Intel Corporation et al. vs Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. - IPR2025-00913

Petitioners' Response to Patent Owner's Reply in Support of Discretionary Denial

PATENT OWNER’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST FOR DISCRETIONARY DENIAL

Ex. 2024 Exhibit A-18 - MultiMatlab References, U.S. Patent No. 10,333,768, as listed in Defendant NVIDIA Corporation's Supplemental Invalidity Contentions in Case No. 1 :19-cv-2032-CFC, Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc., v. NVIDIA Corporation as dated August 17, 2021 in 254 pages (submitted with IDS in U.S. Patent Appln. No. 17/374,789) (ACS_0065212-0065465)

Ex. 2025 Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Intel Corporation, Case No. 7:24-cv-00245-ADA (D.I. 79), Minute Entry Markman Hearing Proceedings Held 08/18/2025

Ex. 2026 VirtaMove, Corp. v. Microsoft Corp., Case No. 1:25-cv-00794-ADA (D.I. 33), Order Granting Motion to Dismiss

Ex. 2027 Yeti Coolers, LLC v. Waterbear Global, LLC, Case No. 1:24-cv-1251-ADA (D.I. 35, 35-1), Unopposed Motion to Extend Scheduling Order Deadlines and Proposed Order

Ex. 2028 Intel Corporation’s Third Amended Preliminary Invalidity And Subject-Matter Eligibility Contentions (Aug. 28, 2025)

Email Correspondence

Petitioners' Opposition to Patent Owner's Request for Discretionary Denial

Ex. 1051 - Microsoft offers AMD alternative

Ex. 1052 - GAMECHANGER_Computing_Intel_Breaking_Defense

Ex. 1053 - El Capitan

Ex. 1054 - PWC data center report

Ex. 1050 - WSJ article on AI Action Plan

Ex. 1056-DoD Extends Contract for ORAN-based Private 5G Networks through2025

Ex. 1057 - Air Force Research Laboratory

Ex. 1058 - ZMicro to Provide Rugged Computers for US Sky Warden Aircraft

Ex. 1059 - argonne-aurora-case-study

Ex. 1060 - Data center market share

Ex. 1055 - Winning the AI Race

Ex. 1061 - X86 vs ARM

Ex. 1062 - US8601101

Ex. 1063 - Judge Moses Order 1.31.24

Ex. 1064 - 409 Transfers to Albright (LexMachina)

Ex. 1066 - 1,700 Federal District Court Cases for Alan D Albright

Ex. 1067 - 10 Docket Entries for Alan D Albright

Ex. 1068 - Tom's Hardware on TensorWave

Ex. 1069 - 2025-08-22_Intel_and_Trump_Administration_Reach_Historic_1748

Ex. 1065 - 80 Patent Transfers to Albright (LexMachina)

Ex. 1071-guidance_memo_on_interim_procedure_recission_20250324(Boalick Memo)

Ex. 1072 - FAQs for Interim Processes (captured 5.13.25)

Ex. 1073 - InterimProcesses-PTABWorkloadMgmt-20250326 (Director Memo)

Ex. 1074 - Interim Director Discretionary Process _ (captured 8.19.2025)

Ex. 1075 - Oracle-AMD collaboration

Ex. 1076 - AMD AI chip focus

Ex. 1077 - Zacks AMD AI Chips Ground

Ex. 1078 - Senate hearing transcript

Ex. 1079 - Meta's obsession with AI

Ex. 1070 - 7 Docket Entries for Alan D Albright _ Lex Machina - trial 20261109

Ex. 1080 - US20050021751A1

Ex. 1081 - US6074427

Ex.1082 - USPTO rescinds memorandum addressing discretionary denial procedures

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response

Brief in Support of Patent Owner's Request for Discretionary Denial

Ex. 2001 DocketNavigator Statistics for Motion Success for Stay Pending IPR (Post-Institution) for Judge Albright

Ex. 2002 J. Albright Standing Order Governing Proceedings (OGP) 4.4 – Patent Cases (Jan 23, 2024)

Ex. 2003 DocketNavigator Statistics for Time-to-Milestones for Judge Albright

Ex. 2004 Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Intel Corporation, Amended Scheduling Order (D.I. 54)

Ex. 2005 Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., Scheduling Order (D.I. 36)

Ex. 2006 Judge Albright Clerk emails

Ex. 2007 Allani v. Apple Inc., No. 6:24-cv-304-ADA (W.D. Tex. May 6, 2025) (D.I. 30)

Ex. 2008 Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. TCL Elects. Holdings Ltd., No. 6:23-cv-309-ADA (W.D. Tex. Sept. 10, 2024) (D.I. 44)

Ex. 2009 Acquis, LLC v. Hon Hai Precision Indus Co. Ltd., No. 6:23-cv-264-ADA (W.D. Tex. May 31, 2024) (D.I. 46)

Ex. 2010 ParkerVision, Inc. v. MediaTek Inc. et al., No. 6:22-cv-01163-ADA (W.D. Tex. April 29, 2024)

Ex. 2011 TOT Power Control, S.L. v. AT&T, Inc. et al., No. 6:21-cv-00107-ADA (W.D. Tex. June 6, 2025)

Ex. 2012 AlmondNet, Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., et al., No. 6:21-cv-00898-ADA (W.D. Tex. June 19, 2025)

Ex. 2013 Intel Corporation’s Amended Invalidity Contention Cover Pleading (Apr. 25, 2025)

Ex. 2015 AMD’s Preliminary Invalidity and Subject-Matter Eligibility Contentions Cover Pleading (Corrected Apr. 23, 2025)

Ex. 2016 AMD’s Preliminary Invalidity Contention – Chart C-8

Ex. 2017 Declaration of Dr. Melissa C. Smith Under 37 C.F.R. § 1.68

Ex. 2018 Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Melissa C. Smith

Ex. 2019 Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Intel Corporation, Order Appointing Technical Advisor (D.I. 71)

Ex. 2020 Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., Order Appointing Technical Advisor (D.I. 53)

Ex. 2021 FAQ: The Sustainable Data Center – More Energy Efficient AI (available at https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/content-details/791405/faq-the-sustainable-data-center-ai-use-case.html?wapkw=sustainability&DocID=791405)

Ex. 2022 NVIDIA Company Overview (May 2025) (available at https://investor.nvidia.com/events-and-presentations/presentations/presentation-details/2025/Company-Overview-5-25/default.aspx)

Ex. 2023 Intel Corporation’s Answer and Counterclaims to First Amended Complaint, Advanced Cluster Systems, Inc. v. Intel Corporation, 7:24-cv-00245-ADA (W.D. Tex. Feb. 5, 2025) (D.I. 41)

EXPUNGED

Notice: Other

Notice: Power of Attorney

Notice: Mandatory Notice

Ex 1001 - US11570034

Ex 1002 - PATENT 11570034 - FILE HISTORY - Part 1 of 2

Ex 1002 - PATENT 11570034 - FILE HISTORY - Part 2 of 2

Ex 1004 - CV - Chandrajit Bajaj

Ex 1005 - MultiMATLAB Integrating MATLAB with High Perf. Parallel Computing

Ex 1006 - MultiMATLAB MATLAB on Multiple Processors - Trefethen

Ex 1007 - RS6000

Ex 1008 - Parallel Operating Environment

Ex 1009 - SPMD

Ex 1010 - SG24-5374-00.SP.InsideOut

Ex 1011 - High Performance Cluster Computing vol 2 excerpts

Ex 1012 - Whitney paper (October 97 - color) nas-97-025

Ex 1013 - Parallel Linear Algebra Server for MATLAB

Ex 1014 - Parallel Matlab - Doing It Right

Ex 1015 - ParallelComputingToolkitDocumentation

Ex 1016 - Mastering Matlab

Ex 1017 - MPI

Ex 1018 - Tanenbaum - Modern Operating Systems

Ex 1019 - Complaint

Ex 1020 - Amended Scheduling Order

Ex 1021 - Time to Trial Statistics

Ex 1023 - Cornell Websites

Ex 1024 - pyMPI

Ex 1025 - Claim Construction for ACS v. NVIDIA

Ex 1026 - SC97 Conference

Ex 1027 - IEEE Declaration

Ex 1028 - Menon ACM Cited by

Ex 1029 - Archive.org Affidavit

Ex 1030 - SC'97 HPC wire article

Ex 1031 - SC1997 Flyer

Ex 1032 - About IEEE Xplore

Ex 1033 - Cornell CTC pioneer

Ex 1034 - ACM Digital Library

Ex 1035 - Trefethen ACM Cited by

Ex 1036 - JICS

Ex 1037 - MPI ACM Cited by

Ex 1038 - RS6000 Link Chain

Ex 1039 - POE Link Chain

Ex 1040 - POPR IPR2021-00019

Ex 1041 - Denying Institution IPR2021-00019

Notice: Power of Attorney

Notice: Power of Attorney

Ex 1022 - 034 ACS v Intel Preliminary Infringement Contentions

Ex 1042 - Notice of Sotera Stipulations for 034 Patent by Intel Corporation

Ex 1043 - Complaint against AMD

Ex 1044 - AMD Scheduling Order Pretrial

Ex 1045 - 034 ACS Preliminary Infringement Contentions against AMD

Ex 1046 - Notice of Sotera Stipulation re 034 Patent

Ex 1048 - Affidavit of Tanya Zeif

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part1 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part2 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part3 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part4 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part5 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part6 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part7 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part8 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part9 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part10 of 11

Ex 1049 - Archive.org Affidavit Exhibits_Part11 of 11

Ex 1003 - Dr. Bajaj Declaration for ACS '034 Patent

Intel v ACS - 034 Petition

Ex 1047 - IBM Declaration