Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al. vs Oura Health Oy et al. - IPR2024-01078

Petitioner Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.’s Updated Power of Attorney

Petitioner Samsung Electronics America, Inc.’s Updated Power of Attorney

Petitioner’s Updated Mandatory Notices Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.8(a)(2)

Petitioner’s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Khanh Leon Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.10(c)

Declaration of Khanh Leon in Support of Petitioner’s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.10(c)

Petitioner’s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Argirenia Zervos Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.10(c)

Declaration of Argirenia Zervos in Support of Petitioner’s Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §42.10(c)

Ex. 1081 (REDACTED)

Ex. 1081 (SEALED)

Ex. 1082

Ex. 1083 (REDACTED)

Ex. 1083 (SEALED)

Ex. 1084

Ex. 1085

Ex. 1086

Ex. 1087

Ex. 1088

Ex. 1089

Ex. 1090

Ex. 1108

Ex. 1109

Ex. 1110

Ex. 1111

Ex. 1112

Ex. 1113

Ex. 1117

Ex. 1120

Ex. 1121

Ex. 1122

Ex. 1123

Ex. 1124

Ex. 1125

Ex. 1126

Ex. 1127

Ex. 1128

Ex. 1129

Ex. 1131

Ex. 1132

Ex. 1133

Ex. 1134

Ex. 1136

Ex. 1139

Ex. 1140

Ex. 1141

Ex. 1143

Ex. 1144

Ex. 1149

Ex. 1150

Ex. 1151

Ex. 1152

Ex. 1153

Ex. 1154

Ex. 1155

Ex. 1156

Ex. 1157

Ex. 1158

Ex. 1159

Ex. 1160

Ex. 1161

Ex. 1162

Ex. 1163

Ex. 1164

Ex. 1165

Ex. 1166

Ex. 1167

Ex. 1168

Ex. 1169

Ex. 1170

Ex. 1171

Ex. 1172

Ex. 1173

Ex. 1174

Ex. 1175

Ex. 1176

Ex. 1177

Ex. 1178

Ex. 1179

Ex. 1180

Ex. 1181

Ex. 1182

Ex. 1183

Ex. 1184

Ex. 1185

Ex. 1186

Ex. 1187

Ex. 1188

Ex. 1189

Ex. 1190

Ex. 1191

Ex. 1192

Ex. 1193

Ex. 1194

Ex. 1195

Ex. 1196

Ex. 1197

Ex. 1198

Ex. 1199

Ex. 1200

Ex. 1201

Ex. 1202

Ex. 1203

Ex. 1204

Ex. 1205

Ex. 1206

Ex. 1207

Ex. 1208

Ex. 1209

Ex. 1210

Ex. 1211

Ex. 1212

Ex. 1213

Ex. 1214

Ex. 1215

Ex. 1216

Ex. 1217

Ex. 1218

Ex. 1219

Ex. 1220

Ex. 1221

Ex. 1222

Ex. 1223

Ex. 1224

Ex. 1225

Ex. 1226

Ex. 1227

Ex. 1228

Ex. 1229

Ex. 1230

Ex. 1231

Ex. 1232

Ex. 1233

Ex. 1234

Ex. 1235

Ex. 1236

Ex. 1237

Ex. 1238

Ex. 1239

Ex. 1240

Ex. 1241

Ex. 1242

Ex. 1243

Ex. 1244

Ex. 1245

Ex. 1246

Ex. 1247

Ex. 1248

Ex. 1249

Ex. 1250

Ex. 1251

Ex. 1252

Ex. 1253

Ex. 1254

Ex. 1255

Ex. 1256

Ex. 1257

Ex. 1258

Ex. 1259

Ex. 1260

Ex. 1261

Ex. 1262

Ex. 1263

Ex. 1264

Ex. 1265

Ex. 1266

Ex. 1267

Ex. 1268

Ex. 1269

Ex. 1270

Ex. 1271

Ex. 1272

Ex. 1273

Ex. 1274

Ex. 1275

Ex. 1276

Ex. 1277

Ex. 1278

Ex. 1279

Ex. 1280

Ex. 1281

Ex. 1282

Ex. 1283

Ex. 1284

Ex. 1285

Ex. 1286

Ex. 1287

Ex. 1288

Ex. 1289

Ex. 1290

Ex. 1291

Ex. 1292

Ex. 1293

Ex. 1294

Ex. 1295

Ex. 1297

Ex. 1298

Ex. 1299

Ex. 1300

Ex. 1301

Ex. 1302

Ex. 1303

Ex. 1304

Ex. 1305

Ex. 1306

Ex. 1307

Ex. 1308

Ex. 1309

Ex. 1310

Ex. 1311

Ex. 1312

Ex. 1313

Ex. 1314

Ex. 1315

Ex. 1316

Ex. 1317

Ex. 1318

Ex. 1319

Ex. 1320

Ex. 1321

Ex. 1322

Ex. 1323

Ex. 1326

Ex. 1327

Ex. 1329

Ex. 1330

Ex. 1331

Ex. 1333

Ex. 1334

Ex. 1340

Ex. 1341

Ex. 1342

Ex. 1344

Ex. 1350

Ex. 1351

Ex. 1352

Ex. 1353

Ex. 1354

Ex. 1355

Ex. 1356

Ex. 1357

Ex. 1358

Ex. 1361

Ex. 1362

Ex. 1363

Ex. 1364

Ex. 1079 - Expert Declaration of Brian W. Anthony, Ph.D (SEALED)

Ex. 1079 - Declaration of Brian W. Anthony, Ph.D. (REDACTED)

Ex. 1080 - Declaration of Michael Davies (SEALED)

Ex. 1080 - Declaration of Michael Davies (REDACTED)

Petitioner's Reply in Support of Petition for Inter Parties Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,281,953 (SEALED)

Petitioner's Reply in Support of Petition for Inter Parties Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,281,953 (REDACTED)

Petitioner's Motion to Seal

Petitioner's Notice of Deposition

Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 2 and 3

Order: Granting Patent Owner's Motion for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order

Patent Owner's Motion to Seal

Patent Owner's Response (Sealed)

Patent Owner's Response (Redacted)

Ex. 2018 IPR2024-01078 - Expert Decl of Dr. Patrick Mercier ('953 Patent)

Ex. 2019 Declaration of Andrew T. Clarke with Appendices (953 Patent) (SEALED)

Ex. 2019 Declaration of Andrew T. Clarke with Appendices (953 Patent) (Redacted)

Ex. 2020 - 2025.02.25 Brian Anthony Depo Transcript Vol. 1

EX. 2021 - 2025.02.26 Brian Anthony Depo Transcript Vol. 2

Ex. 2022 - Deposition Transcript of Dr. Brian Anthony, Vol. 3, dated April 10, 2025

Ex. 2023 - Brian Anthony Depo Exhibit 4 - Wikipedia re PCB

Ex. 2024 - 2024.12.11 - 12.13 Inv. 337-TA-1398 Hearing Transcript Day 1 & 3 (SEALED)

Ex. 2024 - 2024.12.11 - 12.13 Inv. 337-TA-1398 Hearing Transcript Day 1 & 3 (REDACTED)

Ex. 2025 - U.S. Patent No. 5,964,701

Ex. 2026 - Coin Cell vs Button Cell vs Pouch Cell

Ex. 2027 - Ultrahuman Air Ring Teardown Images

Ex. 2028 - RingConn Smart Ring Teardown Images

Ex. 2029 - Oura Ring Gen. 3 Tear Down Images

Ex. 2030 - Oura Ring Gen. 4 Tear Down Images

Ex. 2031 - Go Inside Oura Ring Video Capture

Ex. 2032 - Oura Ring Instagram Page Site

Ex. 2033 - The Motiv Ring User's Manual

Ex. 2034 - Oura Gen1 Schematic (REDACTED)

Ex. 2034 - Oura Gen1 Schematic (SEALED)

Ex. 2035 - Samsung 2023 Business Report_Part1

Ex. 2035 - Samsung 2023 Business Report_Part2

Ex. 2036 - cnbc.com - Samsung Galaxy Ring Launch

Ex. 2037 - zdnet.com - samsung-unveils-galaxy-ring

Ex. 2038 - samsung.com - galaxy-ring-health

Ex. 2039 - samsung.com - galaxy-ring-buy

Ex. 2040 - ouraring.com - Oura Health Privacy Policy

Ex. 2042 - ouraring.com - Oura Terms of Use

Ex. 2043 - businesswire.com - Oura Health Launches Oura Ring Gen 3

Ex. 2044 - ouraring.com - About Us

Ex. 2045 - businesswire.com - Oura Helping Millions of People

Ex. 2046 - ouraring.com

Ex. 2047 - ouraring.com - blog - history-of-oura

Ex. 2048 - zdnet.com - Samsung Galazy Ring vs Oura Ring

Ex. 2049 - ouraring.com - Why Oura

Ex. 2050 - cnbc.com - Oura plans international expansion

Ex. 2051 - ouraring.com - Membership

Ex. 2052 - support.ouraring.com - Previous Oura Ring Generations

Ex. 2053 - support.ouraring.com - Software Updates for iOS

Ex. 2054 - support.ouraring.com - Software Updates for Android

Ex. 2055 - ouraring.com - Introducing the New Oura Ring Gen 3

Ex. 2056 - ouraring.com - product - rings - oura-gen 3-Heritage Silver

Ex. 2057 - ouraring.com - product - rings - oura-gen 3-Horizon Silver.

Ex. 2058 - tomsguide.com - fitness-trackers-oura-ring-4

Ex. 2059 - support.ouraring.com-Oura Ring 4

Ex. 2060 - wired.com - review-oura-ring-4

Ex. 2061 - ouraring.com - Product - Oura Ring 4 - Silver

Ex. 2062 - amazon.com - Oura Ring Gen 4 Silver

Ex. 2063 - Oura Units and membership detail (May 2024) (SEALED)

Ex. 2063 - Oura Units and membership detail (May 2024) (REDACTED)

Ex. 2064 - support.ouraring.com - How to Use the Oura App

Ex. 2065 - support.ouraring.com - Set Up the Oura App

Ex. 2066 - ouraring.com - What Makes the Oura Ring Different

Ex. 2067 - insider.fitt.co-Oura Launches Gen3 Ring, Monthly Subscription

Ex. 2068 - idc.com - IDC Forecasts Growth for Wearables

Ex. 2069 - fortunebusinssinsights.com - Smartwatch Market

Ex. 2070 - researchandmarket.coms - Fitness Tracker Market Size

Ex. 2071 - tomsguide.com - What is a smart ring and what can it do.

Ex. 2072 - samsung.com - Introducing Galaxy Ring

Ex. 2073 - verifiedmarketresearch.com - Smart Ring Market Size

Ex. 2074 - zdnet.com - The best smart rings of 2025

Ex. 2075 - blogs.idc.com - The Future of Smart Rings

Ex. 2076 - idc.com - Wearable Devices Market Insights

Ex. 2077 - cognitivemarketresearch.com - Smart Rings Market Report

Ex. 2078 - theverge.com - This might be the year of the smart ring

Ex. 2079 - globalnewswire.com - Smart Ring Market

Ex. 2080 - forbes.com - The Rise Of Wearable Smart Rings

Ex. 2081 - zdnet.com - About

Ex. 2082 - zdnet.com - Sorry, Oura and Samsung

Ex. 2083 - ccsinsight.com - About CCS Insight

Ex. 2084 - bloomberg.com - Oura Health is in Talks for Funding at $800M

Ex. 2085 - businesswire.com - On the Heels of 1 Million Rings Sold

Ex. 2086 - businesswire.com - Oura Secures $200 Million in Series D Funding

Ex. 2087 - businesswire.com - Oura Reaches Milestone of 600+ Partnerships

Ex. 2088 - investors.dexcom.com - Dexcom and Oura Announce Strategic Partnership

Ex. 2089 - athletechnews.com - Oura, Samsung and More

Ex. 2090 - athletechnews.com - About Us

Ex. 2091 - zdnet.com - We've Entered the Era of the Smart Ring

Ex. 2092 - seattletimes.com - Review - Oura’s Ring 4 leads the emerging

Ex. 2093 - Carlton and Perloff - Modern Industrial Organization_Part1

Ex. 2093 - Carlton and Perloff - Modern Industrial Organization_Part2

Ex. 2093 - Carlton and Perloff - Modern Industrial Organization_Part3

Ex. 2094 - forbes.com - Oura Ring CEO Talks Health

Ex. 2095 - news.samsung.com - Behind the Scenes of Galaxy Ring

Ex. 2096 - Gwin and Gwin (2003) Product Attributes Model

Ex. 2097 - Moorman and Rust (1999) Role of Marketing

Ex. 2098 - web.archive.org - ouraring.com - Product Rings 2024.07.10

Ex. 2099 - theverge.com - Oura Ring Generation 3 review

Ex. 2100 - menshealth.com - Oura Ring Gen3 Review

Ex. 2101 - ouraring.com - Product Rings

Ex. 2102 - tomsguide.com - Oura Ring 4 review.

Ex. 2103 - Samsung 2020 & 2021 Income Statement

Ex. 2104 - Samsung 2021 & 2022 Income Statement

Ex. 2105 - Samsung 2022 & 2023 Income Statement

Ex. 2106 - Samsung Q3 2024 Income Statement

Ex. 2107 - FY22 USD Consolidated Income Statement (SEALED)

Ex. 2107 - FY22 USD Consolidated Income Statement (REDACTED)

Ex. 2108 - FY23 USD Consolidated Income Statement (SEALED)

Ex. 2108 - FY23 USD Consolidated Income Statement (REDACTED)

Ex. 2109 - FY24 USD Consolidated Income Statement (SEALED)

Ex. 2109 - FY24 USD Consolidated Income Statement (REDACTED)

Ex. 2110 - Q1 FY25 USD Consolidated Income Statement (SEALED)

Ex. 2110 - Q1 FY25 USD Consolidated Income Statement (REDACTED)

Ex. 2111 - Rings sold all time - Cumulative (SEALED)

Ex. 2111 - Rings sold all time - Cumulative (REDACTED)

Ex. 2112 - Gross Booked Walk (SEALED)

Ex. 2112 - Gross Booked Walk (REDACTED)

Ex. 2113 - Ultrahuman Social Media Posts

Ex. 2114 - RingConn Images

Ex. 2115 - Pingu Another User-friendly Interface Device 2012

Ex. 2116 - Inv. No. 337-TA-1398 (ITC) [PUBLIC] ID on Violation and Recommended Determination on Remedy and Bond

Ex. 2117 - Webster Dictionary 2012

Ex. 2118- Technology in Oura Ring Gen3 - The Pulse Blog

Ex. 2119 - Discover Oura's health, fitness, and sleep rings _ Oura Gen. 4

Ex. 2120 - U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 20150277559

Ex. 2121 - How To Use Your Oura Charger

Panel Change Order

Motion for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order

Patent Owner Ouraring, Inc. Updated Power of Attorney

Patent Owner Ouraring, Inc. Updated Mandatory Notices Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.8

Joint Stipulation to Move Due Dates 1, 2 and 3 in Part

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Brian W. Anthony

Institution Decision: Grant

SCHEDULING ORDER

CORRECTED EX2014 - How are PCBs made? A Beginner's Guide to the PCB Manufacturing Process

Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response

The Best Smart Rings to Rule Them All

The Best Inventions of 2020

Why the Oura Ring Gen 3 was our wearable of the year

On the Heels of 1 Million Rings Sold, Oura Now Valued at 2.55 Billion

U.S. Patent App. Pub. No. 2012/0317024 (Rahman)

U.S. Patent App. Pub. No. 2013/0106603 (Weast)

U.S. Patent No. 10,768,666

Notice of Allowance re ‘178 Patent

Non Final Office Action re '666 Patent

Response to Non-Final Office Action re '666 Patent

Notice of Allowance re '666 Patent

U.S. Patent App. Pub. No. 2013/0106603 (Stergiou)

Active RFID vs Passive RFIS - What's the Difference?

EXPUNGED

Non Final Office Action re ‘859 Patent

U.S. Patent App. Pub. No. 2003/0142065 (Pahlavan)

U.S. Patent No. 8,554,297 (Moon)

Notice: Notice filing date accorded

Patent Owner Ouraring, Inc. Power of Attorney

Patent Owner Ouraring, Inc. Mandatory Notices

U.S. Patent No. 10,281,953 (“the ’953 Patent")

Declaration of Dr. Brian W. Anthony

Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Brian W. Anthony

Prosecution History of the ’953 Patent (Part 1 of 2)

Prosecution History of the ’953 Patent (Part 2 of 2)

U.S. Patent Publication No. 20120016245 to Niwa (“Niwa”)

U.S. Patent No. 8,954,135 to Yuen (“Yuen”)

U.S. Patent No. 10,303,867 to Schröder (“Schröder”)

Certified Translation of DE 102013012339.9 to Schröder

Original DE 102013012339.9 to Schröder

U.S. Patent Publication No. 20140244009 to Mestas (“Mestas”)

U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/768,279 to Mestas

U.S. Patent Publication No. 20120218184 to Wissmar (“Wissmar”)

U.S. Patent Publication No. 2010/0219989 to Asami (“Asami”)

U.S. Patent Publication No. 2011/0080339 to Sun (“Sun”)

U.S. Patent No. 9,218,058 to Bress (“Bress”)

U.S. Patent No. 8,031,172 to Kruse (“Kruse”)

Claim Mapping Table

Parallel Citations

Dynamic Drinkware-type analysis for Mestas

U.S. Patent No. 4,830,014 to Goodman (“Goodman”)

U.S. Patent No. 6,745,061 to Hicks (“Hicks”)

U.S. Patent No. 7,190,986 to Hannula (“Hannula”)

Reflectance Pulse Oximetry – Principles and Obstetric Application

U.S. Patent No. 6,608,562 to Kimura (“Kimura”)

Pulse Oximetry (“Tremper”)

A Wearable Reflectance Pulse Oximeter (“Mendelson 2006”)

Power-Efficient Design of Finger-Ring Sensors (“Rhee 2000 Part I”)

Power-Efficient Design of Finger-Ring Sensors (“Rhee 2000 Part II”)

Power-Efficient Design of Finger-Ring Sensors (“Rhee 2001”)

U.S. Patent No. 6,699,199 to Asada (“Asada ’199”)

Design and Analysis of Artifact-Resistive Finger Sensors (Rhee Thesis 2000)

Machining of Titanium Alloys (“Olofson”)

Mobile Monitoring with Wearable Biosensors (“Asada 2003”)

A Review on Wearable Photoplethysmography Sensors

U.S. Patent No. 7,468,036 to Rulkov et al. (“Rulkov”)

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2006/0211924 to Dalke et al. (“Dalke”)

Guidelines to Enhancing the Heart-Rate Monitoring Performance

U.S. Patent No. 4,880,304 to Jaeb et al. (“Jaeb”)

Optical Properties of Human Skin

Design of Pulse Oximeters

U.S. Patent Publication No. 20130211291 to Tran (“Tran”)

WO 2001/017421A1 to Lindberg (“Lindberg”)

WO 2011/132009 to Nyiradi (“Nyiradi”)

U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2014/0361945 to Misra et al. (“Misra”)

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2014/0361934 to Ely et al. (“Ely”)

European Patent No. 2281205 (Chen)

Episodic Sampling: Towards Energy-Efficient Patient Monitoring

Flexible PCB-MEMS Flow Sensor (“Petropoulos”)

Wireless Power Transfer for Medical Microsystems (“Sun-Wireless”)

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2014/0187160 to Prencipe (“Prencipe”)

Encapsulation Technologies for Electronic Applications (“Ardebili”)

Injection and Micro Injection of Polymeric Plastics Materials: A Review

LCP Injection Molded Packages—Keys to JEDEC 1 Performance

Encapsulation Process for Electronic Devices

Embedding of Electronics within Thermoplastic Polymers

U.S. Patent No. 6,201,698 to Hunter (“Hunter”)

U.S. Patent No. 4,012,629 to Simms (“Simms”)

Monitoring Human Movements at Home Using Wearable Wireless Sensors

Airwriting Recognition Using Wearable Motion Sensors (“Amma”)

Analysis and Selection of Features for Gesture Recognition (“Zhou”)

A Collaborative Architecture for Energy-efficient Gesture Recognition

GestureWrist and GesturePad: Unobtrusive Wearable Interaction Devices

Automatic Step Detection in the Accelerometer Signal

Wearable Sensor-Based Hand Gesture and Daily Activity Recognition

uWave: Accelerometer-based Personalized Gesture Recognition

Gesture Recognition With a Wii Controller (“Schlömer”)

Machine Learning: A Probabilistic Perspective (“Murphy”)

A Comparison of Machine Learning Algorithms (“Trigueiros”)

Petitioner Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.’s Power of Attorney

Petitioner Samsung Electronics America, Inc.’s Power of Attorney

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,281,953

Notice of Ranking