Nokia Technology vs. Mala - UPC_CFI_484/2023

The UPC Case UPC_CFI_484/2023 was filed on 18 Jan, 2024 by the plaintiff Nokia Technology against the defendant Mala.

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_484/2023

    Patent Number:

    Filing Date:

    18 Jan, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Written Phase

    Plaintiffs:

    • Nokia Technology

    Plaintiff Representatives:

    • Boris KREYE

    Defendants:

    • Mala

    Defendant Representatives:

    • Thomas LYNKER

    Judges:

    • Andrea Perronace
    • Marjolein Visser
    • Maximilian Haedicke

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

DateTitleLink
Apr 1, 2025Panel Appointment-
Jul 22, 2024R 353
Jul 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinder Application To Amend-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinamendpatentdefence-
Jul 10, 2024Template Order-
Jul 10, 2024R 353-
Jul 8, 2024Receipt-
Jul 4, 2024Application-
Jul 2, 2024Template Order-
Jul 2, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 2, 2024App To Amend Workflow
Jun 20, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Jun 20, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 20, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Reply To The Defence To Application To Amend EP709(Signed)-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Rejoinder To Reply To Defence To Revocation (Signed)-
Jun 18, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 18, 2024240618 Reply To Application 29031 2024 (Signed)-
Jun 4, 2024Order Re Workflow And Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Receipt-
May 23, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 21, 2024Reply To Defence-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 17-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 16-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15A-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 13B-
May 21, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
May 13, 2024Ar7-
May 13, 2024Ar6-
May 13, 2024Ar5-
May 13, 2024Ar4-
May 13, 2024Ar3-
May 13, 2024Ar2-
May 13, 2024Ar1-
May 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024240317 Defence To Revocation Application To Amend The Patent (Signed)-
May 7, 2024Po Mala Nokia Anonymized Order 02.05-
May 2, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome-
May 2, 2024Po Mala Nokia
May 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
May 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Apr 30, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 19, 2024Workflow-
Apr 9, 2024Pre Hearing Submission-
Apr 9, 2024240409 Pre Hearing Submission Mala Technologies Signed-
Mar 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
Mar 17, 2024Defence To Revocation-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 7-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 6-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 5-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 4-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 3-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 2-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 1-
Mar 11, 2024Template Order-
Mar 11, 2024Receipt-
Mar 11, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Mar 11, 2024Hearing Invitation-
Mar 11, 2024Final Order Deadline
Mar 8, 2024Request To Extend A Time Period-
Mar 4, 2024Comments To Preliminary Objection-
Mar 4, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024List Of Documents-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2 Confirmation Of Receipt-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2A Confirmation Of Receipt En-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1 Notice Of Appeal-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1A Notice Of Appeal En-
Feb 19, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709-
Feb 16, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709 Corrected-
Jan 18, 2024Power Of Attorney-
Jan 18, 2024Notification Of Service-
Jan 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jan 18, 2024Confirmation Of Service Email Received-
Jan 18, 2024App R293 Receipt-
Jan 18, 2024Application-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Jan 2, 2024Panel Appointment-
Jan 2, 2024Letter For Service-
Jan 2, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Dec 25, 2023Document From Epo-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action (Amended Pleading)-
Dec 21, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Response To The Request For Amendments-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B New-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-
Dec 21, 2023Epo Request For Case Pending-
Dec 21, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Dec 19, 2023Formal Checks Request For Correction-
Dec 15, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 15, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-
Apr 1, 2025Panel Appointment-
Jul 22, 2024R 353
Jul 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinder Application To Amend-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinamendpatentdefence-
Jul 10, 2024Template Order-
Jul 10, 2024R 353-
Jul 8, 2024Receipt-
Jul 4, 2024Application-
Jul 2, 2024Template Order-
Jul 2, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 2, 2024App To Amend Workflow
Jun 20, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Jun 20, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 20, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Reply To The Defence To Application To Amend EP709(Signed)-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Rejoinder To Reply To Defence To Revocation (Signed)-
Jun 18, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 18, 2024240618 Reply To Application 29031 2024 (Signed)-
Jun 4, 2024Order Re Workflow And Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Receipt-
May 23, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 21, 2024Reply To Defence-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 17-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 16-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15A-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 13B-
May 21, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
May 13, 2024Ar7-
May 13, 2024Ar6-
May 13, 2024Ar5-
May 13, 2024Ar4-
May 13, 2024Ar3-
May 13, 2024Ar2-
May 13, 2024Ar1-
May 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024240317 Defence To Revocation Application To Amend The Patent (Signed)-
May 7, 2024Po Mala Nokia Anonymized Order 02.05-
May 2, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome-
May 2, 2024Po Mala Nokia
May 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
May 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Apr 30, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 19, 2024Workflow-
Apr 9, 2024Pre Hearing Submission-
Apr 9, 2024240409 Pre Hearing Submission Mala Technologies Signed-
Mar 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
Mar 17, 2024Defence To Revocation-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 7-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 6-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 5-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 4-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 3-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 2-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 1-
Mar 11, 2024Template Order-
Mar 11, 2024Receipt-
Mar 11, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Mar 11, 2024Hearing Invitation-
Mar 11, 2024Final Order Deadline
Mar 8, 2024Request To Extend A Time Period-
Mar 4, 2024Comments To Preliminary Objection-
Mar 4, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024List Of Documents-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2 Confirmation Of Receipt-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2A Confirmation Of Receipt En-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1 Notice Of Appeal-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1A Notice Of Appeal En-
Feb 19, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709-
Feb 16, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709 Corrected-
Jan 18, 2024Power Of Attorney-
Jan 18, 2024Notification Of Service-
Jan 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jan 18, 2024Confirmation Of Service Email Received-
Jan 18, 2024App R293 Receipt-
Jan 18, 2024Application-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Jan 2, 2024Panel Appointment-
Jan 2, 2024Letter For Service-
Jan 2, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Dec 25, 2023Document From Epo-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action (Amended Pleading)-
Dec 21, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Response To The Request For Amendments-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B New-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-
Dec 21, 2023Epo Request For Case Pending-
Dec 21, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Dec 19, 2023Formal Checks Request For Correction-
Dec 15, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 15, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-
Apr 1, 2025Panel Appointment-
Jul 22, 2024R 353
Jul 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinder Application To Amend-
Jul 18, 2024Rejoinamendpatentdefence-
Jul 10, 2024Template Order-
Jul 10, 2024R 353-
Jul 8, 2024Receipt-
Jul 4, 2024Application-
Jul 2, 2024Template Order-
Jul 2, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Jul 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Jul 2, 2024App To Amend Workflow
Jun 20, 2024Replyamendpatentdefence-
Jun 20, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 20, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Reply To The Defence To Application To Amend EP709(Signed)-
Jun 20, 2024240620 Rejoinder To Reply To Defence To Revocation (Signed)-
Jun 18, 2024Ar3A-
Jun 18, 2024240618 Reply To Application 29031 2024 (Signed)-
Jun 4, 2024Order Re Workflow And Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Receipt-
May 23, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 21, 2024Reply To Defence-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 17-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 16-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15A-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 15-
May 21, 2024Exhibit B&B 13B-
May 21, 2024Defence To Application To Amend-
May 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
May 13, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
May 13, 2024Ar7-
May 13, 2024Ar6-
May 13, 2024Ar5-
May 13, 2024Ar4-
May 13, 2024Ar3-
May 13, 2024Ar2-
May 13, 2024Ar1-
May 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
May 13, 2024240317 Defence To Revocation Application To Amend The Patent (Signed)-
May 7, 2024Po Mala Nokia Anonymized Order 02.05-
May 2, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome-
May 2, 2024Po Mala Nokia
May 2, 2024Hearing Reference-
May 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords-
Apr 30, 2024Hearing Dates-
Apr 19, 2024Workflow-
Apr 9, 2024Pre Hearing Submission-
Apr 9, 2024240409 Pre Hearing Submission Mala Technologies Signed-
Mar 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D4 Epo Office Action EP709-
Mar 17, 2024Exhibit D3 Epo Decision-
Mar 17, 2024Defence To Revocation-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 7-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 6-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 5-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 4-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 3-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 2-
Mar 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 1-
Mar 11, 2024Template Order-
Mar 11, 2024Receipt-
Mar 11, 2024Outcome Of The Order-
Mar 11, 2024Hearing Invitation-
Mar 11, 2024Final Order Deadline
Mar 8, 2024Request To Extend A Time Period-
Mar 4, 2024Comments To Preliminary Objection-
Mar 4, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024Preliminaryobjection-
Feb 19, 2024List Of Documents-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2 Confirmation Of Receipt-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D2A Confirmation Of Receipt En-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1 Notice Of Appeal-
Feb 19, 2024Exhibit D1A Notice Of Appeal En-
Feb 19, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709-
Feb 16, 2024240214 Mal Preliminary Objection Upc EP709 Corrected-
Jan 18, 2024Power Of Attorney-
Jan 18, 2024Notification Of Service-
Jan 18, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Jan 18, 2024Confirmation Of Service Email Received-
Jan 18, 2024App R293 Receipt-
Jan 18, 2024Application-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Jan 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case-
Jan 2, 2024Panel Appointment-
Jan 2, 2024Letter For Service-
Jan 2, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow-
Dec 25, 2023Document From Epo-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 21, 2023Revocation Action (Amended Pleading)-
Dec 21, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Response To The Request For Amendments-
Dec 21, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B New-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 21, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-
Dec 21, 2023Epo Request For Case Pending-
Dec 21, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging-
Dec 19, 2023Formal Checks Request For Correction-
Dec 15, 2023Revocation Action EP709-
Dec 15, 2023Payment Receipt-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 9-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 8-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 7-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 6-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 5-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 4-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 3-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 2-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 14-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 13-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 12-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 11-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10D-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10C-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10B-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10A-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 10-
Dec 15, 2023Exhibit B&B 1-

More cases involving EP2044709B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ACT_595045/2023Jan 18, 2024Nokia TechnologyMala

More cases involving Nokia Technology

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
App_29031/2024May 23, 2024Nokia Technology -
ACT_595045/2023Jan 18, 2024Nokia TechnologyMala

More cases involving Mala

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 9, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APL_26889/2024May 15, 2024MalaNokia Technology
UPC_COA_227/2024May 15, 2024MalaNokia Technology
App_8708/2024Feb 19, 2024MalaNokia Technology