WIZ, Inc. vs Orca Security Ltd.

ORDER Granting Patent Owner’s Motions for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nicole Elena Bruner 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(c)

Notice of Deposition of Avi Shua

Notice of Deposition of Dr. David Kaeli

Panel Change Order

Patent Owner's Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Nicole Elena Bruner

Ex. 2170 809 Declaration of Nicole Bruner ISO PHV Motion (-01109)

Joint Stipulation to Extend Due Dates 2-3

Patent Owner's Response (Redacted)

Ex. 2073_REDACTED_Declaration of Dr. Kaeli (-01109)

Ex. 2074_REDACTED_Declaration of Avi Shua (-01109)

Order: Granting Motion to Seal

Petitioner's Third Objections to Evidence

Ex. 2003 Trend Micro Enterprise Security Virtual Datacenter White Paper

Ex. 2025 Red Hat OpenStack Platform 11-Instances Images (2.19.2018)

Ex. 2048 Wiz's Answering Claim Construction Brief (Excerpt)

Ex. 2075 Stavrou 2075

Ex. 2076 Stavrou 2076

Ex. 2077 Stavrou Angelos Deposition Tr.

Ex. 2078 Video of The CISO Startup Connection Powered by YL Ventures (VIDEO)

Ex. 2079 Transcript - The CISO - Startup Connection Powered by YL Ventures - ORCA Security

Ex. 2080 Video of Full Stack Visibility In Minutes (VIDEO)

Ex. 2081 Transcript - Full Stack Visibility In Minutes

Ex. 2082 Orca, Video of SideScanning vs Traditional Security Assessment Methods(VIDEO)

Ex. 2083 Transcript - Orca Security - SideScanning vs traditional security assessment methods

Ex. 2084 Orca, Australian Business Interview with Avi Shua

Ex. 2085 Orca, CNBC Interview with Avi Shua

Ex. 2086 Orca, The CUBE Interview

Ex. 2087 Matias Experiment, Ep398 Avi Shua

Ex. 2088 Orca, CNBC Prime Time Interview

Ex. 2090 Orca, June 2019 Ultimate Guide to Gaining Full Stack Visibility into Your Cloud Assets

Ex. 2092 2021 SideScanning Technical Brief

Ex. 2093 2022 SideScanning Technical Brief

Ex. 2094 Video of Orca-Pod-(In-Account) Onboarding(VIDEO)

Ex. 2095 Video of AWS Onboarding With Orca Security(VIDEO)

Ex. 2096 Orca, Create AWS Policy

Ex. 2097 Orca, Define AWS Role

Ex. 2098 Orca, GCP Onboarding Video Walkthrough

Ex. 2099 Orca, Deep Cloud Inspection YouTube

Ex. 2100 Orca, MRI for Your Cloud Environment

Ex. 2102 BankInfoSecurity, Qualys Unveils Cloud Agent Platform

Ex. 2103 CSA, Security Agents Dont Belong In Your Cloud

Ex. 2104 Fortra, Agent-Based or Agentless

Ex. 2106 PAN, How Agentless Approaches Sideline Cloud Workload Protection Strategies

Ex. 2107 Orca, Orca Security Lands $6.5M Seed Round

Ex. 2108 Orca, Orca Security Lands $20M for Multi-Cloud Visibility

Ex. 2109 TechCrunch, Orca Security raises $20M Series A for its multi-cloud security platform

Ex. 2110 Orca, ICONIQ Growth Funding

Ex. 2111 TechCrunch, Orca Security Raises $55M for its Cloud-Native Security Platform

Ex. 2112 CRN, Upstart Orca Security Raises $210M In Google-Backed Funding

Ex. 2113 Orca, Orca Security Extends Series C Round with $550M Funding

Ex. 2115 Wiz, Securing Clouds

Ex. 2116 Wiz, 100M ARR in 18 months

Ex. 2117 Panorama IT, Unprecedented Holistic View

Ex. 2118 ORCA_0261399 TAG Cyber Report

Ex. 2119 CRN, 20 Coolest Tech Startups Of 2020

Ex. 2120 Forbes, Top 20 Cybersecurity Startups To Watch In 2021 Based On Crunchbase

Ex. 2121 Orca, Orca Security Named A 2021 Gartner Cool Vendor in CSPM

Ex. 2122 Orca, Orca Security Awarded 2022 Regional and Global AWS Partner Award

Ex. 2123 SC Media, SC Award Winners 2023 Orca Security

Ex. 2124 Orca, Orca Security Wins 2022 SC Award for CSPM

Ex. 2125 Orca, Orca Security Wins Best CWPP at the 2023 SC Media Awards

Ex. 2127 Forbes, Orca Company Overview

Ex. 2128 Orca, Orca Security Named to 2023 Forbes Cloud 100

Ex. 2129 Orca, Orca Security Named to Inaugural Redpoint InfraRed 100 List

Ex. 2130 Orca, Orca Security Named to Redpoint 2024 InfraRed 100 for Second Consecutive Year

Ex. 2131 Rising in Cyber

Ex. 2132 Orca, Orca Security Named to Notable Capitals Rising in Cyber 2024

Ex. 2133 Orca, Deep Cloud Inspection

Ex. 2134 Cyber Magazine, History of Cloud Computing

Ex. 2135 PAN, Palo Alto Networks Shifts Left with Prisma Cloud 3.0

Ex. 2136 PAN, 2018 Cloud Security Report

Ex. 2137 ISSA Journal, The Quest for Visibility and Control in the Cloud

Ex. 2138 Wiz, Agents Are Not Enough

Ex. 2139 CRN, Orca Security Raises $340M To Scale Platform R&D

Ex. 2140 Orca, 2020 Recap

Ex. 2141 TechCrunch, Cloud security startup Wiz, now valued at $10B, raises $300M

Ex. 2142 CNBC, Google-Wiz deal fizzles out

Ex. 2143 SINET, 16 Past Award Winners

Ex. 2144 SINET, 16 Innovator Award

Ex. 2145 Security Current CISO Choice Award Winners 2020

Ex. 2147 Wiz, Detect and Prioritize CISA Known

Ex. 2148 GigaOM Radar for Cloud Workload Security

Ex. 2149 62797718

Ex. 2150 page capture of Azure Onboarding Orca Security

Ex. 2158 AWS CloudTrail

Ex. 2159 AWS Identity and Access Management

Ex. 2160 Wiz Uncover What Is Really Deployed In Your Environment With The Enhanced Wiz Inventory

Ex. 2161 809 Proposed Protective Order (-01109)

Ex. 2162 809 Redline Comparison to Default PO (-01109)

Ex. 2165 Vulnerability Scanning_ How It Works, Why It Matters, What It Finds

Ex. 2172 Stavrou Angelos 040225 Full Size

Ex. 2173 Qualys, Vulnerability Management

Ex. 2174 Man, Live Monitoring with Endpoint Agents

Ex. 2175 Virus, NIST Glossary

Ex. 2176 Vulnerability, NIST Glossary

Ex. 2177 Wiz What Is Lateral Movement

Ex. 2178 Wiz Attack Path Analysis

Ex. 2189 US20200244678A1

Ex. 2190 Automating Cloud Security Governance

Ex. 2191 Evaluation of Security Information

Ex. 2074_PO MATERIAL_Declaration of Avi Shua (-01109

Ex. 2300_PO MATERIAL_Excerpted 2024 Orca Product Documentation SEALED

Ex. 2301_PO MATERIAL_CONFL-00004680 [SEALED]

Ex. 2302_PO MATERIAL_ORCAW_CP010_000899941 [SEALED]

Ex. 2303_PO MATERIAL_ORCAW_CP010_000899997 [SEALED]

Ex. 2304_PO MATERIAL_ORCA_0022161 [SEALED]

Ex. 2306_PO MATERIAL_ORCA_1116082 Email Chain [SEALED]

Ex. 2307_PO MATERIAL_ORCA_1106453 Email Chain [SEALED]

Ex. 2308_PO MATERIAL_ORCA_0155736 SideScanning Email [SEALED]

Ex. 2309_PO MATERIAL_ORCA_0155739 [SEALED]

Ex. 2311_PO MATERIAL_Excerpted 2024 Orca Product Documentation Part 2 SEALED

Ex. 2312_PO MATERIAL_Orca Revenues 2019-2024

Ex. 2313_PO MATERIAL_Excerpted 2024 Orca Product Documentation Pt.2 [SEALED]

Ex. 2400_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0004049 [SEALED]

Ex. 2401_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0004274 [SEALED]

Ex. 2402_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0016844 [SEALED]

Ex. 2403_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0018678 [SEALED]

Ex. 2404_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0052128 [SEALED]

Ex. 2405_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0052141 [SEALED]

Ex. 2406_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0099921 [SEALED]

Ex. 2407_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0136800 [SEALED]

Ex. 2408_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0149031 [SEALED]

Ex. 2409_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0149037 [SEALED]

Ex. 2410_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0149754 [SEALED](AUDIO)

Ex. 2411_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0149754 Transcript [SEALED]

Ex. 2412_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0256317 [SEALED]

Ex. 2413_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0256826 [SEALED]

Ex. 2414_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0257342 [SEALED]

Ex. 2415_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0283267 [SEALED]

Ex. 2416_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0311825 [SEALED]

Ex. 2417_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0481418 [SEALED]

Ex. 2418_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0481419 [SEALED]

Ex. 2419_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0481435 [SEALED]

Ex. 2420_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0640750 [SEALED]

Ex. 2421_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0522675 [SEALED]

Ex. 2422_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0522675_English [SEALED]

Ex. 2425_PO MATERIAL_ WIZ_0611978 SEALED

Ex. 2426_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0611978_English SEALED

Ex. 2427_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0283270

Ex. 2428_PO MATERIAL_WIZ_0283271

Ex. 2073_ PO MATERIAL_809 Declaration of Dr. Kaeli (-01109)

Patent Owner's Response

Patent Owner's Motion to File Documents Under Seal and for a Protective Order

Joint Stipulation to Extend Due Dates 1-3

Order: Granting Motion for Additional Discovery

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Joint Stipulation to Extend Due Dates 1 - 3

Petitioner's Opposition to Motion for Additional Discovery

Delaware Litigation Stay Order

Mr. Argenti's Feb 24-25 Emails

Petitioner's Second Objections to Evidence

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Angelos Stavrou

Patent Owner's Notice of Intent

Ex. 2072 809 Declaration of B. Davis re PHV

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Patent Owner's Authorized Motion for Additional Discovery

Ex. 2053 Listing of Requested Documents

Ex. 2056 Orca's Eleventh Supp. Responses to Wiz's First Set of Rogs_Excerpted and Redacted_Redacted

Ex. 2057 Stipulated Protective Order

Ex. 2058 Email exchange between counsel (Dec. 17-26, 2024)

Ex. 2059 Email exchange between counsel (Dec. 23, 2024 – Feb. 25, 2025)

Ex. 2065 Orca Security Lands $6.5M Seed Round

Ex. 2066 Orca Security, The Ultimate Guidebook to Gaining Full Stack Visibility Into Your Cloud Assets

Ex. 2067 Orca Security Technical Brief

Ex. 2068 Letter from counsel for Orca Security Ltd. to counsel for Wiz, Inc. (May 20, 2024)

Ex. 2069 Letter to the Honorable Sherry R. Fallon from Rodger D. Smith

Ex. 2070 Francis & James Berthoty, Redefining CNAPP

Ex. 2071 Memorandum Order

Conduct of the Proceeding Authorizing Patent Owner’s Motion for Additional Discovery 37 C.F.R. § 42.5(a)

E-mail requesting authorization to file a motion for additional discovery

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner's Notice of Intent

Ex. 2046 Declaration of D. Lumish re PHV

Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List

Patent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices

Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence

Petitioner's First Objections to Evidence

DECISION Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314

SCHEDULING ORDER

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List

194 Stipulation Concerning Invalidity Grounds by Wiz Inc.

Ex. 2002- Kaeli CV

Ex. 2004- Red Hat Virtualization 4.0, Technical Reference (3.29.2018)

Ex. 2006- Red Hat Virtualization 4.3 - Technical_Reference 8.1 (excerpt)

Ex. 2007- Birk, Technical Challenges of Forensic Investigations (1.12.2011)

Ex. 2010- USP 9467465 (Hibbert)

Ex. 2011- USP 10298599 (Zhang)

Ex. 2012- USP 9594912 (Thioux)

Ex. 2014- Complaint, Orca v. Wiz (7.12.2023) (ECF 1)

Ex. 2015- Oral Order (Joint Motion for Discovery Dispute), Orca v. Wiz (5.17.2024 (ECF 62)

Ex. 2016- Wiz's Initial Invalidity Contentions, Orca v. Wiz (6.7.2024) (excerpt)

Ex. 2018- Silberschatz et al., Operating System Concepts (9th ed) (excerpt)

Ex. 2019- Uluski, Real Time Anti-Virus for Virtualized Env't (Thesis) (May 2008) (excerpt)

Ex. 2021- AWS, What is a Hypervisor

Ex. 2022- Perez-Botero et al., Characterizing Hypervisor Vulnerabilities (2013)

Ex. 2026- Wiz, Agentless vs. Agent-Based Security (11.26.2023)

Ex. 2040- Amended Scheduling Order.

Ex. 2041- Ex. D Initial Invalidity Chart (809 Patent)

Ex. 2042- Ex. D-1 Veselov Initial Invalidity Chart (809 Patent)

Ex. 2043- Vishwakarma, Agent-Based Vs Network Based Internal Vulnerability

Ex. 2044- Runecast, Agentless vs. Agent-based Scanning_A Comparative Analysis

Ex. 2045- Claim Construction Chart

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Ex. 2001- Kaeli Declaration (-01109)

Notice : Mandatory Notice

Notice : Power of Attorney

EXPUNGED

Notice: Notice filing date accorded

U.S. Patent No. 11,726,809 to Shua

Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Angelos Stavrou

File History of U.S. Patent Application No. 18/055,201 (’809 Pat.)

Scheduling Order (Dkt. No. 33), Orca security ltd. v. Wiz, Inc., No. 1:23cv

Second Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement (Dkt. No. 15), Orca securi

U.S. Patent No. 11,216,563 B1 to Veselov

U.S. Publication No. 2013/0191919 A1, published July 25, 2013, to Basavapat

Wolf, “Virtualization: From the Desktop to the Enterprise” APRESS (2005)

Waldspurger, “Memory Resource Management in VMware ESX Server,” USENIX, Pro

Goldberg, “Survey of Virtual Machine Research,” COMPUTER, Vol. 7, No. 6 (Ju

U.S. Patent No. 10,944,811 B2 to Doctor

Wood, “Black-box and Gray-box Strategies for Virtual Machine Migration” NSD

Klemperer, “Efficient Hypervisor Based Malware Detection,” Carnegie Mellon

vSphere Web Services SDK Programming Guide, VMWare, Inc. (April 17, 2018)

Souppaya, “Application Container Security Guide,” NIST Special Publication

U.S. Patent No. 11,106,784 B2 to Rosendahl

Scarfone, “Guide to Security for Full Virtualization Technologies: Recommen

U.S. Patent No. 9,881,040 B2 to Rawat

U.S. Patent No. 9,116,633 B2 to Sancheti

“NIST Cloud Computing Standards Roadmap,” NIST Special Publication 500-291,

Roberts, “Public Cloud Service Definition,” VMware vCloud® Architecture Too

ITL Bulletin, “Security Patches and the CVE Vulnerability Naming Scheme: To

ITL Bulletin, “Preventing and Handling Malware Incidents: How to Protect In

Cichonski, “Computer Security Incident Handling Guide: Recommendations of t

ENISA Threat Landscape Report 2018, “15 top Cyberthreats and Trends” V1.0 (

Verizon, “2019 Data Breach Investigations Report” (May 2019)

Di Pietro, “Virtualization Technologies and Cloud Security: Advantages, Iss

Singh, “Overview of Attacks on Cloud Computing, Int’l. J. of Eng. And Innov

Bairwa, “Vulnerability Scanners: A Proactive Approach to Assess Web Applica

Stone, “IT Asset Management,” NIST Special Publication 1800-5 (Sept. 2018)

EP Patent No. 3,360,071 B1 to Li

Garfinkel, “A Virtual Machine Introspection Based Architecture for Intrusio

Tang, “VirtAV: An Agentless Runtime Antivirus System for Virtual Machines,”

Lengyel, “Scalability, Fidelity and Stealth in the DRAKVUF Dynamic Malware

U.S. Patent No. 8,613,080 B2 to Wysopal

Bauman, “A Survey on Hypervisor-Based Monitoring: Approaches, Applications,

Suneja, “Exploring VM Introspection: Techniques and Trade-offs,” ACM, VEE’1

Payne, “Simplifying Virtual Machine Introspection Using LibVMI,” SANDIA Rep

U.S. Publication No. 2013/0111018 A1 to Ammons

U.S. Patent No. 5,893,131 to Kornfeld

U.S. Patent No. 7,975,305 B2 to Rubin

Jiang, “Stealthy Malware Detection and Monitoring Through VMM-Based “Out-of

U.S. Patent No. 9,141,805 B2 to Giakouminakis

U.S. Publication No. 2019/0379700 A1 to Canzanese Jr.

1046 U.S. Patent No. 10,783,241 B2 to Crabtree

Bourquin, “Binslayer: Accurate Comparison of Binary Executables,” 2nd ACM S

U.S. Publication No. 2013/0247133 A1 to Price

Huseinovic – VM Memory Forensics.

Using VMware Workstation Pro: VMware Workstation Pro 14.0, VMware, Inc. (De

VMware VirtualCenter User’s Manual version 1.4, VMware, Inc. (July 7, 2006)

U.S. Publication No.2010/0070725 A1 to Prahlad

U.S. Patent No. 9,830,182 B2 to Ackley

Virtual Disk Programming Guide: vSphere Storage APIs for Data Protection (V

U.S. Publication No. 2015/0033221 A1 to Chari

Archived copy of “CWE-200: Information Exposure,” published by MITRE and ar

Archived copy of “CWE-311: Missing Encryption of Sensitive Data,” published

Archived copy of “CWE-359: Exposure of Private Information (‘Privacy Violat

U.S. Publication No. 2014/0245376 A1 to Hibbert

U.S. Publication No. 2017/0180318 A1 to Lutas

U.S. Patent No. 9,900,333 B2 to Thakar

Zhou, “Always Up-to-date—Scalable Offline Patching of VM Images in a Comput

Jeswani, “ImageElves: Rapid and Reliable System Updates in the Cloud,” 2013

U.S. Patent No. 8,984.478 B2 to Epstein

U.S. Patent No. 11,061,682 B2 to Vorbach

U.S. Publication No. 2013/0024940 A1 to Hutchins

U.S. Patent No. 9,875,160 B2 to Bezbaruah

U.S. Patent No. 10,536,471 B1 to Derbeko

Ammons, “Virtual machine images as structured data: the Mirage image librar

VMware Infrastructure Architecture Overview White Paper, VMWare, Inc. (2006

U.S. Patent No. 9,692,778 B1 to Mohanty

U.S. Patent No. 10,055,576 B2 to Milner

U.S. Patent No. 9,824,216 B1 to Khalid

U.S. Publication No. 2020/0097662 A1 to Hufsmith

Carroll, “Challenges in Modern Digital Investigative Analysis,” published i

U.S. Patent No. 7,831,739 B2 to Lambeth

U.S. Publication No. 2010/0169948 A1 to Budko

United States District Courts—National Judicial Caseload Profile (December

Amended Scheduling Order (Dkt. No. 90), Orca security ltd. v. Wiz, Inc., No

Petitioner WIZ, Inc.'s Power of Attorney

U.S. Publication No. 2017/004826 A1 to Hovor

Guide to Effective Remediation of Network Vulnerabilities, Qualys, Inc. (20

Archived copy of “Vulnerability Management and Scanning: Monitor networks t

Archived copy of “Vulnerability Details : CVE-2004-1137,” published by CVE

Archived copy of “Vulnerability Details : CVE-2004-1145,” published by CVE

Archived copy of “Vulnerability Details : CVE-2006-2923,” published by CVE

Archived copy of “Vulnerability Details : CVE-2007-0018,” published by CVE

Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: Secure Hash Standard

U.S. Patent No. 9,749,349 B2 to Czarny

Declaration of Dr. Angelos Stavrou ('809 Pat)

Petition : as filed