IP Verse

VMware, Inc. vs Cirba IP, Inc.

The detailed information for PTAB case with proceeding number PGR2021-00098 filed by VMware, Inc. against Cirba IP, Inc. on Jul 6, 2021. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Case Details

Proceeding Number: PGR2021-00098
Filing Date: Jul 6, 2021
Petitioner: VMware, Inc.
Respondent: Cirba IP, Inc.
Status: Final Written Decision
Respondent Application Number: 16687966
Respondent Tech Center: 2400
Respondent Patent Number: 10951459
Institution Decision Date: Dec 10, 2021
Termination Date: Dec 7, 2022

Proceeding Documents

The table below shows documents filed in the case, listing each document name, filing date, document type, and filing party. Tracking these filings indicates the activity of the parties involved in the case, and the types of documents filed can provide insights into the legal strategies being employed.

Show Exhibit Documents

Document Name	Filing Date	Category	Filing Party
Alert me when new update on this case
Other: Fed Circuit mandate	Aug 14, 2024	PAPER	BOARD
ORDER Granting Petitioner’s Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel 37 C.F.R. § 42.10	Mar 6, 2023	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioner's Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel	Feb 1, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices	Feb 1, 2023	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal	Jan 31, 2023	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Final Written Decision: original	Dec 7, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Other: Hearing transcript	Nov 22, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Revised Hearing Order	Sep 12, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibit	Sep 12, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Demonstrative Exhibit	Sep 12, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Petitioner)	Sep 9, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
ORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. 42.70	Aug 25, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Order: Panel Change Order	Aug 24, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices	Aug 17, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney	Aug 17, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Granting Patent Owners Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Wesley White 37 C.F.R. § 42.10	Aug 16, 2022	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List	Aug 11, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Declaration of Wesley White In Support of Motion for Pro Hac Vice	Aug 11, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
PATENT OWNERS MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF WESLEY WHITE UNDER 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(c)	Aug 11, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument	Jul 29, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Hearing	Jul 26, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Sur-Reply	Jul 22, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response	Jun 24, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1023	Jun 24, 2022	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1024	Jun 24, 2022	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Notice of Deposition of Dr. Vijay Madisetti PH.D.	Jun 9, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices	May 24, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Joint Notice of Stipulation to Move Due Dates 2 and 3	May 9, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices	Apr 29, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Supplemental Evidence Responding to Petitioner's Objections	Mar 25, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Petitioner's Objections to Evidence Submitted with Patent Owner's Response	Mar 11, 2022	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Response	Mar 4, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Exhibit List	Mar 4, 2022	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Declaration of Dr. Vijay Madisetti in Support of Patent Owner's Response	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
List of Materials Considered by Dr. Vijay Madisetti	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Vijay Madisetti	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Order, D.I. 1161, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Memorandum Opinion, D.I. 1160, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Joint Claim Construction Brief, D.I. 1094, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
DICTIONARY BY MERRIAM-WEBSTER (available at https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/place)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
THE MERRIAM-WEBSTER DICTIONARY (2004)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
ROGET��S II THE NEW THESAURUS (3d ed. 2003)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Newman, Morris et al., IBM, SERVER CONSOLIDATION WITHVMWARE ESX SERVER (January 2005)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Brodkin, Jon, Virtual Server Sprawl Highlights Security Concerns, April 30, 2008	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Provazza, Alyssa, FAQ: Devising a Server Consolidation Plan, November 24, 2010	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
VMware, Inc., Virtualization	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
The Computer Language Company Inc., Virtual Environment	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Hammersley, Eric, PROFESSIONAL VMWARE SERVER 1-9 (2007)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
VMware, Inc., Introduction to VMware Infrastructure, Update 2 and later for ESX Server 3.5, ESX Server 3i version 3.5, VirtualCenter 2.5, copyright 2008, 2009, pp. 1-20	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Defense Industry Daily, The Virtual Armed Forces: US Military Turns to Virtualization, August 15, 2011	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Steele, Colin, Face-Off: VMware vs. Microsoft in the Hypervisor Wars, May 1, 2009	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Kerner, Sean Michael, KVM vs. Xen vs. VMware. Is it a Hypervisor War?, September 6, 2008	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Venezia, Paul, Ramming Microsoft Down IT��s Throat, September 21, 2009	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Dubie, Denise, VMware, MS Battle Over Virtualization Management, June 27, 2008	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Rosenblum, Mendel & Garfinkel, Tal, Virtual Machine Monitors: Current Technology and Future Trends, COMPUTER, Vol. 38, No. 5, 39-47 (May 2005)	Mar 4, 2022	EXHIBIT	PATENT OWNER
Institution Decision: Granting Institution of Post-Grant Review 35 U.S.C. sec. 324	Dec 10, 2021	PAPER	BOARD
Order: Scheduling Order	Dec 10, 2021	PAPER	BOARD
Patent Owner's Election to Waive Its Preliminary Response	Sep 14, 2021	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Order: ORDER Granting Petitioners Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Andrea L. Scripa and Stephen Liu 37 C.F.R. 42.10	Sep 7, 2021	PAPER	BOARD
Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Andrea L. Scripa	Aug 25, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Stephen Liu	Aug 25, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1021	Aug 25, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1022	Aug 25, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices	Aug 25, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Exhibit List	Aug 25, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER
Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices	Jul 27, 2021	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Patent Owner's Power of Attorney	Jul 27, 2021	PAPER	PATENT OWNER
Notice of Accord Filing Date	Jul 19, 2021	PAPER	BOARD
Exhibit 1001	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1002	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1003	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1004	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1005	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1006	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1007	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1008	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1009	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1010	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1011	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1012	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1013	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1014	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1015	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1016	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1017	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1018	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1019	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Exhibit 1020	Jul 6, 2021	EXHIBIT	PETITIONER
Petitioner's Power of Attorney	Jul 6, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER
Petition for Postgrant Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,951,459	Jul 6, 2021	PAPER	PETITIONER