IP Verse

Icpillar vs. Allinea Software - UPC_CFI_495/2023

The case UPC_CFI_495/2023 was filed by the plaintiff Icpillar against the defendant Allinea Software, Apical, ARM, and others on 28 Dec, 2023. The case decision was made on Feb 28, 2024.

Case Timeline

28 Dec, 2023
Case Filed
02 Sep, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
02 Sep, 2024
Rejoinder
02 Sep, 2024
Interim Conference
02 Sep, 2024
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_495/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP3000239

    Filing Date:

    28 Dec, 2023

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Icpillar

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Lionel Martin

    Defendants:

    • Allinea Software
    • Apical
    • ARM
    • ARM France
    • ARM Germany
    • ARM Germany DOO
    • ARM Lreland
    • ARM Poland SP ZOO
    • ARM Sweden AB
    • Hyperglance
    • Simulity Labs
    • SVF Holdco

    Defendant Representative:

    • Christoph CRÜTZEN

    Judges:

    • Andrea Perronace
    • Camille Lignieres
    • Carine Gillet
    • Petri Rinkinen

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Paris

Case Decision

    Decision Date:

    Feb 28, 2024

    Decision Document:

    View document

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Feb 24, 2025Case Closure Formal Check
Dec 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 13, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Dec 13, 2024Final Decision
Nov 22, 2024Receipt
Nov 22, 2024Application To Withdraw Counterclaim Rule 265 Rop
Nov 19, 2024Receipt
Nov 19, 202415332 00101 241119 R.265 R370 Signe
Oct 16, 2024Stay Order
Oct 16, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 15, 2024Receipt
Oct 14, 202415332 00101 241014 R295 VF A Signed
Sep 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Sep 30, 2024Order R 9
Sep 26, 2024Receipt
Sep 26, 202415332 00101 240925 R9 A Signed
Sep 3, 2024Receipt
Sep 2, 2024Reply To Defence To Counterclaim
Sep 2, 2024Rejoinder To The Reply To The Statement Of Defence
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 17
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 16
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 15
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 14
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 13
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 12
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 11
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 10
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 42
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 41
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 40
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 39
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 38
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 37
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 36
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 35
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 34
Sep 2, 2024Exhibit Cc 33
Sep 2, 2024Defence To Application To Amend The Patent
Aug 22, 2024V3 Wikipedia Page Of Gdsii
Aug 22, 2024V2 Affidavit Of Joseph C. Mcalexander Iii
Aug 22, 2024V1 A Practitioner S Guide To European Patent Law Paul England
Aug 22, 2024Receipt
Aug 22, 2024P12 Written Opinion European Examination
Aug 22, 2024Cover Letter Rule 9 Reply Sod A Signed
Aug 22, 2024C22 Arm Flexible Access Data Sheet
Aug 22, 2024C21 Affidavit Of Professor Homayoun
Aug 22, 2024C20 Nic 400 Paper
Aug 22, 2024Ar3 Auxiliary Request No 3
Aug 22, 2024Ar2 Auxiliary Request No 2
Aug 22, 2024Ar1 Auxiliary Request No 1
Aug 22, 2024Answer To Cc And Sod Signed
Jul 16, 2024Receipt
Jul 3, 2024Ar3 Auxiliary Request No 3
Jul 3, 2024Ar2 Auxiliary Request No 2
Jul 3, 2024Ar1 Auxiliary Request No 1
Jul 3, 2024Application To Communicate Information Pursuant To Rule 191 Rop
Jul 3, 2024Application To Amend The Patent
Jul 3, 2024Answer To Cc And Sod Signed
Jun 5, 2024Order Set The Dates Ic And Oh Icpillar V Arm
May 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order
May 30, 2024Order Grant A Leave To Appeal
May 29, 2024Rop 9 Exhibit 2 Legal Expenses Insurance Policy And Endorsement
May 29, 2024Rop9 Exhibit 1 15332 00101 240521 Order Security For Costs
May 29, 2024Receipt
May 29, 202415332 00101 240528 Leave For Appeal
May 21, 2024Security For Costs Order Arm V Icpillar
May 21, 2024Panel Appointment
May 21, 2024Outcome Of The Order
May 14, 2024Exhibit 8: Upc Cfi 252 (Cd Munich) Order Of , President And Fellows Of Harvard College V. Nanostring Tech
May 14, 2024Exhibit 7: Response To The Application To Withdraw Allinea Software Gmbh Filed By Arm S Representative,
May 14, 2024Exhibit 6: Upc Cfi 239 (Ld The Hague) Order Of , Arkyne Technologies S.L. V. Plant E Knowledge
May 14, 2024Exhibit 5: Paris Convention For The Protection Of Industrial Property And Signatories
May 14, 2024Exhibit 4: Delaware Division Of Corporations Website Icpillar Llc And Delaware Code Title 8 Chapter I Subchapter
May 14, 2024Exhibit 3: Upc Cfi 514 (Ld Munich) Order Of , Volkswagen Ag And A. V. Network System Technologies Llc
May 14, 2024Exhibit 2: Upc Cfi 15 (Ld Munich) Order Of , Edwards Lifesciences Corporation V. Meril Gmbh
May 14, 2024Exhibit 1: Declaration Of Mohsin Patel
May 14, 202415332 00101 240514 Written Observations On Application For Security For Costs
May 2, 2024Statement Of Defense
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 9
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 8
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod7
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 6
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 5
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 4
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 3
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 2
May 2, 2024Exhibit Sod 1
Apr 29, 2024Receipt
Apr 29, 2024Po Written Comments Security For Costs
Apr 29, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Apr 29, 2024Order R.9.3 Request
Apr 27, 2024Statement Of Defense
Apr 27, 2024Exhibit Sod 2
Apr 27, 2024Exhibit Sod 1
Apr 27, 2024Application Rule 9
Apr 26, 2024Statement Of Defense
Apr 26, 2024Receipt
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 9
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 8
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod7
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 7
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 6
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 5
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 4
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 3
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 2
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod1
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Sod 1
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Mb D4
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Mb D3
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Mb D2
Apr 26, 2024Exhibit Mb D1
Apr 26, 2024Application For Security For Costs
Apr 11, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome
Apr 11, 2024Po Order Arm V Icpillar 11 April
Mar 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Mar 22, 2024Order Withdrawal Allinea
Mar 21, 2024X05 Arm Limited Subsidiaries From Gov Uk Companies Register Website And Orbis Register Website A
Mar 21, 2024Response To Withdrawal Allinea Software Gmbh
Mar 21, 2024P9 Arm Poland With Profile Of Their Board Members Mcelroy And Gill
Mar 21, 2024P8 Central Division Paris Edwards V Meril Order 13 November
Mar 21, 2024P7 Extract Linkedin Website Senior Software Engineer
Mar 21, 2024P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office
Mar 21, 2024P5 Central Division Munich Amgen C Sanofi Order 24 August
Mar 21, 2024P4 Cour De Cassation Chambre Civile 1 29 June
Mar 21, 2024P3 Extract Arm Website Development Tools And Software Distributors
Mar 21, 2024P2 Extract Arm Website Company Global Offices
Mar 21, 2024P1A Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry (New)
Mar 21, 2024P11 The Present Submissions With Revisions Marks Emphasize In Margin
Mar 21, 2024P10 Building The Future Of Computing Arm
Mar 21, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Mar 21, 2024C17 Extract Arm Website Development Tools And Software Arm Socratres
Mar 21, 2024C01 Extract Arm Socrates User Guide Version 1 5
Mar 21, 202415332 00101 240321 Answer Po2 3 Signed
Mar 14, 2024Receipt
Mar 14, 2024Po Comments Withdrawal Application Allinea
Mar 13, 2024Receipt
Mar 13, 2024Application For Technically Qualified Judge
Mar 12, 2024X05 Arm Limited Subsidiaries From Gov Uk Companies Register Website And Orbis Register Website A
Mar 12, 2024P8 Central Division Paris Edwards V Meril Order 13 November
Mar 12, 2024P7 Extract Linkedin Website Senior Software Engineer
Mar 12, 2024P6 Extract Careers Arm Website Galway Office
Mar 12, 2024P5 Central Division Munich Amgen C Sanofi Order 24 August
Mar 12, 2024P4 Cour De Cassation Chambre Civile 1 29 June
Mar 12, 2024P3 Extract Arm Website Development Tools And Software Distributors
Mar 12, 2024P2 Extract Arm Website Company Global Offices
Mar 12, 2024P1 Extract Arm Website Contact Us Arm Flexible Access Inquiry
Mar 12, 2024Exhibit 1 Of An Official Printout Of The German Commercial Register Including An English Translation Exhibit Mb 3
Mar 12, 2024Confirmation Of Notification Of Appointment
Mar 12, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Mar 12, 2024C17 Extract Arm Website Development Tools And Software Arm Socratres
Mar 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case 12131
Mar 12, 202415332 00101 240312 Comments Po A Signed
Mar 12, 202415332 00101 240312 Application Request R265 R9 A Signed
Mar 7, 2024Preliminary Objection Svf Holdco
Mar 7, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Mb C2
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Mb C1
Mar 6, 2024Preliminary Objection
Mar 6, 2024Exhibit Mb B2
Mar 6, 2024Exhibit Mb B1
Mar 5, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 4, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 1, 2024Order Rop 275 2
Mar 1, 2024Order R275 2
Mar 1, 2024Notification Of Service
Feb 29, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Feb 28, 2024Template Order
Feb 28, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Feb 28, 2024Order Request Withdrawal R 265 Icpillar Against One Of The Defendants Before Service Of Soc
Feb 28, 2024Order R.275.2 Icpillar Alternative Method Service
Feb 27, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Feb 26, 2024X05 Arm Limited Subsidiaries From Gov Uk Companies Register Website And Orbis Register Website A
Feb 26, 2024Receipt
Feb 26, 2024Preliminary Objection
Feb 26, 2024Exhibit Mb 4
Feb 26, 2024Exhibit Mb 3
Feb 26, 2024Exhibit Mb 2
Feb 26, 2024Exhibit Mb 1
Feb 26, 2024Copie Ecran Dhl A
Feb 26, 202415332 00101 240226 Application Request R265 R9(5945980.2) A Sign
Feb 20, 2024Receipt
Feb 15, 2024Exhibit 5 Bailiff Report Svf Holdco
Feb 15, 2024Exhibit 4 Bailiff Report Simulity Labs Limited
Feb 15, 2024Exhibit 3 Bailiff Report Apical Limited
Feb 15, 2024Exhibit 2 Bailiff Report Arm Limited
Feb 15, 2024Exhibit 1 Order 12 Feb 24 Icpillar R 275.1 Signed Cl
Feb 15, 2024Application Request R275.2 Pdf A
Feb 14, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Feb 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Feb 12, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Feb 12, 2024Order Icpillar R. 275
Feb 2, 2024Receipt
Feb 2, 2024Notification Of Service
Feb 2, 2024Ar Arm Sweden Ab
Feb 2, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Feb 1, 2024En Ld Mannheim App 589186 2023 A
Feb 1, 202415332 00101 240201 Request R275 1 A Signed
Jan 26, 2024Notification Of Service
Jan 26, 2024Ar
Jan 15, 2024Letter For Service
Jan 8, 2024Panel Appointment
Jan 8, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jan 3, 2024Document From Epo
Dec 29, 2023Receipt
Dec 29, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Dec 29, 2023Epo Request For Case Pending
Dec 22, 2023X07 Extract Arm Website Job Offer Senior Partner Manager Southern Europe
Dec 22, 2023X06 Extract Arm Website Sophia Antipolis Office
Dec 22, 2023X05 Arm Limited Subsidiaries From Gov Uk Companies Register Website And Orbis Register Website A
Dec 22, 2023X04 Extract Arm Website New Arm Ip Tooling
Dec 22, 2023X03 Article Ecompetitions
Dec 22, 2023X02 About Arm Company Information Benefits History
Dec 22, 2023X01 Extract Arm Website The Official History Of Arm
Dec 22, 2023P11 Confirmation Of Assignment For Icpillar A
Dec 22, 2023P10 European Search Report Of Ep Patent Application
Dec 22, 2023P09 EP14800934Register Extract
Dec 22, 2023P08 International Search Report Of Pct Application PctUS2014039302
Dec 22, 2023P07 Pct Patent Application WO2014190242A1
Dec 22, 2023P06 Us Patent Application US20170139406A1
Dec 22, 2023P05 Us Patent Application US20150121320A1
Dec 22, 2023P04 Us Patent Application US20140351774A1
Dec 22, 2023P03 Extract Wikipedia Website Integrated Circuit Internet Of Things System On A Chip
Dec 22, 2023P02 Patent Application EP4164239A1
Dec 22, 2023P01 Patent EP3000239B1
Dec 22, 2023C19 Arm Tech Symposia China On The Road To Designing A System In A Day With Arm Ip Tooling
Dec 22, 2023C18 Extract Arm Website Suppliers
Dec 22, 2023C17 Extract Arm Website Development Tools And Software Arm Socratres
Dec 22, 2023C16 Extract Arm Developer Website Corstone 1000 Technical Specifications
Dec 22, 2023C15 Extract Arm Website Arm Gpus For Graphics Processing All The Products
Dec 22, 2023C14 Extract Arm Website Products Corelink Generic Interrupt Controller Gic
Dec 22, 2023C13 Extract Arm Website Products Corelink Pck 600
Dec 22, 2023C12 Extract Youtube VIDEO N2
Dec 22, 2023C11 Extract Arm Developer VIDEO
Dec 22, 2023C10 Extract Arm Developer Website Use Software Components
Dec 22, 2023C09 Arm Developer Website Vision User S Guide Setup The Project
Dec 22, 2023C08 Extract Arm Developer Website Developmement Studio Components
Dec 22, 2023C07 Extract Arm Developer Website Project Explorer
Dec 22, 2023C06 Extract Arm Developer Website About Corelinkcreator
Dec 22, 2023C05 Arm Corelink Nic 450 Network Interconnect Technical Overview
Dec 22, 2023C04 Extract Arm Community Blog System Assembly Through Intelligent Configuration
Dec 22, 2023C03 Extract Youtube VIDEO N1
Dec 22, 2023C02 Extract Arm Website Build A Secure Iot System On Chip
Dec 22, 2023C01 Extract Arm Socrates User Guide Version 1 5
Dec 22, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 22, 202314733 00101 231222 Statement Of Claims VF 5873814 4 A Signe

More cases involving EP3000239B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_COA_312/2024Jun 14, 2024Icpillar -
ACT_596432/2023Dec 28, 2023IcpillarAllinea Software, Apical, ARM, ARM France, ARM Germany, ARM Germany DOO, ARM Lreland, ARM Poland SP ZOO, ARM Sweden, Hyperglance, Simulity Labs, SVF Holdco

More cases involving Icpillar

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_61630/2024Nov 19, 2024Icpillar -
APP_35055/2024Jun 14, 2024Icpillar -
UPC_COA_312/2024Jun 14, 2024Icpillar -

More cases involving Allinea Software

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ORD_33243/2024Jun 4, 2024IcpillarAllinea Software
APP_22767/2024Apr 26, 2024Allinea Software -
ACT_596432/2023Dec 28, 2023IcpillarAllinea Software