IP Verse

Advanced Bionics vs. MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft - CC_15513/2024

The case CC_15513/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Advanced Bionics against the defendant MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft on 23 Mar, 2024.

Case Timeline

23 Mar, 2024
Case Filed
24 May, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
28 Oct, 2024
Written Procedure
28 Oct, 2024
Rejoinder
28 Oct, 2024
Interim Conference
28 Oct, 2024
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    CC_15513/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP4074373

    Filing Date:

    23 Mar, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Counter Claim For Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Advanced Bionics
    • Advanced Bionics Gmbh
    • Advanced Bionics Sarl

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Carsten Plaga
    • Miriam Kiefer

    Defendants:

    • MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft
    • Med-El Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft M.B.H.

    Defendant Representative:

    • Michael Ruberg
    • Michael RÜBERG

    Judges:

    • Kerstin Roselinger
    • Paolo Catallozzi
    • Tatyana Zhilova

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Central Division - Paris

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Apr 22, 2025Procedural Order
Apr 22, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Apr 10, 2025Procedural Order (Ord 64504 2024)
Apr 10, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 28, 2025Procedural Order
Mar 28, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 27, 2025Procedural Order
Mar 27, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 27, 2025Final Order 12060 26.03
Mar 17, 2025Receipt
Mar 12, 2025Upc Cfi 338 2023 Upc Cfi 410 2023 Recovery Of Overpaid Witness Advance 12032025
Mar 12, 2025Bbr03
Mar 12, 2025Bbr02
Mar 12, 2025Bbr01
Feb 6, 2025Procedural Order
Jan 28, 2025Receipt
Jan 28, 2025Final Decision 26.12. Anonymized
Jan 28, 2025Decisionoutcome
Jan 28, 2025Decision
Jan 27, 2025Request Ab For Rectification Of Decisions R. 353 Rop Signed
Dec 19, 2024Procedural Order
Dec 19, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 12, 2024Receipt
Dec 12, 2024Exhibit Bb38
Dec 12, 2024Act 576555 Letter 12.12
Dec 5, 2024Procedural Order
Dec 5, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 4, 2024Receipt
Dec 4, 2024Exhibit Bb29
Dec 4, 202412 03 Act 576555 2023 Letter
Nov 21, 2024Receipt
Nov 20, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 20, 2024Confirmation Of Appointment Case 57655 And 15513
Nov 20, 2024Confirmation Of Appointment Case 576555 Cd Munich
Nov 19, 2024Receipt
Nov 19, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Request Me Regarding Access Of Audio Recording 2024 11 08 M35698 St Niwi
Nov 18, 2024Redacted Confirmation Of Appointment
Nov 18, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 18, 2024Confirmation Of Appointment
Nov 8, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Request Me Regarding Access Of Audio Recording 2024 11 08 M35698 St Niwi
Nov 7, 2024Request Ab Regarding Access Of Audio Recording Signed
Nov 7, 2024Receipt
Nov 5, 2024Cc 15513 2024 App 58664 2024 Additional Auxiliary Requests 2024 11 05 M35698 St Niwi
Oct 30, 2024Procedural Order
Oct 30, 2024Hearing Reference
Oct 30, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 28, 2024Written Procedure Closure
Oct 28, 2024Template Order
Oct 28, 2024Summon Oral Hearing
Oct 28, 2024Request R. 333 Ab Re Order On Auxiliary Requests Signed
Oct 28, 2024Procedural Order
Oct 28, 2024Interim Procedure Closure
Oct 28, 2024Interim Conference Decision
Oct 28, 2024Hearing Reference
Oct 28, 2024Hearing Dates
Oct 28, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date
Oct 28, 2024Exhibit Kap R 1 Proof Of Payment
Oct 25, 2024Receipt
Oct 25, 2024Procedural Order
Oct 25, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 25, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Additional Auxiliary Requests 2024 10 25 Signed
Oct 25, 2024Auxiliary Request 3A Star Clean
Oct 25, 2024Auxiliary Request 3A Star
Oct 25, 2024Auxiliary Request 0A Star Clean
Oct 25, 2024Auxiliary Request 0A Star
Oct 15, 2024Receipt
Oct 14, 2024Rejoinder Ab (R. 30 Rop)
Oct 9, 2024Procedural Order
Oct 9, 2024Hearing Dates
Oct 7, 2024Confirmation Ab Interim Conference And Alternative Dates
Oct 7, 2024Act 590988 2023 Cc 15513 2024 Response To The Order Of 3 Oct
Oct 3, 2024Procedural Order
Oct 1, 2024Statement Ab Re Interim Conference
Sep 30, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Antrag Sn Zwischenanhoerung 09 30 M35698 St Niwi
Sep 30, 2024Bb37
Sep 30, 2024Bb36
Sep 30, 2024Bb35A
Sep 30, 2024Bb35
Sep 24, 2024Procedural Order
Sep 24, 2024Hearing Dates
Sep 12, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Upc Cfi 410 2023 Reply To Defence To Application To Amend 2024 09 12. Signed
Sep 12, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Upc Cfi 410 2023 Rejoinder To Reply To Defense To Counterclaim 2024 09 12 Signed
Sep 12, 2024Bb34A
Sep 12, 2024Bb34
Sep 12, 2024Bb33
Sep 12, 2024Bb32
Sep 12, 2024Bb31
Sep 12, 2024Bb30 2
Sep 12, 2024Bb30 1
Sep 12, 2024Bb29A 2
Sep 12, 2024Bb29A 1
Sep 12, 2024Bb29 2
Sep 12, 2024Bb29 1
Sep 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 13, 2024Reply Ab
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D28 Part 02 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D28 Part 01 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D27 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D26 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D25 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D24 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D23 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D22 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D21 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D20 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D19 En
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Kap D18 En
Aug 13, 2024Defence Ab To Application To Amend The Patent
Aug 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 12, 2024Erwiderung Nichtigskeitswiderklage En M35698 St Niwi
Aug 12, 2024Cover Letter Translations Ab
Aug 12, 2024Counterclaim For Revocation Ab Gmbh And Ab Sarl
Aug 12, 2024Cc 15513 2024 Upc Cfi 410 2023 Submission By Order Dated July 26 2024 M35698 St Niwi
Aug 12, 2024Antrag Auf Aenderung Des Patents En M35698 St Niwi
Jul 26, 2024Procedural Order
Jul 12, 2024Procedural Order
Jul 12, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 26, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 25, 2024Panel Appointment
May 27, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb9
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb8
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb7
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb6
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb5
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb4
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb3
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb28
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb27
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb26
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb25
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb24
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb23
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb22
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21E
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21D
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21C
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21B
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21A
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb21
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb20
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb2
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb19
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb18
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb17
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb16
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb15
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb14
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb13
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb12
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb11B
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb11A
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb10
May 24, 2024Exhibit Bb1
May 24, 2024Cc 15513 2024 M35698 St Niwi Erwiderung Nichtigkeitswiderklage
May 24, 2024Cc 15513 2024 M35698 St Niwi Antrag Auf Aenderung Des Patent
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 6 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 6A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 6A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 6
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 5 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 5A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 5A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 5
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 4 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 4A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 4A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 4
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 3 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 3A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 3A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 3
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 2 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 2A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 2A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 2
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 1 De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 1A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 1A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 1
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0C De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0C
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0B De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0B
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0A De
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Mark Up) 0A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 6A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 6
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 5A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 5
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 4A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 4
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 3A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 3
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 2A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 2
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 1A
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 1
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 0C
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 0B
May 24, 2024Auxiliary Request (Clean) 0A
May 24, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
May 24, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Apr 15, 2024Zustellungsbescheinigung
Apr 15, 2024Zustellbescheinigung
Apr 15, 2024Notification Of Service
Apr 2, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Mar 29, 2024Document From Epo
Mar 26, 2024Panel Appointment
Mar 26, 2024Letter For Service
Mar 26, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Mar 26, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Mar 26, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 23, 2024Widerklage Auf Nichtigerklaerung Ab Gmbh Und Ab Sarl
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap Rev 01 De
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D17 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D16 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D15 Part 04 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D15 Part 03 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D15 Part 02 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D15 Part 01 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D14 Part 02 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D14 Part 01 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D13 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D12 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D11 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D10 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D09 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D08 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D07 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D06 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D05 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D04 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D03 Part 02 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D03 Part 01 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D02 En
Mar 23, 2024Anlage Kap D01 En

More cases involving EP4074373B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ACT_33777/2025Jul 28, 2025Medel Elektromedizinische Gerate GesellschaftNurotron, Zhejiang Nurotron Biotechnology
UPC_CFI_688/2025Jul 28, 2025Medel Elektromedizinische Gerate GesellschaftNurotron, Zhejiang Nurotron Biotechnology
UPC_CFI_514/2025Jun 10, 2025Medel Elektromedizinische Gerate GesellschaftZhejiang Nurotron Biotechnology

More cases involving Advanced Bionics

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_25615/2025Jun 2, 2025Advanced Bionics -
APP_25616/2025Jun 2, 2025Advanced Bionics -
APL_9718/2025Feb 26, 2025Advanced BionicsMED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate

More cases involving MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_30200/2025Jun 27, 2025MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft -
APP_25220/2025May 27, 2025MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate Gesellschaft -
APL_9633/2025Feb 26, 2025MED EL Elektromedizinische Gerate GesellschaftAdvanced Bionics