IP Verse

Tandem Diabetes Care vs. Roche - UPC_CFI_454/2023

The case UPC_CFI_454/2023 was filed by the plaintiff Tandem Diabetes Care against the defendant Roche Diabetes Care on 30 Nov, 2023. The case decision was made on Feb 20, 2024.

Case Timeline

30 Nov, 2023
Case Filed
14 May, 2024
Written Procedure
14 May, 2024
Rejoinder
14 May, 2024
Interim Conference
14 May, 2024
Oral Procedure
14 May, 2024
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_454/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP2196231

    Filing Date:

    30 Nov, 2023

    Proceeding Type:

    Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Tandem Diabetes Care
    • Tandem Diabetes Care Europe

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Christian Dekoninck

    Defendants:

    • Roche Diabetes Care

    Defendant Representative:

    • Christof Augenstein

    Judges:

    • Giorgio Checcacci
    • Paolo Catallozzi
    • Tatyana Zhilova

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Central Division - Paris

Case Decision

    Decision Date:

    Feb 20, 2024

    Decision Document:

    View document

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Feb 19, 2025Final Order Anonymized 18.02
Feb 18, 2025Rule 353
Feb 18, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Feb 14, 2025Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Jan 30, 2025Comments On Rectification Merits Decision
Jan 23, 2025Preliminary Order
Jan 20, 2025Receipt
Jan 20, 2025Application To Rectify Decision R 353
Dec 19, 2024Final Order Anonymized 18.12
Dec 18, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Dec 18, 2024Decisionoutcome
Dec 18, 2024Decision
Dec 13, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Dec 13, 2024Application Rop293 Receipt
Dec 11, 2024Notification Pursuant To Rule 293 Rop (Change Of Representative)
Dec 11, 2024Application Rop293
Nov 27, 2024Receipt
Nov 27, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 27, 2024Closing Workflow
Nov 20, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 20, 2024Confirmation Of Appointment Case 589997
Nov 20, 2024Confirmation Of Appointment Anonymized
Nov 15, 2024Receipt
Nov 15, 2024Application
Nov 15, 2024Annex E1
Nov 14, 2024Request For Access To Audio Recording
Nov 14, 2024Annex E1
Nov 6, 2024Hearing Reference
Nov 4, 2024Rule 333
Nov 4, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 4, 2024Order Rule 333 04.11
Oct 31, 2024Final Order 30.10
Oct 30, 2024Template Order
Oct 30, 2024Summon Oral Hearing
Oct 30, 2024Rule 108
Oct 30, 2024Interim Procedure Closure
Oct 30, 2024Hearing Dates
Oct 29, 2024Submission Roche
Oct 29, 2024Exhibit Kap 15
Oct 29, 2024Comments On Definitions
Oct 29, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 25, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 25, 2024Final Order Rop333
Oct 25, 2024Final Order Rop105
Oct 25, 2024Exhibit Kap 14
Oct 25, 2024Closing Workflow
Oct 25, 2024Application To Review Order R. 333
Oct 21, 2024Rule 333
Oct 21, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 18, 2024Template Order
Oct 18, 2024Rule 9
Oct 18, 2024Receipt
Oct 18, 2024Application To Review
Oct 18, 2024Application For A Stay
Oct 14, 2024Order Rule 105 10.10
Oct 10, 2024Rule 105
Sep 11, 2024Hearing Reference
Sep 4, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure
Sep 4, 2024Rule 35
Sep 4, 2024Interimconferencedecision
Sep 4, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date
Jul 29, 2024Rule 30
Jul 29, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Jul 1, 2024Receipt
Jun 28, 2024Auxiliary Request 30
Jun 28, 2024Auxiliary Request 29
Jun 28, 2024Auxiliary Request 28
Jun 28, 2024Auxiliary Request 27
Jun 28, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jun 28, 202406 28 Request For Confidentiality R 262 2 Signed
Jun 28, 202406 28 Rejoinder Roche Signed
Jun 28, 202406 28 New Auxiliary Requests Roche Signed
Jun 27, 2024Time Extension
Jun 27, 2024Rule 28
Jun 27, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Jun 27, 2024Hearing Dates
Jun 26, 2024Brief Roche Regarding Availability
Jun 26, 2024Availability Oral Hearing
Jun 25, 2024Request To Extend Deadline
Jun 25, 2024Receipt
Jun 25, 2024Exhibit Kap 13
Jun 20, 2024Order
May 28, 2024Reply Tandem
May 28, 2024Annex D9
May 28, 2024Annex D8
May 28, 2024Annex D7
May 28, 2024Annex D6
May 28, 2024Annex D10
May 28, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
May 21, 2024Exhibit Kap 12 De
May 21, 2024Brief Re Oral Hearing
May 17, 2024Availability Hearing
May 14, 2024Rule 28
May 14, 2024Hearing Dates
May 10, 2024Template Order
May 10, 2024Preliminary Objection Order Case R
May 10, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome
May 10, 2024Preliminary Objection
May 10, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Mar 28, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Mar 28, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 27, 2024Reply Roche Regarding Request For Correction Formal Checks Signed
Mar 27, 2024Reply Roche Regarding Request For Correction Formal Checks Ii
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 11
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 10
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 09
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 08
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 07
Mar 27, 2024Exhibit Kap 06
Mar 27, 2024Defence To Statement For Dni Signed
Mar 27, 2024Defence To Revocation Signed
Mar 27, 2024Defence To Revocation Amended
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 26
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 25
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 24
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 23
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 22
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 21
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 20
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 19
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 18
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 17
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 16
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 15
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 14
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 13
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 12
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 11
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 10
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 09
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 08
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 07
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 06
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 05
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 04
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 03
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 02
Mar 27, 2024Auxiliary Request 01
Mar 18, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Mar 7, 2024Reply Roche Regarding Request For Correction Formal Checks Signed
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 11
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 10
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 09
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 08
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 07
Mar 7, 2024Exhibit Kap 06
Mar 7, 2024Defence To Statement For Dni Signed
Mar 7, 2024Defence To Revocation Signed
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 26
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 25
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 24
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 23
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 22
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 21
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 20
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 19
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 18
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 17
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 16
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 15
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 14
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 13
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 12
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 11
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 10
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 09
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 08
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 07
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 06
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 05
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 04
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 03
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 02
Mar 7, 2024Auxiliary Request 01
Mar 6, 2024Template Order
Mar 6, 2024Hearing Invitation
Mar 4, 2024Reply Roche Regarding Date For Oral Hearing On Opposition Signed
Mar 1, 2024Availability Hearing
Feb 28, 2024Hearing Date
Feb 26, 2024Rejoinder To Preliminary Objection
Feb 26, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 11
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 10
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 09
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 08
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 07
Feb 23, 2024Exhibit Kap 06
Feb 23, 2024Defence To Statement For Dni Signed
Feb 23, 2024Defence To Revocation Signed
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 26
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 25
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 24
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 23
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 22
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 21
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 20
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 19
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 18
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 17
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 16
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 15
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 14
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 13
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 12
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 11
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 10
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 09
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 08
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 07
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 06
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 05
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 04
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 03
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 02
Feb 23, 2024Auxiliary Request 01
Feb 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Feb 21, 2024Receipt
Feb 20, 2024Request For Time Extension
Feb 20, 2024Request For Confidentiality Act 589997 2023 App 3514 2024 Signed
Feb 20, 2024Reply In Preliminary Objection Roche Act 5899997 2023 App 3514 2024 Signed
Feb 20, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Feb 20, 2024Exhibit Kap 6 En Confidential
Feb 20, 2024Exhibit Kap 05 De
Feb 20, 2024Exhibit Kap 05A En
Feb 15, 2024Request Extension Time Period Statement Of Defence Signed
Feb 15, 2024Receipt
Feb 13, 2024Request For Pleadings
Feb 9, 2024Response To Preliminary Objection
Feb 9, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Feb 9, 2024Annex Po 03 To Response To Preliminary Objection
Feb 9, 2024Annex Po 02 To Response To Preliminary Objection
Feb 9, 2024Annex Po 01 To Response To Preliminary Objection
Jan 26, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Jan 23, 2024Receipt
Jan 22, 2024Request For Confidentiality Act 589997 2023 Signed
Jan 22, 2024Preliminary Objection Roche Act 5899997 2023(457596.3) Signed
Jan 22, 2024Exhibit Kap 04 De
Jan 22, 2024Exhibit Kap 04A En
Jan 22, 2024Exhibit Kap 03 En
Jan 22, 2024Exhibit Kap 02 En
Jan 22, 2024Exhibit Kap 01 En
Jan 2, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Dec 20, 2023Notification Of Service
Dec 20, 2023Ar Revocation Action Tandem Roche 20.12
Dec 13, 2023Panel Appointment
Dec 13, 2023Letter For Service
Dec 6, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Dec 6, 2023Document From Epo
Dec 4, 2023Revocation Action DATED 30 November
Dec 4, 2023Formal Checks Request For Correction
Dec 4, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Dec 4, 2023Epo Request For Case Pending
Dec 4, 2023Annex D5
Dec 4, 2023Annex D4
Dec 4, 2023Annex D3
Dec 4, 2023Annex D2
Dec 4, 2023Annex D1
Dec 4, 2023Annex C4
Dec 4, 2023Annex C3
Dec 4, 2023Annex C2
Dec 4, 2023Annex C1
Dec 4, 2023Annex B1
Dec 4, 2023Annex A4
Dec 4, 2023Annex A3
Dec 4, 2023Annex A2
Dec 4, 2023Annex A1
Dec 4, 2023Amended Statement
Dec 4, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 30, 2023Revocation Action DATED 30 November
Nov 30, 2023Annex D5
Nov 30, 2023Annex D4
Nov 30, 2023Annex D3
Nov 30, 2023Annex D2
Nov 30, 2023Annex D1
Nov 30, 2023Annex C4
Nov 30, 2023Annex C3
Nov 30, 2023Annex C2
Nov 30, 2023Annex C1
Nov 30, 2023Annex B1
Nov 30, 2023Annex A4
Nov 30, 2023Annex A3
Nov 30, 2023Annex A2
Nov 30, 2023Annex A1

More cases involving EP2196231B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APL_7604/2025Feb 17, 2025Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care EuropeRoche
UPC_COA_120/2025Feb 17, 2025Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care EuropeRoche
UPC_CFI_11/2025Jan 20, 2025RocheTandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe

More cases involving Tandem Diabetes Care

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_30135/2025Jun 27, 2025Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe -
APP_30138/2025Jun 26, 2025Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe -
APP_24411/2025May 26, 2025Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe -

More cases involving Roche

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ACT_34241/2025Aug 7, 2025F Hoffmann LA Roche, RocheAmenarini Diagnostics, Amenarini Diagnostics France Sasu, Berlin Chemie
UPC_CFI_712/2025Aug 7, 2025F Hoffmann LA RocheAmenarini Diagnostics, Amenarini Diagnostics France Sasu, Berlin Chemie
APP_29093/2025Jun 19, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche, Roche -