IP Verse

Motorola Mobility vs. Asus Computer - UPC_CFI_303/2024

The case UPC_CFI_303/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Motorola Mobility against the defendant Asus Computer, Asustek Computer on 10 Jun, 2024. The case decision was made on Oct 10, 2025.

Case Timeline

10 Jun, 2024
Case Filed
26 Nov, 2024
Statement of Defence
02 Jul, 2025
Written Procedure
02 Jul, 2025
Interim Conference
02 Jul, 2025
Oral Procedure
Oct 10, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_303/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP3972309

    Filing Date:

    10 Jun, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Oral Phase

    Plaintiffs:

    • Motorola Mobility

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Vanessa Werlin

    Defendants:

    • Asus Computer
    • Asustek Computer
    • Asustek UK

    Defendant Representative:

    • Alexander Wiese

    Judges:

    • Klaus Loibner
    • Matthias Zigann
    • Peter Agergaard
    • Tobias Pichlmaier

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Munich

Case Decision

    Decision Date:

    Oct 10, 2025

    Decision Document:

    View document

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Oct 11, 2025Action.Phasechange
Oct 10, 2025Decision
Oct 10, 2025Action.Issuedecision
Sep 26, 2025Order
Sep 26, 2025Action.Issueorder
Jul 17, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jul 17, 2025Kenntnisnahme
Jul 15, 2025Receipt
Jul 9, 2025Lenovo Klarstellung Antrage In Mundlicher Verhandlung
Jul 9, 2025Anlage Fbd H0A
Jul 9, 2025Anlage Fbd H0
Jul 3, 2025Workflow Geschlossen
Jul 3, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jul 2, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Jul 2, 2025Terminierung
Jul 2, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Jul 2, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Jul 2, 2025Hearing Dates
Jun 30, 2025Receipt
Jun 28, 2025Nachgelassene Stellungnahme Lenovo Frand
Jun 28, 2025Geheimhaltungsantrag Nach R. 262.2 VERFO Epg
Jun 28, 2025Anlage Fbd 126
Jun 28, 2025Anlage Fbd 125 V
Jun 28, 2025Anlage Fbd 124 V
Jun 11, 2025Stellungnahme App 27147 26943
Jun 11, 2025Stellungnahme App 26943
Jun 10, 2025Receipt
Jun 6, 2025Wks Kar 13
Jun 6, 2025Wks Kar 12
Jun 6, 2025Wks Kar 11
Jun 6, 2025Wks Kar 10
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Request Rop9
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Request Rop 262.2 Redacted
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Request Rop 262
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Request Rop 262.2 Redacted
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Request Rop 262
Jun 6, 202520250606 Motorola Asus EP309 Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Additional Frand Brief
May 21, 2025Panel Appointment
May 17, 2025Protokoll Ic
May 17, 2025Outcome Of The Order
May 15, 2025Hearing Dates
May 12, 2025Receipt
May 9, 2025Anlage Fbd T 17
May 9, 2025Anlage Fbd T 16
May 9, 2025Anlage Fbd T 11A
May 9, 202525 05 09 Stellungnahme Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309
Apr 25, 202525 04 25 Stellungnahme Zwischenanhoerung Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309
Apr 25, 202520250425 Motorola Asus EP309 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Submission Re Interim Conference
Apr 11, 2025Wks T 2
Apr 11, 2025Wks T 1
Apr 11, 2025Wks Kar 9
Apr 11, 2025Wks Kar 8
Apr 11, 2025Wks Kar 7
Apr 11, 2025Receipt
Apr 11, 2025Kwy 5
Apr 11, 2025E9
Apr 11, 2025E8
Apr 11, 2025E6A
Apr 11, 2025E2A
Apr 11, 2025E10
Apr 11, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Apr 11, 202520250411 Motorola Asus EP309 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Rejoinder Tech
Apr 11, 202520250411 Motorola Asus EP309 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Rejoinder Frand
Apr 11, 202520250411 Motorola Asus Ep 309 Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Rejoinder Frand 262.2 Request
Apr 11, 202520250411 Motorola Asus Ep 309 Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Brief Re Rejoinder
Mar 27, 2025Terminierung
Mar 10, 2025Receipt
Mar 10, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Mar 10, 2025Anordnung App 11428
Mar 8, 2025Exhibit
Mar 8, 2025Deadline Extension Request
Feb 5, 2025Receipt
Feb 4, 2025Replik
Feb 4, 2025Anlagenkonvolut Fbd H 1A
Feb 4, 2025Anlagenkonvolut Fbd H 1
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 9
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 15
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 14
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 13
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 12A
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 12
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 11
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd T 10
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 123
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 122
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 121
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 120 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 119 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 118 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 117 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 116 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 115 V
Feb 4, 2025Anlage Fbd 114 V
Feb 4, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Feb 4, 202525 02 04 Hinweis Einheitliche Replik Cc Aenderung Patent Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309
Feb 4, 202525 02 04 Geheimhaltungsantrag Replik Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309
Jan 10, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 10, 2025Fv
Jan 9, 2025Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome
Dec 20, 2024Brief Re Extension Of Deadline
Dec 17, 2024Stellungnahme Fva
Dec 17, 2024Receipt
Dec 16, 202424 12 16 Fva Replik Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309 Upc Cfi 303 2024
Dec 11, 2024Unterrichtung Einspruch
Dec 6, 2024Panel Appointment
Dec 4, 2024Hearing Dates
Nov 28, 2024Receipt
Nov 28, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Nov 27, 2024Antrag Geheimhaltung
Nov 26, 2024Schreiben Zur Klageerwiderung
Nov 26, 2024Klageerwiderung
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 6
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 5
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 4
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 3
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 2
Nov 26, 2024Anlage Wks Kar 1
Nov 26, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 16, 2024Unterrichtung Einspruch Rop 20
Sep 26, 2024Commentpreliminaryobjection
Sep 26, 202424 09 26 Stn Einspruch Fbd Lenovo Vs Asus Ep 309 Upc Cfi 303 2024 App 5143 2024
Sep 12, 2024Wks E 3
Sep 12, 2024Wks E 2
Sep 12, 2024Wks E 1
Sep 12, 2024Preliminary Objection DEF 3
Sep 12, 2024Preliminaryobjection
Aug 21, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Aug 21, 2024Fva
Aug 13, 2024Verfahrensanordnung
Aug 13, 2024Receipt
Aug 13, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 12, 2024Deadline Extension Request
Aug 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 29, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 2, 2024Zustellnachweis
Jul 2, 2024Notification Of Service
Jun 25, 2024Letter For Service
Jun 18, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 14, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jun 14, 2024Document From Epo
Jun 11, 2024Receipt
Jun 11, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 11, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jun 11, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jun 10, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 08 Standard 37.340 V15.16
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 07 Standard 38.331 V15.24
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 06 Merkmalsgliederung Anspruch 11
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 05 Merkmalsgliederung Anspruch 1
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 04 Epa Mitteilung Einheitliche Wirkung
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 03 Up Uebersicht
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 02 Auszug Epa Register
Jun 10, 2024Fbd T 01 Patentschrift Klagepatent
Jun 10, 2024Anlagenkonvolut Fbd 113 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlagenkonvolut Fbd 112 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlagenkonvolut Fbd 105 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlagenkonvolut Fbd 103 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlagenkonvolut Fbd 102 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 11 Screenshots Instagram
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 111 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 110 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 10 Onlineshops Epgue Mitgliedsstaaten
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 109 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 108 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 107 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 106 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 104 V
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 101 Asus Etsi Declaration
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 100 Lenovo Etsi Declaration
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 0 Zahlungsnachweis Gerichtskosten
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 09 Fotos Testkaeufe Asus B7402Fv Expert Book B7 Flip
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 08 Fotos Testkaeufe Asus B2402Cb Expert Book
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 07 Fotos Testkaeufe Asus Zenphone 11 Ultra
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 06C Rog Phone 8 E Manual Deutsch
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 06B Fotos Testkaeufe Asus Fr Rog Phone 8
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 06A Fotos Testkaeufe Asus De Rog Phone 8
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 05 (Konvolut) Rechnungen Testkaeufe
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 04 Handelsregisterauszug Asus Uk Limited
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 03 Handelsregisterauzug Asus Computer Germany
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 02 Auszug Geschaeftsbericht Asus
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 02A Asustek Computer Inc. Ico Report
Jun 10, 2024Anlage Fbd 01 Annual Report Lenovo
Jun 10, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jun 10, 202424 06 10 Klageschrift Ep 309 Upc Len Vs Asus
Jun 10, 202424 06 10 Geheimhaltungsantrag Klageschrift No 34697 Upc Cfi 303 2024 VS Asus EP309
Jun 10, 202424 06 10 Formal Response To The Request For Amendments Act 33773 2024 Upc Cfi 303 2024 Ep 309

More cases involving EP3972309B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
CC_60915/2024Nov 26, 2024Asus Computer, Asustek Computer, Asustek UKMotorola Mobility
UPC_CFI_688/2024Nov 26, 2024Asus Computer, Asustek Computer, Asustek UKMotorola Mobility
ACT_33773/2024Jun 10, 2024Motorola MobilityAsus Computer, Asustek Computer, Asustek UK

More cases involving Motorola Mobility

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_33191/2025Jul 18, 2025Motorola Mobility, Motorola Mobility Germany, Motorola Mobility Sales -
APP_33196/2025Jul 18, 2025Motorola Mobility, Motorola Mobility Germany, Motorola Mobility Sales -
APP_33062/2025Jul 17, 2025Motorola Mobility, Motorola Mobility Germany, Motorola Mobility Sales -

More cases involving Asus Computer

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_34857/2025Aug 14, 2025Asus Computer -
APP_34590/2025Aug 12, 2025Asus Computer -
APP_34645/2025Aug 12, 2025Asus Computer -