IP Verse

HL Display AB vs. Black Sheep Retail Products - UPC_CFI_386/2024

The case UPC_CFI_386/2024 was filed by the plaintiff HL Display AB against the defendant Black Sheep Retail Products on 03 Jul, 2024.

Case Timeline

03 Jul, 2024
Case Filed
20 Feb, 2025
Counterclaim for Revocation
12 Jun, 2025
Written Procedure
12 Jun, 2025
Interim Conference
24 Jun, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_386/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP2432351

    Filing Date:

    03 Jul, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Oral Phase

    Plaintiffs:

    • HL Display AB

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Gertjan Kuipers

    Defendants:

    • Black Sheep Retail Products

    Defendant Representative:

    • Tjibbe Douma

    Judges:

    • Edger Brinkman
    • Koen Callewaert
    • Margot Kokke
    • Mélanie Bessaud

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - The Hague

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Oct 10, 2025Final Order
Oct 10, 2025Action.Publishorderdecision
Oct 10, 2025Action.Phasechange
Oct 10, 2025Action.Issuedecision
Oct 10, 2025Action.Communication
Oct 3, 2025Action.Communication
Sep 10, 20251Oral Hearing Referencing 39810 2024 Oh Hag Loc Upc2025082210Am
Aug 26, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 22, 2025Po R. 333
Aug 22, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 39810 2025 Oh Hag Loc Upc2025082210Am
Aug 22, 2025Hearing Dates
Aug 22, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Aug 22, 2025Application For Review R. 333 Signed
Aug 21, 2025Proof Of Payment
Aug 21, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Aug 21, 2025Deposit Of Physical Objects
Aug 21, 2025Application For Review R. 333 Signed
Aug 21, 2025Annex 2 Email To Registry The Hague Local Division 24 February
Aug 21, 2025Annex 1 R.9 Application Submission Physical Exhibit (Signed)
Aug 21, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 19, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Aug 15, 2025Summons To Oh
Aug 15, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Aug 15, 2025R. 105.5 Order
Aug 15, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Aug 15, 2025Hearing Dates
Jul 30, 2025Preliminary R. 105.5 Order
Jun 24, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 39810 2024 Ic Hag Loc Upc2025061710Am
Jun 18, 2025Panel Appointment
Jun 17, 2025Hl Display Comments On Bsrp R9 Application
Jun 12, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Jun 12, 2025Preliminary Order Physical Exhibit
Jun 12, 2025Interim Conference Decision
Jun 12, 2025Fix Interim Conference Date
Jun 6, 2025Receipt
Jun 5, 2025R.9 Application Request Submission Physical Exhibit (Signed)
Feb 25, 2025Receipt
Feb 24, 2025R.9 Application Submission Physical Exhibit (Signed)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb39 Cease And Desist Undertaking Bsrp Shelf Divider 1
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb38 Physical Shelf With Shelf Dividers
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb37 Images Of Hl Display Shelf Products
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb36 Further Hl Display Catalogue Excerpt
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb35 US5803276(Vogler)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb34 US2316892(Saul Jr.)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb33B Overview Of Innovative Bsrp Displays (Part 2)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb33A Overview Of Innovative Bsrp Displays (Part 1)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb32 Bsrp Highlight Display
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb31 Energy Bullets Food Packaging
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb30B Ecocover System (Part 2)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb30A Ecocover System (Part 1)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb29B Chameleon System (Part 2)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb29A Chameleon System (Part 1)
Feb 20, 2025Exhibit Bb28 Bsrp Out Of The Box System
Feb 20, 2025Bsrp Rejoinder In The Claim, Reply In The Counterclaim, Defence To Aap
Feb 20, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Feb 4, 2025Hl Display Comments On Bsrp'S R. 9 Application
Jan 30, 2025Receipt
Jan 30, 2025Hl Display Black Sheep Po Opposition Against Equivalence Argument
Jan 29, 2025R.9 Application Bsrp (Final Signed)
Jan 29, 2025Annex 2 Response Letter Bsrp DATED 12 July And Accompanying Email
Jan 29, 2025Annex 1 E Mail Correspondence Between The Parties DATED 26 June 28 June
Jan 3, 2025Setting Ic And Oh Dates
Jan 3, 2025Order Not To Bifurcate
Jan 3, 2025Hearing Dates
Dec 23, 2024Reply To Defence In Infringement Action
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Hl13
Dec 23, 2024Exhibit Hl12
Dec 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 11, 2024Comments Re Unavailability Dates And Rule 37 Rop
Nov 11, 2024Bsrp Comments
Nov 4, 2024Preliminary Order Blockage Dates And R. 37
Oct 28, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Oct 28, 2024Bsrp Application
Oct 28, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 24, 2024Sod Due Date
Oct 24, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb27 US3308964(Pistone)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb26B Wo (Mcelvaney) 2 Of 2
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb26A Wo (Mcelvaney) 1 Of 2
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb25 US5971173(Valiulis)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb24 US6533131(Bada)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb23 English Machine Translation Of EP1374744A2 (Haltenhof)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb22 EP1374744A2 (Haltenhof)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb21B WO2004112549A1 (Josefsson) 2 Of 2
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb21A WO2004112549A1 (Josefsson) 1 Of 2
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb20 English Machine Translation Of DE 202005005910 U1 (Oechsle)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb19 DE 202005005910 U1 (Oechsle)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb18 US20060186064A1 (Merit)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb17 Ca 2549208A1 (Parshad)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb16 Examples Of Common General Knowledge In Patent(S) (Applications)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb15 Hl Displays Product Catalogue
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb14 US3067903(D7 Or Jones)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb13 Further Amended Claims And Accompanying Letter DATED 28 November
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb12 Communication From The Examining Division DATED 18 May
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb11 Amended Claims After European Search Opinion And Accompanying Letter DATED 9 September
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb10 WO2005084498A1 (D3 Or Ahlund)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb09 Machine Translation Of Se 531 411 C2 (D2 Or Linden)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb08 Se 531 411 C2 (D2 Or Linden)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb07 European Search Opinion EP351
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb06 WO2010134883(Pct Application For EP351)
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb05 The Bsrp Product 2
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb04 Response Letter Bsrp DATED 12 July And Accompanying Email
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb03 E Mail Correspondence Between The Parties DATED 26 June 28 June
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb02 The Bsrp Product
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb01D Bsrp Product Brochures 4 Of 4
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb01C Bsrp Product Brochures 3 Of 4
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb01B Bsrp Product Brochures 2 Of 4
Oct 23, 2024Exhibit Bb01A Bsrp Product Brochures 1 Of 4
Oct 23, 2024Bsrp Sod And Cc
Oct 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 18, 2024Receipt
Oct 18, 2024Bsrp'S Application Under Rule 9 Rop
Jul 25, 2024Panel Appointment
Jul 25, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jul 23, 2024Document From Epo
Jul 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 22, 2024Notification Of Service
Jul 22, 202407 22 Act 39810 Upc Cfi 386 2024 Confirmation Of Service
Jul 17, 2024Letter For Service
Jul 16, 2024Statement Of Claim
Jul 16, 2024Receipt
Jul 16, 2024Panel Appointment
Jul 16, 2024Formal Response To Invitation To Correct Formal Deficiencies
Jul 16, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl11
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl10
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl09
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl08
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl07
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl06
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl05
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl04
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl03
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl02
Jul 16, 2024Exhibit Hl01
Jul 16, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jul 9, 2024Statement Of Claim
Jul 9, 2024Formal Response To Invitation To Correct Formal Deficiencies
Jul 9, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl11
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl10
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl09
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl08
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl07
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl06
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl05
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl04
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl03
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl02
Jul 9, 2024Exhibit Hl01
Jul 8, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Jul 3, 2024Statement Of Claim
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl11
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl10
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl09
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl08
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl07
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl06
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl05
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl04
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl03
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl02
Jul 3, 2024Exhibit Hl01
Jul 3, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP2432351B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
CC_57457/2024Oct 23, 2024Black Sheep Retail ProductsHL Display
UPC_CFI_610/2024Oct 23, 2024Black Sheep Retail ProductsHL Display AB
ACT_39810/2024Jul 3, 2024HL DisplayBlack Sheep Retail Products

More cases involving HL Display AB

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_34903/2025Aug 18, 2025HL Display AB -
ORD_249/2025Jan 3, 2025HL Display ABBlack Sheep Retail Products
ORD_59690/2024Nov 4, 2024HL Display ABBlack Sheep Retail Products

More cases involving Black Sheep Retail Products

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_35301/2025Aug 21, 2025Black Sheep Retail Products -
APP_26908/2025Jun 6, 2025Black Sheep Retail Products -
APP_9257/2025Feb 25, 2025Black Sheep Retail Products -