IP Verse

Aylo Billing vs. Dish - CC_26845/2024

The case CC_26845/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Aylo Billing against the defendant Dish on 13 May, 2024.

Case Timeline

13 May, 2024
Case Filed
13 May, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
17 Apr, 2025
Written Procedure
02 May, 2025
Interim Conference
02 May, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    CC_26845/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP2479680

    Filing Date:

    13 May, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Counter Claim For Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Aylo Billing
    • Aylo Billing Limited
    • Aylo Freesites Ltd
    • Aylo Premium Ltd

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Tilman Mueller-Stoy
    • Tilman Muller-Stoy

    Defendants:

    • Dish
    • Dish Technologies L.L.C.

    Defendant Representative:

    • Denise Benz

    Judges:

    • Dirk Böttcher
    • Peter Tochtermann
    • Walter Schober

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Mannheim

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Jun 6, 2025Decisionoutcome
Jun 6, 2025Decision
May 22, 2025No. Cc 39805 Upc Cfi 385
May 22, 2025No. Cc 36413 Upc Cfi 334
May 22, 2025No. Cc 26845
May 21, 2025No. Cc 45814 Upc Cfi 475
May 2, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
May 2, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
May 2, 2025Hearing Dates
May 2, 2025Doppel Aus Technischen Gruenden
Apr 29, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Apr 17, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Apr 17, 2025Technischer Abschluss Des Workflows
Apr 17, 2025R 28 VERFO
Apr 17, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Apr 17, 2025Hearing Dates
Dec 23, 2024Rejoin Amend Patent Defence
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpwn27 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpwn26Jp Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpwn25 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv47 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv46 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv45 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv44 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv43 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv42 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Bpv41 Aylo
Dec 23, 2024Duplik
Dec 13, 2024Reply Amend Patent Defence
Nov 25, 2024Receipt
Nov 22, 2024Replik Vertraulich
Nov 22, 2024Exhibit Wb2
Nov 22, 2024Exhibit Wb1
Nov 22, 2024Antrag Gem. 262.2 VERFO
Nov 21, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Nov 21, 2024Exhibit Wb1
Nov 21, 2024Duplik
Nov 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 23, 2024Final Order 262A
Oct 23, 2024Final Order 262 A
Oct 22, 2024Receipt
Oct 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 22, 2024Anordnung R 262A (Doppel Aus Technischen Gruenden)
Oct 22, 2024Anordnung R 262A
Oct 21, 2024Schriftsatz
Oct 21, 2024Reply To Defence To Cfr
Oct 21, 2024Exhibit Bpwn24A
Oct 21, 2024Exhibit Bpwn24
Oct 21, 2024Exhibit Bpwn23
Oct 21, 2024Exhibit Bpwn22
Oct 21, 2024Bpwn24A
Oct 21, 2024Bpwn24
Oct 21, 2024Bpwn23
Oct 21, 2024Bpwn22
Oct 21, 2024Antrag/Schriftsatz
Oct 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 12, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 10, 2024Ha9 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha9
Sep 10, 2024Ha8 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha8
Sep 10, 2024Ha7 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha7
Sep 10, 2024Ha6 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha6
Sep 10, 2024Ha5 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha5
Sep 10, 2024Ha4 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha4
Sep 10, 2024Ha3 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha3
Sep 10, 2024Ha2 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha2
Sep 10, 2024Ha1 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha17 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha17
Sep 10, 2024Ha16 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha16
Sep 10, 2024Ha15 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha15
Sep 10, 2024Ha14 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha14
Sep 10, 2024Ha13 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha13
Sep 10, 2024Ha12 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha12
Sep 10, 2024Ha11 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha11
Sep 10, 2024Ha10 Compare
Sep 10, 2024Ha10
Sep 10, 2024Ha1
Sep 10, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 10, 2024Erwiderung Nichtigkeitswiderklage
Sep 10, 2024Antrag Auf Aenderung Des Patents
Sep 10, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 21, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 20, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 20, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Aug 20, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 19, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha9 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha9
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha8 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha8
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha7 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha7
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha6 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha6
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha5 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha5
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha4 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha4
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha3 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha3
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha2 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha2
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha1 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha17 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha17
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha16 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha16
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha15 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha15
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha14 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha14
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha13 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha13
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha12 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha12
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha11 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha11
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha10 Compare
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha10
Aug 19, 2024Exhibit Ha1
Aug 19, 2024Erwiderung Nichtigkeitswiderklage Bridgemaze
Aug 19, 2024Erwiderung Nichtigkeitswiderklage Aylo Billing Us
Aug 19, 2024Document From Epo
Aug 19, 2024Antrag Auf Aenderung Des Patents
Aug 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 14, 2024Panel Appointment
Aug 14, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 14, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 14, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Aug 14, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 14, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 12, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 9 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 9
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 8 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 8
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 7 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 7
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 6 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 6
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 5 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 5
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 4 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 4
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 3 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 3
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 2 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 2
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 1 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 17 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 17
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 16 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 16
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 15 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 15
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 14 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 14
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 13 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 13
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 12 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 12
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 11 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 11
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 10 Compare
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 10
Aug 10, 2024Hilfsantrag 1
Aug 10, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 10, 2024Erwiderung
Aug 10, 2024Antrag Gem. R. 30 VERFO
Aug 10, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 8, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 8, 2024Nichtigkeitswiderklage Beklagte Zu 5
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 21
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 20
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 19
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 18
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 17
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 16
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 15
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 14
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 13
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 12
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 11B
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 11A
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 11
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 10
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 09
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 08
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 07
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 06
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 05
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 04
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 03
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 02C
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 02B
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 02A
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 02
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpwn 01
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 03
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 02
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01F
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01E
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01D
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C09
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C08
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C07
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C06
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C05
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C04
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C03
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C02
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C01
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01C
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01B
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 01A
Aug 8, 2024Exhibit Bpv 00
Aug 8, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 23, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jul 23, 2024Document From Epo
Jul 18, 2024Panel Appointment
Jul 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 18, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jul 18, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jul 18, 2024Document From Epo
Jul 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jul 12, 2024Panel Appointment
Jul 12, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 12, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jul 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jul 9, 2024Nichtigkeitswiderklage Beklagte Zu 4
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Bpv00
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 21
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 20
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 19
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 18
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 17
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 16
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 15
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 14
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 13
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 12
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11B
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11A
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 10
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 09
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 08
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 07
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 06
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 05
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 04
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 03
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02C
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02B
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02A
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpwn 01
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 03
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 02
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01F
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01E
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01D
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C09
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C08
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C07
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C06
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C05
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C04
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C03
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C02
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C01
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01B
Jul 9, 2024Anlage Bpv 01A
Jun 25, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 18, 2024Nichtigkeitswiderklage
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 21
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 20
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 19
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 18
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 17
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 16
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 15
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 14
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 13
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 12
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11B
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11A
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 10
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 09
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 08
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 07
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 06
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 05
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 04
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 03
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02C
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02B
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02A
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpwn 01
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 03
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 02
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01F
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01E
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01D
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C09
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C08
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C07
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C06
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C05
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C04
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C03
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C02
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C01
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01B
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 01A
Jun 18, 2024Anlage Bpv 00 Payment Court Fee
Jun 5, 2024Notification Of Service
Jun 5, 2024Empfangsbestatigung
May 21, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
May 20, 2024Document From Epo
May 15, 2024Panel Appointment
May 15, 2024Letter For Service
May 15, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
May 15, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
May 15, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
May 15, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
May 13, 2024Counterclaim
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 21
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 20
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 19
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 18
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 17
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 16
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 15
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 14
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 13
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 12
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11B
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11A
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 11
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 10
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 09
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 08
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 07
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 06
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 05
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 04
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 03
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02C
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02B
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02A
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 02
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpwn 01
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 03
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 02
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01F
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01E
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01D
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C09
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C08
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C07
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C06
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C05
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C04
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C03
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C02
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C01
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01C
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01B
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 01A
May 13, 2024Anlage Bpv 00

More cases involving EP2479680B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_35893/2025Sep 1, 2025Redacted Natural Person NameAylo Premium
APL_34191/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo Billing, Aylo Freesites, Aylo PremiumDish
APL_34192/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo BillingDish

More cases involving Aylo Billing

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APL_34191/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo BillingDish
APL_34192/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo BillingDish
UPC_COA_709/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo BillingDish

More cases involving Dish

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_34403/2025Aug 14, 2025Dish -
APL_34191/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo Billing, Aylo Freesites, Aylo PremiumDish
APL_34192/2025Aug 6, 2025Aylo BillingDish