulos Deposition Transcript	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2050 SPIE Etendue concerns for automotive headlamps using white LEDs Jiao 2004	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2052 SAE Studies for Headlamp Optical Design Using LEDs Jiao 2004	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2053 SAE Optical Transform Limitations in Headlamp Photometric Performance Jiao 2005	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2055 SPIE High-efficiency reflector optics Volume 6670 Jiao 2007	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2056 Energy Savings Estimates of Light Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2060 Bass Handbook of Optics 3rd Edition Volume V	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2061 TI How DLP Technology Works	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2062 TI Intro to DMDs	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2063 Detection and classification of vehicles IEEE 2002	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2065 Webster dictionary	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2051 Bass Handbook of Optics 3rd Edition Vol 2 Excerpts 2010	Mar 5, 2024	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Deposition of Nikolaos Papanikolopoulos IPR2023-01039	Feb 9, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Updated Mandatory Notice - IPR2023-01039 - 9955551	Jan 3, 2024	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Objections to Evidence	Dec 27, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
Decision Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review	Dec 12, 2023	PAPER	BOARD
Order: SCHEDULING ORDER	Dec 12, 2023	PAPER	BOARD
Sur Reply to IPR2023-01039	Nov 14, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
PETITIONER’S REPLY TO PATENT OWNER’S PRELIMINARY RESPONSE REGARDING GENERAL PLASTIC ARGUMENTS	Nov 7, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
Preliminary Response to IPR2023-01039	Sep 14, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2001 Turk Declaration	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2002 Turk CV	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2003 Best Practices	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2005 IPR2023-01040 Petition	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2006 US20030137849A1 Alden File Wrapper History	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2007 Prospects Bright for Hella	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2008 Hella Matrix Automotive World 2014	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex 2010 Multi-row Headlamp System	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2012 Mercedes LED headlamps 2016	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2013 Torchlight v. Daimler et al Complaint	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2014 Certified File Wrapper Reexamination Application - Part 1 of 4	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2014 - Certified File Wrrapper Reexamination Application - Part 2 of 4	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2014 - Certified File Wrapper Reexamination Application - Part 3 of 4	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Ex. 2014 - Certified File Wrapper Reexamination Application - Part 4 of 4	Sep 14, 2023	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Updated Mandatory Notice - IPR2023-01039 - 9955551	Jul 24, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice : Mandatory Notice	Jul 21, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice : Power of Attorney	Jul 21, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice: Notice filing date accorded	Jun 14, 2023	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioner Power of Attorney	Jun 7, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petition for IPR of Claims 8, 10-18, and 24-47 of U.S. Patent No. 9,955,951	Jun 7, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
EX1001 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1002 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 File History_Part1	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1002 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 File History_Part2	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1002 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 File History_Part3	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1003 - Declaration of Dr. Nikolaos Papanikolopoulos	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1004 - Nikolaos P. Papnikolopoulos CV	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1005 - U.S. Patent Application Publication 2003-0137849A1_Alden	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1006 - U.S. Patent No. 6,049,749_Kobayashi	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1007 - U.S. Patent Application Publication 2002-0057572A1_Kondo	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1008 - WO2001070538A2_Stam	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1009 - Apr. 2023 PTAB Trial Statistics	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1010 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 Parte Reexam File History_Part1	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1010 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 Parte Reexam File History_Part2	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1010 - U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551 Parte Reexam File History_Part3	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1011 - Patent Owner Disclaimer under 37 CFR 1.321(a)	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
EX1012 - Reissue File History of U.S. Patent No. 9,955,551	Jun 7, 2023	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER