IP Verse

Headwater Research vs. Samsung Electronics - UPC_CFI_54/2024

The case UPC_CFI_54/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Headwater Research against the defendant Samsung Electronics on 12 Feb, 2024.

Case Timeline

12 Feb, 2024
Case Filed
08 Jul, 2024
Statement of Defence
09 Sep, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
24 Feb, 2025
Written Procedure
24 Feb, 2025
Rejoinder
24 Feb, 2025
Interim Conference
24 Feb, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_54/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP2391947

    Filing Date:

    12 Feb, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Headwater Research

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Thomas Adam

    Defendants:

    • Samsung Electronics
    • Samsung Electronics France

    Defendant Representative:

    • Denise Benz

    Judges:

    • Andras Kupecz
    • Eric Augarde
    • Matthias Zigann
    • Tobias Pichlmaier

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Munich

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Sep 29, 2025Receipt
Sep 29, 2025Cover Sheet
Sep 29, 2025Application
Sep 25, 2025Final Order
Sep 25, 2025Action.Issuedecision
Sep 24, 2025Receipt
Sep 24, 2025Cover Sheet
Sep 24, 2025Application
Sep 18, 2025Receipt
Sep 18, 2025R 265 Observations
Sep 17, 2025Application To Withdraw Action Pursuant To R. 265.1 Rop
Aug 1, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Aug 1, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Aug 1, 2025Final Order
Aug 1, 2025Decisionoutcome
Aug 1, 2025Decision
Jul 29, 2025Oral Hearing Reference
May 5, 2025Receipt
May 3, 2025Submission Of Further Documentation Regarding Parallel Proceedings On Standing
May 3, 2025Exhibit K Verdict Ii
May 3, 2025Exhibit K R R Ii
May 3, 2025Exhibit K Order Ii
Apr 24, 2025R 262A Final Order Anonymized
Apr 22, 2025Hearing Dates
Apr 16, 2025Summons
Apr 8, 2025Response To Request For Panel Review R. 333 Rop
Apr 8, 2025Comments On Request R. 263 Rop
Apr 3, 2025Workflow Closed
Apr 3, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 31, 2025Receipt
Mar 28, 2025Request For Term Extension
Mar 24, 2025Observations
Mar 21, 2025Summons For
Mar 21, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Mar 21, 2025Receipt
Mar 21, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Mar 21, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 20, 2025Request For Leave To Change Claim, R. 263 Rop
Mar 20, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 20, 2025Annex K Request I
Mar 20, 2025262 A Final
Mar 18, 2025Request For Panel Review, R. 333.1 Rop
Mar 17, 2025Receipt
Mar 17, 2025262 A Oberservations
Mar 14, 2025R 105.5 (2)
Mar 14, 2025Hearing Dates
Mar 13, 2025Submissions Re: Clarification Of Formal Requests And Of Amounts Of Costs
Mar 13, 2025R. 262A Rop Confidentiality Request
Mar 13, 2025R. 262.2 Rop Confidentiality Request
Mar 13, 2025Comments On Enforcement Security Confidential
Mar 13, 2025Comments Of Enforcement Security Confidential
Mar 13, 2025Annex B16 Confidential
Mar 13, 2025Annex B15 Confidential
Mar 13, 2025Annex B14 Confidential
Mar 7, 2025Order Ord 69051 Anonymized
Mar 3, 2025R 105.5 Rop
Mar 3, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Feb 28, 2025Interim Conference Recording
Feb 24, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Feb 24, 2025Interim Conference Decision
Feb 24, 2025Fix Interim Conference Date
Feb 21, 2025Preparation Of Interim Conference
Feb 21, 2025Comments Regarding Interim Conference
Feb 10, 2025Receipt
Feb 6, 2025Further Brief R. 36 Confidential
Feb 6, 2025Exhibit K Witness Raleigh
Feb 6, 2025Confidentiality Request
Jan 24, 2025R 9 Topics For Ic
Jan 24, 2025R 9 Comments
Jan 24, 2025R 263
Jan 24, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 24, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Jan 24, 2025262 A Final
Jan 22, 2025Receipt
Jan 21, 2025Observations On R. 36 Request
Jan 21, 2025Further Written Pleading R. 36 Rop Confidential
Jan 21, 2025Confidentiality Request
Jan 21, 2025Annex B13 Confidential
Jan 13, 2025Receipt
Jan 13, 2025R 36 Final
Jan 13, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 10, 2025Request R. 36 Rop
Dec 31, 2024Template Order
Dec 31, 2024R 265 Final
Dec 31, 2024R 263 Comments
Dec 31, 2024R 190 R 265 Final
Dec 31, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 17, 2024Request For Leave To Change Claim (R. 263 Rop)
Dec 17, 2024Receipt
Dec 13, 2024Receipt
Dec 12, 2024Receipt
Dec 11, 2024Withdrawal App 40275
Dec 11, 2024Withdrawal App 40273
Dec 10, 2024Order R 262 A Comments
Dec 10, 2024Order R 190
Nov 29, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 29, 2024Comments On Confidentiality Order
Nov 29, 2024262 A Final
Nov 19, 2024R 9 R 262A Lodge
Nov 19, 2024R9 R 262A
Nov 19, 2024Exhibit Bp01 Qualcomm
Nov 19, 2024Confidentiality Request Qualcomm
Nov 19, 2024Brief Of Qualcomm
Nov 12, 2024Template Order
Nov 12, 2024Receipt
Nov 12, 2024R 190 Final
Nov 12, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 12, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Nov 12, 2024262 A Comments
Nov 11, 2024Rejoinder Confidential
Nov 11, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262A Rop
Nov 11, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262.2 Rop
Nov 11, 2024Annex B Rdcfr
Nov 11, 2024Annex B Daap
Nov 11, 2024Annex B12
Nov 11, 2024Annex B11
Nov 11, 2024Annex B10
Nov 11, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 5, 2024Panel Appointment
Oct 28, 2024R 37.2 Final Signed
Oct 14, 2024Comments R. 37.2 Rop
Oct 14, 2024Comments On R. 37.2 Rop And Tqj
Oct 11, 2024Further Comments On R190 Request
Oct 11, 2024Comments R. 190 Rop
Oct 11, 2024Annex Rop 190 B2
Oct 2, 2024R 37.2 Comments
Oct 2, 2024R 158 Final
Oct 2, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Oct 1, 2024R 262A Final
Oct 1, 2024R 190 Comments (2)
Oct 1, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Sep 16, 2024Scheduling Final
Sep 16, 2024Hearing Dates
Sep 13, 2024Edtx Docket Control Order
Sep 13, 2024Comments On Proposed Hearing Dates
Sep 13, 2024Comments On Hearing Dates
Sep 10, 2024Scheduling Comments
Sep 10, 2024Reply R. 29A Rop
Sep 10, 2024Hearing Dates
Sep 10, 2024Exegesis Requests Soc Reply
Sep 10, 2024Edtx Transcript Evidentiary Hearing
Sep 10, 2024Edtx Order
Sep 10, 2024Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation
Sep 10, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 9, 2024Reply R. 29A
Sep 9, 2024Exegesis Requests Soc Reply
Sep 9, 2024Edtx Transcript Evidentiary Hearing
Sep 9, 2024Edtx Order
Sep 9, 2024Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation
Sep 9, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 29, 2024Response Of Qualcomm
Aug 29, 2024R 190 Comments
Aug 21, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 20, 2024Proof Of Service
Aug 20, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 16, 2024Response To Request For Security For Costs
Aug 15, 2024Response To Request For Security For Costs
Aug 15, 2024Exhibit K Proo
Aug 15, 2024Exhibit K Edtx
Aug 15, 2024Comments On R 190 Request
Aug 14, 2024Comments On Requests For Term Extension
Aug 12, 2024Comments Pursuant To R. 264 Rop
Aug 6, 2024Letter For Service
Aug 5, 2024Term Extension Comments
Aug 5, 2024R 158 Comments
Aug 5, 2024190 Requests Comments
Aug 1, 2024R 262A Further Comments
Jul 25, 2024Comments On Confidentiality Club
Jul 23, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jul 22, 2024Statement Of Defence Confidential
Jul 22, 2024Response To Request For Correction Following Formal Checks
Jul 22, 2024Exhibit Rfc Ia 1
Jul 22, 2024Annex B Cfr
Jul 22, 2024Annex B9 Confidential
Jul 22, 2024Annex B8
Jul 22, 2024Annex B7
Jul 22, 2024Annex B6
Jul 22, 2024Annex B5.01 24
Jul 22, 2024Annex B5
Jul 22, 2024Annex B4
Jul 22, 2024Annex B3
Jul 22, 2024Annex B2
Jul 22, 2024Annex B1
Jul 15, 2024R 262A Comments
Jul 15, 2024Confidentiality Order
Jul 10, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Jul 10, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 9, 2024Receipt
Jul 8, 2024Statement Of Defence Confidential
Jul 8, 2024Receipt
Jul 8, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262 Rop
Jul 8, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262A Rop
Jul 8, 2024Annex B Cfr
Jul 8, 2024Annex B9 Confidential
Jul 8, 2024Annex B8
Jul 8, 2024Annex B7
Jul 8, 2024Annex B6
Jul 8, 2024Annex B5.01 24
Jul 8, 2024Annex B5
Jul 8, 2024Annex B4
Jul 8, 2024Annex B3
Jul 8, 2024Annex B2
Jul 8, 2024Annex B1
Jul 8, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jul 6, 2024Request For Term Extension
Jul 6, 2024Request For Security
Jul 6, 2024Request For Document Production
Jul 6, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262 Rop
Jul 6, 2024Confidentiality Request R. 262A Rop
Jul 6, 2024Annex Rop 190 B1
Jul 6, 2024Annex Rop 158 B2
Jul 6, 2024Annex Rop 158 B1
Jun 13, 2024R 323 Final
Jun 13, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Jun 13, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Jun 6, 2024Stellungnahme Zu Antrag Nach Art. 49(5) Epgu
May 27, 2024Procedural Order Art. 49.5 Comments
May 24, 2024Receipt
May 23, 2024Exhibit B1
May 23, 2024Antrag Art. 49(5) Upca
Apr 4, 2024Verfahrensanordnung
Apr 4, 2024Notification Of Service
Apr 3, 2024Receipt
Apr 3, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Apr 3, 2024Fva Final
Apr 2, 2024Fristverlangerungsantrag
Apr 2, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 25, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 14, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Mar 13, 2024Sendeverfolgung Dhl Samsung Electronics France S.A
Mar 13, 2024Einsendebeleg Samsung Electronics France S.A.I.
Mar 13, 2024Confirmation Of Notification Of Appointment
Mar 4, 2024Notification Of Service
Mar 4, 2024Dhl Sendeverfolgung Samsung Electronics Gmbh
Feb 20, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Feb 20, 2024Document From Epo
Feb 16, 2024Letter For Service
Feb 15, 2024Panel Appointment
Feb 14, 2024Receipt
Feb 14, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Feb 14, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Feb 12, 2024Uberweisungsbeleg
Feb 12, 2024Registerauszug Fr Inpi EP947
Feb 12, 2024Registerauszug Dpma
Feb 12, 2024Merkmalsgliederung
Feb 12, 2024Klageschrift
Feb 12, 2024Klagepatent
Feb 12, 2024Inhaltsverzeichnis
Feb 12, 2024Handelsregisterauszug Bekl. 2)
Feb 12, 2024Handelsregisterauszug Bekl. 1)
Feb 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP2391947B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_CFI_822/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_823/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung Electronics, Samsung Electronics France SAIHeadwater Research
CC_40130/2024Jul 5, 2024Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research

More cases involving Headwater Research

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_35281/2025Aug 22, 2025Headwater Research -
APP_35282/2025Aug 22, 2025Headwater Research -
ORD_33880/2025Jul 29, 2025Headwater Research -

More cases involving Samsung Electronics

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_CFI_822/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_823/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung Electronics, Samsung Electronics France SAIHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_833/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research