IP Verse

Samsung Electronics vs. Headwater Research - UPC_CFI_396/2024

The case UPC_CFI_396/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Samsung Electronics against the defendant Headwater Research on 05 Jul, 2024.

Case Timeline

05 Jul, 2024
Case Filed
05 Jul, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
24 Feb, 2025
Written Procedure
24 Feb, 2025
Rejoinder
24 Feb, 2025
Interim Conference
21 Mar, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 1, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_396/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP2391947

    Filing Date:

    05 Jul, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Counter Claim For Revocation

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Samsung Electronics
    • Samsung Electronics France SAI

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Denise Benz

    Defendants:

    • Headwater Research

    Defendant Representative:

    • Thomas Adam

    Judges:

    • Andras Kupecz
    • Eric Augarde
    • Matthias Zigann
    • Tobias Pichlmaier

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - Munich

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Oct 1, 2025Action.Phasechange
Sep 30, 2025Receipt
Sep 30, 2025Cover Sheet
Sep 30, 2025Application
Sep 29, 2025Order
Sep 29, 2025Final Order
Sep 29, 2025Action.Issueorder
Sep 29, 2025Action.Issuedecision
Aug 1, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Aug 1, 2025Final Order
Aug 1, 2025Decisionoutcome
Aug 1, 2025Decision
Jul 29, 2025Oral Hearing Reference
Apr 16, 2025Summons
Apr 16, 2025Hearing Dates
Apr 15, 2025Finalorder Summons For
Apr 8, 2025Response To Request For Panel Review R. 333 Rop
Apr 8, 2025Comments On Claimant Submission And R. 30.2 Rop
Apr 1, 2025Term Extension Final
Apr 1, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Apr 1, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Mar 31, 2025Receipt
Mar 28, 2025Request For Term Extension
Mar 24, 2025Observations
Mar 21, 2025Summons For
Mar 21, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Mar 21, 2025Receipt
Mar 21, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Mar 21, 2025Hearing Dates
Mar 21, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Mar 20, 2025Request For Leave To Amend Patent Pursuant To R. 30.2 Rop
Mar 20, 2025Exhibits Arscomplete A
Mar 20, 2025Exhibit Arscomplete B
Mar 20, 2025Exhibit Arscomplete A
Mar 20, 2025Additional Brief Pursuant To Orders Ord 69051 And Ord 69052
Mar 18, 2025Request For Panel Review, R. 333.1 Rop
Mar 7, 2025Order Ord 69052 Anonymized
Mar 3, 2025R 105.5 Rop
Feb 28, 2025Interim Conference Recording
Feb 24, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Feb 24, 2025Panel Appointment
Feb 24, 2025Interim Conference Decision
Feb 24, 2025Fix Interim Conference Date
Jan 24, 2025R 9
Jan 24, 2025R 263
Jan 24, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 24, 2025262 A Final
Jan 22, 2025Receipt
Jan 21, 2025Rejoinder Confidential
Jan 21, 2025Rejoin Amend Patent Defence
Jan 21, 2025Observations On R. 36 Request
Jan 21, 2025Further Written Pleading R. 36 Rop Confidential
Jan 21, 2025Confidentiality Request
Jan 21, 2025Annex Zp9 A
Jan 21, 2025Annex B13 Confidential
Jan 13, 2025Term Extension Final
Jan 13, 2025Receipt
Jan 13, 2025R 36 Final
Jan 13, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 10, 2025Request R. 36 Rop
Jan 10, 2025Request For Term Extension
Dec 31, 2024R 263 Comments
Dec 17, 2024Request For Leave For Amendment
Dec 17, 2024Reply To The Defence To The Application To Amend The Patent
Dec 17, 2024Reply Amend Patent Defence
Dec 17, 2024Rejoinder To Reply To Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation Et Al
Dec 17, 2024Receipt
Dec 17, 2024Exhibit Ps 1
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 24 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 24 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 23 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 23 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 22 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 22 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 21 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 21 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 20 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 20 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 19 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 19 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 18 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 18 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 17 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 17 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 16 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 16 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 12 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 12 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 127Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 11 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 11 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 10 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 10 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 09 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 09 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 08 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 08 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 07 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 07 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 06 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 06 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 03 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 03 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 02 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 02 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 01 Marked
Dec 17, 2024Auxiliary Request 01 Clean
Dec 17, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 16, 2024Rejoinder To Reply To Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation Et Al
Dec 16, 2024Exhibit Ps 1
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 24 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 24 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 23 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 23 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 22 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 22 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 21 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 21 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 20 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 20 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 19 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 19 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 18 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 18 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 17 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 17 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 16 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 16 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 12 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 12 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 11 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 11 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 10 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 10 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 09 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 09 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 08 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 08 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 07 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 07 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 06 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 06 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 03 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 03 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 02 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 02 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 01 Marked
Dec 16, 2024Auxiliary Request 01 Clean
Dec 16, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 13, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 9, 2024Urgent Request For Extension Of Time Period For Rejoinder
Dec 9, 2024Time Extension Final
Dec 9, 2024Receipt
Dec 9, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Nov 19, 2024Scheduling Final
Nov 19, 2024Hearing Dates
Nov 11, 2024Reply To Defence
Nov 11, 2024Exhibit Zp9
Nov 11, 2024Defence To Application To Amend The Patent
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp9
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp8
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp7
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp6
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp5
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp4
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp3
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp2 C
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp2 B
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp2 A
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp2
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp12
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp11
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp10
Nov 11, 2024Annex Zp1
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp2E
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp2D
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp2C
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp2B
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp2A
Nov 11, 2024Annex Sp1
Nov 11, 2024Annex Daap Sod
Nov 11, 2024Annex Daap Rrsod
Nov 11, 2024Annex Daap Rdcfr
Nov 11, 2024Annex Daap Cfr
Nov 11, 2024Annex C B1
Nov 11, 2024Annex C A1
Nov 11, 2024Annex B8
Nov 11, 2024Annex B7
Nov 11, 2024Annex B12
Nov 11, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 17, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 17, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 16, 2024Formal Confirmation Of Requests To Amend Claims
Sep 16, 2024Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation
Sep 16, 2024Auxiliary Requests 1 To 15
Sep 9, 2024Overview Auxiliary Requests
Sep 9, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Sep 9, 2024Defence To Counterclaim For Revocation
Sep 9, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Aug 22, 2024Receipt
Aug 22, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Aug 22, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 22, 2024Fva Final
Aug 22, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Aug 21, 2024Request For Extension Of Time Period
Aug 7, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Aug 7, 2024Document From Epo
Aug 6, 2024Zustellbestatigung E Mail
Aug 6, 2024Notification Of Service
Aug 6, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jul 23, 2024Panel Appointment
Jul 23, 2024Letter For Service
Jul 23, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jul 23, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jul 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Jul 22, 2024Response To Request For Correction Following Formal Checks
Jul 22, 2024Exhibit Rfc Cfr 1
Jul 22, 2024Counterclaim For Revocation
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp7
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp6
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp5
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp4
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp3
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp2
Jul 22, 2024Annex Zp1
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp2E
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp2D
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp2C
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp2B
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp2A
Jul 22, 2024Annex Sp1
Jul 22, 2024Annex C B1
Jul 22, 2024Annex C A1
Jul 22, 2024Annex C 0
Jul 10, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Jul 5, 2024Counterclaim For Revocation
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp7
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp6
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp5
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp4
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp3
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp2
Jul 5, 2024Annex Zp1
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp2E
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp2D
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp2C
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp2B
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp2A
Jul 5, 2024Annex Sp1
Jul 5, 2024Annex C B1
Jul 5, 2024Annex C A1
Jul 5, 2024Annex C 0

More cases involving EP2391947B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_CFI_822/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_823/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung Electronics, Samsung Electronics France SAIHeadwater Research
CC_40130/2024Jul 5, 2024Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research

More cases involving Samsung Electronics

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_CFI_822/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_823/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung Electronics, Samsung Electronics France SAIHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_833/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research

More cases involving Headwater Research

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Oct 30, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
UPC_CFI_822/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_823/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung Electronics, Samsung Electronics France SAIHeadwater Research
UPC_CFI_833/2025Sep 2, 2025Samsung ElectronicsHeadwater Research