IP Verse

Bitzer Electronics vs. Carrier - UPC_CFI_263/2023

The UPC Case UPC_CFI_263/2023 was filed on 29 Jun, 2023 by the plaintiff Bitzer Electronics against the defendant Carrier.

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_263/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP3414708

    Filing Date:

    29 Jun, 2023

    Proceeding Type:

    Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Bitzer Electronics

    Plaintiff Representatives:

    • Tilman PFRANG

    Defendants:

    • Carrier

    Defendant Representatives:

    • Gregory LEES

    Judges:

    • François Thomas
    • Paolo Catallozzi
    • Ulrike Keltsch

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

DateTitleLink
Jul 29, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 29, 2024Decisionoutcome-
Jul 29, 2024Decision
Jun 21, 2024Hearing Reference-
Jun 13, 2024Summons-
Jun 13, 2024Rule 263
Jun 13, 2024Rule 108
Jun 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jun 13, 2024Interimprocedureclosure-
Jun 11, 2024Receipt-
Jun 10, 2024R263 Application-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Clean)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Clean)-
Apr 30, 2024Rule 333
Apr 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 19, 2024Receipt-
Apr 18, 2024Proof Of Fee Payment-
Apr 18, 2024Application For Review Of Case Management Order-
Apr 17, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 17, 2024Closing Workflow
Apr 11, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Apr 11, 2024Rejoinder To Reply To The Defence To The Statement Of Claim And Reply To Defence To The Application To Amend-
Apr 11, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Apr 11, 2024Cover Letter-
Apr 5, 2024Rule 105
Apr 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 2, 2024Receipt-
Apr 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
Apr 2, 2024Application Under Rule 9-
Mar 27, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure-
Mar 27, 2024Receipt-
Mar 27, 2024Interimconferencedecision-
Mar 27, 2024Interim Conference
Mar 27, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date-
Mar 26, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 25, 2024Receipt-
Mar 22, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 13, 2024Rule 28
Mar 13, 2024Hearing Dates-
Mar 13, 2024Email From The Epo-
Mar 13, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Mar 1, 2024Confirmation Schedule Cmc And Op-
Feb 26, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 23, 2024Comments On Proposed Dates-
Feb 19, 2024Rejoinder To The Reply To The Defence And Reply To The Defence To The Application To Amend-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminary Order-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Feb 19, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Feb 12, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 12, 2024Comments To The Hearing Set Dates-
Feb 5, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Jan 19, 2024Reply To Revocation Defence And Application For Amendment-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 10-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Amendpatentdefence-
Jan 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 8, 2024Request For Stay-
Jan 8, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Dec 15, 2023Comments To Request For Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Request For Proceeding Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Receipt-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit E Opposition Observations-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit D Letter From The President Of The Epo-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit C Request For Opposition Acceleration-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit B Statement Of Claim-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit A Notice Of Opposition-
Dec 1, 2023Covering Letter-
Dec 1, 2023Application To Stay Proceedings-
Nov 22, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Nov 22, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Nov 20, 2023Statement Of Defence-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Main Request Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 9 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 8 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 7 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 6 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 5 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 4 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 3 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 2 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 1 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 12 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 11 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 10 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Main Request-
Nov 20, 2023Covering Letter-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 9-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 8-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 7-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 6-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 5-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 4-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 3-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 2-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 12-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 11-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 10-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 1-
Nov 20, 2023Application To Amend-
Nov 20, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Sep 18, 2023Notification Of Service-
Sep 18, 2023Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Aug 9, 2023Panel Appointment-
Aug 3, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Aug 2, 2023Document From Epo-
Aug 1, 2023Statementofrevocation-
Jul 31, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jul 31, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jul 27, 2023Revocation Action-
Jul 27, 2023Mb9-
Jul 27, 2023Mb8-
Jul 27, 2023Mb7-
Jul 27, 2023Mb6-
Jul 27, 2023Mb5-
Jul 27, 2023Mb4-
Jul 27, 2023Mb3-
Jul 27, 2023Mb2-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1D-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1C-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1B-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1A-
Jul 27, 2023Corrected Statement Of Claim-
Jul 29, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 29, 2024Decisionoutcome-
Jul 29, 2024Decision
Jun 21, 2024Hearing Reference-
Jun 13, 2024Summons-
Jun 13, 2024Rule 263
Jun 13, 2024Rule 108
Jun 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jun 13, 2024Interimprocedureclosure-
Jun 11, 2024Receipt-
Jun 10, 2024R263 Application-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Clean)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Clean)-
Apr 30, 2024Rule 333
Apr 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 19, 2024Receipt-
Apr 18, 2024Proof Of Fee Payment-
Apr 18, 2024Application For Review Of Case Management Order-
Apr 17, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 17, 2024Closing Workflow
Apr 11, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Apr 11, 2024Rejoinder To Reply To The Defence To The Statement Of Claim And Reply To Defence To The Application To Amend-
Apr 11, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Apr 11, 2024Cover Letter-
Apr 5, 2024Rule 105
Apr 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 2, 2024Receipt-
Apr 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
Apr 2, 2024Application Under Rule 9-
Mar 27, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure-
Mar 27, 2024Receipt-
Mar 27, 2024Interimconferencedecision-
Mar 27, 2024Interim Conference
Mar 27, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date-
Mar 26, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 25, 2024Receipt-
Mar 22, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 13, 2024Rule 28
Mar 13, 2024Hearing Dates-
Mar 13, 2024Email From The Epo-
Mar 13, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Mar 1, 2024Confirmation Schedule Cmc And Op-
Feb 26, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 23, 2024Comments On Proposed Dates-
Feb 19, 2024Rejoinder To The Reply To The Defence And Reply To The Defence To The Application To Amend-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminary Order-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Feb 19, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Feb 12, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 12, 2024Comments To The Hearing Set Dates-
Feb 5, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Jan 19, 2024Reply To Revocation Defence And Application For Amendment-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 10-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Amendpatentdefence-
Jan 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 8, 2024Request For Stay-
Jan 8, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Dec 15, 2023Comments To Request For Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Request For Proceeding Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Receipt-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit E Opposition Observations-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit D Letter From The President Of The Epo-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit C Request For Opposition Acceleration-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit B Statement Of Claim-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit A Notice Of Opposition-
Dec 1, 2023Covering Letter-
Dec 1, 2023Application To Stay Proceedings-
Nov 22, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Nov 22, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Nov 20, 2023Statement Of Defence-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Main Request Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 9 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 8 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 7 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 6 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 5 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 4 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 3 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 2 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 1 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 12 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 11 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 10 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Main Request-
Nov 20, 2023Covering Letter-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 9-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 8-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 7-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 6-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 5-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 4-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 3-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 2-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 12-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 11-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 10-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 1-
Nov 20, 2023Application To Amend-
Nov 20, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Sep 18, 2023Notification Of Service-
Sep 18, 2023Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Aug 9, 2023Panel Appointment-
Aug 3, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Aug 2, 2023Document From Epo-
Aug 1, 2023Statementofrevocation-
Jul 31, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jul 31, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jul 27, 2023Revocation Action-
Jul 27, 2023Mb9-
Jul 27, 2023Mb8-
Jul 27, 2023Mb7-
Jul 27, 2023Mb6-
Jul 27, 2023Mb5-
Jul 27, 2023Mb4-
Jul 27, 2023Mb3-
Jul 27, 2023Mb2-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1D-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1C-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1B-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1A-
Jul 27, 2023Corrected Statement Of Claim-
Jul 29, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 29, 2024Decisionoutcome-
Jul 29, 2024Decision
Jun 21, 2024Hearing Reference-
Jun 13, 2024Summons-
Jun 13, 2024Rule 263
Jun 13, 2024Rule 108
Jun 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jun 13, 2024Interimprocedureclosure-
Jun 11, 2024Receipt-
Jun 10, 2024R263 Application-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 14-
Jun 10, 2024Auxiliary Request 13-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Statement Of Defence (Clean)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Tracked)-
Jun 10, 2024Amended Application To Amend (Clean)-
Apr 30, 2024Rule 333
Apr 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 19, 2024Receipt-
Apr 18, 2024Proof Of Fee Payment-
Apr 18, 2024Application For Review Of Case Management Order-
Apr 17, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Apr 17, 2024Closing Workflow
Apr 11, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Apr 11, 2024Rejoinder To Reply To The Defence To The Statement Of Claim And Reply To Defence To The Application To Amend-
Apr 11, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Apr 11, 2024Cover Letter-
Apr 5, 2024Rule 105
Apr 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 2, 2024Receipt-
Apr 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
Apr 2, 2024Application Under Rule 9-
Mar 27, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure-
Mar 27, 2024Receipt-
Mar 27, 2024Interimconferencedecision-
Mar 27, 2024Interim Conference
Mar 27, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date-
Mar 26, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 25, 2024Receipt-
Mar 22, 2024Application Under Rule 336-
Mar 13, 2024Rule 28
Mar 13, 2024Hearing Dates-
Mar 13, 2024Email From The Epo-
Mar 13, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Mar 1, 2024Confirmation Schedule Cmc And Op-
Feb 26, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 23, 2024Comments On Proposed Dates-
Feb 19, 2024Rejoinder To The Reply To The Defence And Reply To The Defence To The Application To Amend-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminary Order-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit A Summons And Preliminary Opinion-
Feb 19, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Feb 12, 2024Confirmation Of Availability-
Feb 12, 2024Comments To The Hearing Set Dates-
Feb 5, 2024Rule 28-
Feb 5, 2024Hearing Dates-
Jan 19, 2024Reply To Revocation Defence And Application For Amendment-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit Mb 10-
Jan 19, 2024Exhibit 5'-
Jan 19, 2024Amendpatentdefence-
Jan 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 8, 2024Request For Stay-
Jan 8, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Dec 15, 2023Comments To Request For Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Request For Proceeding Stay-
Dec 4, 2023Receipt-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit E Opposition Observations-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit D Letter From The President Of The Epo-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit C Request For Opposition Acceleration-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit B Statement Of Claim-
Dec 1, 2023Exhibit A Notice Of Opposition-
Dec 1, 2023Covering Letter-
Dec 1, 2023Application To Stay Proceedings-
Nov 22, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Nov 22, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Nov 20, 2023Statement Of Defence-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Main Request Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 9 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 8 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 7 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 6 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 5 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 4 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 3 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 2 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 1 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 12 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 11 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Mark Up Of Auxiliary Request 10 Amendments-
Nov 20, 2023Main Request-
Nov 20, 2023Covering Letter-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 9-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 8-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 7-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 6-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 5-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 4-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 3-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 2-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 12-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 11-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 10-
Nov 20, 2023Auxiliary Request 1-
Nov 20, 2023Application To Amend-
Nov 20, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Sep 18, 2023Notification Of Service-
Sep 18, 2023Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Aug 9, 2023Panel Appointment-
Aug 3, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Aug 2, 2023Document From Epo-
Aug 1, 2023Statementofrevocation-
Jul 31, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jul 31, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jul 27, 2023Revocation Action-
Jul 27, 2023Mb9-
Jul 27, 2023Mb8-
Jul 27, 2023Mb7-
Jul 27, 2023Mb6-
Jul 27, 2023Mb5-
Jul 27, 2023Mb4-
Jul 27, 2023Mb3-
Jul 27, 2023Mb2-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1D-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1C-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1B-
Jul 27, 2023Mb1A-
Jul 27, 2023Corrected Statement Of Claim-

More cases involving EP3414708B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_35673/2024Jun 18, 2024Mathys & SquireBitzer Electronics, Carrier
APP_6758/2024Feb 6, 2024Redacted Natural Person NameBitzer Electronics, Carrier
ACT_555899/2023Jun 29, 2023Bitzer ElectronicsCarrier

More cases involving Bitzer Electronics

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ACT_555899/2023Jun 29, 2023Bitzer ElectronicsCarrier

More cases involving Carrier

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_35673/2024Jun 18, 2024Mathys & SquireCarrier
APP_35421/2024Jun 13, 2024Mathys & SquireCarrier
APP_31421/2024May 28, 2024Redacted Natural Person NameCarrier