The weekly litigation news digest is live. Subscribe now

IP Verse

Winnow Solutions vs. Orbisk - UPC_CFI_327/2024

The case UPC_CFI_327/2024 was filed by the plaintiff Winnow Solutions against the defendant Orbisk on 18 Jun, 2024.

Case Timeline

18 Jun, 2024
Case Filed
03 Oct, 2024
Counterclaim for Revocation
13 Jun, 2025
Written Procedure
13 Jun, 2025
Rejoinder
13 Jun, 2025
Interim Conference
13 Jun, 2025
Oral Procedure
Today Nov 21, 2025
Decision

Case Details

    Case Number:

    UPC_CFI_327/2024

    Patent Number:

    EP3198245

    Filing Date:

    18 Jun, 2024

    Proceeding Type:

    Infringement

    Case Phase:

    Case Closed

    Plaintiffs:

    • Winnow Solutions

    Plaintiff Representative:

    • Gregory Bacon

    Defendants:

    • Orbisk

    Defendant Representative:

    • Roeland Grijpink

    Judges:

    • Alessandro Sanchini
    • Edger Brinkman
    • Margot Kokke
    • Petri Rinkinen

    Court Division:

    First Instance, Local Division - The Hague

Case Decision

Decision pending - set alert to receive updates

Docket Entries

The docket entries provide a comprehensive overview of all filings, motions, orders, and other significant actions taken in the case.

Last updated on: Nov 20, 2025
DateTitle

Notify me when new UPC document is filed

Aug 13, 2025Winnow Orbisk Final Signed Anon
Aug 13, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Aug 13, 2025Final Decision
Aug 13, 2025Decisionoutcome
Jun 25, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 36388 2024 Oh Hag Loc Upc2025061810Am
Jun 17, 2025Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jun 17, 2025Application Rop293 Receipt
Jun 17, 2025Acknowledgement Of Change Of A Representative
Jun 16, 2025General Power Of Attorney Hrm
Jun 16, 2025Application To Change A Representative
Jun 16, 2025Application Rop293
Jun 13, 2025Written Procedure Closure
Jun 13, 2025Summon To Oh
Jun 13, 2025Summon Oral Hearing
Jun 13, 2025R. 105.5 Order
Jun 13, 2025Oral Hearing Referencing 36388 2024 Ic Hag Loc Upc2025052810Am
Jun 13, 2025Interim Procedure Closure
Jun 13, 2025Interim Conference Decision
Jun 13, 2025Hearing Dates
Jun 13, 2025Fix Interim Conference Date
Jun 11, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jun 11, 2025Order Winnows V Orbisk On Ic Hearing
Apr 30, 2025R.262A Application Regarding Confidential Annexes To Rejoinder
Apr 29, 2025Rejoinder Regarding Orbisk S Application To Amend The Claim Under R.263 Rop And Request For An Order To Produce Evidence
Apr 29, 2025Receipt
Apr 29, 2025Annex 2 To The Rejoinder
Apr 29, 2025Annex 1 To The Rejoinder
Apr 4, 2025Panel Appointment
Apr 1, 2025R. 262A Order Winnow Orbisk Iii
Apr 1, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Apr 1, 2025Hearing Dates
Mar 10, 2025Rejoinder In The Main Action, Reply In The Counterclaim
Mar 10, 2025DE44 Japanese Patent Application Publication Jps6378023A Of Shimadzu Corporation Of 8 April 1988
Mar 10, 2025DE44.A Machine Translation By Epo Of The Description Of Jps6378023A
Mar 10, 2025DE43 A. Seymour, "Greene King Drives Down Costs In Pub Chain", Foodservice Equipment Journal, 18 March
Mar 10, 2025DE42 Screenshots Of Winnow'S Website VIA Wayback Machine Prior To 21 April
Mar 10, 2025DE41 Audio Transcript Of The Winnow VIDEO
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Pr 5 Excerpt Of D. Pyle, "Data Preparation For Data Mining", Academic Press 1999
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Pr 4 Excerpt Of R. Nisbet Et Al, "Handbook Of Statistical Analysis And Data Mining Applications", Elsevier
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Pr 3 Excerpt Of J.F. Hair Et Al, "Multivariate Data Analysis", Pearson New International Edition
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Pr 2 Slides Lecture 1 Data Analysis Course Tu Delft
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Pr 1 Cv Emeritus Professor Pc Rem
Mar 10, 2025DE40 Expert Statement Emeritus Professor Peter Rem Of 10 March
Mar 10, 2025DE39 Social Media Posts Of Orbisk At Horecava On 7 January
Mar 10, 2025DE38 Several Screenshots Of Winnow'S Website And Linked Pages VIA Wayback Machine Prior To
Mar 10, 2025D11 Confidentiality Request
Mar 10, 2025Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Feb 6, 2025Response To R.9 Application Regarding Hearing Dates
Feb 3, 2025Rescheduling Oh And Ic Dates
Feb 3, 2025Receipt
Feb 3, 2025R. 9 Rop Request
Feb 3, 2025DE37 Email Bristows 28 November
Jan 31, 2025Setting Ic And Oh Dates
Jan 31, 2025Hearing Dates
Jan 30, 2025R. 190 Order
Jan 30, 2025Outcome Of The Order
Jan 30, 2025Headnote And Keywords
Dec 23, 2024Reply To Defence And Defence To Counterclaim
Dec 23, 2024R. 262A Final Order Winnow Orbisk
Dec 23, 2024R.262A Application For Reply And Defence To Counterclaim
Dec 23, 2024R.262A Application
Dec 23, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 23, 2024Annex 9 Conditional Request 3B (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 8 Conditional Request 3A (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 7 Third Conditional Request (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 6 Conditional Request 2A (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 5 Second Conditional Request (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 4 First Conditional Request (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 3 Main Request (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 2 EP3895085A1 (Orbisk Application)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 1 EP3750126A1 (Winnow Application)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 13 EP3895085Search Report (Orbisk Application)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 12 Screen Recording From Orbisk Website
Dec 23, 2024Annex 11 Winnow Blog Post (January)
Dec 23, 2024Annex 10 Conditional Request 3C (Application To Amend)
Dec 23, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Dec 19, 2024R. 29 Extension
Dec 19, 2024R. 262A Final Order Winnow Orbisk
Dec 19, 2024R. 190 Compliance Final Order Winnow Orbisk
Dec 19, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Dec 3, 2024D8 Response To Further Request Winnow
Dec 2, 2024Rule 9 Request For Extension Of Time
Dec 2, 2024Receipt
Nov 27, 2024Preliminary Order R. 262A
Nov 27, 2024Preliminary Order R. 190 Compliance
Nov 18, 2024Receipt
Nov 15, 2024Submissions Regarding Orbisk'S Non Compliance With R.190 Order
Nov 15, 2024Application For R.262A Treatment Of Confidential Submissions
Nov 7, 2024Letter From Bristows To Court Re Dates Of Unavailability
Nov 7, 2024Comments Pursuant To R. 264 Rop
Oct 29, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 29, 2024Confidentiality Regime
Oct 28, 2024Response To Order To Produce Evidence Pursuant To R.190 Rop
Oct 28, 2024Request For Protection Of Confidentiality Pursuant To R. 262A Rop
Oct 28, 2024R262A Request
Oct 28, 2024DE36 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE35 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE34 Sama Documentation
Oct 28, 2024DE33 Orbi Registration Form
Oct 28, 2024DE32 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE31 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE30 Technical Specification Smart Camera
Oct 28, 2024DE29 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE28 Exhibit
Oct 28, 2024DE27 Technical Specification Orbi
Oct 24, 2024Request Unavailability Dates
Oct 14, 2024R. 190 Order
Oct 14, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Oct 14, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Oct 4, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Oct 4, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 3, 2024Statement Of Defense Also Counterclaim For Revocation Including Corrected Formalities
Oct 3, 2024DE26 Relevant Pages From The Prosecution File Of The Patent
Oct 3, 2024DE25 K. Morris, "Leanpath Weighs In", Embedded Technology Journal, 8 May
Oct 3, 2024DE24 Literature And Screenshots On Data Cleaning Microsoft Access
Oct 3, 2024DE23 Brochure Of Avery Weigh Tronix Regarding The M725 Data Management System Of
Oct 3, 2024DE22 United States Patent Application Us /035769
Oct 3, 2024DE21.E Recycling Today Article On Biohitech'S Eco Safe Digester Entitled "Biohitech Digester...", Dated
Oct 3, 2024DE21.D New Atlas Article On Biohitech'S Digester Entitled "Ecosafe: Big Data Less Waste", DATED 2 December
Oct 3, 2024DE21.C Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S VIDEO Of The Eco Safe Digester
Oct 3, 2024DE21.B Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S Website In Relation To The Cloud, DATED 6 February
Oct 3, 2024DE21.A Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S Website In Relation To The Eco Safe Digester, DATED 11 March
Oct 3, 2024DE20 Presentation By Mr. Shakman (Ceo Of Leanpath) Entitled "The Virtues Of Now:...", At Tdwi On 4 March
Oct 3, 2024DE19 Presentation By Mr. Shakman (Ceo Of Leanpath) Entitled "Food Waste Tracking...", At The Nra Show
Oct 3, 2024DE18 Leanpath'S United States Patent Us 7,415,375,B2
Oct 3, 2024DE17 Brochure Of Leanpath'S Valuewaste Food Waste Tracker Of
Oct 3, 2024DE16 Brochure Of Avery Weigh Tronix Entitled "Waste & Recycling Weighing Systems" Of
Oct 3, 2024DE15 Service Instruction Manual Of Avery Berkel'S Programmable Indicator L240 DATED 14 November
Oct 3, 2024DE14 Various Screenshots In Relation To Winnow'S VIDEO About Its Second Generation Product Winnow Vision
Oct 3, 2024DE13 Various Twitter Posts Of Foodsave About Sales Of The Winnow System As Of 2 April
Oct 3, 2024DE12 M. Zornes, "Food Save Reducing Food Waste With The Sra", Blog Post On Winnowsolutions.Com DATED 31 March
Oct 3, 2024DE11 A. Cassidy, Guardian Article About The Winnow System..., The Guardian, 15 May
Oct 3, 2024DE10 V. Lim Et Al., "Eco Feedback For Non Consumption", 13 September
Oct 3, 2024DE09 J. Warwick, "Restaurants Turning To High Tech Solutions To Save Money And Food", The Guardian 28 March
Oct 3, 2024DE08 Korhonen Et Al., "Waste Container Weighing Data...", Waste Management 39 () 15 25
Oct 3, 2024DE07 J.M. Hellerstein, "Quantitative Data Cleaning For Large Database", 27 February
Oct 3, 2024DE06 T. Dasu And T. Johnson, "Exploratory Data Mining And Data Cleaning", Wiley
Oct 3, 2024DE05 VIDEO About The Winnow System Dated February
Oct 3, 2024DE04 Various Screenshots In Relation To Winnow'S VIDEO About The Winnow System
Oct 3, 2024DE03 Chinese Utility Model Application Cn203324802U Of Guangzhou Eastsoft Technology Co Ltd. Published On 4/12
Oct 3, 2024DE03.A Chinese Utility Model Application Cn203324802U (Certified Translation)
Oct 3, 2024DE02 Priority Document US61/982,012 Filed On 21 April
Oct 3, 2024DE01 Original Application EP3198245Filed On 21 April
Oct 3, 2024D3 Statement Of Defence
Oct 3, 2024Change Details Of A Representative In A Pending Case Pursuant To Rgr16.1(B) In Act 36388
Oct 3, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Oct 2, 2024Headnote And Keywords
Oct 1, 2024Formal Checks Request For Correction
Sep 27, 2024DE26 Relevant Pages From The Prosecution File Of The Patent
Sep 27, 2024DE25 K. Morris, "Leanpath Weighs In", Embedded Technology Journal, 8 May
Sep 27, 2024DE24 Literature And Screenshots On Data Cleaning Microsoft Access
Sep 27, 2024DE23 Brochure Of Avery Weigh Tronix Regarding The M725 Data Management System Of
Sep 27, 2024DE22 United States Patent Application Us /035769
Sep 27, 2024DE21.E Recycling Today Article On Biohitech'S Eco Safe Digester Entitled "Biohitech Digester...", Dated
Sep 27, 2024DE21.D New Atlas Article On Biohitech'S Digester Entitled "Ecosafe: Big Data Less Waste", DATED 2 December
Sep 27, 2024DE21.C Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S VIDEO Of The Eco Safe Digester
Sep 27, 2024DE21.B Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S Website In Relation To The Cloud, DATED 6 February
Sep 27, 2024DE21.A Various Screenshots Of Biohitech'S Website In Relation To The Eco Safe Digester, DATED 11 March
Sep 27, 2024DE20 Presentation By Mr. Shakman (Ceo Of Leanpath) Entitled "The Virtues Of Now:...", At Tdwi On 4 March
Sep 27, 2024DE19 Presentation By Mr. Shakman (Ceo Of Leanpath) Entitled "Food Waste Tracking...", At The Nra Show
Sep 27, 2024DE18 Leanpath'S United States Patent Us 7,415,375,B2
Sep 27, 2024DE17 Brochure Of Leanpath'S Valuewaste Food Waste Tracker Of
Sep 27, 2024DE16 Brochure Of Avery Weigh Tronix Entitled "Waste & Recycling Weighing Systems" Of
Sep 27, 2024DE15 Service Instruction Manual Of Avery Berkel'S Programmable Indicator L240 DATED 14 November
Sep 27, 2024DE14 Various Screenshots In Relation To Winnow'S VIDEO About Its Second Generation Product Winnow Vision
Sep 27, 2024DE13 Various Twitter Posts Of Foodsave About Sales Of The Winnow System As Of 2 April
Sep 27, 2024DE12 M. Zornes, "Food Save Reducing Food Waste With The Sra", Blog Post On Winnowsolutions.Com DATED 31 March
Sep 27, 2024DE11 A. Cassidy, Guardian Article About The Winnow System..., The Guardian, 15 May
Sep 27, 2024DE10 V. Lim Et Al., "Eco Feedback For Non Consumption", 13 September
Sep 27, 2024DE09 J. Warwick, "Restaurants Turning To High Tech Solutions To Save Money And Food", The Guardian 28 March
Sep 27, 2024DE08 Korhonen Et Al., "Waste Container Weighing Data...", Waste Management 39 () 15 25
Sep 27, 2024DE07 J.M. Hellerstein, "Quantitative Data Cleaning For Large Database", 27 February
Sep 27, 2024DE06 T. Dasu And T. Johnson, "Exploratory Data Mining And Data Cleaning", Wiley
Sep 27, 2024DE05 VIDEO About The Winnow System Dated February
Sep 27, 2024DE04 Various Screenshots In Relation To Winnow'S VIDEO About The Winnow System
Sep 27, 2024DE03 Chinese Utility Model Application Cn203324802U Of Guangzhou Eastsoft Technology Co Ltd. Published On 4/12
Sep 27, 2024DE03.A Chinese Utility Model Application Cn203324802U (Certified Translation)
Sep 27, 2024DE02 Priority Document US61/982,012 Filed On 21 April
Sep 27, 2024DE01 Original Application EP3198245Filed On 21 April
Sep 27, 2024D3 Statement Of Defence
Sep 27, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging
Sep 26, 2024D4 R190 Rejoinder (Def Signed)
Sep 17, 2024Receipt
Sep 17, 2024Orbisk May Rejoin Re R. 190
Sep 16, 2024Reply To Response To Request For Order To Produce Evidence
Sep 6, 2024DE10 V. Lim Et Al. Eco Feedback For Non Consumption 13 September
Sep 6, 2024DE09 Guardian Article Entitled Restaurants Turning To High Tech Solutions To Save Money And Food Of 28 March
Sep 6, 2024DE08 Korhonen Et Al. Waste Container Weighing Data Processing To CR EATE Reliable Information Of Household Waste Gener
Sep 6, 2024DE07 J.M. Hellerstein Quantitative Data Cleaning For Large Databases 27 February
Sep 6, 2024DE06 T. Dasu And T. Johnson, Exploratory Data Mining And Data Cleaning , Wiley
Sep 6, 2024DE05 VIDEO Winnow System
Sep 6, 2024DE04 Various Screenshots In Relation To Winnow'S VIDEO About The Winnow System
Sep 6, 2024DE03 Chinese Utility Model Application Cn203324802U Of 4 December (Incl Eng Translation))
Sep 6, 2024DE02 Priority Document US61 982012 Filed On 21 April
Sep 6, 2024DE01 Original Application EP3198245Filed On 21 April
Sep 6, 2024D2 R190 Response
Aug 6, 2024Outcome Of The Order
Aug 6, 2024Order Extension Deadline R. 190
Aug 5, 2024Receipt
Aug 2, 2024Receipt
Aug 2, 2024Claimant'S Response To Defendant'S R.9 Request
Aug 1, 2024Reasoned Request To Extend A Time Limit
Jul 30, 2024Defendant To Respond
Jun 28, 2024Receipt
Jun 27, 2024Request For Order To Produce Evidence Under Rule190 Rop
Jun 27, 2024Notification Of Service
Jun 27, 2024Epouploaddocumentsworkflow
Jun 27, 2024Document From Epo
Jun 27, 2024Act 36388 Upc Cfi 327 Confirmation Of Service
Jun 27, 2024Acknowledgement Of Access To Case
Jun 26, 2024Letter For Service
Jun 25, 2024Panel Appointment
Jun 24, 2024Receipt
Jun 24, 2024Formal Checks Notification Of Positive Outcome
Jun 24, 2024Epo Request For Case Pending
Jun 18, 2024Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 9 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 8 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 7 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 6 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 5 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 4 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 3 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 2 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 28 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 27 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 26 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 25 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 24 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 23 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 22 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 21 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 20B To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 20A To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 1 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 19 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 18 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 17 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 16 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 15 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 14 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 13 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 12 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 11 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Annex 10 To Statement Of Claim
Jun 18, 2024Acknowledgement Of Lodging

More cases involving EP3198245B1

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Nov 20, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
CC_53523/2024Sep 27, 2024OrbiskWinnow Solutions
UPC_CFI_557/2024Sep 27, 2024OrbiskWinnow Solutions
ACT_36388/2024Jun 18, 2024Winnow SolutionsOrbisk

More cases involving Winnow Solutions

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Nov 20, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
ORD_58078/2024Oct 24, 2024Winnow SolutionsOrbisk
APP_52022/2024Sep 16, 2024Winnow Solutions -
APP_38567/2024Jun 28, 2024Winnow SolutionsOrbisk

More cases involving Orbisk

This table lists the related cases associated with the patent, including case numbers, plaintiffs, and defendants involved in each case.

Last updated on: Nov 20, 2025
Case NumberFiling DatePlaintiffsDefendants
APP_11672/2025Mar 11, 2025OrbiskWinnow Solutions
ORD_58078/2024Oct 24, 2024Winnow SolutionsOrbisk
CC_53523/2024Sep 27, 2024OrbiskWinnow Solutions