IP Verse

City Glass And Glazing Private vs. Maars France - UPC_CFI_455/2024

The case UPC_CFI_455/2024 was filed by the plaintiff City Glass And Glazing Private against the defendant Maars France on 31 Jul, 2024.

Case Timeline

31 Jul, 2024
Case Filed
14 Nov, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
20 Feb, 2025
Written Procedure
27 Mar, 2025
Rejoinder
27 Mar, 2025
Interim Conference
22 May, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_455/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP1651838

    Filing Date:

    31 Jul, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • City Glass And Glazing Private

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Joel Coles

    Defendants:

    • Maars France
    • Maars Holding
    • Maars Partitioning Systems
    • Maars Projecten

    Defendant Representative:

    • Michiel Rijsdijk

    Judges:

    • Edger Brinkman
    • Margot Kokke
    • Paolo Ernesto Crippa
    • Stefan Johansson

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - The Hague

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Aug 29, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Aug 29, 2025Decisionoutcome
Aug 29, 2025Decision On The Merits
Jul 11, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 44624 2024 Oh Hag Loc Upc2025070810Am
Jun 30, 2025Uploaded For Technical () Reasons Only
Jun 30, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Jun 30, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Jun 4, 2025Hearing Dates
May 23, 2025Exhibit Mar 12B. Translation Of Quotes From Exhibit Mar 12 (DE 2452087 A1)
May 23, 2025Exhibit Mar 12A. DE 2452087 A1 English Translation
May 23, 2025Exhibit Mar 10A. Figures 9 11 Missing In Exhibit Mar 10 (Nz 198562 A)
May 23, 2025Exhibit Cit 15 En
May 23, 2025Exhibit Cit 14 En
May 23, 2025Claimant'S Response To R. 105.5 Order
May 23, 2025.05.23 Response Maars Et Al. After Interim Conference Submission Of Exhibits
May 22, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 44624 2024 Ic Hag Loc Upc2025050811Am
May 22, 2025Decisions Taken At Ic
May 21, 2025Fix Interim Conference Date
May 11, 2025Outcome Of The Order
May 11, 2025Order Uploaded To Close The Workflow
May 9, 2025Outcome Of The Order
May 9, 2025Order Uploaded To Close The Workflow
May 8, 2025Interim Conference Decision
May 2, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Apr 25, 2025Response To Preliminary Order
Apr 25, 2025Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Apr 25, 2025Application Rop293 Receipt
Apr 25, 2025.04.25 Response To Application For Order To Produce Evidence Maars Et Al.
Apr 18, 2025Receipt
Apr 18, 2025Opportunity To Comment
Apr 17, 2025Application For Order Under Art. 59 Upca Rop 190 191
Mar 27, 2025Exhibit Mar 17. Annex To The Communication From The Examining Division Pursuant To Art. 94(3) Epc
Mar 27, 2025Exhibit Mar 16. US4539243A
Mar 27, 2025Exhibit Mar 15. Drawings Of The Assembly Of The System Of De'087
Mar 27, 2025Exhibit Mar 14. Drawings Of The Assembly Of The System Of Us'205
Mar 27, 2025Exhibit Mar 13. Drawings Of The Assembly Of The System Of Nz 562
Mar 27, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 27, 2025.03.27 Rejoinder To The Reply And Reply To Defence To Revocation Maars Et Al. V City Glass
Feb 28, 2025Panel Appointment
Feb 27, 2025Panel Appointment
Feb 20, 2025Setting Dates
Feb 20, 2025Hearing Dates
Feb 20, 2025.02.20 Response Maars Et Al. Re Interim Conference Availability
Feb 19, 2025Claimant'S Response Regarding Interim Conference
Feb 18, 2025R.37.2 Order
Feb 17, 2025Opportunity To Comment
Feb 17, 2025Hearing Dates
Jan 28, 2025Reply To Defence And Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation
Jan 28, 2025Exhibit Cit 17 Collingwood V Aurora [] Ewhc 228 (Pat)
Jan 28, 2025Exhibit 18 Schenck Rotec V Universal Balancing [] Ewhc 1920 (Pat)
Jan 28, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jan 10, 2025Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jan 10, 2025Application Rop293 Receipt
Dec 19, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Dec 17, 2024R.158 Security
Dec 17, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 10, 2024R.9 Order To Align Deadlines
Dec 10, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 5, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Dec 5, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 4, 2024Response To R9 Application
Dec 4, 2024Personal Id M.W. Rijsdijk
Dec 4, 2024Application To Change The Details Of A Representative
Dec 4, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 3, 2024Opportunity To Comment
Dec 2, 2024Receipt
Dec 2, 2024Generic Procedural Application (R. 9 Rop)
Nov 27, 2024Formal Response To Request For Correction
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 9. Response Letter From Applicant Dated
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 8. Amended Claim 1 As Filed On
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 7. Amended Claim 1 As Filed On
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 6. Correspondence With Sa Ip Between 25 November And 26 December
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 5. Response Letter To Sa Ip Dated
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 4. Correspondence With Sa Ip Dated
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 3. Cease And Desist Letter To Maars Middle East Fze Dated
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 2. Screenshots Website City Glass
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 1. Declaration Of Mr. E. Boschman Dated
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 12. DE 2452087 A1
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 11. US3155205A
Nov 27, 2024Exhibit Mar 10. Nz 198562 A
Nov 27, 2024Application To Change Details Representative Rgr16.1(B)
Nov 27, 2024Application To Change A Representative (Rop293)
Nov 27, 2024Application Rop293
Nov 27, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 27, 2024.11.14 Statement Of Defence Including Counterclaim For Revocation Maars Holding B.V. Et Al V City Glass Amended
Nov 27, 2024.11.14 Statement Of Defence Including Counterclaim For Revocation Maars Holding B.V. Et Al V City Glass
Nov 26, 2024Application To Change A Representative (Rop293)
Nov 26, 2024Application Rop293
Nov 18, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 9. Response Letter From Applicant Dated
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 8. Amended Claim 1 As Filed On
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 7. Amended Claim 1 As Filed On
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 6. Correspondence With Sa Ip Between 25 November And 26 December
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 5. Response Letter To Sa Ip Dated
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 4. Correspondence With Sa Ip Dated
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 3. Cease And Desist Letter To Maars Middle East Fze Dated
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 2. Screenshots Website City Glass
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 1. Declaration Of Mr. E. Boschman Dated
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 12. DE 2452087 A1
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 11. US3155205A
Nov 14, 2024Exhibit Mar 10. Nz 198562 A
Nov 14, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 14, 2024.11.14 Statement Of Defence Including Counterclaim For Revocation Maars Holding B.V. Et Al V City Glass
Oct 7, 2024Claimant'S Response To The Request For Security For Costs
Sep 25, 2024Opportunity To Comment
Sep 24, 2024Receipt
Sep 20, 2024Application For A Security For Costs Rop 158
Sep 20, 2024Annex I To Application For Security
Sep 20, 2024Annex Ii To Application For Security
Sep 20, 2024Annex Iii To Application For Security
Aug 30, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 26, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 20, 2024Panel Appointment
Aug 20, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 20, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Aug 20, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 20, 202408 19 Act 44624 2024 Upc Cfi 455 2024 Confirmation Of Service Maars France
Aug 19, 2024Document From Epo
Aug 16, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 16, 202408 16 Act 44624 2024 Upc Cfi 455 2024 Confirmation Of Service Maars Projecten B.V.
Aug 16, 202408 16 Act 44624 2024 Upc Cfi 455 2024 Confirmation Of Service Maars Partitioning Systems B
Aug 16, 202408 16 Act 44624 2024 Upc Cfi 455 2024 Confirmation Of Service Maars Holding B.V.
Aug 15, 2024Letter For Service
Aug 14, 2024Receipt
Aug 14, 2024Panel Appointment
Aug 14, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 14, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Aug 13, 2024Statement Of Md
Aug 13, 2024Statement Of Claim
Aug 13, 2024Formal Response To The Request For Amendments
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 9
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 8
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 7
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 6
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 5
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 4
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 3
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 2
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 16
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 15
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 14
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 13
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 12
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 11
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 10
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Cit 1
Aug 13, 2024Entitlement To Reduced Fee
Aug 13, 2024Entitlement Of Reduced Fee
Aug 6, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Aug 2, 2024Statement Of Claim
Aug 2, 2024Formal Response To The Request For Amendments
Aug 2, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 9
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 8
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 7
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 6
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 5
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 4
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 3
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 2
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 16
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 15
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 14
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 13
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 12
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 11
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 10
Aug 2, 2024Exhibit Cit 1
Aug 2, 2024Entitlement To Reduced Fee
Aug 2, 2024Entitlement Of Reduced Fee
Aug 2, 2024Application To Change Details Of A Representative
Aug 2, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 1, 2024Statement Of Claim
Aug 1, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 9
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 8
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 7
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 6
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 5
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 4
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 3
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 2
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 16
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 15
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 14
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 13
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 12
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 11
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 10
Aug 1, 2024Exhibit Cit 1
Aug 1, 2024Entitlement Of Reduced Fee
Jul 31, 2024Statement Of Claim
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 9
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 8
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 7
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 6
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 5
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 4
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 3
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 2
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 16
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 15
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 14
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 13
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 12
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 11
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 10
Jul 31, 2024Exhibit Cit 1
Jul 31, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP1651838B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
CC_60624/2024Nov 14, 2024Maars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars ProjectenCity Glass And Glazing Private
UPC_CFI_684/2024Nov 14, 2024Maars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars ProjectenCity Glass And Glazing Private
ACT_44624/2024Jul 31, 2024City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars Projecten

More cases involving City Glass And Glazing Private

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_18931/2025Apr 18, 2025City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars Projecten
ORD_7920/2025Feb 17, 2025City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars Projecten
ACT_44624/2024Jul 31, 2024City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France, Maars Holding, Maars Partitioning Systems, Maars Projecten

More cases involving Maars France

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_18931/2025Apr 18, 2025City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France
ORD_7920/2025Feb 17, 2025City Glass And Glazing PrivateMaars France
CC_60624/2024Nov 14, 2024Maars FranceCity Glass And Glazing Private