Microsoft Corporation vs Edge Networking Systems, LLC

Director Discretionary Decision: Refer

Patent Owner's Reply In Support Of Motion for Discretionary Denial

Email Correspondence

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

IPR2025-00619 Petitioner’s Opposition to Patent Owner’s Request for Discretionary Denial of Institution

EX1073 U.S. Patent Publication No. 20130223442 to Narayanan (Narayanan)

EX1074 Excerpt from Zenious et al., BIODESIGN; THE PROCESS OF INNOVATING MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES (EX2010 in iRhythm Technologies Inc. v. Welch Allyn Inc., IPR2025-00363)

EX1075 March 2025 Email with Sotera Stipulation (ENS v MSFT)

EX1076 April 2025 Emails with Board re filing Sotera stip for MSFT v ENS IPRs

EX1077 Dkt 41 - ENS v Microsoft - Order setting Markman Hearing for 10-7-2025 (6-11-2025)

EX1078 Dkt 43 - ENS v Microsoft - Amended Scheduling Order (6-27-2025)

EX1079 Edge Networking Sys Certificate of Formation(19460076.1)

EX1080 assignment-pat-63454-352 - Taaghol to Edge Networking(4-20-2023)

EX1081 assignment- 624 Patent Taaghol to BDF (11-7-2019)

EX1082 assignment- BDF to Taaghol (3-16-2023)

EX1083 USP 9843624 (Taaghol)(19460036.1)

Brief In Support Of Motion for Discretionary Denial

Ex. 2001 - Shatzkamer

Ex. 2002 - McKeown et al - Openflow Paper

Ex. 2003 - Draluk - US20130160147

Ex. 2004 - Homiller - US20040237081

Ex. 2005 - Petition In IPR2018-01739

Ex. 2006 - USP 10496387

Ex. 2007 - Excerpts of File History of USP 10496387

Notice: Power of Attorney

Notice: Mandatory Notice

Notice: NOTICE OF FILING DATE ACCORDED TO PETITION AND TIME FOR FILING PATENT OWNER PRELIMINARY RESPONSE

Notice: Mandatory Notice

Notice: Power of Attorney

1001 U.S. Patent No. 10,686,871 (the “’871 Patent”)

1002 Prosecution history of the ’871 Patent (“’871 File History”)

1004 U.S. Patent No. 6,496,575 to Vasell, et al.

1005 File history of related U.S. Patent No. 9,483,624 (the “’624 Patent”)

1006 File history of related U.S. Patent No. 10,893,095 (the “’095 Patent”)

1007 File history of related U.S. Patent No. 11,695,823 (the “’823 Patent”)

1008 Excerpts from A. de Castro Alves, “OSGi in Depth”, Manning Publication

1009 Excerpts from R. Hall, et al., “OSGi in Action - Creating Modular

1010 J. E. Kim, et al., “Seamless Integration of Heterogeneous Devices

1011 J. S. Rellermeyer and S. Bagchi, “Dependability as a cloud service

1012 S. Kächele, et al., “Component-based scalability for cloud application

1013 OSGi Alliance, “About the OSGi Service Platform”, Technical Whitepaper

1014 Declaration of June A. Munford

1015 U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/088,437

1016 U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/123,971

1017 “About Gatespace”, Gatespace AB website, archived on January 6, 2000

1018 “Carlstedt Research & Technology Forms New Company for Developing Soft

1019 “Ericsson e-services is a part of the Open Services Gateway Initiative

1020 “Fifteen industry leaders to create standard for bringing Internet

1021 “People”, Carlstedt Research & Technology AB website

1022 “Open Services Gateway Initiative: Charter”, OSGi website

1023 “Open Services Gateway Initiative: Officers”, OSGi website

1024 “Open Services Gateway Initiative Elects New Leadership”, Home Toys In

1025 “Management Team”, Gatespace AB website, archived on February 8, 2002

1026 “About Us: Background”, Gatespace AB website

1027 “About Makewave: History in Making”, Makewave AB website

1028 The OSGi Alliance, “OSGi Service Platform Enterprise Specification”

1029 T. Forst, “Cisco Application eXtension Platform – OSGi Add-on

1030 U.S. Patent Publication No. 2013/0086147 to Kashyap

1031 Excerpts from A.S. Tanenbaum, “Modern Operating Systems”

1032 Excerpts from A.S. Tannenbaum, “Computer Networks”

1033 Excerpts from D. Downing, et al., “Dictionary of Computer and Internet

1034 Excerpts from E. Cole, et al., “Network Security Bible”, Wiley Publish

1035 Curriculum Vitae (CV) of Petitioner’s Expert Dr. Erez Zadok.

1036 S. Soltesz, et al., “Container-based Operating System Virtualization:

1039 Li, et al., “ExpoNet: A Flexible Platform for Concurrent Experiments

1041 P. Kriens, “The Bundle Repository”, OSGi Alliance Blog, April 7, 2006

1042 “Knoplerfish Pro Premium” and “Knoplerfish Pro Enterprise” Data Sheets

1043 R. Kawashima, “vNFC: A Virtual Networking Function Container for SDN-e

1044 Excerpts from A.S. Tanenbaum, “Modern Operating Systems”

1045 Excerpts from S. Garfinkel, et al., “Web Security & Commerce”

1046 Oasis Standard Specification, “Web Services Security: SOAP Message

1047 “Web Service Security Cheat Sheet”, The Open Web Application Security

1048 “REST Security Cheat Sheet”, The Open Web Application Security Project

1050 The Open Services Gateway Initiative, “Specification Overview”

1051 R. Hall, “Oscar Bundle Repository”, archived on June 30, 2004

1052 Excerpts from B. Sosinsky, “Cloud Computing Bible”, Wiley Publishing

1053 “Java Secure Socket Extension (JSSE) Reference Guide for Java Platform

1054 “Java™ Remote Method Invocation API (Java RMI)”, Oracle Java SE

1055 “Using Custom Socket Factories with Java RMI”, Oracle Java SE Document

1056 “Using Java™ RMI with SSL”, Oracle Java SE Documentation

1057 Microsoft Computer Dictionary, 3rd ed., 1997, excerpts

1058 Usenix Jails in FreeBSD for Fun and Profit, Paco Hope, USENIX ;login

1059 Excerpts from Silberschatz et al., Operating System Concepts

1060 Excerpts from Silberschatz et al., Operating System Concepts

1061 Excerpts from McKusick and Neville-Neil, The Design and Implementation

1062 Excerpts from Benevenuti, Understanding Linux Network Internals (2006)

1063 Excerpts from Stallings, Operating Systems Internals and Design

1064 “apache_1.3.19.tar.gz.md5” Hash File, Apache Software Foundation

1065 “apache_1.3.19.tar.gz.asc” Signature File, Apache Software Foundation

1066 “Apache Archive Distribution Directory”, Apache Software Foundation

1067 U.S. Department of Commerce, FIPS PUB 186-2, Digital Signature

1068 J. Preshing, “Hash Collision Probabilities”, Preshing on Programming

1069 “Avalanche Effect”, Wikipedia, archived on April 30, 2010 at Internet

1070 Plaintiff Edge Networking Systems, LLC’s Opening Claim Construction

1071 Defendant Microsoft Corporation’s Responsive Claim Construction Brief

1072 Scheduling Order, filed as Document No. 27, on September 4, 2024

Notice: Power of Attorney

1003 Declaration of Petitioner’s Expert, Dr. Erez Zadok, (Zadok)

Petition: as filed