IP Verse

Nanostring Europe vs. President And Fellows OF Harvard College - UPC_CFI_252/2023

The case UPC_CFI_252/2023 was filed by the plaintiff Nanostring Europe against the defendant President And Fellows OF Harvard College on 27 Jul, 2023. The case decision was made on Jul 25, 2024.

Case Timeline

27 Jul, 2023
Case Filed
27 Jul, 2023
Counterclaim for Revocation
24 Jan, 2024
Written Procedure
24 Jan, 2024
Rejoinder
24 Jan, 2024
Interim Conference
02 Apr, 2024
Oral Procedure
Jul 25, 2024
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_252/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP2794928

    Filing Date:

    27 Jul, 2023

    Proceeding Type:

    Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Nanostring Europe

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Daniela Kinkeldey

    Defendants:

    • President And Fellows OF Harvard College

    Defendant Representative:

    • Axel Berger

    Judges:

    • Andras Kupecz
    • Eric André Enderlin
    • Ulrike Voß

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Central Division - Munich

Case Decision

    Decision Date:

    Jul 25, 2024

    Decision Document:

    View document

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Jan 3, 2025Procedural Order
Dec 17, 2024Template Order
Dec 17, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 17, 2024Order Re Release Of Security
Dec 17, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Dec 17, 2024Final Order Application To Release Security
Dec 9, 2024Reply
Nov 25, 2024241125 Nanostring Response To Order Re Security
Nov 18, 2024Preliminary Order
Oct 25, 2024Comments Re Cost Security 10 25 Signed
Oct 18, 2024Receipt
Oct 18, 2024Preliminary Order
Oct 17, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Oct 17, 2024Decision Revocation Action 252
Oct 17, 2024Decisionoutcome
Oct 17, 2024Decision Anonymised
Oct 17, 2024Bsec4
Oct 17, 2024Bsec3
Oct 17, 2024Bsec2
Oct 17, 2024Bsec1
Oct 17, 2024241017 Nanostring Request To Release Security
Sep 25, 2024Recording Of Oral Hearing Reference
Sep 18, 2024Receipt
Sep 17, 2024Rule 9 Rop Application
Sep 5, 2024Receipt
Sep 4, 2024Submission Of Harvard Re Attendees In Oral Hearing
Sep 4, 2024Submission For Costs Incurred Harvard
Sep 4, 2024Final Order
Sep 4, 2024Exhibit Bp29 Harvard Confidential
Sep 4, 2024Application For Protection Of Confidentiality R262A Harvard
Sep 3, 2024Receipt
Sep 3, 2024240903 Nanostring Attendees Oral Hearing
Aug 20, 2024Template Order
Aug 20, 2024Rop 9 Order
Aug 20, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Aug 16, 2024240816 Comments Pursuant To Rop264
Aug 14, 2024Translation Of Exhibits
Aug 14, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Aug 14, 2024Opportunity To Comment
Aug 13, 2024Request Of Harvard For Procedural Order Signed En
Aug 13, 2024Receipt
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Bp28 Harvard De
Aug 13, 2024Exhibit Bp27 Harvard En
Aug 12, 2024Receipt
Aug 12, 2024D60
Aug 12, 2024240812 Submission Forwarding De Nullity Decision
Jul 25, 2024Summons Oral Hearing
Jul 25, 2024Summons
Jul 25, 2024Rop 9 Order
Jul 25, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Jul 25, 2024Interimprocedureclosure
Jul 25, 2024Hearing Dates
Jul 24, 2024240724 Inadmissibility Of Further Submission Of Patentee
Jul 23, 2024Receipt
Jul 23, 2024Preliminary Order Re Further Submission
Jul 22, 2024Exhibit Bp 26
Jul 22, 2024Exhibit Bp 25
Jul 22, 2024Brief Harvard 07 22 Signed
May 16, 2024Receipt
May 16, 2024D59
May 16, 2024D58
May 16, 2024240516 Submission Re Closing
Apr 26, 2024Receipt
Apr 26, 2024D57
Apr 26, 2024240426 Nanostring Submission
Apr 2, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Apr 2, 2024Order Re Postponement Oral Hearing
Mar 20, 2024Brief Harvard (Signed)
Mar 20, 2024240320 Submission On Invalidity Of Ar2
Mar 15, 2024Receipt
Mar 15, 2024Preliminary Order
Mar 15, 2024D56
Mar 15, 2024240315 Submission Response R 103/105.5 Rop
Mar 8, 2024Receipt
Mar 8, 2024Preliminary Order
Mar 7, 2024Response To US043Attacks Harvard Signed
Mar 7, 2024240307 Nanostring Response To Defendant
Mar 4, 2024Receipt
Mar 4, 2024Preliminary Order Subsequent Application To Amend
Mar 1, 2024Subsequent Application To Amend The Patent 03 01 Signed
Mar 1, 2024Exhibit Bp24 Harvard En Signed
Mar 1, 2024Exhibit Bp24A Harvard En Signed
Mar 1, 2024Exhibit Bp23 Harvard De
Mar 1, 2024Exhibit Bp23A Harvard En
Feb 2, 2024Template Order
Feb 2, 2024Interim Conference Reference
Feb 2, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date
Feb 2, 2024Final Order 103/105.5 Rop
Jan 31, 2024Template Order
Jan 31, 2024Final Rop103 105 Order After Interim Conference
Jan 31, 2024Final Order Ic
Jan 24, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure
Jan 24, 2024Interimconferencedecision
Jan 16, 2024Intended Closure Written Proceedings And Interim Conference Invitation
Jan 12, 2024Rejoinder To The Reply To The Defense To An Application To Amend The Patent
Jan 12, 2024Rejoinamendpatentdefence
Jan 12, 2024D55A
Jan 12, 2024D55
Dec 27, 2023Reply To The Defence To The Application To Amend The Patent Harvard (Signed)
Dec 27, 2023Replyamendpatentdefence
Dec 27, 2023Rejoinder To The Reply To The Defence To Revocation Harvard (Signed)
Dec 27, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 12, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Dec 12, 2023Confirmation Order
Dec 5, 2023Receipt
Dec 5, 2023Confirmation Of Payment
Nov 27, 2023EP928Response To Patentee
Nov 27, 2023D54
Nov 27, 2023D53
Nov 27, 2023D52
Nov 27, 2023D51
Nov 27, 2023D50
Nov 27, 2023D49
Nov 27, 2023D48
Nov 27, 2023D47
Nov 27, 2023D46
Nov 27, 2023D45
Nov 27, 2023D44
Nov 27, 2023D43
Nov 27, 2023D42
Nov 27, 2023D41
Nov 27, 2023D40
Nov 27, 2023D39
Nov 27, 2023D38
Nov 27, 2023D37
Nov 27, 2023D36
Nov 27, 2023D35
Nov 27, 2023D34
Nov 27, 2023D33
Nov 27, 2023D32
Nov 27, 2023D31
Nov 27, 2023D30
Nov 27, 2023D29A
Nov 27, 2023D29
Nov 27, 2023D28A
Nov 27, 2023D28
Nov 27, 2023D27A
Nov 27, 2023D27
Nov 27, 2023D26A
Nov 27, 2023D26
Nov 27, 2023D25
Nov 27, 2023D24
Nov 27, 2023D23
Nov 27, 2023D22
Nov 27, 2023D21
Nov 27, 2023D20
Nov 27, 2023D19
Nov 27, 2023D18
Nov 27, 2023D17
Nov 27, 2023D16
Nov 27, 2023D15
Nov 27, 2023D14
Nov 27, 2023D13
Nov 27, 2023D12
Nov 27, 2023D11
Nov 27, 2023D10
Nov 27, 2023D09
Nov 27, 2023D08
Nov 27, 2023D07
Nov 27, 2023D06
Nov 27, 2023D05
Nov 27, 2023D04
Nov 27, 2023D03
Nov 27, 2023D02
Nov 27, 2023D01
Nov 27, 2023Amendpatentdefence
Nov 27, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 6, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Nov 6, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Nov 3, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Nov 3, 2023Order Closing Workflow
Nov 3, 2023Official Date
Nov 3, 2023Nanostring Response To Preliminary Order Rop 28 Of 2 Nov (Timing)
Nov 3, 2023Final Order Rop 28 Dd
Nov 2, 2023Template Order
Nov 2, 2023Rop28 Further Preliminary Order DATED 2 November
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp9 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp8 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp7 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp7A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp18 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp18A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp17 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp17A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp16 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp16A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp15 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp15A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp14 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp14A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp13 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp13A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp12 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp12A Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp11 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Bp10 Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Exhibit Application To Amend Patent Harvard En
Nov 2, 2023Application To Amend Patent Harvard (Signed)
Oct 31, 2023Response To Preliminary Order Rop 28 Dated
Oct 31, 2023Response To Preliminary Order Harvard (Signed)
Oct 31, 2023Bundle Of Exhibits Bp 22 Harvard De
Oct 30, 2023Final Order Security Request Rop 158
Oct 27, 2023Rop 28 Preliminary Order
Oct 27, 2023Preliminary Order Rop 28 Dated
Oct 26, 2023Receipt
Oct 26, 2023Application R 9 Rop Further Comments On Timing
Oct 20, 2023Response Of Harvard To Preliminary Order Rop 28 (Signed)
Oct 20, 2023Exhibit Bp20 Harvard De
Oct 20, 2023Bundle Of Exhibits Bp21 Harvard De
Oct 19, 2023Comments On Timing Proposed By The Central Division
Oct 16, 2023Response To Patentee Submission Re Security For Legal Costs
Oct 16, 2023Provisional Date
Oct 16, 2023Preliminary Order Rop 28 Dated
Oct 5, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Oct 4, 2023Response To Preliminary Order Harvard (Signed)
Oct 4, 2023Preliminary Objection Decisionoutcome
Oct 4, 2023Order Informing The Parties In Accordance With Rule 20.2 Rop
Oct 4, 2023Exhibit Bp4A Harvard En
Oct 4, 2023Exhibit Bp19 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Response To Defendant And To Preliminary Opinion
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp9 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp8 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp7 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp7A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp6 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp5 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp4 Harvard De
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp18 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp18A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp17 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp17A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp16 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp16A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp15 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp15A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp14 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp14A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp13 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp13A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp12 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp12A Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp11 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Exhibit Bp10 Harvard En
Sep 28, 2023Defence To Revocation Harvard Signed
Sep 28, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 22, 2023Response Of Harvard To Preliminary Order
Sep 20, 2023Template Order
Sep 20, 2023Preliminary Order Rule 9 Rop Re Security Request
Sep 15, 2023Preliminary Order 15 September
Sep 11, 2023Commentpreliminaryobjection
Sep 11, 2023Comment On Preliminary Objection
Aug 29, 2023Preliminaryobjection
Aug 28, 2023Preliminary Objection And Security For Legal Costs
Aug 28, 2023Exhibit Bp03
Aug 28, 2023Exhibit Bp02
Aug 28, 2023Exhibit Bp01
Aug 4, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Aug 1, 2023Document From Epo
Jul 28, 2023Notification Of Service
Jul 28, 2023Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 27, 2023Statementofrevocation
Jul 27, 2023Revocation Action
Jul 27, 2023Proof Of Payment
Jul 27, 2023Panel Appointment
Jul 27, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 27, 2023D45
Jul 27, 2023D44
Jul 27, 2023D43
Jul 27, 2023D42
Jul 27, 2023D41
Jul 27, 2023D40
Jul 27, 2023D39
Jul 27, 2023D38
Jul 27, 2023D37
Jul 27, 2023D36
Jul 27, 2023D35
Jul 27, 2023D34
Jul 27, 2023D33
Jul 27, 2023D32
Jul 27, 2023D31
Jul 27, 2023D30
Jul 27, 2023D29A
Jul 27, 2023D29
Jul 27, 2023D28A
Jul 27, 2023D28
Jul 27, 2023D27A
Jul 27, 2023D27
Jul 27, 2023D26A
Jul 27, 2023D26
Jul 27, 2023D25
Jul 27, 2023D24
Jul 27, 2023D23
Jul 27, 2023D22
Jul 27, 2023D21
Jul 27, 2023D20
Jul 27, 2023D19
Jul 27, 2023D18
Jul 27, 2023D17
Jul 27, 2023D16
Jul 27, 2023D15
Jul 27, 2023D14
Jul 27, 2023D13
Jul 27, 2023D12
Jul 27, 2023D11
Jul 27, 2023D10
Jul 27, 2023D09
Jul 27, 2023D08
Jul 27, 2023D07
Jul 27, 2023D06
Jul 27, 2023D05
Jul 27, 2023D04
Jul 27, 2023D03
Jul 27, 2023D02
Jul 27, 2023D01
Jul 27, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP2794928B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APL_66414/2024Dec 17, 2024President And Fellows OF Harvard CollegeNanostring Europe
UPC_COA_808/2024Dec 17, 2024President And Fellows OF Harvard CollegeNanostring Europe
APP_61570/2024Nov 18, 2024BerggrenNanostring Europe, President And Fellows OF Harvard College

More cases involving Nanostring Europe

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_22758/2025May 14, 2025Nanostring Europe -
APP_56792/2024Oct 17, 2024Nanostring Europe -
ACT_551180/2023Jul 27, 2023Nanostring EuropePresident And Fellows OF Harvard College

More cases involving President And Fellows OF Harvard College

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ORD_34900/2025Aug 15, 2025Nanostring, Nanostring Germany, Nanostring NetherlandsPresident And Fellows OF Harvard College
APL_33593/2025Jul 24, 2025Nanostring, Nanostring Germany, Nanostring NetherlandsPresident And Fellows OF Harvard College
ORD_28329/2025Jun 13, 2025VizgenPresident And Fellows OF Harvard College