IP Verse

Plant E vs. Arkyne SL - UPC_CFI_239/2023

The case UPC_CFI_239/2023 was filed by the plaintiff Plant E against the defendant Arkyne SL on 12 Jul, 2023. The case decision was made on Mar 4, 2024.

Case Timeline

12 Jul, 2023
Case Filed
09 Nov, 2023
Statement of Defence
22 Mar, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
22 Mar, 2024
Reply Filed
23 May, 2024
Written Procedure
23 May, 2024
Interim Conference
19 Nov, 2024
Oral Procedure
19 Nov, 2024
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_239/2023

    Patent Number:

    EP2137782

    Filing Date:

    12 Jul, 2023

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Plant E
    • Plant E Knowledge

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Oscar Lamme

    Defendants:

    • Arkyne SL

    Defendant Representative:

    • Bernd Allekotte

    Judges:

    • Edger Brinkman
    • Margot Kokke
    • Samuel Granata
    • Simon Walker

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - The Hague

Case Decision

    Decision Date:

    Mar 4, 2024

    Decision Document:

    View document

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Jan 22, 2025Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Jan 21, 2025Power Of Attorney
Jan 21, 2025Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jan 21, 2025Application To Change A Representative Re. Rop 293
Jan 21, 2025Application Rop293 Receipt
Jan 21, 2025Application Rop293
Dec 13, 2024This Order Is Issued For Technical Reasons Only
Dec 13, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Nov 22, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Nov 22, 2024Decisionoutcome
Nov 22, 2024Decision On The Merits
Nov 19, 2024This Order Is Not Relevant
Nov 19, 2024Summon Oral Hearing
Nov 19, 2024Oral Hearing Referencing 549536 2023 Oh Hag Loc Upc2024093010Am
Nov 19, 2024Oral Hearing Referencing 549536 2023 Ic Hag Loc Upc2024060510Am
Nov 19, 2024Interim Procedure Closure
Nov 19, 2024Hearing Dates
Nov 19, 2024Fix Interim Conference Date
Oct 1, 2024Uploading Of R.105.5 Order To Close Workflow
Oct 1, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 1, 2024Closing Of Work Flow
Sep 30, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Sep 30, 2024Order To Close Workflow
Sep 18, 2024Opportunity To Comment
Sep 17, 2024Receipt
Sep 16, 2024EP44 Helder
Sep 16, 2024E25 The Preliminary Legal Costs Estimate Pursuant To Order From 6 June And Separate Application Pursuant To R.9
Sep 13, 2024Receipt
Sep 13, 2024Gp47 Preliminary Cost Statement Bioo 13 9
Sep 13, 2024Gp46 Bioo Panel Assessment
Sep 13, 2024Gp45 Second Expert Statement By Dr Benet Gunse
Sep 13, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 13, 2024Bioo Response To Plant E Submission 13 9
Sep 13, 2024Annex To Gp45
Aug 5, 2024R.262A Confidentiality Order
Aug 2, 2024Receipt
Aug 2, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 2, 2024EP32.A Annex A E Mail Query Regarding Root Resistance Of The Cloth English Translation
Aug 2, 2024EP32.A Annex A E Mail Query Regarding Root Resistance Of The Cloth
Aug 1, 2024Receipt
Aug 1, 2024Photos Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Photo 5
Aug 1, 2024Photos Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Photo 4
Aug 1, 2024Photos Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Photo 3
Aug 1, 2024Photos Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Photo 2
Aug 1, 2024Photos Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Photo 1
Aug 1, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 8
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 7
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 6
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 5
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 4
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 3
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 2
Aug 1, 2024EP42Video Of Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9 Part 1
Aug 1, 2024EP41 E Mail Lawyer Bioo Regarding Gp9
Aug 1, 2024EP40 Expert Statement By Dr. Arends
Aug 1, 2024EP39 Of Webpage Donker Groep
Aug 1, 2024EP38 Of Linkedin Post Made By The Director Of VAN Wijnen Lelystad
Aug 1, 2024EP37 Of Webpage Of Website Age Checker
Aug 1, 2024EP36 Of Webpage Of Waybackmachine
Aug 1, 2024EP35 Of Webpage Online Platform Euroquity
Aug 1, 2024EP34Video Pitch Of Bioo On Platform Euroquity Part 4
Aug 1, 2024EP34Video Pitch Of Bioo On Platform Euroquity Part 3
Aug 1, 2024EP34Video Pitch Of Bioo On Platform Euroquity Part 2
Aug 1, 2024EP34Video Pitch Of Bioo On Platform Euroquity Part 1
Aug 1, 2024EP34Video Pitch Of Bioo On Platform Euroquity
Aug 1, 2024EP33 Third Expert Statement By Prof. Dr. Esteve Nunez
Aug 1, 2024EP32 Test Report
Aug 1, 2024EP32.D Annex To Test Report.7Z
Aug 1, 2024EP32.D Annex To Test Report.7Z
Aug 1, 2024EP32.D Annex To Test Report.7Z
Aug 1, 2024EP32.D Annex To Test Report.7Z
Aug 1, 2024EP32.D Annex To Test Report.7Z
Aug 1, 2024EP32.C Annex C De Jager
Aug 1, 2024EP32.B Annex B Quigley
Aug 1, 2024EP32.A Annex A E Mail Query Regarding Root Resistance Of The Cloth
Aug 1, 2024E24 Submission In Response To Gp36, Gp39, Further Evidence In Reply Gp9 And Test Reports Of Bioo Panels
Jun 19, 2024G02 Arkyne Technologies S.L. Statement Of Defence 9 11 2023 Further Redacted Plant E
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp46
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp17.B Letter 19 January
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit Gp17.A Letter 14 July
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45.G Part 5 Of 5
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45.G Part 4 Of 5
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45.G Part 3 Of 5
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45.G Part 2 Of 5
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45.G Part 1 Of 5
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45
Jun 19, 2024Exhibit 45
Jun 19, 2024EP17 Redacted
Jun 19, 2024E23 Request For Confidentiality Per Rule 262.2 Rop (Signed)
Jun 19, 2024E08 Reply To The Application To Provide Security For Costs (Redacted)
Jun 19, 2024E02 Request For Confidentiality Per Rule 262.2 Rop (Translation) (Signed)
Jun 19, 2024E01 Eis In Rechte Plant E V. Bioo (En Translation) Redacted
Jun 19, 2024Application To File Further Documents And Evidence Pursuant To The R105.5 Order (Signed)
Jun 19, 2024Act 549536 Arkyne Technologies S.L. Statement Of Defence 9 11 2023 Redacted
Jun 6, 2024R.105.5 Order Setting Out Decisions Taken At Interim Conference
May 31, 2024Receipt
May 30, 2024EP31Video Of Installation Of Bioo Panel Set Up Of Gp9.7Z
May 30, 2024EP31Video Of Installation Of Bioo Panel Set Up Of Gp9.7Z
May 30, 2024EP31Video Of Installation Of Bioo Panel Set Up Of Gp9.7Z
May 30, 2024EP31Video Of Installation Of Bioo Panel Set Up Of Gp9.7Z
May 30, 2024EP31Video Of Installation Of Bioo Panel Set Up Of Gp9
May 30, 2024E22 Application Pursuant To R. 9.1 Rop For Submitting Further Evidence
May 30, 2024E21 Comments Plant E Pursuant To Rule 264 Rop Regarding The Rule 9 Rop Order Of 23 May
May 30, 2024Comments On Rule 9 Application 30 May
May 23, 2024Writtenprocedureclosure
May 23, 2024R.35 And R.103 Preliminary Order
May 23, 2024Interimconferencedecision
May 21, 2024Reply To Plant E S R190 Application
May 15, 2024R.262A Confidentiality Order
May 15, 2024Outcome Of The Order
May 8, 2024Opportunity To Comment
May 7, 2024Receipt
May 1, 2024R.28 Order Setting Of Dates For Ic And Oral Hearing
May 1, 2024Hearing Dates
May 1, 2024E20 Application For Order To Produce Evidence Under R. 190
Apr 17, 2024E16 Rejoinder From Plant E To Reply From Bioo In 262A Application
Apr 12, 2024Reply To Plant E S Submission In Bioo S 262A Application
Apr 12, 2024Opportunity To Comment In Workflow 597352
Apr 9, 2024Opportunity To Comment
Apr 5, 2024E15 Submission Plant E Reply To Rule 262A Application By Bioo
Apr 5, 2024E15.1 Submission Plant E Reply To Rule 262A Application By Bioo
Mar 25, 2024Opportunity To Respond To R.262A Application
Mar 22, 2024Rejoinder In Main Proceedings And Reply Counterclaim
Mar 22, 2024R 262A Application
Mar 22, 2024Gp44 Resource
Mar 22, 2024Gp43 Xu
Mar 22, 2024Gp42 Emerson 1994
Mar 22, 2024Gp41 Hall 1980
Mar 22, 2024Gp40 Kaku
Mar 22, 2024Gp39 In Field Validation Bioosensor Brenes (Seville) Report (Unredacted)
Mar 22, 2024Gp38 Lopez Martinez Expert Opinion
Mar 22, 2024Gp37 Dr. Gunse Forcadell Expert Opinion
Mar 22, 2024Gp37.B Annexes To Gunse Report Part 2
Mar 22, 2024Gp37.B Annexes To Gunse Report Part 1
Mar 22, 2024Gp37.A Resume Dr. Gunse Forcadell
Mar 22, 2024Gp36 Assessment Of Bioo Panel Performance Light Exposure And Plant Presence Effects (Unredacted)
Mar 22, 2024Gp35 Linkedin Conversation Abraham Esteve Naroa Uria
Mar 22, 2024Gp34 Correspondence Prof Esteve With Bioo
Mar 22, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 4, 2024Confidentiality Order
Feb 15, 2024R. 37 Order Regarding The Application Of Art. 33(3) Upca
Feb 13, 2024R. 158 Order
Feb 13, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Feb 8, 2024Second Reply To 262A Application
Feb 8, 2024E13 Written Submission Per R.264 Rop Pursuant To R.262A Application
Jan 31, 2024E12 Submission Plant E Regarding The Application Of Article 33(3) Upca
Jan 26, 2024Preliminary Order
Jan 19, 2024Submission Pursuant To Rule 264 Rop Regarding The Application Of Article 33(3) Upca
Jan 17, 2024Rule 9 Procedural Order
Jan 12, 2024EP26 Bioo Ed Youtube Clips
Jan 12, 2024EP25 Statement By Prof. Dr. Esteve Nunez
Jan 12, 2024EP25.K Lin
Jan 12, 2024EP25.J Esteve Nunez
Jan 12, 2024EP25.I Panikov
Jan 12, 2024EP25.H Choudhury
Jan 12, 2024EP25.G Niessen
Jan 12, 2024EP25.F Strik
Jan 12, 2024EP25.E Maier
Jan 12, 2024EP25.D Jones
Jan 12, 2024EP25.C Paul
Jan 12, 2024EP25.B Paul
Jan 12, 2024EP25.A List Of Publications
Jan 12, 2024EP24 Plant E Team
Jan 12, 2024EP23 Bioo Deck
Jan 12, 2024EP22 E Mail Registry Upc D.D29 November
Jan 12, 2024EP21 E Mail Registry Upc D.D14 November
Jan 12, 2024E10 Reply To Statement Of Defence
Jan 12, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 13, 2023Reply To Request For Confidentiality
Nov 30, 2023Invitation To Arkyne To Comment On R. 262A Application
Nov 28, 2023EP20 Upc Email D.D13 November
Nov 28, 2023EP19 Plant E Entry In Cordis Registry
Nov 28, 2023EP18 Plant E Website Article Of Eic Grant
Nov 28, 2023EP17 Termsheet Signed
Nov 28, 2023E09 Application For Protection Of Confidential Information
Nov 28, 2023E08 Reply To The Application To Provide Security For Costs
Nov 28, 2023E08 Reply To The Application Of Security For Costs (R. 158 Rop)
Nov 16, 2023Term Extension
Nov 16, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Nov 15, 2023Receipt
Nov 14, 2023Reply To R. 158.1 Request Arkyne
Nov 14, 2023E07 Application Per R. 9(3)(A) Rop To Extend The Time Period To Reply To The Application Of Securi
Nov 13, 2023Receipt
Nov 13, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Nov 10, 2023Application Of Security For Costs (Rule 158 Rop)
Nov 9, 2023Statement Of Defence (Unsigned)
Nov 9, 2023Statement Of Defence
Nov 9, 2023Gp9
Nov 9, 2023Gp8
Nov 9, 2023Gp7
Nov 9, 2023Gp6
Nov 9, 2023Gp5
Nov 9, 2023Gp4
Nov 9, 2023Gp33
Nov 9, 2023Gp32
Nov 9, 2023Gp31
Nov 9, 2023Gp30
Nov 9, 2023Gp3
Nov 9, 2023Gp29
Nov 9, 2023Gp28
Nov 9, 2023Gp27
Nov 9, 2023Gp26
Nov 9, 2023Gp25
Nov 9, 2023Gp24
Nov 9, 2023Gp23
Nov 9, 2023Gp22
Nov 9, 2023Gp21
Nov 9, 2023Gp20
Nov 9, 2023Gp2
Nov 9, 2023Gp19
Nov 9, 2023Gp18
Nov 9, 2023Gp17
Nov 9, 2023Gp16
Nov 9, 2023Gp15
Nov 9, 2023Gp14
Nov 9, 2023Gp13
Nov 9, 2023Gp12
Nov 9, 2023Gp11
Nov 9, 2023Gp10
Nov 9, 2023Gp1
Nov 9, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 24, 2023Continuation Of The Proceedings
Oct 18, 2023Receipt
Oct 18, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Oct 18, 2023Order Of The President Ex R
Oct 18, 2023E06 Aanvullende Akte Re Verzoek Taalwijziging
Oct 13, 2023E05 Verweer Verzoek Taalwijziging
Oct 8, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Oct 5, 2023Procedurele Beslissing
Sep 29, 2023E04 Reactie Op Verzoek Tot Wijzigen Taal VAN De Procedure Ex Rule 322 Rop
Sep 27, 2023E04 Reactie Op Verzoek Tot Wijzigen Taal VAN De Procedure Ex Rule 322 Rop
Sep 26, 2023Beslissing 322 Rop
Sep 25, 2023Receipt
Sep 21, 2023Verzoek Tot Taalwijziging Namens Bioo
Sep 7, 2023Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 14, 2023Notification Of Service
Aug 14, 2023Confirmation Of Service (2)
Aug 14, 2023Confirmation Of Service
Aug 3, 2023Outcome Of The Order
Aug 3, 2023Beslissing Ex R. 7
Jul 27, 2023Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jul 26, 2023Document From Epo
Jul 24, 2023Panel Appointment
Jul 24, 2023Letter For Service
Jul 20, 2023Statementofclaim
Jul 20, 2023Receipt
Jul 20, 2023Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 17, 2023Receipt
Jul 17, 2023E03 Verzoek Ex Rule 13(Q) Rop Niet Vertalen Engelstalige Producties
Jul 13, 2023EP16 Uittreksels Handelsregister Kvk Plant E Knowledge En Plant E
Jul 13, 2023EP15 Licentieovereenkomst Plant E Knowledge En Plant E
Jul 13, 2023EP14 Bioo Urban Solutions Deck
Jul 13, 2023EP13 Screenshot Website Bioo Panel
Jul 13, 2023EP12B Eu Horizon Projectinformatie (Printed Pdf)
Jul 13, 2023EP12A Eu Horizon Projectinformatie (Screenshot)
Jul 13, 2023EP11 Bioo Panel Datasheet
Jul 13, 2023EP10 EP782Onderverdeeld In Kenmerken
Jul 13, 2023EP09 Uittreksels EP782Nationale Registers
Jul 13, 2023EP08 Brief Bioo Aan Plant E (Engels)
Jul 13, 2023EP07 Brieven Plant E Aan Bioo En Donker
Jul 13, 2023EP06 Brief Plant E Aan Bioo (Engels)
Jul 13, 2023EP05 Brief Bioo Aan Plant E (Engels)
Jul 13, 2023EP04A Brief Bioo Aan Plant E (Spaans)
Jul 13, 2023EP03A Brief Plant E Aan Bioo (Spaans)
Jul 13, 2023EP02 Interview P Vidarte Girbaulab
Jul 13, 2023EP01 EP2137782B1
Jul 13, 2023Eis In Rechte
Jul 13, 2023E02 Verzoek Om Vertrouwelijkheid Ex Rule 262.2 Rop
Jul 13, 2023Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP2137782B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_16352/2025Apr 3, 2025Redacted Natural Person NameArkyne SL, Plant E, Plant E Knowledge
APL_3486/2025Jan 22, 2025Arkyne SLPlant E, Plant E Knowledge
APL_3595/2025Jan 22, 2025Arkyne SLPlant E Knowledge

More cases involving Plant E

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_22747/2025May 14, 2025Plant E Knowledge -
UPC_CFI_832/2024Dec 20, 2024Plant E, Plant E KnowledgeArkyne SL
UPC_CFI_833/2024Dec 20, 2024Plant E KnowledgeArkyne SL

More cases involving Arkyne SL

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_16352/2025Apr 3, 2025Redacted Natural Person NameArkyne SL
APL_3486/2025Jan 22, 2025Arkyne SLPlant E, Plant E Knowledge
APL_3595/2025Jan 22, 2025Arkyne SLPlant E Knowledge