IP Verse

F Hoffman LA Roche vs. AIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland - UPC_CFI_504/2023

The case UPC_CFI_504/2023 was filed by the plaintiff F Hoffman LA Roche against the defendant AIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland, Dinno Sante SAI, Rubin Medical, and others on 02 Jan, 2024.

Case Timeline

02 Jan, 2024
Case Filed
19 Apr, 2024
Statement of Defence
23 Aug, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
29 Mar, 2025
Written Procedure
29 Mar, 2025
Interim Conference
29 Mar, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_504/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP1970677

    Filing Date:

    02 Jan, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • F Hoffman LA Roche

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Christof Augenstein

    Defendants:

    • AIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland
    • Dinno Sante SAI
    • Rubin Medical
    • Tandem Diabetes Care
    • Tandem Diabetes Care Europe
    • Vitalaire

    Defendant Representative:

    • Christine Kanz
    • Roland KÜPPERS

    Judges:

    • Christoph Schober
    • Jule Schumacher
    • Margot Kokke
    • Ronny Thomas

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Dusseldorf

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Jul 25, 2025Case Closure Formal Check
Jun 30, 2025Zuruckweisung Antrage Auf Ruckerstattung
Jun 30, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 30, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Jun 24, 2025Receipt
Jun 24, 202506 24 Ld Duesseldorf Antrag Rueckerstattung Gerichtsgebuehren Signiert
Jun 20, 2025Schliessung Des Workflows
Jun 20, 2025Receipt
Jun 20, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 20, 2025Bestatigung Vergleich Klagerinnen Und Beklagte Zu 6
Jun 20, 2025Bestatigung Vergleich Klagerinnen Und Beklagte Zu 3 Bis 5
Jun 18, 2025Schliessung Des Workflows
Jun 18, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 18, 2025Order R. 262A VERFO
Jun 18, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Jun 18, 202506 18 Antrag Rueckerstattung Gerichtsgebuehren Roche Ep 677 Upc Dus Signed
Jun 17, 2025Comments Pursuant To Rop264
Jun 17, 2025250617 S11866 24 01 Stellungnahme Geheimnisschutzantrag
Jun 13, 2025Receipt
Jun 13, 2025Pre Order R. 262A VERFO
Jun 13, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 13, 2025Confirmation Of Appointment
Jun 13, 2025Comments Pursuant To Rule 264
Jun 12, 2025Antrag Nach R. 262.2 VERFO
Jun 12, 2025Antrag Nach 262A VERFO
Jun 11, 2025Receipt
Jun 11, 2025Pre Order R. 262A VERFO
Jun 11, 2025Aufhebung Des Verkundungstermins
Jun 11, 2025Antrag R 365 Vitalaire
Jun 11, 2025Antrag R 262A Vitalaire
Jun 11, 2025Antrag R 262.2 Vitalaire
Jun 11, 2025Anlage Kap S 01 Streng Vertraulich
Jun 11, 2025250611 S11866 24 01 R.365 Antrag
Jun 10, 2025Exhibit 1
Jun 10, 2025Antrag R 365 Roche
Jun 10, 2025Antrag Nach R. 365 VERFO
Jun 10, 2025Antrag Nach R. 262.2 VERFO
Jun 10, 2025Antrag Nach 262 A VERFO
Jun 4, 2025Verlegung Des Verkundungstermins
Jun 4, 2025Receipt
Jun 4, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 4, 2025Antrag Verlegung Verkuendungstermin Roche
Jun 2, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 2, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Jun 2, 2025Bestatigung Teilvergleich
May 28, 2025Schliessung Des Workflows
May 28, 2025R. 262A Rop Order
May 28, 2025Outcome Of The Order
May 28, 2025Comments Pursuant To Rop264
May 28, 2025250528 S11866 24 01 Stellungnahme Geheimnisschutzantrag
May 27, 2025Template Order
May 27, 2025R. 262A VERFO Anhorung
May 23, 2025Receipt
May 23, 2025Ld Dus 2025 05 23 Antrag 365 1 Lk Dusseldorf Signiert
May 23, 2025Ld Dus 2025 05 23 Antrag 262 Signiert
May 23, 2025Ld Dus 2025 05 23 Antrag 262A Signiert
May 23, 2025Antrag R 365 Roche EP677Upc Duesseldorf
May 23, 2025Anlage Bby 1 Strictly Confidential
May 21, 2025Verlegung Des Verkundungstermins
May 20, 2025Headnote And Keywords
May 20, 2025Geheimhaltungsanordnung
May 20, 2025E Mail
May 20, 2025Dokument Zur Akte
May 19, 2025Stellungnahme Roche
May 15, 2025Receipt
May 15, 2025Pre Order R. 262A VERFO
May 14, 2025Antrag 262A Signiert
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 12 Hra Roche Diabetes
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 11 Hra Roche Diagnostics
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 10 Registerrolle
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 09 Written Witness Statement Vitalaire Gmbh
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 09A Written Witness Statement Vitalaire Gmbh De
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 08 Website Diabetiker Bedarf
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 07 Website Diabetes News
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 06 Wws Shannon Hansen
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 06A Wws Shannon Hansen De
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 05 Roche Letter
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 05A Roche Letter De
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 04 Accu Chek Combo
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 03 Accu Chek Solo
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 02 Accu Chek Insight
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 01 Auszug Dqa
May 13, 2025Anlage Bby 01 Auszug Dqa
May 13, 202505 13 Antrag Anordnung Sicherheit Final Und Eingereicht Signiert
Apr 30, 2025Tandem Request For Access To Audio Recording Of Oral Hearing
Apr 30, 2025Receipt
Apr 11, 2025597323/Oh/Dus Loc/Upc202504090930Am/S01
Apr 9, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Apr 9, 2025Ladung Zur Mundlichen Verhandlung
Apr 9, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Apr 9, 2025Hearing Dates
Apr 7, 2025Tandem Comment On Procedural Order From 2 April
Apr 7, 2025Stellungnahme Roche
Apr 7, 2025Hrm B12 Uebersicht Ziff I
Apr 7, 2025Exhibit D10
Apr 7, 2025Ablauf Der Mundlichen Verhandlung
Apr 7, 2025250407 S11866 24 01 Stellungnahme Vorbereitung Mv
Apr 2, 2025Template Order
Apr 2, 2025Anordnung Im Zwischenverfahren
Mar 29, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Mar 29, 2025Abschluss Schriftliches Verfahren
Mar 14, 2025Verfahrensanordnung Simultanverdolmetschung
Mar 14, 2025Schliessung Des Workflows
Mar 14, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 14, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Mar 14, 2025Comment On Preliminary Procedural Order
Mar 13, 2025Stellungnahme Roche
Mar 13, 2025Receipt
Mar 13, 2025250313 S11866 24 01 Stellungnahme Vitalaire
Mar 13, 2025250313 S11866 24 01 Stellungnahme
Mar 12, 2025Antraege Roche
Mar 7, 2025Request For Simultaneous Interpretation R 109
Mar 7, 2025Receipt
Mar 7, 2025Pre Order (Ii) Simultanverdolmetschung
Mar 6, 2025Receipt
Mar 6, 2025Pre Order R. 109 VERFO
Mar 6, 2025250306 S11866 24 01 R109 Request
Feb 26, 2025Panel Appointment
Feb 25, 2025Receipt
Feb 24, 2025250224 Rejoinder To Amendment (Tandem)
Feb 4, 2025Ladung Zur Mundlichen Verhandlung
Feb 4, 2025Hearing Dates
Dec 9, 2024Panel Appointment
Nov 29, 2024Order R.37.2 Art. 33
Nov 8, 2024Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Oct 22, 2024Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Oct 16, 2024Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Oct 14, 2024Order R. 28 Rop Oral Hearing
Oct 14, 2024Hearing Dates
Sep 30, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 30, 2024Application Rop293 Receipt
Sep 20, 2024Stellungnahme Roche Terminverhinderungen Signed
Sep 20, 2024Kommentare Zur Verfugbarkeit Fur Anhorungen
Sep 20, 2024Application To Change A Representataive
Sep 20, 2024Application Rop293
Sep 20, 2024240920 S11979 24 01 Stellungnahme Mv (002)
Sep 18, 2024Stellungnahme Roche Signed
Sep 18, 2024Comment
Sep 18, 2024240918 S11979 24 01 Stellungnahme Aussetzung
Sep 17, 2024Termin Zur Mundlichen Verhandlung
Sep 16, 2024Stellungnahme Roche Signed
Sep 16, 2024Response
Sep 16, 2024240916 S11979 24 01 Stellungnahme Mv
Sep 9, 2024Template Order
Sep 9, 2024R. 28 VERFO Anhorung Termin Zur Mundlichen Verhandlung
Sep 9, 2024Hearing Dates
Sep 6, 2024Anhoerung Parteien
Aug 24, 2024Hrm B9 US4643723
Aug 24, 2024Hrm B11 US6010485A
Aug 24, 2024Hrm B10 EP1633417B1
Aug 24, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 24, 2024240824 S11979 24 01 Duplik EP677
Aug 23, 2024Rejoinder And Reply To Counterclaim
Aug 23, 2024Annex C7
Aug 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jun 24, 2024Replik
Jun 24, 2024Anlage Kap 32 De
Jun 24, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
May 7, 2024Headnote And Keyword Translated
Apr 30, 2024Headnote And Keyword Translated
Apr 30, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Apr 22, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Apr 19, 2024Statement Of Defence
Apr 19, 2024Receipt
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B8 EP1970677A1
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B7 Schreiben V 2312008
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B6 EP0980690A2
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B5 US5807321A
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B4 WO2007000064A1
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B3 US2005159708A1
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B2 Ch668224A5
Apr 19, 2024Hrm B1 Widerklage Auf Nichtigkeit
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit E2
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit E1
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D9
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D8
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D7
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D6
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D5
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D4
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D3
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D2
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit D1
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C6
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C5
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C4
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C3
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C2
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit C1
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit B2
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit B1
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit A2
Apr 19, 2024Exhibit A1
Apr 19, 2024Application For Confidentiality
Apr 19, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Apr 19, 2024240419 S11866 24 01 Klageerwiderung
Apr 11, 2024Rule 21.2 Anordnung
Apr 11, 2024Rule 21
Apr 11, 2024Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome
Mar 22, 2024Stellungnahme
Mar 22, 2024Further Comments Preliminary Objection
Mar 21, 2024Postal Service B1
Mar 21, 2024Notification Of Service
Mar 15, 2024Preliminary Order
Mar 14, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Mar 14, 2024Fristvlg
Mar 13, 2024Stellungnahme Roche Auf Einspruch Signed
Mar 13, 2024Receipt
Mar 13, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Mar 12, 2024R.9 Order
Mar 12, 2024Fristverlaengerung
Mar 12, 2024Anlage Einspruch Signiert
Mar 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 8, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Mar 8, 2024Einspruch
Mar 8, 2024Eingangsbestaetigung
Mar 6, 2024Stellungnahme Roche Auf Einspruch Signed
Mar 6, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Feb 21, 2024Preliminary Objection DATED 21 February
Feb 21, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Feb 16, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jan 29, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jan 26, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jan 26, 2024Document From Epo
Jan 25, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jan 23, 2024Postal Service B6
Jan 23, 2024Postal Service B 5
Jan 23, 2024Postal Service B4
Jan 23, 2024Postal Service B3
Jan 23, 2024Postal Service B2
Jan 23, 2024Notification Of Service
Jan 3, 2024Receipt
Jan 3, 2024Panel Appointment
Jan 3, 2024Letter For Service
Jan 3, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jan 3, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Dec 27, 2023Klage
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 31
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 30
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 29
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 28
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 27
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 26
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 25
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 24
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 23
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 22
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 21
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 20
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 19
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 18 Teil 2
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 18 Teil 1
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 17
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 16
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 15
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 14
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 13
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 12
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 11
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 10
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 09
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 08
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 07
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 06
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 05
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 04
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 03
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 02
Dec 27, 2023Anlage Kap 01
Dec 27, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP1970677B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
CC_20972/2024Apr 19, 2024Rubin Medical, Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care EuropeF Hoffman LA Roche, Roche
CC_21542/2024Apr 19, 2024AIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland, Dinno Sante SAI, VitalaireF Hoffman LA Roche, Roche
ACT_597323/2023Jan 2, 2024F Hoffman LA Roche, RocheAIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland, Dinno Sante SAI, Rubin Medical, Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe, Vitalaire

More cases involving F Hoffman LA Roche

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_29093/2025Jun 19, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche -
ORD_27832/2025Jun 11, 2025F Hoffman LA RocheAIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland, Dinno Sante SAI, Rubin Medical, Tandem Diabetes Care, Tandem Diabetes Care Europe, Vitalaire
APP_24380/2025May 23, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche -

More cases involving AIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ORD_27832/2025Jun 11, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche, RocheAIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland
ORD_24208/2025May 21, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche, RocheAIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland
ORD_24106/2025May 20, 2025F Hoffman LA Roche, RocheAIR Liquide Healthcare Nederland